    
  

  


          ,    (    ),           ,               . .. .       .

 ,         .





  ,   

    



  , , , 2018

 .. , .. , 2018

  , 2018


* * *




 

.. , . . , ., .. , . . , 




              . ..          .        :     ( II) (   );   :  ,    (   [1 -            ,      (      ).     . ..         :  ,   ,       .  .];   );       (  );  :     (  ).

              ,     ,  ,        .




1. 


          .   ,                       ,     .                         , ,    .          .

      .. ,      ,                  .      ,     ;      ,      [2 -  ..     . ., 2011. . 1.].         :   (  )     ,     ,   (, )       , - (-)    [3 -  .. .        . ., 1998. . 64.].

       .    ,     廠  ?                  (         ).          :     ,  ,   ,    [4 - .: Samuel G. An Introduction to Comparative Law Theory and Method. Oxford, 2014. P. 11.].    (    ,  , , , )     ,      .   , -,         .

           (,       ).  ,  ,   (..   )    .   ,     ,          .      ()   .          ,             (..    ,    );      :   , ,     , ,       (   ); [5 - .:  ..     :     //      . 2015. 5. . 747;  .  . ; ., 2008. . 78.]  [6 - .: Przeworski A. Methods of Cross-National Research: An Overview // Comparative Policy Research: Learning from Experience / Ed. by M. Dierkes. Aldershot, 1987. P. 35.]   (   );     ( , ,  ,  )    - [7 - .:  .     :    //      . 2006. 3. . 58;  ..   . ., 1996. . 5758.]      .         ,   ;        [8 -       .:  ..   . ., 2015. . 158.],       ,       , ,  ,  ,        .  ,  ,   ,      . , ,        ,         ,     .    ,           ,      ;           ,      ,     ,    .

           .          B ,      ()     .     ,        ,         - , ,   ()   ..[9 - .: Jansen N. Comparative Law and Comparative Knowledge // The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Law / Ed. by M. Reimann, R. Zimmermann. Oxford University Press, 2008. P. 310.]  ,         ,  ,   (tertium comparationis), ,      ,    , ,          ,   .

   ,    ,       ,         ;    ,   ,     ,    [10 - .: Jansen N. Op. cit. P. 314.].          ,          [11 - .:  .,  .   :  2. ., 2010.].          .

     - ,       .        ,   .         ,   ,    (     ;    ,        ,     ,   ;    ,          ,    ..). ,           , ..    ,    ,   ,        ,      [12 - .: Jackson V.C. Comparative Constitutional Law: Methodologies // The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Constitutional Law. P. 6266.].        (   , ,  ..)        .

           (  ,  ,  ,  )       ,    [13 - Bell J. Comparing Public Law // Comparative Law in the 21


Century / Ed. by A. Hardy, E. ?r?s?. London, 2002. P. 235247.].        ,          ,       ,     [14 - .: Harding A., Leyland P. Comparative Law in Constitutional Context // Comparative Law / Ed. by E.?r?s?, D. Nelken. Oxford, 2007. P. 316.]. ,  ,      ,         ,   .     ,                    [15 - .: Legrand P. Comparative Legal Studies and the Matter of Authenticity // http://www. pierre-legrand.com/comparing-authentically.pdf].      ,  .   , -,      .           ,        .        ,    ,              .

 ,       [16 - ., .: Siems M. Comparative Law. Cambridge, 2014. P. 27, 37.],        ,     [17 - .: Jackson V.C. Comparative Constitutional Law: Methodologies. P. 67.],   ,  -   , , ,    - [18 - .: Whytock Ch. A. Legal Origins, Functionalism, and the Future of Comparative Law // Brigham Young University Law Review. 2009. 6. P. 1880.].

,              , ,  ,      ,      [19 - .: Legrand P. Op. cit. P. 367.].        (  )     ,    ,            .     ,   ,     ,       ,   [20 - .: Jackson V.C. Methodological Challenges in Comparative Constitutional Law // Penn State International Law Review. 2010. P. 325.]. ,   ,  ,  ,    ;           ,  ,  - ,        .. ,     ,            ;      ,      -       ,   -    ,   ,          .      (     )            [21 - .:  .          //   . 2004. 3. . 51.].

 ,           ,   ,        .  ,  ,     ,      ,          [22 -  ,         ,        ,      ,   ,    .],            .

  ,          .     (, ?, )  ,    , , ,     -      ,       [23 - .:  ..  :    //    . 2007 /  . .. . ., 2008. . 19.],       ,        [24 - .:  ..   :        //   . 2011. ., 2011. . 19.].   - ,          , -    ?

,                       . , ,    -  - ,                ,      , ..   ,         [25 - .:  ..  :  . ., 2007. . 1819.]. ,       , ,   ,       ,      ,                    [26 - .: Whytock Ch. A. Taking Causality Seriously in Comparative Constitutional Law: Insights from Comparative Politics and Comparative Political Economy // Loyola of Los Angeles Law Review. 2008. P. 639640.];           .

 ,   ,   -       ,      ()                  [27 - .:  ..  :      //  -  /  . .. , .. . ., 2013. . 3031.]         ,       ,     , ,     ; ,    . ,           ,         .           ,   ,    ,           ,        .               .      ,                 .     -               ,   [28 - .:  ..,  ..,  ..        . ., 2015. . 31.].

  ,           ,      ,            -         [29 - .: Jackson V.C. Comparative Constitutional Law: Methodologies. P.63.].       ,    .       [30 - .: Leyland P. Opposition and Fragmentations: In Search of a Formula for Comparative Analysis // Comparative Law in the 21


Century. P. 221.]. -          ,       - .                ,                ,        -   .                 -            .         ,    .

 -        ,              .

, ,   , ,   ,         ,            -  .           ,         ,                   .     ,           ,      (),           .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/a-a-troickaya/sravnitelnyy-metod-v-konstitucionnom-prave/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


           ,      (      ).     . ..         :  ,   ,       .  .




2


 ..     . ., 2011. . 1.




3


 .. .        . ., 1998. . 64.




4


.: Samuel G. An Introduction to Comparative Law Theory and Method. Oxford, 2014. P. 11.




5


.:  ..     :     //      . 2015. 5. . 747;  .  . ; ., 2008. . 78.




6


.: Przeworski A. Methods of Cross-National Research: An Overview // Comparative Policy Research: Learning from Experience / Ed. by M. Dierkes. Aldershot, 1987. P. 35.




7


.:  .     :    //      . 2006. 3. . 58;  ..   . ., 1996. . 5758.




8


      .:  ..   . ., 2015. . 158.




9


.: Jansen N. Comparative Law and Comparative Knowledge // The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Law / Ed. by M. Reimann, R. Zimmermann. Oxford University Press, 2008. P. 310.




10


.: Jansen N. Op. cit. P. 314.




11


.:  .,  .   :  2. ., 2010.




12


.: Jackson V.C. Comparative Constitutional Law: Methodologies // The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Constitutional Law. P. 6266.




13


Bell J. Comparing Public Law // Comparative Law in the 21


Century / Ed. by A. Hardy, E. ?r?s?. London, 2002. P. 235247.




14


.: Harding A., Leyland P. Comparative Law in Constitutional Context // Comparative Law / Ed. by E.?r?s?, D. Nelken. Oxford, 2007. P. 316.




15


.: Legrand P. Comparative Legal Studies and the Matter of Authenticity // http://www. pierre-legrand.com/comparing-authentically.pdf




16


., .: Siems M. Comparative Law. Cambridge, 2014. P. 27, 37.




17


.: Jackson V.C. Comparative Constitutional Law: Methodologies. P. 67.




18


.: Whytock Ch. A. Legal Origins, Functionalism, and the Future of Comparative Law // Brigham Young University Law Review. 2009. 6. P. 1880.




19


.: Legrand P. Op. cit. P. 367.




20


.: Jackson V.C. Methodological Challenges in Comparative Constitutional Law // Penn State International Law Review. 2010. P. 325.




21


.:  .          //   . 2004. 3. . 51.




22


 ,         ,        ,      ,   ,    .




23


.:  ..  :    //    . 2007 /  . .. . ., 2008. . 19.




24


.:  ..   :        //   . 2011. ., 2011. . 19.




25


.:  ..  :  . ., 2007. . 1819.




26


.: Whytock Ch. A. Taking Causality Seriously in Comparative Constitutional Law: Insights from Comparative Politics and Comparative Political Economy // Loyola of Los Angeles Law Review. 2008. P. 639640.




27


.:  ..  :      //  -  /  . .. , .. . ., 2013. . 3031.




28


.:  ..,  ..,  ..        . ., 2015. . 31.




29


.: Jackson V.C. Comparative Constitutional Law: Methodologies. P.63.




30


.: Leyland P. Opposition and Fragmentations: In Search of a Formula for Comparative Analysis // Comparative Law in the 21


Century. P. 221.


