 . 2016. 
  

  


  
       ,               .           .







 . . 2016





 


          .. .         .    ,   1755 .   .. ,   .

    I .       ,     , ,  .        1989 .     ,   2009 .   .

              PR-  GR-, , , ,   .         ,        - .

       , ,        ,    .       , ,   ,            .      , ,  ,   ,   .           ,    .

   ,    ,   ,         . ..  ..            XIX ., ..  ..   ..      , ..   ..            ,  ..   ..         .

     ,      ,     .     ..         ..       .      ..         .

                 .    ,     ..,           .             ,          .          ,   .   .., .., ..  ..          2016 . ..             .     . ,     .. ,   ,              .     ..    -    .

            .       ,    . ..        ,  ..            .

       .     .             ..          ,       ..   ..         .

,      , ,        .     ,               .



 ..,
 ..




 :      





  ,   ,          XIX 




.. , .. [1 -   ,   , ,            . .., e-mail: juliaartamonova@yahoo. com;   ,   , ,          . .. , e-mail: arthur@leadnet.ruArtamonova Yulia, Lomonosov Moscow State University, e-mail: juliaartamonova@yahoo.com; Demchuk Artur, Lomonosov Moscow State University, e-mail: arthur@leadnet.ru]

.   -          .       ;      (-)             . ,                ;                      - () .

 : - () ;  ; ;  ;  ;  .


Yu.D. Artamonova, A.L. Demchuk


On the alliance of statistics, law and ethics, or a disciplinary field of moral and political science of the first half of the 19


 century

Abstract. Active discussions revolve around the notion (concept) moral-political science and the subjects (fields) that form the content of this science. The article presents the main standpoints within the framework of those discussions; going to the history of the notions (concepts) moral (moral-political) and social science allows to demonstrate partial invalidity of interpretations offered by the adherents of those standpoints. It demonstrates that the tradition of classical education conveys the idea of phronesis formulated way back by Aristotle as a key idea in defining political disciplines; the ideas of a natural law and of political economy formulated on its basis during the Enlightenment are the key to defining the subject content of moral-political (ethical) science.

Keywords: moral-political (ethical) science; social science; phronesis; natural law; common sense; political economy.

        XIX .;           .     1804 .,            ;      ;    ; : ,   ;       ;    ,    ;     [  (5  1804 .)].  1816 . -         .        :  ,      ;  ,    ; ; ,        ,    [, 2008, . 183].         . ,         ,   1803 . (  ,   1832 .        ).        :  ; ,    ;    ;   (philosophie, morale, lgislation, droit public et jurisprudence, conomie politique et statistique, histoire gnrale et philosophique) [. : Rosanvallon, 1985].

   ,  ..        :         .    () 껠  .       ( .),        (the science of the formation of character),     廠   ,        (the science of society),    (the social science),        [.: , 2011].

              .             .     .  ,           ,  . , ,   XVIII   XIX .  ,  ,  ( ),  ,   , ,           .   ,           ,      ,     ,  ,  [., : , 2009, . 6].

   :  ,     ,               .     ,           [, 2012].   ,        ,      :                    ,          [, 2012].   ,    ,    :    ,        1790- ,   ,                          .       ,        [ ].

      ,    .

      1824 .      [Thompson, 1824]    ,      ,        .       (     ),     (   ,    ,  , ,   [Considerant, 1847])       ,     .       . ,      ..,      ,    . , , ,           .  , .  :            ,     ,      ,    ,  ,   ,        [, 2000, . 541].         ;            -         .

 ,         ,     ,   ,        ,        . ,       26  1835 .     c    :    ,    ,   : 1- : 1) . 2)    . 3)   . 4)      . 5)     . 6)  . 7)  . 8)    . 9)  : )  ,   ; )     [  (26  1835 .)].       23  1884 .       ,  ,  ,  ,    ,   [  (18  1884)].

      (    )?     ,    ,      .         . ,  ,    :      ,     ,   ,      ,    ?  ,         ,            ,    腻 [  1994, . 447, 452].  :  ,    ?         .     ,       ,   ,    ,       ?    ,           ,   ,         ,             . ,         ,   ,        ,   ,   , ,    ,       ,              [  1994, c. 455].            (  ,   ..)       .

     ( )?             . ,         ,                  [,   1994, c. 219].           ,       ,             ,   ,         ,          [ , c.223].  ,    (        ,   ), ,     ;        ,    .       ,                      ,      .       ,   .             ,     ,  ,    ?     ,         ? [,   1994, c. 220].    ,      ,        (              ) [ , c. 221222].

    ,         . ,      ,  ; ,     ,         ,  ,       .

  ,    [., : , 1988],  .       , sensus ommunus,        .

      ,   .    ,     ,    ,       .     ars  ,          .

    ( )  .      , ,     .      ,    .     ().

  ,          ,   .          ,  ,      ,       .   ,      ,         :      ,       ,   .    , -,    ,            ; -,         .         ,      : , ,    -  -,        (            ,     ,  ,     ..).        ()        ,    ,    ,   .     .     ()    ,        , .

 ,      ,               .

             ,     ,   ,       .  ,            ,    .

                  XVIII .           ,            .

         ,           .  ,          .        .     .:   ,        ,          ,     ,           [, 1998, c.49]. ..                   ,    ,    ,  .         1755 .    ,     ,        ,            [ .. ]. ..               :     .        ,       ;    , ,     ,   ,    ;            ,        [, 2005, . 1314].

             . -,      ,    , , ,   . -,             ,      .

     .           .   , ..  ,      ,    . , ,  ,  ,      - ;   .  ,      . ,   .        , , .      ,        ;    ;            .  ,   ,    ,       (  ,   ).     ,      .          . ,      ,        ,     -     [, 2010, c. 205].     . ,         ,             .            .

         ,          [, 2010, c. 205].   ,            .

  ,    ,   ,       ,   ..,   ,         .   .. ,          XIX .,       ,    :             ,             ,               [, 2014, c. 17].

          ,    ..            XIX .   ,   . .. , , ,  , ,          [, 2014, c.17]. ..    :   ,     1819   - ,    1805        :   ;       ;    ;   ;    (,  526) [, 2009, c. 6].  -  -      :   , ,  ;     ,   ,   , , ,   [-    2014, c. 12].    XIX .       .      .  .-.,     (  ),      :      :    ,                          ,             ;       ,      ; ,     ,                  ,     ,   ,     ,        [  1994, . 457458].     .. (,  ,  ): ,      ,      .             ,     , ,         ;         [, 2011, c. 43]. ..       .-.,    , ,     ,      ,    :  1-       .  2-    ,    .  3-  ,        [, 2008, c. 145146].

 ,      XIX .        ,       ,      (  )      (,    ).            ,       ,    .

        ,      ,   , -,     , -.    , -,        [., : Real social science 2012].


 

 .-.   :  . : . . /. . . . .. . .: , 1988. 704 .

 .  :    //   . ., 2000. . 507588.

 ..   .  . .: , 2005. 671 .

 ..     //   .     1917 .:  /  . . .. . ., 2008. . 145146.

 ..       . .: -  . 2011. 128 .

 . : . .: -, : , 1998. 656 .

 ..     :         : . . . 5-, . . .: URSS, 2011. 832 .

-   , 18041835 / . . .. , . .. . .: -  , 2014. 64 .

 ..  ..      (19   19  1754).  : http://letopis.msu.ru/documents/ 264 ( : 1.12.2016.)

  (  ) //       /  .  .. .: , 1994. . 441475.

,  ,    //       /  .  .. .: , 1994. . 220223.

 ..     -   XIX. //  . . ., 2009. 4. . 519.

 ..         //   .     1917 .:  /  . . .. . ., 2008. . 182.

  (18  1884).  : http://letopis.msu.ru/ documents/2761 ( : 1.12.2016.)

  (26  1835 .).  : http://letopis.msu.ru/ documents/2123 ( : 1.12.2016.)

  (5  1804 .).  : http://letopis.msu.ru/ documents/327 ( : 1.12.2016.)

 .      // . ., 2012.  : http://gefter.ru/archive/6037 ( : 1.12.2016.)

 ..    //    . ., 2010   1, . XXIII. . 189192.

 .         // -   , 18041835 / . . .. , . .. . .: -  , 2014. . 1518.

Considerant V. Principes du socialisme: Manifest de la democratie au XIX ciecle suivi du process de la democratie au XIX si?cle suivi de la process de la democratie pacifique. P., 1847.

Real social science: applied phronesis / Ed. By B. Flyvbjerg, T. Landman, S. Schram. Cabridge, MA: Cambridge univ. press, 2012. 308 p.

Rosanvallon P. Le Moment Guizot. Paris: Gallimard, 1985. 414 p.

Thompson W. An inquiry into the principles of the distribution of wealth most conducive to human happiness; applied to the Newly proposed system of voluntary equality of wealth. L.: Longman, Hurst Rees, Orme, Brown & Green, 1824. P. IXX.




..      




.., ..[2 -   ,      . .., e-mail: sobvlad1992@yandex.ru;   ,   , ,    -      . .., e-mail: jants@yandex.ruSobolev Vladimir, Lomonosov Moscow State University, e-mail: sobvlad1992@yandex.ru; Shirinyants Alexander, Lomonosov Moscow State University, e-mail: jants@yandex.ru]

.           .        ,     .          ,           - .       ,        ,     - .     1989 .              .   -        (19272014),                 .  1965.      ,   ,             ,    ,   ,   ,                .

 : ..;    ;    .


V.A. Sobolev, A.A. Shirinyants


F.M. Burlatsky and formation of political science in the USSR

Abstract. Analysis of the problems of emergence and development of political science in Russia still remains an important theoretical task. Attempts to reduce the history of Russian political science to the contemporary, post-Soviet stage of its deve-lopment are not correct. Russian political science emerged and developed as an integral and inseparable part of the international political science, but its formation rooted in the domestic tradition of socio-political thought. Russian political science has gone in its growth through many structural changes, there were periods of neglect and denial of past achievements, but the development of social and political thought remained uninterrupted. Official acknowledgement of political science in the Soviet Union in 1989 marked the final stage in the history of the recognition of this scientific discipline in the country. One of the founders of the Soviet political science was Fyodor Burlatsky (19272014). Burlatsky was the first Soviet scholar to publicly call for the reinstatement of political science as a scientific and academic discipline. Starting from 1965, Burlatsky substantiated uniqueness of the subject of political science, greatly contribu-ting to its preservation as an independent discipline, as well as to development of methodology of political science and new analytical approaches. He was the first to study such new subjects as political system of the USSR, problems of political leadership and political elites.

Keywords: Burlatsky; political science in the Soviet Union; history of political science.

           ,    . ,     .  ,  ,           ,  ,  ,    ,       .         :  ,   ,    ,     ,   ,      ,   ,  ,    .

   ..    ,    ,     ,    ,    , ..,  , .          , , , , , ,          [, 2001, . 196],  ..  1965 . ,               ,         [, 2013, . 18].           ,    ,  ,      .

       ,       -  [, 1999; , 2001, . 521; , 2001, . 6888; , 2005, . 932; , 2007a, . 517; , 2007b, . 318; , 2011, . 5063;   2014, . 110136; , , 2015, . 18; , , 2015, . 726; , 2015, . 610].  -    XI.,           [, 2007, . 2429; , 2011a, . 3450; , 2011b, . 94102, , 2015a, . 112118; , 2015b, .195224].   -        .      ,  ,          ,   ,       ,   ,       ,    .           ,     -, , -   .   XIX . (     XX.,   XXI .),       ,         ,   (,   ..),     , -  -        (,  )   (,   ). , ,       ,    1804.       () -  [  2009; -  2014; , 2015a, . 3244; , 2015c, . 5664].      ,                       [, 2011; , 2012, . 3955; , 2015].

           (      , , , , , , ,     )  , , ,   .    ,    ;  ,  ()            ;        ;   -          ;        , ,  ;      ;  (, )   ()    -     ;   ( )   , , , ,            [   , 2009, . 6581; , 2016, . 14, 19].

 ,                  ,    ,        .       ,           ,     . -,    ,              ,           . -,                  ,       -    ,   ,     ,          ,      ;           , , ,        ..  .         (19272014),   -  [3 -       4  1927 .     (19451947),        (19501951),            ..  (1951).  19521953 .     ,  19531960 .   .  1960-                    ...  1964 .      ,    .      (19651967),            (19681969),         (19691971),   -        (19711989),   ( 1982 .),     (19901991).   1980-  ..   ,             (19891990).        (1988),  (1992),  (1993) .    ..         ..  ( 2011 .).  26  2014 . .].


* * *

  ,        ,        ,    , .      ,        ,    -   .

  ..,         : - - ;   ,    ;         ;    ;    , ,  [, 2015, . 125137].

..    ,            ( . .., ..)   XX ,         [, 2001, . 196].   ..,   1960-    .., .., .., ..  ,          ,       .

..,   ,   :              . ,   ,    .  ,     -  ,      ,   ,  ,   ,   .        ,              .

     ,            ,          .  , ,     ,        -  , - ,     ,        ,   ,  ,  ,   ..         ,          [4 -    : [ -, 1960].].    ,     ,     [5 -    (19122006)      ,    (1947),  (1947), -   (1964,  1991 . ).      (19681972), -     (19681970).           ,      ,      (.. ),         ,     (..),        ,           [  2006, . 141156].]           ,    .

           , ,    ,       ,  ,   ,      . -       ,      1965 . [  2006, . 143].

 ..         10  1965.[6 -          ,    .            .]   ..      :           .      ,            ,   .                  ,        ,     .

      ,    ,    , ,    .  ,    ,          ,    .

         ,    . ,            ,     ,      .    , ,   ,      ,      ,  ,  ,  ,    ,     ,  ,    ..  ,       .  ,        ,        .

            ,  ,       .

,            .       .           , ..  ,   ,        [, 2013, . 1718].

 ..            .   -    ,     : .   , ,  ,   ,      ,       [, 2013, . 294295].       .   1965.         ,       ,          .

..,    ,     :         .   . -                10  1965 .    .       10 .   .    -     ,   .  .   1965   (    )    ,   .     - .      .  .   -   (  ,   )?   ,  .  녻 [, 2003, . 125].

         ..    1969.        .   ,   .., ..  .., -   ..       .        ,  .. ,     ...     ,    .

               1979.  XI       () [, 2015b, . 8088; , 2016, . 199217].

..      :                  .           ,        ,      .        .    ,   ,       .  ,        ( ,  ,     )         .   -       (, ,   ) , ,   .          .           [, 2001, . 4950].

            ()     ,    19551960 . [, 2014, . 3].       ,  ,      :    ,      ,    ,  ,   ,     [   2015].   ,    1970-      .

 XI  ,    1466 ,       ,  ,          .   1970-   1980-         .., ..   [, 1982, . 5766; , 1984, . 6374].

                ,                   [     , 1987, . 498]. .. : 4  1988 .           .               ( ) 386     ,         .             ,     .

       1  25  1989. ,   ,          - .

       ,       .    ,     ,   .  1990.         ,   26  

         1990.       (   - . , . ..)      .    ?      ,       .. [, 2007b, . 45].


* * *

    ,  ..                 [, , 2014, . 124128].               [, 2003, . 115]. ..         ,   ,   ,  .

     ,        .    ..         .      ,      (1965),     . .  (1970),   ..  . .   (1974),          .  12:   (2012) [, 1970; , , 1974; , 2012, . 1527].

  , ..             .     ,            ,   ,             .             , ,          ,                [, 2012, . 16].         ,      [ , . 22].          ,  ,  ,  ;             , ,    ,       [, 2012, . 22].

      ,     .           (1963),        (1978),    ..  :     (1985)   ..   : -     (1986) [, 1963; , 1978; , , 1985; , , 1986].    ,         (    ,  -, -,   .)                    .           ,    ,       .     ,     ,   ,   ,         ,      .. ,   ,    ,     ,         [, , 1985, . 3132].




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/kollektiv-avtorov/politicheskaya-nauka-2016-specvypusk/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes



1


  ,   , ,            . .., e-mail: juliaartamonova@yahoo. com;   ,   , ,          . .. , e-mail: arthur@leadnet.ru

Artamonova Yulia, Lomonosov Moscow State University, e-mail: juliaartamonova@yahoo.com; Demchuk Artur, Lomonosov Moscow State University, e-mail: arthur@leadnet.ru




2


  ,      . .., e-mail: sobvlad1992@yandex.ru;   ,   , ,    -      . .., e-mail: jants@yandex.ru

Sobolev Vladimir, Lomonosov Moscow State University, e-mail: sobvlad1992@yandex.ru; Shirinyants Alexander, Lomonosov Moscow State University, e-mail: jants@yandex.ru




3


      4  1927 .     (19451947),        (19501951),            ..  (1951).  19521953 .     ,  19531960 .   .  1960-                    ...  1964 .      ,    .      (19651967),            (19681969),         (19691971),   -        (19711989),   ( 1982 .),     (19901991).   1980-  ..   ,             (19891990).        (1988),  (1992),  (1993) .    ..         ..  ( 2011 .).  26  2014 . .




4


   : [ -, 1960].




5


   (19122006)      ,    (1947),  (1947), -   (1964,  1991 . ).      (19681972), -     (19681970).           ,      ,      (.. ),         ,     (..),        ,           [  2006, . 141156].




6


         ,    .            .


