 
 


 -      ,     ,           ,    ,         .     ,         ,      ,      , , .      ,    ,       .    





 

 



      ,     .       ,         ,     -.        ,  , ,            .   ,    ,     .       ,       . ,         ,    ,              .

     .   ,  ,       ,        ,    ,     .

,  :     ,     .   ,   (,     )     .       ,              .   , ,        4       .        ,       .   ,     :   , .     .  , .

 ,         ,   ,       .         .

  ,        ,       .   ,  ,   :    ,  .

  .



 









		,  .
		    ?
		    .
		     
		    .



          XVIIXVIII.   .[1 -        XVI.       .]  ,              .            .[2 - Gottfried (Strange, pp. 28 ff)      .    ,      .        .  1920-      (Isaacson, Einstein, p. 284).]

        ,            .         .          .         .       .

    ,   :   ,    ,        ,     XX.[3 -  (XVII.):  solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short (, , ,      .).    .]        .

   ,        񻠖   ,   .             . ,  2008 -       ,        ,    .         ;           ,   ;            .  ,  ?

 ,  ,   ,    (   ,   );    ,     .      ,   ,  ,       ( ) .[4 -    .   , .   ,  (     ,       ). - .    . ,   .     Harrington, Socialism      ,     .        .  컠   ,   -.    Thomas (       )  Fascism.] ,    ,   ,    ,  ,     .       ().  ,   ,    .

  ,  ,  -.[5 - -,  (1958)    : Kelso  Adler, The capitalist. ,  ,  Callinicos, An anti-capitalist.]         (          ).         ,      .[6 -        :      .   . .]    (   )       .[7 -       (. 17-   , . 16).]    , :       .[8 -  ,    - :   .  :       ,     [ , ]  ,      .  ,  ,  :   - ().]

          .   ,  ,  . ,      ,     .[9 - ,     ( ?).      ,  -  :   -  ,  , : ,   .]       ,      .[10 - . itro  Kalton. Future;   itro  Cork  Norwood. The 200Census.]

     .       .   XII   , , ,  - ,           ?

   ,       . ,   ,   ,    , . - (!)    ,     ,     ,  ,         ? ,   ,   ,   ,  ;      .             ,    .    .

  軠                ,            . ,     ,   ,   ,  .     ,       ,      .

        XX.     .        .[11 -   . ,   1981    :     .        1979 (   1976)  Todd, Final (  1990).   (,  . 60:       ,   22 ).   :        .     The making of modern France (Cambridge: Mass., 1991)   ,   .] ,    , ,     .     ,    - .  ( )     100 ;    .   ,   .    ,   -  .

, ,    ,     ,    .  20089  ,      .

         ( ) ,  ;   ,   .  1917 (   )  ,  ,      (  ) ,    .       ;     ,    .



   ,  .       .  ,     ( ,    ), ,  ,   ,     ,    ,     ,   ,    .




 I.  


     ,   ,   ,    .

 

        (,   ,     ).          (  ,     ).     .      (    :    ,    ).    ;      (,  )  .[12 -    mot     1962 (!): ,     , ,    .    ,      .]

       -    ,    ,    .[13 -         ,      (. , Menger. Investigation, p. 152).]       .     XX.  ( . ,         ).

    :                    . .    .    컠     . ,         (. ),    .

   :              .[14 -   - (Hayek. Individualism, p. 3).      (Muravchik. Heaven, p. 57).]     ,   (-),  .[15 -      . . , ,     (.      i i.      , 1908, 10). ,       .       .]     .  ,   -,  -.[16 - -, -     .]     (guild) .    - .     .     Socialism   .     , . .    .[17 -  ( !)     Schumpeter, Capitalism, part V.          (    ),    ,      . .        .]

    ,  ,    .[18 -         .   I. Berlin, Karl, p. 1011:   (,   ,  )  .     Bukovsky, USSR.]             ,        .        ,    .      ( , !)       .              .       .

   ()  .         ,     ,     ,   (   )  ,   .[19 - Piore. Beyond.       .     .  ,    ,   .    -    .        .]             .     ,     ( )    .[20 -      . :          [   ]    .]  .

,      :   ,   ,       ,   . ,    ,    .

 .  (  . ),     (. :        ),  ( ) ,        .[21 - . .      Socialism and social theories (Berlin. The sense).]      .   ,   4  :

  ;

 ;

 ;

 ( ).

   .  ,   ,   ,     .     :    .[22 - Schumpeter. Ten, p. 5: In one important sense Marxism is a religion.]   ,        .    ,  ,    .

,     ,     .[23 - . , . 283 ff.]           :   ,   .        ,            ,       .[24 -   .     nature or nurture:   ,     .    :    ,      ,     .]

            .       ,   ( )   .    ,   ,   .[25 - ,       :     .]

    ,     .   ,    ,    .      ,      .      (liberalism),         .[26 -        .    Liberalism Mises   .  ,    .           -.]

 (              )     , ,   ,  ,       .            ().

,  ,   .[27 -      100   .: Lasch. American;   .: Gottfried. Strange, p. 54 ff.       .] ,  1986     .[28 - Stephens. Transition.]




 II. 


 ,  ,  ,        .

  

      ( ,  . ),   ?[29 -    . Schumpeter    Capitalism       (  ,  ,    p. 172). Hayek (Socialism, p. 221 ff)    . . : .  , . 36 ff.]    ,          .   ,   () .     ,   .

    ,   ,   .        .   ,  ,    ,    .  ,   .              .[30 -       ,  :    ,       ,   ,   . ,   ,    .    ,    .      ; ,    ?  ,     .    ,         ,            ,       .       The Superior Virtue of the Oppressed (Russell. Unpopular.      ).] ,       .[31 -          ,      .]

     .    ,    .      :    ,     []       .[32 -    ()    (. 219):      ,     ,    .  - ,    ,   ,   :  ,   ,    .                 ,   .]       ,   ,          /  .       ,      ,  ,  ,    .

   ,       ?[33 - Popper (Open, v. 2, p. 82) ,       ,      .    ; Schumpeter. Capitalism, p. 23:      :  ,     .  (    )    ,      .]    ,   ,    ?[34 - . ():   ,    .   ,                ,        ,    ,  ,      ,     ,      .  ,        ,     ,  ,   ,        ,         .         (     ,     Marxism)   ?      .   :   ,   ,      .  , ,     .]     ;  (  ),     ,     (   ).

   ,          (            ,         ).     .[35 -         (Liberalism, p. XXVII ff),   . :  ,   (.    , , . 1, . 6).]       ,         ,   ,   .[36 - Mises. Anti-capitalistic, p. 15 ff.  ,     .       .,   , :    ,    ;  ,   -  ,    -  . - ,   ,          .         .     c  , .        .]    ;      ,     .[37 -  XVII.   Thomas Hobbes,   David Hume.      . Mises. Liberalism, p. XXVIII:      ,  ,     ,    ,    ,   .]        ?

, ,           (0,62   ).[38 - Pinker. The blank, p. 283.   .]           .        ,    .       ,  ,   ,  .

        ,    . ,  ,   , :      ,   ,   ,                     ,   ,          ,         ,    .[39 - . , . 84. .  , 2000, 1, . 235 ff.] ,  ,  ,       ,   (   )  -  .   XIX    .   ,         .[40 -        .  ,   , ,   ,        (Schumpeter. Capitalism, p. 26).]

     .  ,   .   ,    .  :     ( ),     . , ,     .[41 -  :   黠   ( -).       .    ,   .]

   ,    ,   .    (   )    ,    ,  () ,  .[42 -  (   ,    Ayn Rand)      (.  Virtue, p. 1ff).      .    .   ,   . ,       ,  .]  ( 600 ) Mises, Socialism  1994  -.           .   ,     .[43 -         .          ?   , ,  ,     .    .    ,     ,   . . ,  :   .    ,   .]        ,    .[44 -     . ,        .]     1922,   Socialism:             .        . ,    ,  .

     ,     . ,      .[45 - Mises. Liberalism, p. 12.    Menger  Investigations (p. 82)       .           . ,   ,         .]     . ,     ,      .

    :     ,   (     ),  , - ,  ,    .[46 -       . .]        :     .

      (  ),     .    ,   ; ,       .[47 - ,   ,     ( )  The memories,      .]

      . ,  ,    ,     ,          (      ),    ,      (,   ),  .[48 -       , .: The Times Literary Supplement. 10.04.09, p. 6.  (Preston. Franco, p. 6) :    ,   ,         .   mot :       .] ,  ,       .  ,   -,    ( ):      .    .

     .       ,   .[49 -       (, ),  Schumpeter,    Ten ,     (    ),         (untenable).        ,      (Hayek. Individualism, p. 136). .  Schumpeter, Capitalism, ch. III.    . ,   Althusser  Balibar, Reading   ,    ,  Index,   30  (     Althusser. For Marx. L.: 1969), :  .  1948    . (.  B?hm-Bawerk. The exploitation, p. 147):                     .      ,         (Watson. Ideas, p. 517).]      ,  pro     contra.[50 -   Balkin, Poverty        ,   , ,  ,   ..    ,    .K.  (Miller. Popper, p. 26)       .]

        ,   - (     ),    .  Mises:         .         .[51 - Socialism, p. 457. ,      .         Furniss  Tulton The case, p. 51:        .   ,   ,  .]

    ; ,    , ,   .[52 -  Harrington, The Other   ,        .   .       .]        ..,      ( 20089  ).[53 -        Heilbroner: Between  21


century.]   ,        :     .[54 - Schumpeter. Capitalism, p. 144:      .]

     ,        ,     ,     ,    (,    ). , ,      ,  ,      ,   .[55 - The memories, p. 7.1]




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/igor-birman/kapitalisticheskiy-manifest/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


       XVI.       .




2


Gottfried (Strange, pp. 28 ff)      .    ,      .        .  1920-      (Isaacson, Einstein, p. 284).




3


 (XVII.):  solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short (, , ,      .).    .




4


   .   , .   ,  (     ,       ).

 - .    . ,   .     Harrington, Socialism      ,     .        .  컠   ,   -.    Thomas (       )  Fascism.




5


-,  (1958)    : Kelso  Adler, The capitalist. ,  ,  Callinicos, An anti-capitalist.




6


       :      .   . .




7


      (. 17-   , . 16).




8


 ,    - :   .  :       ,     [ , ]  ,      .  ,  ,  :   - ().




9


,     ( ?).      ,  -  :   -  ,  , : ,   .




10


. itro  Kalton. Future;   itro  Cork  Norwood. The 200Census.




11


  . ,   1981    :     .        1979 (   1976)  Todd, Final (  1990).   (,  . 60:       ,   22 ).   :        .     The making of modern France (Cambridge: Mass., 1991)   ,   .




12


   mot     1962 (!): ,     , ,    .    ,      .




13


        ,      (. , Menger. Investigation, p. 152).




14


  - (Hayek. Individualism, p. 3).      (Muravchik. Heaven, p. 57).




15


     . . , ,     (.      i i.      , 1908, 10). ,       .       .




16


-, -     .




17


 ( !)     Schumpeter, Capitalism, part V.

          (    ),    ,      . .        .




18


        .   I. Berlin, Karl, p. 1011:   (,   ,  )  .

     Bukovsky, USSR.




19


Piore. Beyond.       .     .  ,    ,   .    -    .        .




20


     . :          [   ]    .




21


. .      Socialism and social theories (Berlin. The sense).




22


Schumpeter. Ten, p. 5: In one important sense Marxism is a religion.




23


. , . 283 ff.




24


  .     nature or nurture:   ,     .    :    ,      ,     .




25


,       :     .




26


       .    Liberalism Mises   .  ,    .           -.




27


     100   .: Lasch. American;   .: Gottfried. Strange, p. 54 ff.       .




28


Stephens. Transition.




29


   . Schumpeter    Capitalism       (  ,  ,    p. 172). Hayek (Socialism, p. 221 ff)    . . : .  , . 36 ff.




30


      ,  :    ,       ,   ,   . ,   ,    .

    ,    .      ; ,    ?

  ,     .    ,         ,            ,       .       The Superior Virtue of the Oppressed (Russell. Unpopular.      ).




31


         ,      .




32


   ()    (. 219):      ,     ,    .  - ,    ,   ,   :  ,   ,    .                 ,   .




33


Popper (Open, v. 2, p. 82) ,       ,      .    ; Schumpeter. Capitalism, p. 23:      :  ,     .

  (    )    ,      .




34


. ():   ,    .   ,                ,        ,    ,  ,      ,     ,      .  ,        ,     ,  ,   ,        ,         .

         (     ,     Marxism)   ?      .   :   ,   ,      .  , ,     .




35


        (Liberalism, p. XXVII ff),   . :  ,   (.    , , . 1, . 6).




36


Mises. Anti-capitalistic, p. 15 ff.  ,     .       .

,   , :    ,    ;  ,   -  ,    -  . - ,   ,          .

         .     c  , .        .




37


 XVII.   Thomas Hobbes,   David Hume.      . Mises. Liberalism, p. XXVIII:      ,  ,     ,    ,    ,   .




38


Pinker. The blank, p. 283.   .




39


. , . 84. .  , 2000, 1, . 235 ff.




40


       .  ,   , ,   ,        (Schumpeter. Capitalism, p. 26).




41


 :   黠   ( -).       .    ,   .




42


 (   ,    Ayn Rand)      (.  Virtue, p. 1ff).      .    .   ,   . ,       ,  .




43


        .          ?   , ,  ,     .

    .    ,     ,   . . ,  :   .    ,   .




44


    . ,        .




45


Mises. Liberalism, p. 12.    Menger  Investigations (p. 82)       .           . ,   ,         .




46


      . .




47


,   ,     ( )  The memories,      .




48


      , .: The Times Literary Supplement. 10.04.09, p. 6.

  (Preston. Franco, p. 6) :    ,   ,         .   mot :       .




49


      (, ),  Schumpeter,    Ten ,     (    ),         (untenable).        ,      (Hayek. Individualism, p. 136). .  Schumpeter, Capitalism, ch. III.    . ,   Althusser  Balibar, Reading   ,    ,  Index,   30  (     Althusser. For Marx. L.: 1969), :  .  1948    .

 (.  B?hm-Bawerk. The exploitation, p. 147):                     .

      ,         (Watson. Ideas, p. 517).




50


  Balkin, Poverty        ,   , ,  ,   ..    ,    .

K.  (Miller. Popper, p. 26)       .




51


Socialism, p. 457. ,      .         Furniss  Tulton The case, p. 51:        .   ,   ,  .




52


 Harrington, The Other   ,        .   .       .




53


       Heilbroner: Between  21


century.




54


Schumpeter. Capitalism, p. 144:      .




55


The memories, p. 7.1


