.    2017.  . 34 (3031):     
  


 
   -         .          ,          .

    , ,   , .







:   .  .     . 





 





 :    .  2[1 -          (),   17-33-00025 :  .]


.. 

 008.2; 101.1


      


, , skvortsovcgsir@mail.ru

   .   . ,  .                (,  , , ,  ,   ..),         .        ,     ,   ,     .      ,        . ,   .           XXI .

 : ; ; ;  ;  ;  .

: 10.03.2017

  : 27.04.2017


L.V. Skvortsov


Truth of heterotopia: Between phantom and reality. Part 2


Institute of scientific information for social sciences of Russian academy of sciences


Moscow, Russia, skvortsovcgsir@mail.ru

The paper evaluates Michel Foucalts understanding of heterotopia. It proves that heterotopia is not only the reality of other place (prison, psychiatric clinic, library, cemetery, colony, ship etc.), but also the other place for seeking the truth of social life. Methodology of aquiering this truth is described as archeology of knowledge (Larcheologie du savoir), as the way towards the truth pursued by the mass conscience. This truth does not coincide with religions, ideological, or scientific understanding. It is reality and priority of discourse objectivity, which includes elements of ideological and scientific knowledge. It is demonstrated that M. Foucalts conception predicts the emergence of certain forms and methods of discourse objectivity as a ruling force of mass consciousness in the global politics of the XXI


century.

Keywords: Foucalt; heterotopia; truth; mass consciousness; other place; global politics.

Received: 10.03.2017

Accepted: 27.04.2017


[2 -   ( 1)      ( 12 (2829)  2017 .).]


3.        

 ,    . ,   ,              .           ,   ,  , , , , .

     .      ,        .  ,        ,    .       ,           . .  ,               .     ,      .

       .        .        ,  .       ;          .         ,          .

      :     ,     .       :          .           .

           .     .     ,    .         ,   .            ,         .

  ,              .         ,    ,      .                 .  ,        ,       .

      ,          .       ,    ,          .        , , ,     .

  ,        ,            .  ,       ,      .

. ,        ,   . ,     XIX .   ,       -  ,  ,      ,                  [, 1996, . 44].

, ,  XIX .  -       ,       ,       .            .               . ,         ,     . ,  . ,     ,     ,            [ , . 47].

             ,            .   ,   ,               . ,              ,           1944 .,        ,      ,        .

.  ,       ,   .      ,        ,        ,       .

.  ,           ,         .    .   .      ,    ,     [, 1996, . 4748].    ,       .    , ,    ,      ,    ,      ,    ,  ,  ,   .


4.        

   ,     , ,    .           :  ?    ,  ,    .  ,       ,    ,           ,  ,     .

,  . ,          ,    [, 1996, . 48].     ,       ,       .  .        , ,                 .

         , ..   ,        ,  ,  ,    ,     .    , ,      ,  ,       ,       ,     ,   .

     , ,   ,       , ..     ,     ,        .

     ,        ,  ,   ,   .       ,  .      ,   , ,   .       :    ,         ,        .          ,     .      , ..   .     .        ,      ,   ,      ,     [, 1996, . 63].

 ,      ,        -     .  - , ,  ,   , , ,  ,  ,    :     .         ,         .   ,      ,          ,     .

     ,     ,   , , ,  ,  ,      ,      .      .           ,             .             ,       .

 . , , ,  ,                      ,    ,     .

                 XXI . ,                            .            ,       .    , ..            ,    .                     2016 .

              .       ,     ,              ,       .                .

   ,      ,        .                  .          ,     .

   ,       ,        .       ,    .  .  , ,  .      ,          [, 2016, . 364372].

 ,         ,            .     ,      ,   , ..       .


5.   XXI .?

           ,      .        .         .

     ,   ,       ,      ,         .             ,        .

         .     ,    ,      .    ,      ,       ,        , ,      .    ?

              ,  .

           . .      .    , , ,       ,   ,  , .        ,     .

.     ,  ,  :     ,       .         ,        .

    ,    ,        .           ,  ,    ,   .   ,            .    ,         .

 ,  .                  .      :            ,   ,  ,     ,     ?

  ,          .     ,       ,    .     ,    , .   ,          ,      ,    ,         ,     [, 1996, . 136].

 ,    . ,      ,    ,      ,   .       .      :    ,         [ , . 164].

   ,      .       ,   ,     . .        .          XVIII .,             , .        ,   terminus a quo  terminus ad quem.             .      .

       , .. , ,  ,  ,  ,  .

        ,     ,   ,  ,       . ,        ,  ,     ,       :  ,  ,  ,    [, 1996, . 161].  ,  . ,        ,       [ , . 201].

                    .             .       ,     .     ,    .

  ,                  XX .,           XXI .             ,        .          ,           .

                 .        ;      ,           ,        .     ,     ,  ,     .

              2016 .   .            . , ,             .     .

         .        ,         ,      :  ,       .        .    ,       ,            .                  .

    ,      ?          ,      ,      ,    ,     .

.  ,   ,        ,         ,   .        ,   ,   .   :      .                ,      ,       .          ,     ,   [, 1996, . 181].

 ,            .   ,    ,      ,          .       ,         .  ,          ,       .               .        ,     .         , ,    ,     ,   .  ,           ,             .

    ,               ,          ,         ,     .

 ,   ,    ,   , ..       , ..    ,    .        ,    ,            .

,     .         XXI .        .      .     ,               ,           .  ,        ,    ,      ,         .    ,          ,     ,     .

        .    ,  ,      ,   ,    ,  ,     ,   ,    .

      .              ,      ,  .              ,        .       ,   .


 

1. ..  . .; .:   , 2016. 384 .

2.  .   / . .; . . . . : -, 1996. 208 . (. opera aparta; . 1).


References

1.Skvortsov L.V. Civilizacionnye razmyshlenija. M.; SPb.: Centr gumanitarnyh iniciativ, 2016. 384 s.

2. Foucault M. Arheologija znanija / Per. sfr.; obshh. red. Br. Levchenko. Kiev: Nika-centr, 1996. 208 s. (Ser. opera aparta; Vyp. 1).




      - [3 -          (),   17-33-00025 :  .]


.. 

 236.95


      


, , grrom@mail.ru

     ,        XIX .    . ,             XX . ,        ????????, ????????, ??????????,   ,     ,    : ,       .

 : ;  ; ; ; ; .

: 15.04.2017

  : 16.05.2017


R.S. Granin


To the Question of Definition of the Concept Eschatology in the Christian Religious and Philosophical Discourse


Institute of scientific information for social sciences of Russian academy of sciences


Moscow, Russia, grrom@mail.ru

The article focuses on the origin of the theological term eschatology arisen in the first third of XIX century in the environment of German liberal Protestantism. It is shown that proliferation of meaning of the term goes within schools of the Biblical hermeneutics of the beginning of XX century. It is established that depending on interpretation of three Greek words ????????, ????????, ??????????, which could mean both the First, and the Second Coming of the Christ, three paradigmatic scenarios were formulated: carried out, postponed eschatology and eschatology which began to be implemented.

Keywords: eschatology; biblical hermeneutics; parousia; apocalyptic; theophany; apocatastasis.

Received: 15.04.2017

Accepted: 16.05.2017

       ,   XIX  [, 2001],         .   ,    ,   ,    .           . ,   ,     (   )       50-  XVI .[4 - Webster's Online Dictionary. Mode of access: http://alpha.totodefinition.com/ search.php?word=eschatology ( : 24.07.2017.)]               Systema locorum theologicorum (16651677),      ??????????? sacra [, 2014, . 54].              XIX .  ,        .   1822 .   (Der Christliche Glaube)   :         ,      ,      ,            ,      [Schleiermacher, 1928, . S. 703].               1897 .,   :  ,  , ,    []   [] [5 - Eschatology // The Oxford English Dictionary / Ed. James A.H. Murray and others. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1897. Vol. 3. P. 614.].    ???????????     : ???????, ?, ? [?]   , ; , , ;  ?????  , , [6 - ??????? // -  / .  ..,  .. .:  , 1980. . 353.].         ??????? (???????)    .   ???????, ?, ??    , ,    , , .     ?? ???????  ,  (??? ??????? ??? ???    , ..    (. 1:8; 13:47)).   ??????? ??????  ,  (. 12:22; 1. 15:8),     ???????  ; ??????? ???     (. 5:23)[7 - ??????? // -    / . .  .. .:   , 1997. C. 93.].

 1904 .          .. ,    :      ,           .          , ,                  , -,   腻 [, 1904, . 127].                ,  -  .  ,           ,   ,   .        ,     .

  XIX   XX .    (   )     [8 - ,   (. ??????????  )       ,     (. ????????  ),     (. ????????  , ).      ,            ,      ( ..  :  3 . .:    , 2002. . 1. . 249).]. ,        ,        XX .:  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,   [Caird, 1980, . 243255].                  .              ????????, ????????, ??????????,               .

         ??????????, ??? (1 . 1:7, 13; 1. 1:7),            (. 16:25).      ????????????  , ,  (  ??? (??, ??),   , , ,   ?????????  )[9 - ?????????? // -   . C. 32.].        , , ;   ?????????? (???????????)  , ,  , , [10 - ?????????? // -   . C. 33.].

 ????????  ,    (?????????),       (1 . 6:14; 2. 4:1, 8; 2. 2:8),        (2 . 1:10).

 ???????? (, , )        .       ????    ?????  ,      .                  .          (1908)          ,       adventus.       ,       . , ,     ,         ,           ,      Adventus Aug (usti) Cor (inthi)[11 -     Wikipedia.  : http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/ ( : 12.03.2017.)].    ???????? (adventus)          ,     .             (2 . 1:16).             ,         .                 .  ,                 ????? ( ). ,      (1 . 3:16),     (. 3:4; 1. 5:4; 1. 2:28; 3:2) [, 2001].        ????????? (),       .

       (????????, ????????, ??????????)   : ,      ,       .         :      ,            [Schweitzer, 1951, . 228].      .      ,  ,                .      ,        [, 2001].        , ,  ,            .

     ,    ,     (      )   .       (1941)  :       ,      ,     .       [, 1994, . 302339].      [12 -  (. ???????  , )   ,           (:  14:24; 1 1:21). .  : http://dic.academic.ru/dic.nsf/ruwiki/1519635 ( : 24.07.2017.)]    .                    [, 2001].

            .. .  ,       ( ):            .   ,       ,   ,        .       ,      (. 10:2324),    (. 1:15),      (. 11:20)         (. 21:31) [Dodd, 1961, p. 37].

      ,     (. sich realisierende Eschatologie),    .               ,     [Jeremias, 1972].      (,   )    ,      ,        .       (. inaugurated eschatology)      .  ,                  :        .             .       ,     .             .       ,    ,    ,      [Minear, 1962, p. 2327].      divine-human (     ), ,  뻠  --.  , -?       ,  ,  -, .. .

   ,    ,  ..    ,   ,        .            (. 18:11),              (-  ).       ,    .   ,     .        .     ,       :       ,          -     (     . 17:21) [, 20002001, . 469].




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/kollektiv-avtorov/chelovek-obraz-i-suschnost-2017-gumanitarnye-aspekty-3-4/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes



1


         (),   17-33-00025 :  .




2


  ( 1)      ( 12 (2829)  2017 .).




3


         (),   17-33-00025 :  .




4


Webster's Online Dictionary. Mode of access: http://alpha.totodefinition.com/ search.php?word=eschatology ( : 24.07.2017.)




5


Eschatology // The Oxford English Dictionary / Ed. James A.H. Murray and others. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1897. Vol. 3. P. 614.




6


??????? // -  / .  ..,  .. .:  , 1980. . 353.




7


??????? // -    / . .  .. .:   , 1997. C. 93.




8


,   (. ??????????  )       ,     (. ????????  ),     (. ????????  , ).      ,            ,      ( ..  :  3 . .:    , 2002. . 1. . 249).




9


?????????? // -   . C. 32.




10


?????????? // -   . C. 33.




11


    Wikipedia.  : http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/ ( : 12.03.2017.)




12


 (. ???????  , )   ,           (:  14:24; 1 1:21). .  : http://dic.academic.ru/dic.nsf/ruwiki/1519635 ( : 24.07.2017.)


