 .        
 ظ


 
     ,       .      ,  ,   ,  ,        ,     ,              ;          (,  ,     ).                 .       ,  ,    ,      .     ,      ,        ,  XVIII   .    ,                .  ,   ,              .





 ظ

 :       



 2011 by Nothern Illinois University Press.     Nothern Illinois University Press

 . , . ., 2018

 OOO   , 2018


* * *


		!     ,
		,  ,   .

. .  3,  2 ( . . )









     ,         2000          ,  .  ,             ,            ,     , ,       (Ruins of Modernity),         2010 .              ,     .

         ,       ,       .

-     ,         ,        .    ,    ,  ,  ,         .   ,    ,    .             ,     .       . .       . . , . . , . .             .       . . , . .   . . ,     -. . .      -          .       ,   . .  (  ),   ( )    ( ),         .  ,  ,        ,       ,                   ,     .

    -,        ,     .        ,    ,      .  ,  ,             ,       ,             .         .

             .                  2009 (95)  2003 (59)  .   ,       ,         (Ruins of Modernity),            2010 . ,                  . .  ,      ( , 2008).                  .

               . . ,        .     ,         .  ,            .           .

             ,              ,         !







		 , , !
		   
		 ,  
		 ?  :
		   
		   ;
		     :
		      [1 - Des ruines moi je men moque      (.).].
		  ,  ,
		    
		  ,   .

 [2 -  . .       ,  . :   , 1857. . 102103.  . . ,       .]

 ,       , ,            ,   (1840),       .  ,           ,    ,       ,           .                        .         ,               .           (1848)       ,     ,           ,        ,        :



  ?  ?   ,  -    ,     .       ?       ; -,       ,      ;      -,  ,       ,    ,        ,    [3 -  . .       (1848) //  . .   :  4. . 4. .:  - . . , 1914. . 207.]


              .  ,       ,      . ,         ,    , ,     .         1812 ,  :



 -   :  ,  ?         . -      . ,     - ,      ,    .      :  ,    [4 -  . .    . 206.].


      ,    ,             ,         ,    ,    ,       ,    .

                   .  ,            ,       XVIII , ,       ,       ,         .  1820?        ,        ,  ,  ,   .        ,    .   ,      ,  ?            [5 - .:   . .   , ,     17841788. //  . 1878. 23 (). . 238.        .]. ,         , ,    ,      ,       .       : ,   ,   ,    𻠖    ,        ,      [6 -  . .   . .:  , 1963. . 2. . 55.].         ,     ,     ,                ,     .        ,       ,     .  ,            ,         .               ,         ,   ,    ,     :              .

         [7 -      (modernity)      ,   (modernization);  ,      ,              .         . .: Habermas J. Modernitys Consciousness of Time and Its Need for Self-Reassurance // The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity: Twelve Lectures / Trans. F. G. Lawrence. Cambridge: MIT Press, 1987. P. 122.      (modern)    .: Gumbrecht H. U. Modern, Modernit?t, Moderne // Geschichtliche Grundbegriffe. Stuttgart: Klett-Cotta, 1978. V. 4. P. 93131.    ,        , .: Berman M. All That Is Solid Melts into Air. New York: Verso, 1982. .      : Kangaspuro M., Smith J. (Eds.) Modernisation in Russia since 1900 / Studia Fennica Historica. V. 12. Helsinki: Finnish Literature Society, 2006.].              ,     , ,  ,    ,    .       ,   ,   ,     ,       ,   .                       .                , ,   .                      ,     .       lieux de mmoire[8 -   (.).],       .                , ,      ,      .  , -     ,       .             ,         ( )  [9 -    (supermodernity) .: Aug M. Non-Places: Introduction to an Anthropology of Supermodernity. London: Verso, 1995.].

                . ,           1783   .          ,        ,        :  1917        .             :                    .

       ,     ,         .     ,     ,  ,   ,     ,    :                . ,      ,     ,   :    ,     ,       ;     .              ,        .       ,       ,           ,      .   ,       ,      [10 - .         : Hell J., Sch?nle A. (ds.) Ruins of Modernity. Durham: Duke University Press, 2010; Roth M. S., Lyons C., Merewether Ch. Irresistible Decay. Los Angeles: The Getty Institute, 1997; Woodward Ch. In Ruins. New York: Pantheon Books, 2001; Assmann A., Gomille M., Rippl G. (Hrsg.) Ruinenbilder. M?nchen: Wilhelm Fink Verlag, 2002; Bolz N. (Hrsg.) Ruinen des Denkens. Denken in Ruinen. Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp, 1996.].                      . ,  ,              .

,      ,       .      ,  ,   ,  ,        ,       (    ),              ;          (,  ,     ).                 .       ,  ,    ,       .  ,  ,  ,      ,        ,  XVIII    .    ,                .  ,  ,              .






. 1.  .    , 1979



   ?  ,       ,      ,             .     ,       , ,  ,  ,          .        ,        :     (    )     (    ,        . .   ).    ,    ,      ?    : ,    ,     ,   , -    ,    .     ,    ?

  ,       (,      ,        ),       .      ,    (  ),          .   ,  .           .   ,       - ,     .     ,     ,    ,         ,     ,    [11 -    .: Edensor T. Industrial Ruins: Space, Aesthetics and Materiality. Oxford: Berg, 2005.].  ,      ,   .     ,   ,  ,    ,              ;       ,        -  .


* * *

            ,    .     ,  ,           250 ,  ,  (   )    .             ,        ,       .                     , ,       ,    ,          ,     [12 -  .          / . . . . . .: , 1979. . 80.].   ,       ,    -    ,  ,     ,        ,       ,  ,          [13 -  . . 79.].                 ,      ,    . ,       ,     ,     ,   ,   ,     ,   ,  [14 -  . . 78.].  ,                  [15 -  .],    .   ,    ,      ,      ,          [16 -  . . 79.]. ,   ,          ,       ,    .      ,   ,   [17 -    .: Womersley D. Introduction // Burke E. A Philosophical Enquiry into the Origin of Our Ideas of the Sublime and Beautiful. London: Penguin, 1998. P. XXV.].

      ,    ,       [18 - .:  . . . . 88.].         ,            [19 -           ,         . ,    ,       .          ,      ,  . .: Hartmann P. Du sublime (de Boileau ? Schiller). Strasbourg: Presses universitaires de Strasbourg, 1997. P. 4546.].        [20 -  . . . . 94.].          ,  ,      , ,       ,          [21 -  . . . . 88  9899 .].     ,       .      ,  ,    , ,       .      ,  ,     ,        养     [22 -  . . 74.]. ,         ,           [23 -  1770?  ,     ,   ,        .            .       (/),          .      ,     ,  ,                .                 . .  : White S. K. Edmund Burke: Modernity, Politics, and Aesthetics. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publication, 1994.               . .: Womersley D. Op. cit. P. XXXXVIII.].

           .     , , ,      1666           1750  .  ,       1746 ,      ,    [24 -         :        ,    .           .  ,    ,   ,    , , ,   . . : Ayling S. Edmund Burke: His Life and Opinions. London: Cassell, 1988. P. 6.].       1757 ,     ,      [25 -     ,        ,   1754 .   (1759)      .   ,       腻    10     . .: Boulton J. T. Editors Introduction // Burke E. A Philosophical Enquiry into the Origin of Our Ideas of the Sublime and Beautiful. London: Routledge, 1958. P. XVXXVI.].              1755 .    ,     XVIII .              ,    ,    ,        .

        ,       :      .            ,    ,         ( )  .         [26 -       ,      .   Β ,       ,    ,     ,    . .: OBrien C. C. The Great Melody: A Thematic Biography and Commented Anthology of Edmund Burke. London: Sinclair-Stevenson, 1992. P. 448451.]. ,          ,   ,    ,     .   , ,    ,          - [27 -  . . . . 79.      , ,    ,              (. . 1,  13, 15). .: Blumenberg H. Shipwreck with Spectator: Paradigm of a Metaphor for Existence. Cambridge: MIT Press, 1997.].         ,  ,     , ,           [28 -      ,  ,        ;                ,     ( . . . . 72).].           ,                  .     , , ,    ,   -    ,           [29 - Fritzsche P. Ruins // Fritzsche P. Stranded in the Present: Modern Time and the Melancholy of History. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2004. P. 92130.].

 ,     ,   ,   .    1767      ,      .  ,            .           ,  ,         [30 - May G. Diderot and Burke: A Study in Aesthetic Affinity // PMLA. December 1960. Vol. 75. 5. P. 527539,   : . 529.                   .: Baridon M. Ruin as a Mental Construct // Journal of Garden History. 1985. 5. P. 8496.].    ,      .        :       ,      ,     ,      ,  ,      - ,   .       . ,          ,       :      ,         .

 ,      1767 ,   ,  ,        .              :       [31 - .    ,       : Fried M. Absorption and Theatricality: Painting & Beholder in the Age of Diderot. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1980. P. 122131.].         ,   .         .                 .             ,      ,         ,            ,         ,        ,   .

       . ໠  ,    ,     .        :        ,      .           , 



   ,    ,     ,              .   ?   ?  ,  .   ? .   ? .   ,    .      [32 -  .  1767  / . . .  //  . :  2. .: , 1989. . 2. . 67.].


             [33 -           -        ,           ,         ,   ,   .             ,  ,        (Peyrach-Leborgne D. Sublime, sublimation et narcissisme chez Diderot // Recherches sur Diderot et sur lEncyclopdie. 1992. Vol. 13. P. 3146.].   ,    , ,      ,      [34 - Fried . Op. cit. P. 130131.].

    ,    ,    ,   ,  ,    .      ,            :        :



   ,     ,        ?    ,        .      ,   ,       ,     . ,  ,  , , ,       .          ,    ,    .          ,   .     [35 -  .  1767 . . 131.].


   ,      ,   .         ,         ,     ,        ,   [36 -  .].      ,            ,  . ,  ,       .    ,   ,       ,     ,    ,   ,   ,              ,  ,     [37 -  . . 142.].    :      ,   [38 -  . . 130.].   ,  ,     ,  ,   ,    .     .    ,        ,     .       ,     , , [39 -  . . 131.].

     ,     ,    .     :          ,   ,     [40 -  .  1767 . . 132.].        ,     ,         ,  . , ,   ,          ,         .     ,     , ,    ,        ,    .

   :               ,     ,       .            ,          .    ,         .  ,          ,         ,      ,      ,     [41 -  . . .     / . . . . . .: , 2000. . 7374.      . . .].      ,       .        : ,  ,    ,      ,    [42 -  . . 74.].       ,        .

    ,           [43 -  . . 119120.].  , ,       ,          :



  ,   ,  ,  ,   ,        ,     ,    . <> ,     ,                ,       ,      ,         . ,      <> ,  ,   ,  ,    ,  ,        [44 -  . . .    . . 120.].


    , ,     . ,     ,     ,    .       ,   . ,   ,           ,            .        ,        ,            ,    ,        [45 - .: Hegel G. W. F. Grundlinien der Philosophie des Rechts. Vol. 7 // Hegel G. W. F. Werke in zwanzig B?nde. Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp, 1970. S. 49293.].       ,     ,       ,       ,      .      -      , ,   .

      ,    ,       . ,    ,    ,     .  ,            ,   ,         .       .         ,           [46 -             : Presner T. Hegels Philosophy of World History via Sebalds Imaginary of Ruins: A Contrapuntal Critique of the New Space of Modernity // Hell J., Sch?nle A. (Eds.) Ruins of Modernity. Durham: Duke University Press, 2010. P. 193211.].    ,   ,   ,  ,    ,                ,        .      ,  ,   ,         .

         XIXXX       .    1907  :             [47 - .:  .  / . . . .  //  . :  2. . 2.  . .: , 1996. . 227233.].      ,          ,         ,    ,     ,   .   ?  ,     ,     ,   ,  ,          .       ,  ,         ,   ,     ,     [48 -  . . . 227.].     ,        [49 -  . . 228229.].   ,     ,        ,           . ,  ,      ,         [50 -  . . 228.].    ,   ,       ,      [51 -  . . 233.].        ,   [52 -  . . 232.].       .

      ,       ,    ,      .         ,          .  ,  ,       ,     ,         .      ,    ,     (Dazugeh?ren)[53 -  . . 231.].              , ,   [54 -  . . . 232.].            .   , ,    .               ,    [55 -       (1911)      ,     (  -)  . .: Simmel G. The Ruin // Simmel G. Essays on Sociology, Philosophy and Aesthetics. New York: Harper Torchbooks, 1959. P. 259266.].     -, , ,         [56 - Freud S. Delusion and Dream in Wilhelm Jensens Gradiva // Jensen W. Gradiva. Copenhagen: Green Integer, 2003. P. 231.].  ,       ,        .          ,        .

       ,           .               .  ,         .  ,        [57 -  .     / . . . . .: , 2002. . 185.].     ,      ,    .          ,     .                 ,        .         -     ,   ,         ;    . ,  ,      ,   ,    ,     .         ,   ,       ,                      .           ,           .

            (    ).    Angelus Novus  ,    ,  ,      ,            [58 -  .    / . . .  //   . 2000. 46. . 84.].    ,   .    ,   , ,      ,          .        :          ,          ,    .  ,     .      ,      . , ?        , , ,   ,        .    ,       ,  .

       ,        .    ,      ,  , ,    ,   .      ;     .  ,    ,      .  ,    ,    ,     ,    .            ,               ( II),     ,     ,       [59 -  .   . . 81, 84.]. ,  ,   ,     :     ,     .             ,             ,         [60 -       .: Maeseneer Y. de. Horror Angelorum: Terroristic Structures in the Eyes of Walter Benjamin, Hans Urs von Balthasars Rilke and Slavoj Zizek // Modern Theology. October 2003. Vol. 19. 4. P. 511527.].

 ,  ,                   ,      ,   ,        . ,        (XVIII )   ,  ,  ,        XX  XXI [61 - Horkheimer M., Adorno Th. W. Dialektik der Aufkl?rung. Frankfurt am Main: Fischer, 1969; Baudrillard J. LEsprit du Terrorisme // South Atlantic Quarterly. Spring 2002. Vol. 101. 2. P. 403415; Zizek S. Welcome to the Desert of the Real: Five Essays on September 11 and Related Dates. London; New York: Verso, 2002; Aug M. Le temps en ruines. Paris: Galilee, 2003.].         ,        ,             .     ,      .     ,    ,        .        ,   ,      . .      [62 - .: Sebald W. G. On the Natural History of Destruction. London: Hamish Hamilton, 2003.].      ,      ,       ?  ,  ,      ? ,  -    ?  ,    ,     ,  ,   ,   ,      ,   ,        ?       , , ,      ,        ,           .


* * *

                , ,   ,           .          ,        .         ,    ,    .      ,        [63 - .:     .     / . . .   . .:    , 2002. . 10.].     ,        ,     .             ,   ,     . ,   1722 ,      ,     ,      [64 -  . . 14.].                .      ,    ,     ,       [65 -  . . 1920.].      ,       .             ,        .

  XVIII             ,        . ,       ,    ,    ,  ,     .       :            ,            ,              .       ,           ,     .    XIX          .      . . ,    ,      -.  I        , ,     ,     I,  1826 ,           .               , ,      [66 -     . . 45.].   , ,        ,      ,         .    ,            XIX .     ,    , ,         ,   -   [67 -  . . 5358.].     1812          .  1826       ,     .  ,                 [68 -  . . 8081.].

,       ,      ,      ,    . ,     ,    ,    .  ,   ,      ,       ,           ,     [69 -     . . 94.].         ,   ,    ,   .     ,     .        ,     ,           ,    -       .                    .

      .     ,  , ,  ,            ,     ,     .       ,       .            . ,  ,     ,    (   ).        ,     :      [70 -  . . 98.].             (   ,   )        , ,       ,     .  ,      [71 -  . . 112.].          XI       [72 -  . . 114.].

   XIX        .    .         ,        .                        [73 -  . . 156157.].         ,   .              ,        [74 -  . . 158.].                   .      ,        ,      .        ,       ,      ,         --[75 -  . . 167171.    --   1887 ,        и      (The Seven Lamps of Architecture, 1849), ,  .  . . 290296.].   -                .

           .      , ,        ,   .              ,         [76 -     . . 221222.].     , -   1880?       .   XIX      ,        .       ,      ,       .            .       . . ,       ,   ,    .                   [77 -  . . 328329.].          ,       .   ,                  ,           .

 ,                        ,     ,            .           ,   ,    .  ,                  ,    [78 -  . . 477.].    ,             .           .        ,                .

   XX         ,         ,          .       ,    ,       ,     .          .  ,      ,    ,   , ,       ,      .

   1917           ,         ,       .             .   1927         ,    ,   ,           ,  ,   .     .   1930?      ,      ,         .      1930?    ,              .

   ,      ,   ,            [79 -  . . . (.)     .    . .:   , 2004. . 94.].    ,    ,     ,  ,               .                   .   ,      .     ,     ,   ,       .         ,    ,         ,     [80 -     . . 217.].       ,    ,      (   )    ,     [81 -  . . 301.].  ,     ,       [82 -  . . 299.].

                  .         .          XVIII  XIX ,  .           .                   ,        ,     [83 -             .:  . .    . .:  , 1999.     .:  . . .  .      ,       - . .:    , 1971.].  , ,     ,    [84 -     . . 338341.].  ,          XVIII        ,        , ,   ,     [85 -  . . 346, 357.].

 1949         .   [86 -  . . 213.].     ,         , , ,   ..      ,    ,     .  1960?        ,          .         ,      .  , ,   ,       [87 -     . . 272273.].  ,  ,         ,          [88 -  . . 311321.].   1964 ,          ,        .

   1960?           [89 -  . . 274.].   ,        ,    1960?    .  1976           . ,  ,      .  , ,    ,           .                 19701980?       ,      [90 -  . . 590.].        ,         .         1980?        .       ;       .

               .                   . ,  ,            ,        ,             . ,   ,      : ,         ,   ,     19601970? ,        .             ,    ,           .   ,       ,    ,    ,    ,    . ,      ,        .   ,       ,    ,        .         .         .

,         .                .       ,                ,    .       ,   ,         .


* * *

       ,         ,       ,         ,    . ,      ,                  ,          .  , ,          ,    ,                  .                            .        ,   ,   ,   ,                      ,   .

        ,         .       ,    ,        ,      1812    ,  ,         , ,      .   ,        ,        .     ,  ,     ,   ,                        [91 -               XIX .    ,       .   ,   ,       ( )    ,    ?   .       .      ., ,          ,            ,    , ,        ,    XX .].

      :   , , , , , , ,   ,  .        ,     ,  .         ,      XX          ,       .   ,             .   XVIII     ,   ,       ,        .               1800? .           ,    .  ,    ,   1812 , ,     .

           XVIII ,       . .   .               ,   .           ,     .        .

       1812 ,        .  ,   ,         .        ,    Grande Arme[92 -   (.).], ,  ,      .             ,     ,        ,     .

                 ,       .                   .        ,    ,           .           ,                .                       .

     .      ,    ,       ,        .      ,          ,       ,      .         ,      ,       ,       ,    .

         19201921 .       ,           .        :       ,   .                .            ,        .

            .    ,         ,             .                - .

         .          ,          .                    ,     .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/andreas-shenle/arhitektura-zabveniya-ruiny-i-istoricheskoe-soznanie-v-ross/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


Des ruines moi je men moque      (.).




2


 . .       ,  . :   , 1857. . 102103.  . . ,       .




3


 . .       (1848) //  . .   :  4. . 4. .:  - . . , 1914. . 207.




4


 . .    . 206.




5


.:   . .   , ,     17841788. //  . 1878. 23 (). . 238.        .




6


 . .   . .:  , 1963. . 2. . 55.




7


     (modernity)      ,   (modernization);  ,      ,              .         . .: Habermas J. Modernitys Consciousness of Time and Its Need for Self-Reassurance // The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity: Twelve Lectures / Trans. F. G. Lawrence. Cambridge: MIT Press, 1987. P. 122.      (modern)    .: Gumbrecht H. U. Modern, Modernit?t, Moderne // Geschichtliche Grundbegriffe. Stuttgart: Klett-Cotta, 1978. V. 4. P. 93131.    ,        , .: Berman M. All That Is Solid Melts into Air. New York: Verso, 1982. .      : Kangaspuro M., Smith J. (Eds.) Modernisation in Russia since 1900 / Studia Fennica Historica. V. 12. Helsinki: Finnish Literature Society, 2006.




8


  (.).




9


   (supermodernity) .: Aug M. Non-Places: Introduction to an Anthropology of Supermodernity. London: Verso, 1995.




10


.         : Hell J., Sch?nle A. (ds.) Ruins of Modernity. Durham: Duke University Press, 2010; Roth M. S., Lyons C., Merewether Ch. Irresistible Decay. Los Angeles: The Getty Institute, 1997; Woodward Ch. In Ruins. New York: Pantheon Books, 2001; Assmann A., Gomille M., Rippl G. (Hrsg.) Ruinenbilder. M?nchen: Wilhelm Fink Verlag, 2002; Bolz N. (Hrsg.) Ruinen des Denkens. Denken in Ruinen. Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp, 1996.




11


   .: Edensor T. Industrial Ruins: Space, Aesthetics and Materiality. Oxford: Berg, 2005.




12


 .          / . . . . . .: , 1979. . 80.




13


 . . 79.




14


 . . 78.




15


 .




16


 . . 79.




17


   .: Womersley D. Introduction // Burke E. A Philosophical Enquiry into the Origin of Our Ideas of the Sublime and Beautiful. London: Penguin, 1998. P. XXV.




18


.:  . . . . 88.




19


          ,         . ,    ,       .          ,      ,  . .: Hartmann P. Du sublime (de Boileau ? Schiller). Strasbourg: Presses universitaires de Strasbourg, 1997. P. 4546.




20


 . . . . 94.




21


 . . . . 88  9899 .




22


 . . 74.




23


 1770?  ,     ,   ,        .            .       (/),          .      ,     ,  ,                .                 . .  : White S. K. Edmund Burke: Modernity, Politics, and Aesthetics. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publication, 1994.               . .: Womersley D. Op. cit. P. XXXXVIII.




24


        :        ,    .           .  ,    ,   ,    , , ,   . . : Ayling S. Edmund Burke: His Life and Opinions. London: Cassell, 1988. P. 6.




25


    ,        ,   1754 .   (1759)      .   ,       腻    10     . .: Boulton J. T. Editors Introduction // Burke E. A Philosophical Enquiry into the Origin of Our Ideas of the Sublime and Beautiful. London: Routledge, 1958. P. XVXXVI.




26


      ,      .   Β ,       ,    ,     ,    . .: OBrien C. C. The Great Melody: A Thematic Biography and Commented Anthology of Edmund Burke. London: Sinclair-Stevenson, 1992. P. 448451.




27


 . . . . 79.      , ,    ,              (. . 1,  13, 15). .: Blumenberg H. Shipwreck with Spectator: Paradigm of a Metaphor for Existence. Cambridge: MIT Press, 1997.




28


     ,  ,        ;                ,     ( . . . . 72).




29


Fritzsche P. Ruins // Fritzsche P. Stranded in the Present: Modern Time and the Melancholy of History. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2004. P. 92130.




30


May G. Diderot and Burke: A Study in Aesthetic Affinity // PMLA. December 1960. Vol. 75. 5. P. 527539,   : . 529.                   .: Baridon M. Ruin as a Mental Construct // Journal of Garden History. 1985. 5. P. 8496.




31


.    ,       : Fried M. Absorption and Theatricality: Painting & Beholder in the Age of Diderot. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1980. P. 122131.




32


 .  1767  / . . .  //  . :  2. .: , 1989. . 2. . 67.




33


          -        ,           ,         ,   ,   .             ,  ,        (Peyrach-Leborgne D. Sublime, sublimation et narcissisme chez Diderot // Recherches sur Diderot et sur lEncyclopdie. 1992. Vol. 13. P. 3146.




34


Fried . Op. cit. P. 130131.




35


 .  1767 . . 131.




36


 .




37


 . . 142.




38


 . . 130.




39


 . . 131.




40


 .  1767 . . 132.




41


 . . .     / . . . . . .: , 2000. . 7374.      . . .




42


 . . 74.




43


 . . 119120.




44


 . . .    . . 120.




45


.: Hegel G. W. F. Grundlinien der Philosophie des Rechts. Vol. 7 // Hegel G. W. F. Werke in zwanzig B?nde. Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp, 1970. S. 49293.




46


            : Presner T. Hegels Philosophy of World History via Sebalds Imaginary of Ruins: A Contrapuntal Critique of the New Space of Modernity // Hell J., Sch?nle A. (Eds.) Ruins of Modernity. Durham: Duke University Press, 2010. P. 193211.




47


.:  .  / . . . .  //  . :  2. . 2.  . .: , 1996. . 227233.




48


 . . . 227.




49


 . . 228229.




50


 . . 228.




51


 . . 233.




52


 . . 232.




53


 . . 231.




54


 . . . 232.




55


      (1911)      ,     (  -)  . .: Simmel G. The Ruin // Simmel G. Essays on Sociology, Philosophy and Aesthetics. New York: Harper Torchbooks, 1959. P. 259266.




56


Freud S. Delusion and Dream in Wilhelm Jensens Gradiva // Jensen W. Gradiva. Copenhagen: Green Integer, 2003. P. 231.




57


 .     / . . . . .: , 2002. . 185.




58


 .    / . . .  //   . 2000. 46. . 84.




59


 .   . . 81, 84.




60


      .: Maeseneer Y. de. Horror Angelorum: Terroristic Structures in the Eyes of Walter Benjamin, Hans Urs von Balthasars Rilke and Slavoj Zizek // Modern Theology. October 2003. Vol. 19. 4. P. 511527.




61


Horkheimer M., Adorno Th. W. Dialektik der Aufkl?rung. Frankfurt am Main: Fischer, 1969; Baudrillard J. LEsprit du Terrorisme // South Atlantic Quarterly. Spring 2002. Vol. 101. 2. P. 403415; Zizek S. Welcome to the Desert of the Real: Five Essays on September 11 and Related Dates. London; New York: Verso, 2002; Aug M. Le temps en ruines. Paris: Galilee, 2003.




62


.: Sebald W. G. On the Natural History of Destruction. London: Hamish Hamilton, 2003.




63


.:     .     / . . .   . .:    , 2002. . 10.




64


 . . 14.




65


 . . 1920.




66


    . . 45.




67


 . . 5358.




68


 . . 8081.




69


    . . 94.




70


 . . 98.




71


 . . 112.




72


 . . 114.




73


 . . 156157.




74


 . . 158.




75


 . . 167171.    --   1887 ,        и      (The Seven Lamps of Architecture, 1849), ,  .  . . 290296.




76


    . . 221222.




77


 . . 328329.




78


 . . 477.




79


 . . . (.)     .    . .:   , 2004. . 94.




80


    . . 217.




81


 . . 301.




82


 . . 299.




83


            .:  . .    . .:  , 1999.     .:  . . .  .      ,       - . .:    , 1971.




84


    . . 338341.




85


 . . 346, 357.




86


 . . 213.




87


    . . 272273.




88


 . . 311321.




89


 . . 274.




90


 . . 590.




91


              XIX .    ,       .   ,   ,       ( )    ,    ?   .       .      ., ,          ,            ,    , ,        ,    XX .




92


  (.).


