 : 
  


           -         .        ,         ;       ;    ,    ;               .              ,        .    , , ,      ,      .





 : 

  .. 



:

 ..             ,   , 

 ..   -           ,   , 



ARBITRAL PROCEDURE

TEXTBOOK



Executive editor T.I. Otcheskaya

Moscow

YUSTITSINFORM

2017



Reviewers:

Usmanova L.F.  Professor of Civil Law and Civil Procedure Department of the Institute of State and Law of the Tyumen State University, Doctor of Law, Professor

Astakhova M.A.  Head of the Civil Law Subjects Department of the Moscow Institute of State Management and Law (Tyumen branch), PhD, Associate Professor



rbitral procedure: textbook / group of authors; executive editor T.I. Otcheskaya  M.: Yustitsinform, 2017. 500 .

978-5-7205-1369-6



This textbook contains main points of arbitral procedural law taking into account the recent procedural and institutional changes in Arbitration Court system of the Russian Federation and their jurisdiction.

The authors focus on subjects of competence of arbitration tribunals, preparations for the hearings and stages of arbitration; peculiarities of curtain types of arbitration cases; proceedings of court of appellate jurisdiction, court of cassation, court of supervision; effectuation of retrial of enforceable court ruling on the basis of new or newly discovered circumstances.

This textbook provides variants of solutions of complicated law enforcement matters on the basis of legal positions and legal approaches made by arbitration court of appellate jurisdiction, court of cassation and court of supervision.

This textbook is for students, graduates, postgraduates, and also for practicing lawyers and all those interested in the problems of arbitral procedural law.



Keywords: concept of arbitral procedure and arbitral procedural law, competence of arbitration tribunals, participants of arbitral procedure, representation in arbitration tribunal, evidences and proving in arbitral procedure, procedural terms, court costs, conciliatory procedures, writ proceedings.

 LLC Yustitsinform, 2017



 :

  ,   , :  2, 3, 9;    ..  1, 5, 6, 12, 14;  ..  10, 11, 13, 15;  ..  16, 18, 19;  ..  4, 7, 8. 19

  ,   :  1, 5, 6, 12, 14 (   ..)

  , \  :  10, 11, 13, 15 (   ..)

  ,   :  16, 18, 19 (   ..)

   ,   :  4, 7, 8, 19 (   ..)



Authors:

Otcheskaya T.I., Doctor of Law, Professor: Chapters 2, 3, 9; coauthored with Volodina D.V.: Chapters 1, 5, 6, 12, 14; with Dorkina A.V. Chapters 10, 11, 13, 15; with I.E. Otcheskiy  Chapters 16, 18, 19; with Shevtsov A.V. Chapters 4, 7, 8. 19

Volodina D.V., PhD: Chapters 1, 5, 6, 12, 14 (co-authored with Otcheskaya T.I.)

Dorkina A.V., PhD: Chapters 10, 11, 13, 15 (co-authored with Otcheskaya T.I.)

Otcheskiy I.E., PhD: Chapters 16, 18, 19 (co-authored with Otcheskaya T.I.)

Shevtsov A.V., PhD: Chapters 4, 7, 8, 19 (co-authored with Otcheskaya T.I.)







              .

    ,         , ,  ,          ,    ,   - .

                  .         .

                 .

   ,     ,      90-  XX.           .

                      .

      ,     ,  ,   .             .

          ,            ,           .

   ,            .

      .       2002.       .

                     ,     6  2014.         .

       ,        .

  ,  ,    ,              [1 - .:    :  /  . .. , .. . .: , 2013. . 320.].

   ,   ,        -         ,       .

   ,       ,   [2 - .:     ..   VIII    18.12.2012. //http://www.ssrf.ru/menu/27.].

            .

               ,       .

       ,     .

 ,              , , , ,  ,   ,    .                         .

           .



    

 

  ,

 .. 




 


       .

      .

       .

      .        .

     - .         .

      .       .

  - .

   .

   .

   .

    .

. .

. .

.  .

.  .

.  .

. .




 1

      .    


     2002 ,           , ,            ,          .

                     .

             ,    .          ,       ,  .

    ,            ,            .

      1993.,     (   ),                      (  2002.),           ,   -   .








             5  2014. -     . ,           ,                   ,        .

       ,  ,            ,           ,      .

                .



 

            ,        , -,       



             ,     ( )    ,  


    ,       ,    ,                   .              .



   

        ,    ,    ,     ,      


                  .

 ,             .

      ,      , ,   ,    ,   .








              :

1)   ;

    ;

       .

              .

           , ..    ,         .



  :

 

 

  ,       

 

     ()

 

 

      

 



 

  ,             ,         (. II  )




  ,       

1)         ,            ;

2)     ,    ()  ,   ,     ;

3)   ;

4)      




 

  ,        ,    (. 27  ),         ,       


           ()   - (. 28  ).

        . 1. 33       (. 28.1  );       ,      ,  ;  ,    ,                    ;  ,           ,   ,  , , ,     ,  ,    ;         ,       ,    ,           . 4. 34  ;          .

      ,    (. 29  ).                     .

  1  2016.        ,      . 29.1  ,      2  2016. 47-.

-       .

      ,  :

1)             ,   ,   ,   ,         ;

2)        ,     ,         ;

3)       ,               .

                      (. 30  ),               (. 31  ), ,         (. Ill  ).



   

   ,             


       , , ,  ,           .

           .

   ,       ,              . , ,       , ..  ,     1950- .

    .             19701980- .

          :      ,   ,   ,    ,      .

?       ,  ,    ,    .

    ,  ,      ,   .

  ,         ,          ,     :

  ;

10    (  );

21   ;

85    ;

1    (   ).

      .

           21  2014. 6-                               .

,       (83)  .     .  (84)[3 - .:   23  2014. 154-                         //   . 2014. 26 (. I). . 336.],     ,     . [4 - .:   23  2014. 10-                      //   . 2014. 26 (. I). . 3359.].

   ( )           ,   ,             ,   .             ,        .

             ,                  ,   ,           ,   ,      .

            ,        .

              ,        .

        ,   .          (. [5 - .:      22  2012. 17          //   . 2012. 8. . .])   ,        ,     ,       .

       ,    .  ,      ,        Ի.

   ,         ;     ()    ;        ;     ;     ;   ,    .

          , ,  ,   ,        ;        , ,        ,   .

             .      .           .       -              .

          .

         ,     - .          .

               ,             .



  :

  

  

    

    

  

  



   

     ,        


   (. 2 ):

        ,      ,       ,  ,         ,    ,     ,   ,  ,     

         

     

    

      

           

      ,      

        ,   ,                .

 ,     . 1. 11                     ,        ,  , .     ,      ,    ,              .

 ,                , :

                         ;

             .

               ,      , ..     .

           . 47  ,    . 6        ,         30  1998. 54-              .

          . 2                           .

           ,                .

   . 2                      .

  -         ,          ,            ,      ,        .

  ,         ,        (. 46  ),         .

         ,                 ,           ,             ,   ,    ;      . .

    ,                (. 48  ).   . 59                ,  , ,       ,                  .            ,    ,   ,    ,          . .

          ,   .

             ,             (,        . .),             ,         .

    ,          . 2. 333.22        ,   ,           .

                 (. 3. 2 )     . 6       .

 . 6 ,                      ,    .        .            ,          (. 21  ).

     ,    ,              ,         ,                 ,              .

             (. 9 )    (. 8 ),     ,   ,    (. 41, 65, 66, 133, 135, 156, 158, 159  ).

        ,          ,      ,      .

          .  . 11           ,       .

 . 5, . 2. 67, . 167  .       . ,        ,         .         ,   .    ,                      [6 - .:     //  .].

          ,            ,   ,     .

            .      ,             ,       .

,   ,        ,      ,   ,     .            ,   ,     ,       .

        ,   ,             .

 . 4                 .

                        ,   .

 ,   ,        .

   2002.       ,          . ,  . 3. 5  ,        ,    .

 . 18   ,                ,      ,     .

        .

      :

        ,    ;

   ,       ,     (),    ,        ,   ;

          ,     ,       ;

                .

                 ,          .

      ,    ,        ,      ,        ,      .

        ,               (. 17, 46  ).     :            (. 4 ).

                                  .

                  ?      ?

           ,      .             .

           ,         ,            .

   ,            :

)          ,  ;

)     ;

)     ;

)    .

             ,    ,   ,    ,         ,      , ..    (. 167  ),         (. 148  )        (. 150  ).

                      ,        ,     ,   . 5 6 . 148  ,    . 6. 4 .

                .

, ,    26  2002. 127-   () (    ) ,             (. 3. 33   ).

       ,        (. 6. 4 , . 2. 1, . 5   24  2002. 102-      ).

 . 6, 6.1, 7, 8, 10. 11, 12           ,       ;      ;  ;   ;   .

 . 9     .       ,   ,         .   ,  ,   ,           .

 . 9           ,     ,   ,             ,   ,         .

 ,   ,          ,  ,     ,       ,      ,         ,   ,    ,   ,       (. 125, 126  ).

             ,    ,    .          (. 128  )  ,          .            ,     (. 131  ),           .

        ,         ,      ,             ..

  ,         ,  ,   ,        ,       .

        ,        ,                          (. 124  )[7 - .:  ..  :     //    . 2009. 3. . 94.]. ,                ,  ,       ,   .

      .

        ,   ,   ,    ,    ,     ,     (  ,  ,  ,  ,    . .).

 , ,   ,     ,       ,     ,  ,    ,  ,  ,     ,      ..

          ,   ,   .

           ,   ,      ,            ,          ,   ,       .

 . 3. 9          .             ,          ,             .

 ,        ,   ,    ,   .         , ,     ,   ,         ,     ,    ,    .

   ,       ,      ,          ,     ,              .




 2

  


,                  .





,         ,       ,          


      . 27       1 . 4 .

 . 1. 27  ,            ,        , ..             .  ,       ,       , ..    ,      .

?                     ,  . 46           .

 ,        . 13  ,  ,   ,         ,       .                         ,   [8 - .:        4  2000.     ;  22  2009.       ( 21851(3)).].

      ,          ,  ,             . 1. 27     . 3. 22  .

           ,   , ,            ,   ,       ,   ,  ,  ,  ,   ,  ,  , ,     ,  ,     .

     ,  .. [9 - .:  ..       . ., 1997. . 280.]:



 

  ,     ,                   ,             () 


    ,           ,    ,         (. 1. 27  ).      ,          .

?      . 3. 1. 2 :



 

,     ,    ,    ,  ,      ,        


     , -,   ,     ,        [10 - .:  ..      . ., 2003. . 88.].

   . 3. 27             ,    . 1. 27  , .

    . 4. 29  . 1. 213               ,      ,         .

       (. 58.6      5,    29  26  2009.   ,             ).

     ( )          (. 3. 23.1),      (. 14.1, 14.1014.14  .),    (. 15.10),    (. 19.19)  .

,      , ,  ,          ,      ,           ,     ,    ,        (. 5. 27  ).    ,         ,      ,  ,     ,     ,    . 1. 1. 150  .

         ,  ,    ,  ,  ,   ,   ,    ,       .

   . 28                  ,             ,   ,       ,    .

,     . 28    ,  :          ,    ?

        ,             ,     .          ,    ,     ,      ,    [11 - .:  .. . . . 9495;             /  . .. . ., 2013. . 2223.].

. 28       ,   ,    ,                ,   . 27  .           ,      . 8 .

?  . 1. 8 ,       ,      ,        ,         ,              .



    :

1.    ,  ,       ,     ,    ;

2.    ,  ;

3.       ,           ;

4.  ,     ;

5.     ,  ;

6.    , , ,      ;

7.    ;

8.  ;

9.      ;

10. ,          - 



             ,     ,                    (. 2 )[12 - .:  .. . . . 95.].

      ,      (,    ,      ).     ,         ,      ,       .

     . 29               (  ,    ,    )     ,           :

1)        ,                ;

2)      ,       ,                ;

3)                 ,    ()  ,   ,  , ,         ,  ;

4)  ,          ;

5)     ,      ,  , ,         ;

6) ,       ,          .

     :

1)      ,        ;

2)           ,        .

   . 31                     ,        .



    (. 1. 33  ):

1.  ();

2. ,    225.1  ;

3.      ,      , ;

4. ,    ,                    ;

5. ,           ,   ,  , , ,     ,  ,    ;

6.        ,       ,    ,           . 4. 34  ;

7.          ;

8. ,        ,  ,   



?               :

1)  (  )         ;

2)        ;

3)         ,    ,    .

              .



 ,   

     ,    .

        [13 - .:  ..,  ..      : - . .: , 2011. 120 .]:





      ,      


    ,                [14 - .:  ..         //  . 2011.].








       ,     .

 ,       (  ).

    ,   . 1. 34  , ,   ,       , , ,   ,  ,   (     ),   ,           .

   . 4. 34            :

1)         ,                ,            ,     ,     (-),      , , ,   ,         ;

1.1)                 ,     ,     (-),      , , ,   ,         ,       ;

2)                ,     ,     (-),      , , ,   ,         ,       ;

3)                   , , ,    (      ,   ),   :

    ,    ()       ,           ,   ,           ;

          ,          , , ,   ;

  ;

     ,  ,     ,       ,            ,          ;

         .

         .

                .

     . 36        ( ).

,   ,     ,  ,                         (. 1. 36  ).

      ,              .

  . 38      :

1)              ;

2)       ,   ,           ;

3)  ,     ,    ,     ,      ,        ;

3.1)   ,   ,   ,   ,      ,   ,  ,   ,   ,      ;         ;

4)            ;

4.1)      ,   . 225.1  ,         ,   . 225.1  ;

5)   ,   ,           ,      ,     ,       ,         ;

6)      ()               ;

7)     ,         ,             -;

8)     ,                  ,      .

9)               ,       ,              ,        ,     ;

10)              .

  . 38        .

   . 38   ,      ,   ,    .

              . 39  .

, ,          ,      ,           (. 1. 39  ).

             , :

1),     ,     ,                (. 1. 2. 39  );

2)            (. 2. 2. 39  );

3)     ,           (. 3. 2. 39  );

4)      ,  ,   ,     .

,       ,      ,    .            (. 4. 39  ).




 3

  


      . 5 ,          9  2002. 11   ,       Ի,  20  2006. 65      ,  30  2009. 32   ,      ,      (),  28  2009. 36            ,  23  2009. 57       ,        ,  17  2011. 12            27  2010. 228-      Ԕ,  22  2012. 35    ,      ,  12  2012. 42     ,   ,      10,    22  29  2010.   ,       ,         ,      25  2012. 223       ,          13  2004. 82,  22  2005. 99,  9  2010. 143,  31  2011. 145.








      -  .



 

          ;       




 

        ;         ,        


              , ,   .

               (  ,  ,  ,         )               .



?        .  ,      ,   .



   ,         ,    ,       ,   .








       :

   ,    ,  ;

 ;

     ,      ,    ;

    ,  , ,   ,           ;

  ,   ,   ,   ,   ;

  ,   ,   ,             ;

  ;

       ,   ,         ;

   

? ,   ,       .

        .

          .

, ,                       ,   [15 - .:  ..    //  . 2002. 5. . 4852.].

        .








 , . 2. 31      ,   (  )            .   ,  ,  .   ,  ,     [16 - .: -        / . ..   .. . ., 2001. . 99100.].








? ,    ,          ,     ,         ,   .       ,   .

   . 46                 ( ).



   :

      ()     ;

  ()        ;

      

             .          .

        ,           .

                             .

              ,    ,       ,                .

    ,          .           ,       ,   ,  ,        ,     .

    ,            .

             ,  ,   .

-,   . 46        .

-,       ,   

        ,            .

-,  . 53        . 2,                .

  ,   ,   .








                       .

            ,   ,  ,         ,     .



 (. 45  )

  ,                  ;        


 ,   ,  ,                   .     ,      ,       . ,    ,        .               ,     .

        . 40  52  .



     

      ,          ,   ,               ;

     ,        ,   ,     ,  ,    ,    ()     ,    ,    ;

      ,          ,   ,               ;

           



           ,                      (. 1 2 . 52  ).

     (  )                 .

 . 5. 52     ,      ,   ,           ,   ,    .

,   ,       (. 3. 52  ).

     ,     ,        ,         .      ,        -    .

 ,                 ,         ,    .

 ,  ,     ,   ,        ,     (. 3. 125  ).

?               .           .    ,     ,      (. 4. 52  ).

       .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/kollektiv-avtorov/arbitrazhnyy-process-uchebnik/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


.:    :  /  . .. , .. . .: , 2013. . 320.




2


.:     ..   VIII    18.12.2012. //http://www.ssrf.ru/menu/27.




3


.:   23  2014. 154-                         //   . 2014. 26 (. I). . 336.




4


.:   23  2014. 10-                      //   . 2014. 26 (. I). . 3359.




5


.:      22  2012. 17          //   . 2012. 8. . .




6


.:     //  .




7


.:  ..  :     //    . 2009. 3. . 94.




8


.:        4  2000.     ;  22  2009.       ( 21851(3)).




9


.:  ..       . ., 1997. . 280.




10


.:  ..      . ., 2003. . 88.




11


.:  .. . . . 9495;             /  . .. . ., 2013. . 2223.




12


.:  .. . . . 95.




13


.:  ..,  ..      : - . .: , 2011. 120 .




14


.:  ..         //  . 2011.




15


.:  ..    //  . 2002. 5. . 4852.




16


.: -        / . ..   .. . ., 2001. . 99100.


