  
 


 
                 .  ,           ,       .            ,     ,     .  .





 

  


,   



DAVID THROSBY

ECONOMICS AND CULTURE



 Published by the Press Syndicate of the University of Cambridge, 2001

 David Throsby, 2001

    .     , 2013; 2018







                ,   .   ,   ,  ,        ,     .  ,        ,  ,       ,     , ,   ,  ,  ,      ,   ,           .    ,  ,    , ,    . , ,    ; ,     ,      , ,     ,  ,    .         : ,        ,        - ,   ,    ?  ,  ,       ?

         . ,      ,    ,               ,        .    ,     -      ,              ,    . ,        .        .                       .   ,   ,   ,  ,           ,           XVIII .

   XX.,                    ,       .    1970-      ,           ,   ,        . , ,     ,            ,  ,   .     ,  ,         ,   ,  ,  ,        .

                    ,  20   10  .       ,                             .          - ;   Journal of Economic Literature      Z1,      ,     ,    .         ,   -    JEL,    .

        ,   ,               .        ,                   .   ,  ,                .       1998.,    150    ,                .        1999.,   ,        , ,                       .

     ,  ,      ,   ,  .     ,   , .   ,                ,   ,            ,      ,  ,          .   ,   ,          , ..           ,    .       ,           .  ,  ,    ,        ,   ,          ,       .

       . -,        ,      ,      .           ,              .  ,            ,    .                         .  ,    ,   ,       ,      ,                  (   )    ,     .

 1999.                , .       ,        .  ,           ,         ,         .        ,       ,        .              ,        .

,               /    .     ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,     .       ,            .



 
,  2000







     ,        .               ,     ,           :           :     (The Production and Consumption of the Arts: A View of Cultural Economics // Journal of Economic Literature. 1994. No. 32. P. 129);                  (The Relationship between Economic and Cultural Policy // Culture and Policy. 1987. No. 8. P. 2536);                   (Economic and Cultural Value in the Work of Creative Artists // Values and Heritage Conservation / E. Avrami et al. (eds). 2000. P. 2631)              (Cultural Capital and Sustainability Concepts in the Economics of Cultural Heritage, 1999); Harwood Academic Publishers GmbH       :    (Sustainability and Culture; Some Theoretical Issues // International Journal of Cultural Policy. 1997. No. 4. P. 720); Kluwer Academic Publishers     ,    (Culture, Economics and Sustainability // Journal of Cultural Economics. 1995. No. 19. P. 199206)      (Cultural Capital // Journal of Cultural Economics. 1999. No. 23. P. 312); Macmillan Press Limited  St Martin's Press           (Seven Questions in the Economics of Cultural Heritage // Economic Perspective on Cultural Heritage / M. Hutter, I. Rizzo (eds). 1997. P. 1330);            (The Role of Music in International Trade and Development // World Culture Report. 1998. No. 1. P. 193209).




I.


   ,     .

. ,  ,  IV[1 -  . .   //  . . : 4. . 1. .: , 1981. . .]




 


     ,  ,        , :    ,  ,  [2 - [Blackmore, 1869].].   ,  ,       ,  ,         .

,        . , ,               ,          .       ,   ,        ,  ,          .     ,   ,    ,        ,         .   ,            ,      ,               .              ,    .

                       .         , ,                .                 ,              .    ,            ,      ,      .      (      )    :       ,   ,   ,      ,     .

  ,           ,    ,        ,                      .             ,   ,        ,     .  ,  ,   ,  ;     ,    ,             ,  , , ,  , , ,   ,      .

,     ,  ,        ,          .      ,   .  ,     ,        .        ,      - ,     ,             .     ,           .

           ,      .               [3 - [Williams, 1976, p. 76].].   ,          [4 - [Borofsky, 1998, p. 64].];         ,       ,    .   . ໠ ,      ,       .             ,       ,        -       [5 -      , ,     , .: [Marcus, Fischer, 1986],   [Ruttan, 1988]; [Appadurai, 1996]      1  2  [Borofsky, 1998].      .: [Di Maggio, 1994]    .: [Cooper, Denner, 1998].].

 ,         .    , ,    .  XVI.         .         :   ,      ,  ,        , ,  ,        .    XIX.                 ,    ,    .           ,        ,       .

           .     ,      ?    ,     ,     ; ,     , ,  ,   ,      .    ,       ,            .

 ,       ,      ,    , , , ,   ,   .       , , ,      ,     , ,   ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,    .. ,  ,     , , , , ,      ..           (      )   ,              .                    .

      ,    ,   ,    ,    ,      .      ,      ,         .        ,  [6 -  [Williams, 1976, p. 81] ,        XIX .],   ,  ,      .    ,  ,                   .    :

        ;

      ;

   ,    ,    .

,       ,  ,  ,      ,    ,      .       ,       ,    .

             ,          . , ,       , , , , ,    ..     .  ,         ,  ,  , , ,  ,       ,            .   , , ,  ,      , ,           ,       ,       ,     [7 -   ,      ,                       .].             ,          .      .      ,           ,   ,     ,    .      ,          , ..    ,   ,        [8 -        .  [Seaman, 1999].].

   ,  ,    ,        ,    ,                 .       ,        ,          [9 -        ,           (    ); .      [Caves, 2000].].             ;             .         ,      ,      . II.

 ,             .  ,       ,     .  ,         , , ,             , [10 -    -; .: [Dolfsma, 1999].].          .             .




 


       .     , ,      ,     ,    :              .   ,   ,  ,   ,  ,  ,      ,  ,     ,                       ,     .

         ,      ,    ,      ,     , .      ,         ,   .      ,  , ,  ,      ,   ,     .        ,  ,        ,            ,        .  ,                . ,      ,         ,   , ,  ,       [11 -             (The World Commission on Culture and Development, 1995, p. 3351);   ,      ,          ,     .].     ,  ,    ,       ,    ,           ,     .

 ,   ,  ,      .       ,   ,  ,   ,       ,   .      ,      ,    ,  ,   [12 - .     [Wright, 1998].].        ,      . , ,      ,    -         .       , ,             .  ,  ,   , ,       ,   , ,    .      ,           ,   ,  ,     ,    ,        ,    .

 ,  ,   ,   ,  ,     ,   .  ,      ,               .  , , ,  , ,      ,     ,               .   ,  -      ,       ,        ,            :         [13 - [Williams, 1958];       .: [Peterson, 1976].].              (    , , ,   ),         ,  ,  .




    ?   


       ,             ,     ,   ,        ,     ,          .         ,           ,     ,            .

  ,  :    ,        ,         ,      ,         ,    .                ,                 ,   , , , ,  ,  ,      .        ,    ,        ,           . ,   ,      ,     ,                      ,           .     ,  , , ,                     , ,      ,        ,    .

 ,           ,    ,   ,       . ,    , ,     ,            ,    .                ,   ,       [14 - [McCloskey, 1985; 1994; Amariglio, 1988].]. ,    ,          ,    , , ,       ,     [15 - ., ,     ,      ( ),  ,      [Klamer, 1988, p. 260262].]; ,    ,            .

                .  ,    ,       ,  .    ,              ,              .            ,       ,         ,  ,       ,   ,    [16 -            . ,               [Mayhew, 1994, p. 117; North, 1990; , 1997; Stanfield, 1995].            [Escobar, 1995, ch. 3].].   ,      ,        .  ,       ,                [17 - [Cozzi, 1998].].           ,  -           .

   ,                       . ,                 [18 -    19041905. .  : [Weber, 1930].  .: [ONeil, 1995; Armour, 1996].].   ,     ,     .           . ,     ,        ,        ,    ,     ,            [19 - [Landes, 1969; Temin, 1997].].          ,      ,               ,  ,    .       . IV.




  :   


         ;    .                .                  .

      , ,   ..,   ,                 ,         .          ,   ,  , ,   ..   .        ,              .       ,   ,         .        ,       ,        . ,              ,  ,    [20 - [Jackson, 1996];    .: [Harris, 1979].].

 ,                      ,       ,     .  ,             (1995),          .  , ,      ,  ,    , ,   ,       ,   ,                   ,        .       . IV.

       ,       ,     . ,        ,                          ,     ,    .            ,   ,  1947.    ,   .  ,          ;         [21 - [Adorno, Horkheimer, 1947; , , 1997; Adorno, 1991].].           ,         .

   ,    , ,       ,               (  ,    )[22 - [Storey, 1993, p. 618].].       ,    ,             .          ,              ,   , , ,         [23 - [Connor, 1997, p. 51].].        ,    (). , ,  ,    ,    ,   [24 - [Baudrillard, 1994, p. 1214]; . : [Best, Kellner, 1999, p. 111145; Storey, 1993, p. 162165].].

       .        ( , ),     .                  ,     Journal of Cultural Economics    Journal of Economic Literature,     .              [25 -   , ,  [Galbraith, 1960, ch. 3].],            :   (1966).       ,               [26 -          [Throsby, 1994b; Hutter, 1996; Towse, 1997a, vol. I, p. xii-xxi; Blaug, 1976; Netzer, 1978; Throsby, Withers, 1979; Hendon et al., 1980; Feld et al., 1983; Hendon, Shanahan, 1983; Kurabayashi, Matsuda, 1988; Frey, Pommerehne, 1989; Grampp, 1989; Feldstein, 1991; Moulin, 1992; Towse, Khakee, 1992; Heilbrun, Gray, 1993; Mossetto, 1993; Peacock, 1993; Towse, 1993; Trimarchi, 1993; Farchy, Sagot-Duvouroux, 1994; Peacock, Rizzo, 1994; Ginsburgh, Menger, 1996; Klamer, 1996; Hutter, Rizzo, 1997; Cowen, 1998; O'Hagan, 1998; Benhamou, 2000; Frey, 2000]  .   [Towse, 1997a]         .]   .            ,             . , , ,        ,         ,        ;         -      .           , ,    ,          .  ,   ,      ,      ,         . ,           ,               ,        ,  ,     ,        .          . VII.




  


  ,    ,         ,              [27 -         . : [Infantino, 1998]; ,      .: [Rushton, 1999].],    ,     ,  ,      .                   .   ,   :    ,    .

  , -,  ,      ,         ,      ,      ,   ,    .      ,       ,      ,               .         ,     ;    ,          ,              .

,       .         ,            . ,   ,       ,        ,       .        .            ,    ,    -.           .

-,   ,     ,    ;                 ,    .  ,      ,    ,    ,        .       ,        .         ,     ,       ,    ,         [28 -         .: [Becker, 1974].].       ,          ,         . ,      .        ,  ,  ,  ,        ,    .    ,   ,  ,         ,           .  ,         ,            ,      ,       .

 ,     ,                  ,             ,        .                  .




 


 ,   -    ,     ,  ,     . ,             ,           ,      ,       .  II,  ,          , ,     .        ,      ,    , ..      ,    ,         .     . III,           ,     .                    ,       ,       .   ,        ,       :       ,       ,     .                  .

 . IV  V        ,    .  . IV       :       ,                  ,      .       -       ,   -         .  . V    : , ,     , ,         .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/devid-trosbi/ekonomika-i-kultura-12024932/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


 . .   //  . . : 4. . 1. .: , 1981. . .




2


[Blackmore, 1869].




3


[Williams, 1976, p. 76].




4


[Borofsky, 1998, p. 64].




5


     , ,     , .: [Marcus, Fischer, 1986],   [Ruttan, 1988]; [Appadurai, 1996]      1  2  [Borofsky, 1998].      .: [Di Maggio, 1994]    .: [Cooper, Denner, 1998].




6


 [Williams, 1976, p. 81] ,        XIX .




7


  ,      ,                       .




8


       .  [Seaman, 1999].




9


       ,           (    ); .      [Caves, 2000].




10


   -; .: [Dolfsma, 1999].




11


            (The World Commission on Culture and Development, 1995, p. 3351);   ,      ,          ,     .




12


.     [Wright, 1998].




13


[Williams, 1958];       .: [Peterson, 1976].




14


[McCloskey, 1985; 1994; Amariglio, 1988].




15


., ,     ,      ( ),  ,      [Klamer, 1988, p. 260262].




16


           . ,               [Mayhew, 1994, p. 117; North, 1990; , 1997; Stanfield, 1995].            [Escobar, 1995, ch. 3].




17


[Cozzi, 1998].




18


   19041905. .  : [Weber, 1930].  .: [ONeil, 1995; Armour, 1996].




19


[Landes, 1969; Temin, 1997].




20


[Jackson, 1996];    .: [Harris, 1979].




21


[Adorno, Horkheimer, 1947; , , 1997; Adorno, 1991].




22


[Storey, 1993, p. 618].




23


[Connor, 1997, p. 51].




24


[Baudrillard, 1994, p. 1214]; . : [Best, Kellner, 1999, p. 111145; Storey, 1993, p. 162165].




25


  , ,  [Galbraith, 1960, ch. 3].




26


         [Throsby, 1994b; Hutter, 1996; Towse, 1997a, vol. I, p. xii-xxi; Blaug, 1976; Netzer, 1978; Throsby, Withers, 1979; Hendon et al., 1980; Feld et al., 1983; Hendon, Shanahan, 1983; Kurabayashi, Matsuda, 1988; Frey, Pommerehne, 1989; Grampp, 1989; Feldstein, 1991; Moulin, 1992; Towse, Khakee, 1992; Heilbrun, Gray, 1993; Mossetto, 1993; Peacock, 1993; Towse, 1993; Trimarchi, 1993; Farchy, Sagot-Duvouroux, 1994; Peacock, Rizzo, 1994; Ginsburgh, Menger, 1996; Klamer, 1996; Hutter, Rizzo, 1997; Cowen, 1998; O'Hagan, 1998; Benhamou, 2000; Frey, 2000]  .   [Towse, 1997a]         .




27


        . : [Infantino, 1998]; ,      .: [Rushton, 1999].




28


        .: [Becker, 1974].


