  :     
 


    ,   .      ,   ,  ,    ,     .                    ,       . 젖   ,  ,    ,  ,  ,   蠖   .   ,   ,   .





 

  :     








  

  

  . 

- . 

 . , . 

  . 

   The Granger Collection / Alamy Stock Photo



 Massimo Pigliucci, 2017

This edition published by arrangement with The Science Factory, Louisa Pritchard Associates and The Van Lear Agency LLC.

    , , .   -, 2018



  .      .                        ,         ,           .             5.  (. 49 ),            6  (. 146  ).


* * *


  ,        .       ,   .  ,   , ,    ,   







 1

,    


		    ,
		    ,
		     .

.  . .  [1 -  . .]

      ,   :  ?      ?           ? , ,       ?

         ,          .              ,       .          ,  ,  -          .                ,      .

   ,     ,    ,           .         -- ,            ࠖ  .    ,     ,  ,  ,     .   ,     ,       ,  ,            (,   ).

    .   ,     ,  - .        (            ),            .    젖      ,   ,           .   ,     ,   :     ,        .    ,     :    ,   ,       .     ,   젖        ,      ,     .

         ,      蠖 .   (       )            ,     .         ,   ,        :    ,      .                       .

        ,     ,      . ,  ,  ,    堖       .     ,             ,       ,           .

     ,         ( )       ( ).         :           (Answers for Aristotle: How Science and Philosophy Can Lead Us to a More Meaningful Life),    ,   -   .   ࠖ      (           )          ,  ,   ,    ,       .  ,           .

       ,     .  ,      .               (Why I Am Not a Christian),     , -                     . ,              .      ,  젖      ,       .         ࠖ        .                   .     (    )      ,   ,    .            ,           :     [1 -     :  , II.12.           : http://classics.mit.edu/Epictetus/discourses.html (http://classics.mit.edu/Epictetus/discourses.html);       () ,   135 ,       : http://classics.mit.edu/Epictetus/epicench.html (http://classics.mit.edu/Epictetus/epicench.html). [       ,  , 1997 ,    . . . . .]],      : "   , ?   ?",  ,        ,    . -       ,      .

,        ,     ,   ()   .      ,       ,      ,      .          ,        ,            (, ,       ).  ,     ,    :        .  ,      ,       ,    ,            . ,      ,   ,    ,   .

     ,    ,             .   ,         .      :       ,        .      ,   ,      (      ,       ,        ,     ).

  ࠖ  ()  ,          .              . ?       ,           (   ).        . , ,           ,            .              :   [2 -   :  , I.27.]    ,     ?

  蠖     ,     :              ,     .    50 ,  ,        :     ?   ,      ,        .  ,            .        ,            ,        .          ,     ,     ,              .  ,   ,          ,     ,   .

,      ,          .    [3 -    셻:     .  XXIV (Seneca, Complete Works, Delphi Classics, 2014, 19). [         ,  -,  . . . . .]],       .          : ,  ,   [4 - ,  ,   : ,     (Seneca, "On Tranquility of Mind", 11).],     .   ⠖  ,    ,   ()   : ,     .        ,        (  ,   ) ,    .   ,         ,      ,   .   ,     ,   ,         .

         ,                     XXI .           [5 -  :      (      -)     http://modernstoicism.com/ (http://modernstoicism.com/).        STOICON,    : http://modernstoicism.com/stoicon-media/ (http://modernstoicism.com/stoicon-media/).]     - ,       ,          .  ,              ,         ,  ,         .      (            ?   ),   . ,       9%-   , 11%-     14%-        . (   ,       ,      ,  .) 56%   ,      . ,       ,               .   ,   ,     ,             ,        .

     ,  젖       ,        --   .   ,     ꠖ   [6 -    ꠖ   䅻:    : Robert Epstein, "The Prince of Reason," Psychology Today, 1  2001 .]       .    ,       ,         "!".    (Man's Search for Meaning)[2 -  .   "!".   . :.  -, 2017.].                  .  ,           ,       .                  (In Love and War) -    ࠖ ,          - .  ,    ( ,   )          .             -  ().       ,         .      (Cognitive Therapy of Depression)      , ,     [7 -    腻:  , . ,         (Aaron T. Beck, A. John Rush, Brian F. Shaw, and Gary Emery, Cognitive Therapy of Depression, New York: Guilford Press, 1987, 8).]    .

   : 젖  ,    ,     .  ,        ,      , ,       (         ).    蠖  ,        ,       ,   .      ,     .      ,   ,            .      ,              .

,      ,     .    ,     ,    . ,       ,    ,           .                  ,          .    젖     :     ,   ,   ,                軠     .

            ,   (, ,   )    (,     ).  ,  ,     ,  ,                .          ,       .            頖   .     ,     ,   . 堖 ,               (  ),            .

,      ,        .

    ,       ,   ,          ( ).           ,      :   ?   ,   ,         (), ,    ( ),     ().

   ,   ,    ,     . ,          (A Guide to the Good Life)       ( )  ,     [8 -    : William Irvine, A Guide to the Good Life (New York: Oxford University Press, 2008).]  ,        .           ,            ,    ,      - .  ,             .     ,         . ,   ,      [9 - ,   ,      : , -  ,       , ,             .           . ,     ,    ,     (  !)    .]       ,     .

        ࠖ    ,      ,      .          (,    )          .      , ,      [10 - ,      养:     .  XXXIII (Seneca, Complete Works, Delphi Classics, 2014, 11).] [ ],   ,   .    ,    .      .                .

    ,          ,        . 젖  ,          ,   ,         . ,    ,           ,    .

   :       ,           ,    ,             .        ,      ,      ,  ,   . ,     ()   .    ,              . ,    ,   ,    ,   ࠖ   .   ,   ,          .  ,        - ,          .

    (   )  55 .    :    ,    ,        ; ,      , -     .    ,     ( ),      .                    頖   [11 -       頖   :       -.              (Cynthia King, Musonius Rufus: Lectures and Sayings, ed. by William B. Irvine).].

    68       (            ),        ,     93 .            .            ,    .         ,        .      (   ࠖ    ),  ,        .

           - 蠖 ,  ,     ,        (  ,  , , ,     [12 -   , ,     :         .      ,          .    ,      .     ,   167 ,       ,   : http://classics.mit.edu/Antoninus/meditations.html (http://classics.mit.edu/Antoninus/meditations.html).]).      ,    :      ,       蠖        (     ).       ,               .    ,        ,        (     ).    135 .

    ?  ,     ,    ,    ,       ,           (   ), 80- . ,   :  , ,   , -          .          ,     -,   ,      ,                                  ,   II     - XXI .

,       ,       .       ,  ,      ,   ,  ,  ,      ,   (  )    .           ⠖   ,     ,        ,           ,          .          :     ?




 2

  :  


  ,          ?

 , I. 4

   ,      .   ,   ,     ,  ࠖ        .        ,         ,      .         .  ,                 (    ,     ),      ,         . ,        ,          , ,     ,       .

     ,     ,       300    .        [13 -        :    ,     ,  VII.1 (Diogenes Laertius, Lives of the Eminent Philosophers, VII.12; https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Lives_of_the_Eminent_Philosophers (https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Lives_of_the_Eminent_Philosophers)). [        ,     ,  , , 1986 ,  . . . . .]] ( ), ,   ,        ,        ,       .     30    ,        ,      .              ,     ,      ,    ,  .       - .      :     .     ,    ,         ,      . ,         ,   . ,         ,     .      ,   ,     :    , ?       !         ,     .

      , ,            (       ),     .          , , , , , ,     . ( ,      ,          .)      ,    ,  98 ,      .    ,    ,  頖  ,       ,    .

         ,        ࠖ    .         .      ,      [14 -      :          . , ,     ,   ,     ,        .].   ,          (    : 705 !) ,   ,    ,    .    :   [15 -   :    ,     ,  VII.5.],     .         ,    .

,     .           ,     ,   ⠖   (       ).            ,   ,  ( ) ,  ,  .          !  ,  ,    ,           .      (,   ), 堖   (, ),     ()     ().        .

   155    ,        [16 -  155    ,        : : David Sedley, "The School, from Zeno to Arius Didymus," in The Cambridge Companion to the Stoics, edited by Brad Inwood (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2003).]:   (   ),       ,        .   ,               ,    ,   .      .

    ,     ,        ,      .      -            .

,  88?86    ,     ,     ,      (  :    !),    :        ,         .         ,             ,           ࠖ  ,      .

         .                 ,    .         .   ,                 .        ,      ( ),  (  ),  ,   -  .

    312   , ,      ,    .        529           -  .         ,     .         ,     , ,  ,  ,  ,  , ,  ,  ,   .            .    ,    ,     ,       , --        - .

           (,      ).         ,     :   (  )  ,    :   (    )     (          ).        .

           : ,   .  ,           ,      .               ,    (     )   . (   ,         ,       .)          ,          ( ,        ).          ( ),  (          )   ( ,    ,      ).

     . ,       ,      ,     .       ,     .                   ?           .      ?thos,     ,      moralis,   , .       moralis        ?thos! ,     ,           ,     .

   ,    .      :      ,    ,    .    ,           .     ,    ,    .  ,        ,    ,   .    ,     .

           :



  [17 -   :  , III.2.],       ,     : ,    ,  ,        ,       ; ,    , ,  ,  ,    , , ; 頖  ,    ,  , .


     :  ,     .       ,      (     )  .



[18 - .2.1:            (Donald Robertson, Stoicism and the Art of Happiness: Ancient Tips for Modern Challenges, Teach Yourself, 2013).  ,   ,        :    (Pierre Hadot, The Inner Citadel: The Meditations of Marcus Aurelius, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1998).]






          ,    .   (   ) ,       . ,   ,    ,       ,    .       ,  ,   .  ,   ,   ,   ,     (   ).         :  (       )   (        ,  ).   (    ,     )     .      ,   ,    .     . ,   (  ) ,     ,           ,   .      蠖          ,  .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/massimo-piluchchi/kak-byt-stoikom-antichnaya-filosofiya-i-sovremennaya-zhi/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes









1


 . .




2


 .   "!".   . :.  -, 2017.










1


    :  , II.12.           : http://classics.mit.edu/Epictetus/discourses.html (http://classics.mit.edu/Epictetus/discourses.html);       () ,   135 ,       : http://classics.mit.edu/Epictetus/epicench.html (http://classics.mit.edu/Epictetus/epicench.html). [       ,  , 1997 ,    . . . . .]




2


  :  , I.27.




3


   셻:     .  XXIV (Seneca, Complete Works, Delphi Classics, 2014, 19). [         ,  -,  . . . . .]




4


,  ,   : ,     (Seneca, "On Tranquility of Mind", 11).




5


 :      (      -)     http://modernstoicism.com/ (http://modernstoicism.com/).        STOICON,    : http://modernstoicism.com/stoicon-media/ (http://modernstoicism.com/stoicon-media/).




6


   ꠖ   䅻:    : Robert Epstein, "The Prince of Reason," Psychology Today, 1  2001 .




7


   腻:  , . ,         (Aaron T. Beck, A. John Rush, Brian F. Shaw, and Gary Emery, Cognitive Therapy of Depression, New York: Guilford Press, 1987, 8).




8


   : William Irvine, A Guide to the Good Life (New York: Oxford University Press, 2008).




9


,   ,      : , -  ,       , ,             .           . ,     ,    ,     (  !)    .




10


,      养:     .  XXXIII (Seneca, Complete Works, Delphi Classics, 2014, 11).




11


      頖   :       -.              (Cynthia King, Musonius Rufus: Lectures and Sayings, ed. by William B. Irvine).




12


  , ,     :         .      ,          .    ,      .     ,   167 ,       ,   : http://classics.mit.edu/Antoninus/meditations.html (http://classics.mit.edu/Antoninus/meditations.html).




13


       :    ,     ,  VII.1 (Diogenes Laertius, Lives of the Eminent Philosophers, VII.12; https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Lives_of_the_Eminent_Philosophers (https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Lives_of_the_Eminent_Philosophers)). [        ,     ,  , , 1986 ,  . . . . .]




14


     :          . , ,     ,   ,     ,        .




15


  :    ,     ,  VII.5.




16


 155    ,        : : David Sedley, "The School, from Zeno to Arius Didymus," in The Cambridge Companion to the Stoics, edited by Brad Inwood (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2003).




17


  :  , III.2.




18


.2.1:            (Donald Robertson, Stoicism and the Art of Happiness: Ancient Tips for Modern Challenges, Teach Yourself, 2013).  ,   ,        :    (Pierre Hadot, The Inner Citadel: The Meditations of Marcus Aurelius, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1998).


