   : , ,      
  


Humanitas
 ..           - 頖      1917.   ,       .           ,  , ,   .       ,      ,     ,    ,       .          ,      ,          .

  a4.pdf    .





 

   : , ,      



 ..,   Humanitas,  , 2017

 .., 2017

   , 2017


* * *


 堖   ,      ,   堖   ,    .







.  : , ,  


   1917.  ,         ,  ,    .      , , , ,    ,        .     : -,          ( )   , ,     ; -,      ,     ; -,              .        ,         ,           () .

         ,   ࠖ   ,  (   )  ,    .     ..  ,     ,    ,   .      ,      ,   ,   ,   .    ,  .,  :           ,      ,   ,   .  ,   ,   ,      , .. ,           ,     ,     [1 - .   . . 2.  . ., 2015. . 52.].    ⠖     ,     .          ,       ,    .        ,      ,            .       (-) ,     (     ),   ࠖ    .          .

     ,    .    :    (      );  ,     (  ࠖ ,    );   (     ); ,       (             ); ,     (         ).   ,     ,                       .      ,      ,      (   )          ,    :     ,   ,             .       ,      ,          ,        ,       ,         ,    ,     .

      ,       蠖    ()      ,          [2 -          : ..     . ., 2008;  .   :  . ., 2010;  .       :  . .; ., 2013.].    ,             (       ,               )[3 -  : , ,  .    ... ., 2011;     ..      //  . 2010. 1. . 131166; :   .    . ., 2010;      :   //  . 2011. 8. . 345.  :      // XI     1213  2011. ., 2011. . 1. . 362365.    堖      .     . ., 2008;    .        // . -      . 2011. 16 (). . 3235;       ..         . .:   .   . . 44. ., 2013;     . ., 2014.].

  ,  ..,             .          .,                 ;    ,    .         :      ,    ,    ,             [4 - ..   :  . ., 2010. . 333.].            () .  ,       ,               (     ,     ).      XXXXI.      [5 -        .: .. //  . . ., 2015. . 3. ., 2015. .264279. . :   :   // ..       . .; ., 2013. . 748.].

  蠖              ⠖     .        ,    ,    ,      ,     [6 - ..       ՠ  XXI. (   ..        // .   . 2014. 5 (89). . 145147.]           ,        , ,    [7 -    ..         : ..    (   ..) //    . 2011. 1. . 139148; .., .. ..       //  . 2009. 1. . 141150; ..      .. //  . 2010. 12. . 163164; .      ꅻ ...        // . 2014. 9; ..        (  ..) //    . 2014. . 84. 12. . 11401141; ..   :     (     .) //    . 2015. 2. . 8495  .].  ..                  . ,   堖         [8 - ..    ..:         //  .   . 2015. 2. . 1727.].     ,            ,  ,       .

      :            蠖   ;          ,   [9 - .. -        //  . 2009. 10. . 7092;  . -      //  . 2009. 4. . 322;  .        //   . 2011. 5 (84). . 3042;  :   :       //  . 2015. 3 (. 34). . 108132.].  ,    ,   ,           .        ,        .

         ,   (    ) -        ,               .                (      )       (   ),   ,       젖    .                     [10 - Beyond Soviet Studies. Washington, 1995; Soviet and Post-Soviet Russia in a World in Change. Lanham, 1994; Constructing Russian Culture in the Age of Revolution, 1881-1940. N.Y.; Oxford, 1998; Reinterpreting Russia. L., 1999; The Russian Revolution: The Essential Reading. L.; Toronto, 2001; Imperial and National Identities in Prerevolutionary Russian, Soviet, and Post-Soviet Russia. Helsinki, 2002; Late Imperial Russia: Problems and Prospects. N.Y., 2005; Russia in the European Context 17891914: A Member of the Family. N.Y., 2005; Reinterpreting Revolutionary Russia. Palgrave, 2006.].               ,         [11 - Beloff M. An Historian in the Twentieth Century: Chapters in Intellectual Autobiography. New Haven, 1992; Ideas, Intellectuals, and Ideology in Russian History: Los Angeles, 1993; Dukes P. Fifty Years of Russian History //   : , ,  . ., 2010.].   ,            ,         .         ,  ,   ,       (        ),  蠖    (   )    ,     ()     ( ).       1990- ,         ,    -     .         ,      ,  (    ),    , ,     .   ,      ,    [12 - Smith S. Writing the History of the Russian Revolution after the Fall of Communism // The Russian Revolution; The Essential Readings. L.; Toronto, 2001. P. 265.].

         ,         [13 -   //  . 2008. 5. . 318.].          ,        :     ( 蠖  );     ,        (  )     (      );  ,              ࠖ   ,        .    ,  ,  ,          , ,   ..    ,     -     [14 - ..         //  . 2012. 1. . 316.].

        (  ).     ,        ,           .             .       ,   堖      (           ).        (, ,  , ,   ..).    蠖 .             ()   .               .  ,      ,   ,  .   ,        ,  ,   .      ,     .    堖    .        ,      ,  蠖     ?            :        (   )      ,       ,     .    ,        .

,          ,          ,      (    );      ,     (    )         ,         .           :      ,          ,   (     ) ,            (       ).                 ,   ,      ,         ,       [15 -    XXI.:    . ., 2000.].     ,               ,                [16 -  1917 :    (    2223  1988.) / . . -.   ... ., 1989.].               [17 -   1917    :   //  . 2007. 5;      :   //  , 2008. 6.].         ,          ,                      [18 -       :    : 20  . ., 2011;    .   . ., 2011. . : ..     :  ,       //  . 2012. 4. . 203208.].     :                [19 -           , ,       ,       - .                : .   .  . 19171923. ., 1990. . 12; .   . ., 1998;  .    19171991. ., 1995  . .: ..             //     . ., 2014.].    ., ., .,    .,      ?      .

       .            :   ;      - ,         .   ,    , ,     .           蠖   ,    ,   ,      ,   ( ,  ,   ),      (  )   (,   ),       ,      ,         .

    ,     ,          .        ⠖ ,    ,    -      .    ,      堖      (  , , - ).  ࠖ     :    ;      ;     ;          ;         [20 -          : Constitution Makers on Constitution Making. The Experience of Eight Nations. Washington, 1988. LEcriture de la Constitution de 1958. Paris, 1992; Sartori G. Comparative Constitutional Engineering. An Inquiry Into Structures, Incentives and Outcomes. L., 1994; Designs for Democratic Stability. Studies in Viable Constitutionalism. N.Y., 1997.].          :     ,     ; ,     ,     ;       ,    ,       ,        .

 ,     ,          XVIIIXIX.,        [21 - Blackey R. (Ed.). Revolutionists. A Comprehensive Guide to the Literature. Oxford, 1982.   : P. 158178.].           ,       ,   ,               [22 - Brinton C. The Anatomy of Revolution. N.Y., 1952; Moore B. Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy. Lord and Peasant in the Making of Modern World. Boston, 1967; Scocpol T. States and Social Revolutions. A Comparative Analysis of France, Russia and China. Cambridge, 1980; Tilly Ch. European Revolutions. 14921992. Oxford; Cambridge, 1993.].              [23 - The Russian Provisional Government. 1917. Documents. Selected and edited by R.P. Browder and A.F. Kerensky. Stanford Univ Press. Stanford, California, 1961.Vol. IIII; The Russian Revolution and the Soviet State. 19171921. Documents.Selected and Edited by Mc Cauley. L., 1975; The Rise and Fall of Soviet Union.A Selected Bibliography of Sources in English. L., 1992.].  ,      ,         .     ,       ,  ,   ,       [24 - Butler W. Russian Law. London; Oxford, 2009.].      ,                   .       [25 - Late Imperial Russia: Problems and Prospects. N.Y., 2005.].                   [26 - Power and Legitimacy Challengers from Russia. L.; N.Y., 2012.].          ,        .    蠖           ,       .    ,  ,    (    ),           ,      .            () ,    (       ).                   - ,            .             1920-        (  )  ,        ,  ,   [27 - Juristen. Ein Biographisches Lexikon. Vo n der Antike bis zum 20. Jahrhundert. M?nchen, 1995.].          ,             .

          -,              [28 - ..   . . . . 12. , 1925; Timashev N.S. Grundz?ge der Sovjetverfassung. Heidelberg, 1925; ..     . , 1931.].   ,     ,         (     ),       ,         (              ),          .  ,             .    -          19201930- ,               - [29 -  , 19171939. ., 2000.].            ,      .  ,         :          ,            . , ,   ,  ,          [30 - Fitzpatrick Sh. The Russian Revolution. Oxford, Univ. Press, 2008.].            (   );     ,       - ,        .

        .         ࠖ         ,           .                  (   )    (    ). , ,            ,          ,       ,       ,       ,      ( ).               .     ,        ,       .  ,   ,                        .        蠖        ,          ,    .                        .   (    )      ,        . ࠖ             .

           ,   ,    ࠖ  :     ,    ,    - .  頖      ,   ,       ;    ,  ,     ,      ;  頖   ,       ;  頖        ,            ;  頖     ,         .   ( )                      ( )[31 -     .: ..       :  , ,   //  . 2016. 3. C. 131160.].

      ,   ࠖ          ,    ,         蠖       ,      ,          .        ,     ,      .        ,     :        ,      堖      .

            -   .                   .    堖       (   ):          , ..      ,       ,   ,      .         (  ),   ,    ,      ,           . ,        ,       ,    ,            .

 , -,     蠖       (       ),            (      ,    ); -,        ,            ; -,       頖       () , ,    (       ); -,   -     젖       (..     ); -,         젖                     ; -,     ꠖ    ,            ,      ; , -,      (           )[32 -       :  . ., 2001;   XVIII  XX . ., 2005;    . ., 2009.].

        , ,       :       ࠖ        (    );    (   ,     ),   (     )     (     );                 ,      ;             (     頖    )     ;             ;               ;   :     (  )   [33 -    XIX  XX . ., 2013.].

         .        :                 ,     ,         .         .     ,    ,        堖      . (1905.,     1917.)       (   1930-    19851990.).       :               (          1920- ),     .   ,    ,             蠖   .



                                   .            ,   ,    ,          .        頖   ,      .    ,     ,       - ,     [34 - The Revolution, the Constitution, and the Americas Third Century. Philadelphia, 1976. Vol. 12; Wood G. The Creation of the American Republic 17761787. North Carolina. 1998.].     ,     ,              . ,   1789.,       ,     ,      ,  ,        (1958)[35 - ChevallierJ.J. Histoire des institutions et des rgimes politiques de la France (de 1789 a nos jours). Paris, 1986.].         ,              [36 - Constitution // Dictionnaire Critique de la Rvolution Fran?aise. Institutions et Crations. P., 1992; P. 9899; Doyle W. Origins of the French Revolution. N.Y., 1980.].  ,     ,     1910.,      .[37 - Knight A. The Mexican Revolution. Cambridge, 1987, Vol. 12; Krauze E. Biografa del poder. Caudillos de la revolucion Mexicana (19101940). Mexico, 2006.].  ,      1911.   ,    (    ), -,               [38 - Bianko L. Les origins de la rvolution Chinoise, 19151949. Paris, 1967; FairbankJ.K., Goldman M. China. A New History. Cambridge; L., 2006.].   1979., ,     ,         ,        ,        [39 - Khosrokhavar F. LUtopie Sacrifee. Sociologie de la rvolution iranienne. Paris, 1993.].

                ,             .  ,  ,        ,               .        ,      , ,                [40 - KimmelM.S. Revolution. A Sociological Interpretation. L., 1990.].    , ,  :  (    )  ,    ,           ,          ,      ,      ,  ,     ,    .        , ,         (19171991), ,        ,      .

         (      )    (         ).      ,   ,    . -,       ; -,   (  )   ,       ; -,           (            ); -,         ,              ; , -,     ,       ,      .          ,          .        ,               (            ),      1991.      .

          ,     60-   .        ,   頖  ,    ,     ,          ,       ,      .    廠         頖   [41 - ..  .   . ., 2015.].     ,   ,        .           (    )?    ,    ,     .,            .          (  ).   ,  , -,     ,       (, ,   ); -,       (  ), -,         (  ,    ).    XIXXX.    ,        ,         ,        .              ,     .       頖      , . ,    ( )   .  status quo     ,   ⠖   ,      :   ,    ,        .                 .

             ,       ;         -   ;          [42 - ..   :     . ., 1998;  .      . ., 2002;  .   . ., 2005;  .     . ., 2007;    XVIII  XX . ., 2010;  .   :    XIX  XX. ., 2010;  . Russian Constitutionalism. Historical and Contemporary Development. L., 2006.].              [43 - ..    . ., 1994;  .   . ., 1993:  .     . XVIII  XXI . ., 2005;  .  . ., 2006;  .    . ., 2014.].                       .[44 - ..   :   ? ., 2014:  .  :       . .; ., 2015.]                   ,   [45 - ..        1917  //  . 2007. 5. . 330;  .      //  . 2011. 1. . 327;  .    :         //  . 2012. 3. . 318;  .      //  . 2010. 6. . 329;  .          //  , 2011. 6. . 330;  .      1917 ? // . 2012.].                         .            (, ,      ),               ,      [46 - ..    .         //  . 2012. . 33. . 147159.].            ,        ,       ,   ,                  .            - ,  蠖  - ,          [47 - ..         //    . 2013. 3. . 4456;  .   : , ,  // . 2013. 12. . 4152; Medushevskii A. Problems of Modernizing the Constitutional Order: Is it Necessary to Revise Russias Basic Law // Russian Politics and Law. Vol. 52. N. 2. March-April 2014. P. 4459.].                :          ;      ,      ,    ?

      (  )      ࠖ ,       ,         ,    .                  ,       ( )   .          ,   [48 - ..   :      ՠ XXI . ., 2014. . 18.].    (   - )        蠖      ,      (   )    ,     ,          .             ,                ,        ,       .

    ,     ()            .       ,  ,    ( )    ,     ( ,   ).   ,      ,    , ,      蠖        .   (  )      . ,     ,            ,             ,                 - .

        ,          ,    -    [49 - . ,     . ., 1997.].    ⠖        .        ,    ,                  .      (   )      ,     (          ).                     .           ,     ,      ,    (      )   (      ),    (       ),          .      ,    ,    [50 -    :   . ., 2013.].                       .              .         ,            .    ,             .  ,      ,  ,    (),   .

        ,   , -   -   . , -,        (          ); -,     頖       1993.); -,   (  ),            .             .     ,               (    )[51 - ..    : , ,   //       . 2016. 12.].                  ,       1918, 1924, 1936  1977.,     1964.         ,      .            1993.        -  (- , ,  ,     ,   ); ,      (      ,   ,     ,  蠖   );   (  ,      ); ,           (        ,    ,    ); ,          ,    ,    (      ); ,   ,   , ,        ,     .

      ,            ,    ,     ,     ,          ,      .        ,     .    ,    (  )            , ,     ,                  .   : )     , b)         ; )         ,    .      ,        .    頖   ( ),         .

          젖   ,   .  ,             ;     ,          ,              ;   ,                 ,   ,     ;        ,     ,                , ,      - .       ,    ,     :               ,      ,             ,   ,         ,  ,     [52 -      :  .  . ., 2014.].

    ,      ,      ,     .           .        .             ,    ,            .           ()     (   ).       (   ), ࠖ , ࠖ .

        ,         .        (, , , , , ,  ),       ,    . 頖  ,       ,         ( ),     (   ,        ). 頖    ,       .             :       ,     ,  ,    ,   .      , ,     (          ).

       ()      ,     .     ,     .    ,    ࠖ ,  ,  ⠖  (     ),    ,        ,      .                .    ,  頖  ,      ,     ,       ,     ,   .  ,    (),       .    ,    .        ,         .       (   ),          .  ,  ,     ,  ,    ,        .        ࠖ  ,   .        ,  ( )   ,   ,  ,  ,    堖     ,    .        ,    -          .         ,      .

          :        ࠖ        1917.    (. IIII);    蠖          1918.                1924. (. IVVI);          ࠖ   1936.       (. VIIIX);      軠    1964.) (. X);          1977. (. XI);           (19851991),     ,         ( 1993.    ) (. XII).            .

 蠖           ,           ;         ,   ,     ;          ,     .          ,   堖     .




I.      



           ,     .  , ,      ,           [53 - ..      ? ., 2014.].     ,        .,           ,    ,         .   ,   ,  堖  ,    ,              .                 :     ,     ,   .  蠖        ,       60-  XIX.,      .       ,       (  )             [54 - ..    . ., -, 2014.].      ,    (  ) .        ,                 .       ( )  ,     ,     25  1917.

  ,        1917.,          .[55 -    .  . ., 2004.]                   ,           ,             .    ,   ,        ,             .    ,        ?        ,         ,    , ,   .




1.        :     


             ,    [56 - Tocqueville A. de. Lancien rgime et la Rvolution. Paris, 1967.].     :   ,   ,    ,   ,  , ,   .         ( ) , ,       .     (),       .               [57 - ..   . ., 2005. . 405.].  ,              .              .           [58 - Furet F. Tocqueville et le probl?me de la Rvolution fran?aise // Furet F. Penser la Rvolution fran?aise. Paris, 1978. P. 173211.].          ,         .       ,                  [59 - ..   :     //  . 2005. 10. . 119128.].  , ,               .   ,        .          :     ;        ;            .

             ࠖ  ,    [60 -        :  .   . ., 1998. . 12;  :     . ., 20012002. . 13;     19021905. ., 2001;   17 .      19051915. ., 19962000. . 12;   ,  , .    19061916. ., 2002;     .    19051906. ., 2004;  :   . , , . ., 1996;    - . ., 19972000. . 13;       -  1905  1930- . ., 19961999. . 16;   . ., 2001;    . 19171924. ., 19972004. . 15;   1931 . ., 1999. . 12; .   . 18941921. ., 2010;  - .   . ., 2003;  -.    19051925. ., 19972000. . 13;  -. ,  19061924. ., 2002; .   . ., 1999. . 12.]. -,     ,    ; -,      -   ; -,          (         ); -,           (     ); -,            .        ,      . ,              .  ,      , :      ;     ;   ;   ;    ;   ,        ;       .




2.,   -    


               .           ,        .            ,         .  ,   ,            .         ,    蠖 ,   .

  ,    ,   ,    ,     ,     :     ,       ,           .  ,     19051907.,   .    ࠖ 廠    ,         ,    , ,     ,      17   [61 -  .   . ., 1998. . 1. . 111113, 542.].   ࠖ    (    )  ,        ,         ,    蠖 ,      .          ,  , -   ,   ,     ,   , ,   [62 -  .   . ., 1998. . 1. . 343344.].    :       ⠖ ,   ໠    젖      ,     .        ,        ,      ,  堖   [63 -  .   . ., 1998. . 1. . 122, 212, 614619.].         ,     ,     (   ,     ).   , ,    ,              .

  ( ,  ,   )      ()     ,     : -,       ,       (   ); -,        ; -,        .  ,   1905.,     17   ,           .  ,    ,            .     蠖        .  (   -   )       ,          [64 -   17 .      19051915. ., 1996. . 1. . 4850, 152.].           (     XVII.),          ,    ,         ,     ,     頖       .

     -  ,      蠖   ,   , - ,  - ,       .    ,     ,    - .               ,             .  , ,     (     )        ,   -    .           ,     .               ,        ,         .         ,      ,         ,           ,          .              [65 -   ,  , .    19061916. ., 2002. . 40.].      :   ,    ;  ,    ,        ;     ,        ;   ,    ࠖ   ,  ,   ;   ,   .              ,          ,      ,     [66 -   ,  , .    19061916. ., 2002. . 6364.].      ,     -      ,      ໠         ,   ,         ,          .        ( ),   ( )    (   ). ,              ,       ,          ,         ;       ;     .    ,      ,       (  ),  -              ,   젖 ,   [67 -     .    19051906. ., 2004. . 27, 4448, 114, 175.].  ,     17 ,    ,    蠖   - ,     (   ),     ,   17      [68 -   17 .      19051915. ., 1996. . 1. . 147.].          頖  (   ),        ( )   .

 ,    ,      .        1906.,             17  1905.:  ,         ,      [69 -    - . ., 2000. . 2 (19081914). . 83, 175.].            蠖             .         .            .    ,       ,         [70 -    - . ., 1997. . 2 (19121914). . 4145.].   (  ,   ,  ,   )    -      .     ⠖      ,    .               [71 -    - . ., 2000. . 2.. 242.].

      堖  ,  , .  젖     ,  .      蠖  ,   ;     젖     ,     .   ,        [72 -    - .., 1997. . 2. . 103.].  ,        ,           .          , ..       .      ?  ...       ,            ,   ,                 .  , ,     . ,  ,  ,   蠖   [73 -    - . . . 3. . 1 (19151917). . 692.].

     ( )  ,   () 蠖    ,             ,     .             .           ,    .    ,  ,       ,    ()      ,    [74 -   17 .      19051915. ., 1996. . 1. . 244245, 292.].   3  1906.      ,        ,             ( ).           .      ,           ,  ,   ..,          컠       . ,      ,  , ,    .    (   ..)        , 堖     .          ,    ,      ,          .             ,  頖  ()   ()    (    ).         (  ) .

-  (        )      :                 ⠖ ,   .        ⠖    ,                    ( ,     ).         ࠖ  ,     蠖  :       .

        ໠    ,        軠  ,           .      (           )      ,     (    ),              ,   ⠖         .           ,            .          17  1905.,       :      ,     蠖  .      ,      ,    [75 -  -.   . ., 2001. . 2 ( 1907  1917.). . 190, 390391.].     ,       (     ..),         ⻠     ࠖ       [76 -  -.   . ., 2001. . 2 ( 1907  1917.). . 3047, 182, 246256, 322325.].

-   堖           蠖          1793.,      蠖 , , ,       , , .          [77 - .    . .; ., 1948.]   [78 - KennedyM.L. The Jacobin Clubs in the French Revolution. Princeton, 1988.],        ..          ,       .        ,    :   蠖    ;      ;     ,           ,        ; ,   ,         ,  ,    ;     ,  ,     , ,      .            ,    ,   ,     ,          .   ,  ,     ,       .         ,      .          :       ,    - 젖 , ,   ,          ,      ,   [79 -  -. ,  19061924. ., 2002. . 2224.].          ,    ,  ,     .  ,  ,     ,      蠖   ,    ,     [80 -  -. ,  19061924. ., 2002. . 83.].

 -,   ,       ,      . ,      ,      ,     -   ,          .    ,  ,    -       ,     .     (  ) ,  ,  ,            ,   ,      ,      [81 - Bottomore T. Marxism and Sociology // A History of Sociological Analysis. London, Heinemann, 1978. P. 118148; Kolakowski L. Hauptstr?mungen des Marxismus. Entstehung. Entwicklung. Zerfall. M?nchen; Z?rich, 1981. Bd 13.].                      .  ,  ,     , ,            ,       [82 - LithL.T. Lenin Rediscovered: What is to be done? In Context. Leiden, 2006. Haimson L. Lenins Revolutionary Career Revised. Some Observations on Recent Discussions // Kritika: Explorations in Russian and European History. Bloomington, 2004. Vol. V. P. 5580.].

    , ,     ,     -,      ,        .        ,            .                .   ,             ,  ,    :   ,         -   ;   ,        -.   ,      ,   :  ,           -,     .     :     (    ) .      ,       ,      ,       : ,   , -, ,    (,     , ,   )            ; -,      ,         (   :                  ,  ).    蠖              ,     ,     [83 - .. . . 41. . 70.].  ,     ,   ,  ,       ,        .     堖        (    ).    .      1905.  1917.,       19911993.  ,                    (    ,   ).

    (,   )                   ,   ;          ;      .         蠖      ,    ;        ;       . ,        ,         ࠖ   ,    .




3.  : ,    


         ࠖ          .   ,       ,           .        ,  ..,            ,     , ,        ,        .     ,     ,   [84 - ..   //      . ., 2008. . 259263.].       ,                   .        ,      -  (  ) [85 - Mannheim K. Ideology and Utopia. Introduction to the Sociology of Knowledge. L., 1949. P. 131.],         .  ,     ,            .              .

                       .             ,   .   ,     1861.      ,       ,            ;          ,    ( ),       ,    堖     [86 - ..      //  . 2011. 1. . 327;  .    :         //  . 2012. 3. . 318;  .        1917  //  . 2007. 5. . 330.].

              :       ;   ,               .                        19051907.[87 - The Russian Revolution of 1905: Centenary Perspectives. L., 2005; Haimson L. Russias Revolutionary Experience, 19051917: Two Essays. N.Y., 2005.] ,       ,  :         ,      ,       1917.     ,       :    (   ),       [88 - 100- :     . 19092009.   //  . 2009. 6.],           [89 - ..      :   //  19051907 :   :     1920  2005. ., 2005.]. ,             ,    ,    .     (    ,   )             ,         [90 - Social Identities in Revolutionary Russia. N.Y., 2001.];    [91 - Halfn G. From Darkness to Light: Class, Consciousness and Salvation in Revolutionary Russia. Pittsburgh, 2000.],  [92 - KellyA.M. Toward Another Shore: Russian Thinkers between Necessity and Chance. New Haven, 1998.],  ,  [93 - Morrissey S. Heralds of Revolution: Russian Students and the Mythologies of Radicalism. N.Y.; Oxford, 1998.],        [94 - Waldron P. The End of Imperial Russia, 18551997. Basingstoke, 1997; Longworth Ph. Russias Empires: Their Rise and Fall: From Prehistory to Putin. L., 2005.],                (         II  - 1917.)[95 - Moon D. The Problem of Social Stability in Russia, 15981998 // Reinterpreting Russia. L., 1999. P. 5474.].              ,     [96 - Lohr E. Nationalizing the Russian Empire: The Campaign against Enemy Aliens during World War I. L.; Cambridge, 2003.],       ,     .    ,     ,    蠖    (  )      .            ,               (  , ,   ,     )[97 - FullerW.C. The Foe Within: Fantasies of Treason and the End of Imperial Russia. Ithaca, 2006.].           ,       ,     [98 - Price M.Ph. Dispatches from Revolutionary Russia, 19151918. Durham, 1998.].         :           ,       ,   .    : ,    ;      ;           .

                  ,           .    ,  ,    ,       蠖       90-   .,             XXI. (        ).         (  軠  - ),    (       ),    (    );       蠖   ,      (        1905. ).         :    17921793 ,  ,  ,  堖  . ,  ,      :        ,       ,      .      ໠   ,     [99 -     .    V        1917.  //  . ., 1991. . I. . 191204.].         ()        .  ,      ,       (       ,       ).

  ,         ,   ,       .         .  19181919.       :          ,  ,  , ,   .    ,  ,  ,   ,  ,   ,   ,    .      ,     [100 -    1919 .   -   . .. //  . ., 1992. . IIIII. . 362384.].   頖     ,      ,  젖    .

           ,     ࠖ    ,         .             ,     .                  .                  .         .                ,     .   ,   ,   ,             .   , ,     ,          ࠖ   .

                    .        :    [101 -  .   . ., 1998. . 2. . 212.],    ,     [102 -   17 .      19051915. ., 1996. . 1. . 279.].    , ,     .       ,     頖                 .  :   ,         ?[103 -  - .   . ., 2003. . 115.]    蠖    ,      .  ,    ,        ;       ,    () ,  젖    ().     ,  ,       .  ,  ..,               .      . ,  ,     [104 - ..     (19171932) //   . ., 2009. . 359.].

               ,       . -,             .     1917.   ,    ,    [105 -  .   . .,1998. . 2. . 619.].        :    ,        (       1915.)[106 - ..       19141916. //  . 1992. . IIIII. . 291.].      ,   ,     ,    [107 -   ,  , .    19061916. ., 2002. . 392394.].            .

-,      .        ,           .  ,       ,          .      1914.      ?.           .  ,     ,       (..);  ,       򻠖     ,   (..)       , ,     ,   (..),  ,     -  (..)         pronunciamento (..).   ,      ,  ࠖ .. (, ,      ). ,  ,    ,    [108 -    - . ., 1997. . 2. . 260261, 268, 270275.].  1916.  :       ,   ,       (..)[109 -    - . ., 1998. . 3 (19151920). . 297.].      .   :            ,     .           , ,         .          [110 -  -.   . ., 2000. . 3. . 1 (  1917.). . 24.].   :       ,         [111 - .   . 18941921. ., 2010. . 418.].   ,   ,        .       ,  ,     [112 - .. . . 30. . 328.].  :              .         ,   ,           [113 - . . . ., 2006.].

      ,     ,                 ,     .




4.       


         , ,     ,    .               .            ,    1848.,       ,   ,         (  )    .        ,      蠖 , , ,    .[114 - .    .       (17891804). ., 1902.].      ,   .., .., .., ..  .[115 - ..   . ., 1895. . 12; ..  1848   . ., 1908. . 12; ..   . ., 1918;  .      1848. ., 1917.]                    ;       ,   ࠖ      .                   [116 - ..           . ., 1906. . 13.].        頖     () ,      ,    .                ,     ,        [117 - ..   . ., 1924.].    , , [118 - .    . ., 19771983. . 16.]      [119 - .         17891794. .; ., 1923.]        ,        ,      ,      .

  ,      ,   ,   .        .,       . ,   ,        ,       (   );               ,     ,    ,     (   );     ,     (, ,  );        -   ,     (    90-   .  ,     );            (     ),  , ,    (       )        ;          ,          (    )    ;         ,            ,            (      );         ,    , , , ;             ,  ⠖  ,     ( ); ,        ,        (        ).         蠖       (  )        .    .                     [120 - Furet F. Penser la Rvolution Fran?aise. Paris, 1978; KimmelM.S. Revolution. A Sociological Interpretation. L., 1990; Krejci J. Great Revolutions Compared. The Outline of a Theory. L., 1994.].     .       ,      .

    ,  ,     ,           .,    ,           .         .    ,      ,      .      , ,        ,          . ,              .            [121 - Davidson Ph. Propaganda and the American Revolution 17631783. Chapel Hill, 1941.].  ,       ,   ,              ,        ,         ,    [122 - ..  . ., 2002. . 129.].    XVII.  ,            頖  ,   [123 - .   . ., 1859.].            ,    [124 - Dictionnaire Critique de la Rvolution Fran?aise. Sous la direction de F. Furet et M. Ozouf. P., 1992. Vol. 14.]         ,   [125 - Gerard A. La revolution Fran?aise. Muthes et interprtation (17891970). P., 1970. P. 53.],      ,     .        ,   .[126 - Burke E. Reflections on the Revolution in France // The Writings and Speeches of Edmund Burke. Vol. VIII (The French Revolution. 17901794). Oxford, 1989.],     ,         ,       .       .        .:   ,      .    ,    .     ,    ,   ,      [127 - .  . ., 2000. . 26.].   堖   ,   .         ,   ,   ,     ,  堖     ,        ,               [128 - .: Kenez P. The Birth of the Propaganda State: Soviet Methods of Mass Mobilization, 19171929. Cambridge, 1985.].    ,          ,   .

              .    , -,           ; -,          ( ) ; -,          (, , , , ).              , ,    ,    [129 - .  . 17921804. ., 1974; .  .   , 1995.].            [130 -  : ..     . ., 1966.].   ,           ,     [131 - .    . ., 1918;  .     . ., 1922.].  ,             ,        .

      ,     ,      :      ,    ,  ,   (    )    ,    (      )    . ,     (   )       (  ).    ,       , ,  ., ,    [132 - .   . ., 1925.].                 .        ,      (       )[133 -    .:  .   .     . , 1922.],                              ,   ..[134 - ..       //    . ., 2004. . 4.].        ,   蠖        .         .

           . -,   (    1917.  )     ࠖ  -          (  - ). -,                 (,         ). -,        (  ).   ,   ,      (             ).     :          ;   堖    (    );   堖     -  (    )    ( ).

    (    )      ;       ;          ,      .         ,     [135 - Totalitarismus in 20. Jahrhundert: Eine Bilanz der internazionale Forschung. Baden-Baden, 1996.].   ࠖ              堖    [136 - Swain G. The Origins of the Russian Civil War. L.; N.Y., 1996.]        [137 - GaddyC.G. The Price of Past: Russias Struggle with the Legacy of Militarised Economy. Washington, 1996.].            ,       .

  ,        ( ,    ),  ,   ,         [138 -        : Maistre J.de. Considrations sur la France. Essai sur le Principe gnrateur des Constitutions politiques. Prface du Comte B. de Vesins. Paris, 1907. P. 95.].                .  ,   ,              ,      .      ,        ,        .       ,    ,    ,       .

      .

1.               ,       .

2.           ( ). 3.           .       ; 頖   (       ,            );          ( ) 19911993.       ,     :   ;        ;     (  堖  ); , ,    ,       [139 -     .:   . ., 2001.].

                 ,    :  ,      .       ,              .  頖     ࠖ  ,       .   ,     ,          .




5.    :    


                    .  ,  ,       : 1)    (  ,    ); 2)    (     ); 3)    (       ); 4)  ; 5)        ()  6)        . , 7)  ,        ,      (  .  .).             .

    蠖  ,   ( )            .   (..)         蠖      ,     ,         .           (        )   (    )[140 - .    (). .; ., 1925. . 12. . 113.].           ( ),          .

 ()          ,     .          . - ,  ,  .,     :     , 頖    , 頖 , 頖      .               [141 - .    -  (  ). .; ., 1923. . VIII (    ). . 256.].  , ,    ,  ,     ,       ,                  .      ..: ,  ,  1905.  ,   1917.     ?   ,                     .     1917.         ࠖ   ,       .      ,        [142 - ..     XIXXX. ., 1924.].    ,      ,   ,         . .             ,     ,     .     ,          ,              .   ,     , [143 - .      (   ). .; ., 1926. . 26.].    ,    ,       蠖    ..     ( )           .

   (..)               .              ⠖       [144 - SorokinP.A. The Sociology of Revolution. London, 1924. . 367;  .  . . ., 1992.].   (     )       .         ,                .    ,          .  ,          , , ,   [145 -    .:   . .:   , 2000;  /  . ... .: , 2003; . ., 2005; ..  . ., 2006. . 3.],           ,     ,         .

           ,  ()   . ,  ..,    ,  , ,  ,  ,     ,       ,  ,   ,    [146 - ..    //  ,    , 18591929. , 1929. . 32.].

   .,     ..[147 - ..  . 19171923. ., 1990. . 12.],    - ,   ( , )       . ,      .   50- ,      蠖   ,      ,   .  , ,     .   ,   .,  ,    ,       .       ,  ,    , ,     .  ,  ,      [148 - Toynbee A. Looking Back // The Impact of the Russian Revolution. 19171967. The Influence of Bolshevism on the World outside Russia. London, N.Y., 1967. P. 17.].

      ,     ,         ,         .           ,           (..      ,    ,     ).            젖        (,        ).           ,  ,     , ,      [149 - The Soviet Union. The Fifty Years. Ed. By H. Salisbury. N.Y., 1967; Marxism, Communism and Western Society. A Comparative Encyclopedia. N.Y., 1973. Vol. 7; The Russian Revolution and the Soviet State. 19171921. Documents. Selected and Edited by Mc Cauley. L., 1975; Brown D. Doomsday 1917. The Destruction of the Russian Ruling Class. L., 1975.].      ,   ,      ,     [150 - .  . ., 1994. . 12.].

                     .                 ,          [151 - ..     1917  30- . ., 1981.].    ,      ,   .        70- .  ..,            ,        :             ,       -    頖 ?        ,   1917.  ?    ,  1917.,  ,       ?       ? , ,         ,        ?[152 -  1917 :    (    2223  1988.) / . . -.   ... ., 1989. . 13.]

      .    :       ,      .     .     (..). ,     ,    ,         ,   (..),      : ,   ,    ,      , , ,   -   :  ,    (..).       ,         [153 -  1917 :    (    2223  1988.) / . . -.   ... ., 1989. . 3139.].    :        ,      ,        [154 -  90-    :   //  . 2007. 6.],       [155 -      :   //  . 2007. 6.].  ,      ,  ,     .              [156 - ..    .         //  . 2012. . 33. . 147159.].

                     ,       .  ,   ,  ,        XVII.       ࠖ       [157 - .    . ., 2007.].           ,        [158 - .  .     . ., 2010.].  ,        ,         ,       ( ),             ,      .                     ,  堖           .

        . , -,           .     ; -,           ,     ,     ; -,              ; -,       ,       ; -,       .

  , -,   ; -,        ; -,       ,      1917.    ; -,                   ; -,       ,       .      .       - ,      :      ,       ,          ,    ?            ,           ?               ? ,            (     ),           ?           ?




6.      


                      XXI.         ,     ,    19701980-   ,   1990-   ,    ,   ,       .      (  ),               [159 - Linz J., Stepan A. Problems of Democratic Transition and Consolidation. Southern Europe, South America, and Post-Communist Europe. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1996; Democratic Transition and Consolidation in Southern Europe, Latin America and Southeast Asia. Ed. by D. Ethier. London: Macmillan Press, 1999; Transiciones y Dise?os Institucionales. Maria del Refugio Gonzalez, Sergio Lopez Ayllon (Ed.) Mexico: Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico, 2000.].   1917.                 .

   ()               .        頖 , -,   ,        , ,  ,         [160 -      . XVIIIXX . ., 2001;   :   -        . ., 2006.].  , ,  .                       [161 - Autorit?re Regime in Ostmittel und S?dosteuropa 1919-1944 / Hrsg. von E. Oberl?nder in Zsarb. mit R. Ahmann et al. Paderborn etc.: Sch?ning, 2001;     .   , ,    . , 1996.].               .              (   1936.)[162 -    :   . ., 1996;    : . ., 1997; 1917    . ., 1998;        . ., 2005;  //   XVIII  XX . ., 2005. .383385.].     1970-  (     ),           .,      [163 - .  .     . ., 2003.].                    .  , , ,      ,     ,     .

        : -,   :        (, , )        ,     ; -,           ; -,             .              : -,      ,         (      ); -,    ,     , ,        ; -,     ,       [164 - ..   . ., 2005.],  ,                      .

     ,          .           堖     ( , ,  ),   (           ),  堖         ,    .   ( )        (  ),           :         , , ,      () ,      .                 (    ). , ,      ,                 .         .

  ,        , ,   , ,  ,    .    :        ,  ,          ;     ,  ,    ()         ,  ,  ꠖ  ,      .               [165 - ..      . ., 2002.]. ,          ,  蠖 .           .  [166 - .    . ., 1905.]  .[167 - .    .       (17891804). ., 1902.],    蠖  .[168 - Furet F. La Rvolution Fran?aise. Paris, 1988. Vo l. 12.].        .




7.  


    ,    ,      ,  ,       .                      .    ,     ,            ,      .           -     蠖              .   ࠖ                ( )      .       ,      ,                 (  ,      ).

      .         ,  ()     (       )      ;             .           .       .          ,   ,      .  ,      , ,   ,    :           .

                    .            ,       ();              ;   ()   ;       ;  (    )        .                       ,          .

                          ,          .         ,     .             ,       .          ,       .

          :         ;        ;             ;        ;         ;           (     ).        ,                  ՠ  XXI.




II.      1917 



  .     ,       -    [169 - ..   :     . ., 1998.].                       .         ,              .

            (      ).              ,     ,        .             ,     ,       [170 - ..   . ., 1994;  .   :    XIX  XX. ., 2010.].          ,   ,          .        ,       ,     .      ,      ,     .            (      ),       ,        ,      (     1991.).             .

     .           ,  .,        :        ,    .     ,   .        [171 - .   (  ). , 1931. . 195.].         ,          [172 - .. Deux rvolutions. P., 1921.].                   (..),       (.)  ,     ,        ,   [173 - ..   (1925-1935). ., 2004. . 242; .    //  . 1922. . IX. .269293.].            ,  ,             .




1.   :         


                  .    蠖        .          .            (       )    ,      , ,           .        ,   ,    (    ).        .   -       ,       .

-,          ,        1906.[174 -         23  1906. //    . 1906. . 1.]       ,         ,     .     17  1905.          頖 ,    .         . II ,         ,       [175 -   II. 1890-1906. ., 1991. . 88, 249.].     蠖      ,        .    , ,                      .             , , ,    ,     -        [176 -  19051907.   (  ..) //  . ., 1994. . V. . 374.].            (   ),    [177 - ..  .   . ., 2003. . 12; .. . ., 2004.].        ,     .          :       .  ,        , ,     ,            .

          ,                 [178 -  . ., 1905; ..    . ., 1906; ..   . ., 1908; ..     . ., 1908; ..   (  ). . ., 1909; ..     . ., 1912; ..  :  - . ., 1907;  .     . ., 1912; ..   . ., 1917. : ..   :     . ., 1998.].   ,      . 87,      [179 -    - . ., 1998. . 3. . 328.].           .            [180 - ..  . ., 1990. . 215.].   26    II  ,           . ,         ,                   ,       .

-,       :      ,    ;              ,           [181 -   II //  II.  . . ., 1927. . 223; The Russian Provisional Government. 1917. Documents. Selected and edited by R.P. Browder and A. F. Kerensky. Stanford, California, 1961. Vol. IIII;   1917 . .   . ., 1996; : .  . ., 2006.].

-,          ,     .    3     ,       ,     .  ,   ..,        [182 - ..   (). ., 1991; .   //   ,  ... , 1920. . 1. . 996.].

-,       .  ,     (      )        , ..  ,           .   ,  ,               . ..  ,    1917.    ,        .        3     ,     ,  ,   ,          ,               ,      . ,  ,        , ,  ,                . ,  ,    ;          .      ,    ,      [183 - . .      . 19801917. ., 2006. . 324.].   3- ,  ..,          [184 - ..   1917 . , 1961. . 357.].   .., ,         ,   3 [185 - ..    . ., 2001. . 51. . : .        .. //  . 1927. . XXXII. . 434452.].

-,      :        (       27 ),     ( 2 ),     .     ,  ,    ,   ,           ,  젖      [186 -   :          //  55 (3797)  5 (18)  1917. . 2    (      6  1917.) //  56 (3798) (, 7 (20)  1917.). . 2.]




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/andrey-medushevskiy-6100831/politicheskaya-istoriya-russkoy-revolucii-normy-instituty-formy-socialnoy-mobilizacii-v-hh-veke/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


.   . . 2.  . ., 2015. . 52.




2


         : ..     . ., 2008;  .   :  . ., 2010;  .       :  . .; ., 2013.




3


 : , ,  .    ... ., 2011;     ..      //  . 2010. 1. . 131166; :   .    . ., 2010;      :   //  . 2011. 8. . 345.  :      // XI     1213  2011. ., 2011. . 1. . 362365.    堖      .     . ., 2008;    .        // . -      . 2011. 16 (). . 3235;       ..         . .:   .   . . 44. ., 2013;     . ., 2014.




4


..   :  . ., 2010. . 333.




5


       .: .. //  . . ., 2015. . 3. ., 2015. .264279. . :   :   // ..       . .; ., 2013. . 748.




6


..       ՠ  XXI. (   ..        // .   . 2014. 5 (89). . 145147.




7


   ..         : ..    (   ..) //    . 2011. 1. . 139148; .., .. ..       //  . 2009. 1. . 141150; ..      .. //  . 2010. 12. . 163164; .      ꅻ ...        // . 2014. 9; ..        (  ..) //    . 2014. . 84. 12. . 11401141; ..   :     (     .) //    . 2015. 2. . 8495  .




8


..    ..:         //  .   . 2015. 2. . 1727.




9


.. -        //  . 2009. 10. . 7092;  . -      //  . 2009. 4. . 322;  .        //   . 2011. 5 (84). . 3042;  :   :       //  . 2015. 3 (. 34). . 108132.




10


Beyond Soviet Studies. Washington, 1995; Soviet and Post-Soviet Russia in a World in Change. Lanham, 1994; Constructing Russian Culture in the Age of Revolution, 1881-1940. N.Y.; Oxford, 1998; Reinterpreting Russia. L., 1999; The Russian Revolution: The Essential Reading. L.; Toronto, 2001; Imperial and National Identities in Prerevolutionary Russian, Soviet, and Post-Soviet Russia. Helsinki, 2002; Late Imperial Russia: Problems and Prospects. N.Y., 2005; Russia in the European Context 17891914: A Member of the Family. N.Y., 2005; Reinterpreting Revolutionary Russia. Palgrave, 2006.




11


Beloff M. An Historian in the Twentieth Century: Chapters in Intellectual Autobiography. New Haven, 1992; Ideas, Intellectuals, and Ideology in Russian History: Los Angeles, 1993; Dukes P. Fifty Years of Russian History //   : , ,  . ., 2010.




12


Smith S. Writing the History of the Russian Revolution after the Fall of Communism // The Russian Revolution; The Essential Readings. L.; Toronto, 2001. P. 265.




13


  //  . 2008. 5. . 318.




14


..         //  . 2012. 1. . 316.




15


   XXI.:    . ., 2000.




16


 1917 :    (    2223  1988.) / . . -.   ... ., 1989.




17


  1917    :   //  . 2007. 5;      :   //  , 2008. 6.




18


      :    : 20  . ., 2011;    .   . ., 2011. . : ..     :  ,       //  . 2012. 4. . 203208.




19


          , ,       ,       - .                : .   .  . 19171923. ., 1990. . 12; .   . ., 1998;  .    19171991. ., 1995  . .: ..             //     . ., 2014.




20


         : Constitution Makers on Constitution Making. The Experience of Eight Nations. Washington, 1988. LEcriture de la Constitution de 1958. Paris, 1992; Sartori G. Comparative Constitutional Engineering. An Inquiry Into Structures, Incentives and Outcomes. L., 1994; Designs for Democratic Stability. Studies in Viable Constitutionalism. N.Y., 1997.




21


Blackey R. (Ed.). Revolutionists. A Comprehensive Guide to the Literature. Oxford, 1982.   : P. 158178.




22


Brinton C. The Anatomy of Revolution. N.Y., 1952; Moore B. Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy. Lord and Peasant in the Making of Modern World. Boston, 1967; Scocpol T. States and Social Revolutions. A Comparative Analysis of France, Russia and China. Cambridge, 1980; Tilly Ch. European Revolutions. 14921992. Oxford; Cambridge, 1993.




23


The Russian Provisional Government. 1917. Documents. Selected and edited by R.P. Browder and A.F. Kerensky. Stanford Univ Press. Stanford, California, 1961.

Vol. IIII; The Russian Revolution and the Soviet State. 19171921. Documents.

Selected and Edited by Mc Cauley. L., 1975; The Rise and Fall of Soviet Union.

A Selected Bibliography of Sources in English. L., 1992.




24


Butler W. Russian Law. London; Oxford, 2009.




25


Late Imperial Russia: Problems and Prospects. N.Y., 2005.




26


Power and Legitimacy Challengers from Russia. L.; N.Y., 2012.




27


Juristen. Ein Biographisches Lexikon. Vo n der Antike bis zum 20. Jahrhundert. M?nchen, 1995.




28


..   . . . . 12. , 1925; Timashev N.S. Grundz?ge der Sovjetverfassung. Heidelberg, 1925; ..     . , 1931.




29


 , 19171939. ., 2000.




30


Fitzpatrick Sh. The Russian Revolution. Oxford, Univ. Press, 2008.




31


    .: ..       :  , ,   //  . 2016. 3. C. 131160.




32


      :  . ., 2001;   XVIII  XX . ., 2005;    . ., 2009.




33


   XIX  XX . ., 2013.




34


The Revolution, the Constitution, and the Americas Third Century. Philadelphia, 1976. Vol. 12; Wood G. The Creation of the American Republic 17761787. North Carolina. 1998.




35


ChevallierJ.J. Histoire des institutions et des rgimes politiques de la France (de 1789 a nos jours). Paris, 1986.




36


Constitution // Dictionnaire Critique de la Rvolution Fran?aise. Institutions et Crations. P., 1992; P. 9899; Doyle W. Origins of the French Revolution. N.Y., 1980.




37


Knight A. The Mexican Revolution. Cambridge, 1987, Vol. 12; Krauze E. Biografa del poder. Caudillos de la revolucion Mexicana (19101940). Mexico, 2006.




38


Bianko L. Les origins de la rvolution Chinoise, 19151949. Paris, 1967; FairbankJ.K., Goldman M. China. A New History. Cambridge; L., 2006.




39


Khosrokhavar F. LUtopie Sacrifee. Sociologie de la rvolution iranienne. Paris, 1993.




40


KimmelM.S. Revolution. A Sociological Interpretation. L., 1990.




41


..  .   . ., 2015.




42


..   :     . ., 1998;  .      . ., 2002;  .   . ., 2005;  .     . ., 2007;    XVIII  XX . ., 2010;  .   :    XIX  XX. ., 2010;  . Russian Constitutionalism. Historical and Contemporary Development. L., 2006.




43


..    . ., 1994;  .   . ., 1993:  .     . XVIII  XXI . ., 2005;  .  . ., 2006;  .    . ., 2014.




44


..   :   ? ., 2014:  .  :       . .; ., 2015.




45


..        1917  //  . 2007. 5. . 330;  .      //  . 2011. 1. . 327;  .    :         //  . 2012. 3. . 318;  .      //  . 2010. 6. . 329;  .          //  , 2011. 6. . 330;  .      1917 ? // . 2012.




46


..    .         //  . 2012. . 33. . 147159.




47


..         //    . 2013. 3. . 4456;  .   : , ,  // . 2013. 12. . 4152; Medushevskii A. Problems of Modernizing the Constitutional Order: Is it Necessary to Revise Russias Basic Law // Russian Politics and Law. Vol. 52. N. 2. March-April 2014. P. 4459.




48


..   :      ՠ XXI . ., 2014. . 18.




49


. ,     . ., 1997.




50


   :   . ., 2013.




51


..    : , ,   //       . 2016. 12.




52


     :  .  . ., 2014.




53


..      ? ., 2014.




54


..    . ., -, 2014.




55


   .  . ., 2004.




56


Tocqueville A. de. Lancien rgime et la Rvolution. Paris, 1967.




57


..   . ., 2005. . 405.




58


Furet F. Tocqueville et le probl?me de la Rvolution fran?aise // Furet F. Penser la Rvolution fran?aise. Paris, 1978. P. 173211.




59


..   :     //  . 2005. 10. . 119128.




60


       :  .   . ., 1998. . 12;  :     . ., 20012002. . 13;     19021905. ., 2001;   17 .      19051915. ., 19962000. . 12;   ,  , .    19061916. ., 2002;     .    19051906. ., 2004;  :   . , , . ., 1996;    - . ., 19972000. . 13;       -  1905  1930- . ., 19961999. . 16;   . ., 2001;    . 19171924. ., 19972004. . 15;   1931 . ., 1999. . 12; .   . 18941921. ., 2010;  - .   . ., 2003;  -.    19051925. ., 19972000. . 13;  -. ,  19061924. ., 2002; .   . ., 1999. . 12.




61


 .   . ., 1998. . 1. . 111113, 542.




62


 .   . ., 1998. . 1. . 343344.




63


 .   . ., 1998. . 1. . 122, 212, 614619.




64


  17 .      19051915. ., 1996. . 1. . 4850, 152.




65


  ,  , .    19061916. ., 2002. . 40.




66


  ,  , .    19061916. ., 2002. . 6364.




67


    .    19051906. ., 2004. . 27, 4448, 114, 175.




68


  17 .      19051915. ., 1996. . 1. . 147.




69


   - . ., 2000. . 2 (19081914). . 83, 175.




70


   - . ., 1997. . 2 (19121914). . 4145.




71


   - . ., 2000. . 2.

. 242.




72


   - .

., 1997. . 2. . 103.




73


   - . . . 3. . 1 (19151917). . 692.




74


  17 .      19051915. ., 1996. . 1. . 244245, 292.




75


 -.   . ., 2001. . 2 ( 1907  1917.). . 190, 390391.




76


 -.   . ., 2001. . 2 ( 1907  1917.). . 3047, 182, 246256, 322325.




77


.    . .; ., 1948.




78


KennedyM.L. The Jacobin Clubs in the French Revolution. Princeton, 1988.




79


 -. ,  19061924. ., 2002. . 2224.




80


 -. ,  19061924. ., 2002. . 83.




81


Bottomore T. Marxism and Sociology // A History of Sociological Analysis. London, Heinemann, 1978. P. 118148; Kolakowski L. Hauptstr?mungen des Marxismus. Entstehung. Entwicklung. Zerfall. M?nchen; Z?rich, 1981. Bd 13.




82


LithL.T. Lenin Rediscovered: What is to be done? In Context. Leiden, 2006. Haimson L. Lenins Revolutionary Career Revised. Some Observations on Recent Discussions // Kritika: Explorations in Russian and European History. Bloomington, 2004. Vol. V. P. 5580.




83


.. . . 41. . 70.




84


..   //      . ., 2008. . 259263.




85


Mannheim K. Ideology and Utopia. Introduction to the Sociology of Knowledge. L., 1949. P. 131.




86


..      //  . 2011. 1. . 327;  .    :         //  . 2012. 3. . 318;  .        1917  //  . 2007. 5. . 330.




87


The Russian Revolution of 1905: Centenary Perspectives. L., 2005; Haimson L. Russias Revolutionary Experience, 19051917: Two Essays. N.Y., 2005.




88


100- :     . 19092009.   //  . 2009. 6.




89


..      :   //  19051907 :   :     1920  2005. ., 2005.




90


Social Identities in Revolutionary Russia. N.Y., 2001.




91


Halfn G. From Darkness to Light: Class, Consciousness and Salvation in Revolutionary Russia. Pittsburgh, 2000.




92


KellyA.M. Toward Another Shore: Russian Thinkers between Necessity and Chance. New Haven, 1998.




93


Morrissey S. Heralds of Revolution: Russian Students and the Mythologies of Radicalism. N.Y.; Oxford, 1998.




94


Waldron P. The End of Imperial Russia, 18551997. Basingstoke, 1997; Longworth Ph. Russias Empires: Their Rise and Fall: From Prehistory to Putin. L., 2005.




95


Moon D. The Problem of Social Stability in Russia, 15981998 // Reinterpreting Russia. L., 1999. P. 5474.




96


Lohr E. Nationalizing the Russian Empire: The Campaign against Enemy Aliens during World War I. L.; Cambridge, 2003.




97


FullerW.C. The Foe Within: Fantasies of Treason and the End of Imperial Russia. Ithaca, 2006.




98


Price M.Ph. Dispatches from Revolutionary Russia, 19151918. Durham, 1998.




99


    .    V        1917.  //  . ., 1991. . I. . 191204.




100


   1919 .   -   . .. //  . ., 1992. . IIIII. . 362384.




101


 .   . ., 1998. . 2. . 212.




102


  17 .      19051915. ., 1996. . 1. . 279.




103


 - .   . ., 2003. . 115.




104


..     (19171932) //   . ., 2009. . 359.




105


 .   . .,1998. . 2. . 619.




106


..       19141916. //  . 1992. . IIIII. . 291.




107


  ,  , .    19061916. ., 2002. . 392394.




108


   - . ., 1997. . 2. . 260261, 268, 270275.




109


   - . ., 1998. . 3 (19151920). . 297.




110


 -.   . ., 2000. . 3. . 1 (  1917.). . 24.




111


.   . 18941921. ., 2010. . 418.




112


.. . . 30. . 328.




113


. . . ., 2006.




114


.    .       (17891804). ., 1902.




115


..   . ., 1895. . 12; ..  1848   . ., 1908. . 12; ..   . ., 1918;  .      1848. ., 1917.




116


..           . ., 1906. . 13.




117


..   . ., 1924.




118


.    . ., 19771983. . 16.




119


.         17891794. .; ., 1923.




120


Furet F. Penser la Rvolution Fran?aise. Paris, 1978; KimmelM.S. Revolution. A Sociological Interpretation. L., 1990; Krejci J. Great Revolutions Compared. The Outline of a Theory. L., 1994.




121


Davidson Ph. Propaganda and the American Revolution 17631783. Chapel Hill, 1941.




122


..  . ., 2002. . 129.




123


.   . ., 1859.




124


Dictionnaire Critique de la Rvolution Fran?aise. Sous la direction de F. Furet et M. Ozouf. P., 1992. Vol. 14.




125


Gerard A. La revolution Fran?aise. Muthes et interprtation (17891970). P., 1970. P. 53.




126


Burke E. Reflections on the Revolution in France // The Writings and Speeches of Edmund Burke. Vol. VIII (The French Revolution. 17901794). Oxford, 1989.




127


.  . ., 2000. . 26.




128


.: Kenez P. The Birth of the Propaganda State: Soviet Methods of Mass Mobilization, 19171929. Cambridge, 1985.




129


.  . 17921804. ., 1974; .  .   , 1995.




130


 : ..     . ., 1966.




131


.    . ., 1918;  .     . ., 1922.




132


.   . ., 1925.




133


   .:  .   .     . , 1922.




134


..       //    . ., 2004. . 4.




135


Totalitarismus in 20. Jahrhundert: Eine Bilanz der internazionale Forschung. Baden-Baden, 1996.




136


Swain G. The Origins of the Russian Civil War. L.; N.Y., 1996.




137


GaddyC.G. The Price of Past: Russias Struggle with the Legacy of Militarised Economy. Washington, 1996.




138


       : Maistre J.de. Considrations sur la France. Essai sur le Principe gnrateur des Constitutions politiques. Prface du Comte B. de Vesins. Paris, 1907. P. 95.




139


    .:   . ., 2001.




140


.    (). .; ., 1925. . 12. . 113.




141


.    -  (  ). .; ., 1923. . VIII (    ). . 256.




142


..     XIXXX. ., 1924.




143


.      (   ). .; ., 1926. . 26.




144


SorokinP.A. The Sociology of Revolution. London, 1924. . 367;  .  . . ., 1992.




145


   .:   . .:   , 2000;  /  . ... .: , 2003; . ., 2005; ..  . ., 2006. . 3.




146


..    //  ,    , 18591929. , 1929. . 32.




147


..  . 19171923. ., 1990. . 12.




148


Toynbee A. Looking Back // The Impact of the Russian Revolution. 19171967. The Influence of Bolshevism on the World outside Russia. London, N.Y., 1967. P. 17.




149


The Soviet Union. The Fifty Years. Ed. By H. Salisbury. N.Y., 1967; Marxism, Communism and Western Society. A Comparative Encyclopedia. N.Y., 1973. Vol. 7; The Russian Revolution and the Soviet State. 19171921. Documents. Selected and Edited by Mc Cauley. L., 1975; Brown D. Doomsday 1917. The Destruction of the Russian Ruling Class. L., 1975.




150


.  . ., 1994. . 12.




151


..     1917  30- . ., 1981.




152


 1917 :    (    2223  1988.) / . . -.   ... ., 1989. . 13.




153


 1917 :    (    2223  1988.) / . . -.   ... ., 1989. . 3139.




154


 90-    :   //  . 2007. 6.




155


     :   //  . 2007. 6.




156


..    .         //  . 2012. . 33. . 147159.




157


.    . ., 2007.




158


.  .     . ., 2010.




159


Linz J., Stepan A. Problems of Democratic Transition and Consolidation. Southern Europe, South America, and Post-Communist Europe. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1996; Democratic Transition and Consolidation in Southern Europe, Latin America and Southeast Asia. Ed. by D. Ethier. London: Macmillan Press, 1999; Transiciones y Dise?os Institucionales. Maria del Refugio Gonzalez, Sergio Lopez Ayllon (Ed.) Mexico: Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico, 2000.




160


     . XVIIIXX . ., 2001;   :   -        . ., 2006.




161


Autorit?re Regime in Ostmittel und S?dosteuropa 1919-1944 / Hrsg. von E. Oberl?nder in Zsarb. mit R. Ahmann et al. Paderborn etc.: Sch?ning, 2001;     .   , ,    . , 1996.




162


   :   . ., 1996;    : . ., 1997; 1917    . ., 1998;        . ., 2005;  //   XVIII  XX . ., 2005. .383385.




163


.  .     . ., 2003.




164


..   . ., 2005.




165


..      . ., 2002.




166


.    . ., 1905.




167


.    .       (17891804). ., 1902.




168


Furet F. La Rvolution Fran?aise. Paris, 1988. Vo l. 12.




169


..   :     . ., 1998.




170


..   . ., 1994;  .   :    XIX  XX. ., 2010.




171


.   (  ). , 1931. . 195.




172


.. Deux rvolutions. P., 1921.




173


..   (1925-1935). ., 2004. . 242; .    //  . 1922. . IX. .269293.




174


        23  1906. //    . 1906. . 1.




175


  II. 1890-1906. ., 1991. . 88, 249.




176


 19051907.   (  ..) //  . ., 1994. . V. . 374.




177


..  .   . ., 2003. . 12; .. . ., 2004.




178


 . ., 1905; ..    . ., 1906; ..   . ., 1908; ..     . ., 1908; ..   (  ). . ., 1909; ..     . ., 1912; ..  :  - . ., 1907;  .     . ., 1912; ..   . ., 1917. : ..   :     . ., 1998.




179


   - . ., 1998. . 3. . 328.




180


..  . ., 1990. . 215.




181


  II //  II.  . . ., 1927. . 223; The Russian Provisional Government. 1917. Documents. Selected and edited by R.P. Browder and A. F. Kerensky. Stanford, California, 1961. Vol. IIII;   1917 . .   . ., 1996; : .  . ., 2006.




182


..   (). ., 1991; .   //   ,  ... , 1920. . 1. . 996.




183


. .      . 19801917. ., 2006. . 324.




184


..   1917 . , 1961. . 357.




185


..    . ., 2001. . 51. . : .        .. //  . 1927. . XXXII. . 434452.




186


  :          //  55 (3797)  5 (18)  1917. . 2    (      6  1917.) //  56 (3798) (, 7 (20)  1917.). . 2.


