
  


            .              .       (,   .),       ,    ,     .         .  ࠖ  :   ,  ,  , .                -.





 



,   



 . , 2019

 . ,   , 2019

 OOO   , 2013; 2019


* * *







    ,      .               .        .       ,          . , , , ,        .           .  ,     ,        .

   19             .          .           .             ,   .      ,       ,   ,   .

 ,       ,        .     ,         ,       .     ,    ,     .      蠖 , , , , , , , , , , , ,    :   ,    ,  ,    .        ,         蠖 ,   :    ;   ;   ,      .  ,         ,    ,   .       ,     .

             ,         . , ,         .     .      : ,  ,   .    ,   ,                .     ,           .          ,        .      ,     .    ,        .     ,       .    ,      ;        .             ,    ,      .         ,     ,       .

          19 .      ,    .            I       ;       ,      ,   1880-;        ; ,   .         .       ,        ,   ,    .           .

  蠖  ,  , , ,       .      ,             .             .       - .        ,            .    19       ,    ,   ,       20-.

    ,    젖   .    -             .       ,     ,        .           .   ,      - 젖 , , , , .

          ,      ,    ,   ,    .   ,   ,      [1 - . : Carl E. Schorske. Fin-de-Ciecle Vienna. Politics and Culture. London: Weidenfeld, 1979, XXV.].       .      , , ,      ,   ,       ,   ,             .

   ⠖   ,   ,         ,          -  .      .       .    ,   ,     .         ,      .         ,    ,  ,  ,  .    , , ;     .

    ,   ,   ,        .    ,          .    ,         ,  .      ,    ,      ,    [2 - Julia Kristeva. Semiotike. Paris: Seuil, 1969; Harold Bloom. The Anxiety of Influence. New York: Oxford University Press, 1973; Michael Riffater. Text Production. New York: Columbia University Press, 1983.        .: Renate Lachmann. Gedachtnis und Literatur. Intertextualitat in der russischen Moderne. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp, 1990.];  ,    ,          [3 -  ,    ,        ; . Stephen Greenblatt. Shakespearean Negotiations. The Circulation of Social Energy in Renaissance England. Oxford: Clarendon, 1988; New Historicism and Renaissance Drama, ed. Richard Wilson and Richard Dutton. London, 1992; The New Historicism Reader, ed. A. E. Veeser. New York, 1994,    Representation.   ,   ,   : Irina Paperno. Chernyshevsky and the Age of Realism. A Study in the Semiotics of Behavior. Stanford University Press, 1988; Richard Stites. Revolutionary Dreams. Utopian Vision and Experimental Life in the Russian Revolution. New York: Oxford University Press, 1989; Laura Engelstein. The Keys to Happiness. Sex and the Search for Modernity in Fin-de-Siecle Russia. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1992; Svetlana Boym. Common Places. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1994; Katerina Clark. Petersburg, Crucible of Cultural Revolution. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1995; Eric Naiman. Sex in Public. The Incarnation of Early Soviet Ideology. Princeton, New Jercy: Princeton University Press, 1997.].     ,           ;   ;       .              .        ,  ,   頖     ,     ,    ;    ,              ;      .







             .     -   ,         .

      :   ( )   -;    ; Widener Library  .   ,         ;       -;   . .   ;    , .               -;      -;    , -; Houghton Archive  ;     , .

          :   , Wiener Slawistischer Almanach, Revue des etudes Slaves, , , , ,  , Studia Slavica Finlandensia, Studia Russica Helsingiensia et Tartuensia.

    CIMO (),  ,     ,       (),     ,     .        ,   ,     -;    ;    ;  - ();    -.

  ,        .




 1

  








  1905                 ,       ,   [4 -        .  . .   . . ࠖ  -1.   .   , 1964, 393.].        [5 -      . -,     ,         ,   (18551937)   .      ,           ,       (-, 1905).],     ,     .      ,    .       :   ,      .

     .       ,   ,    :



  ,    , ,    ,  ;         ,       .     []    ,  []   .  , , , ,     [6 -     . . . -, 1936, 109;     : . . .          . : - , 1989, 176180.].


  , , , ,  (堖  ),   ,  ,      - ,        .    ,  .   ,  . ,   [7 - .   , 179.].     [8 -     , 393.].    (     )    ,       .  . ,       . , -, , .   ,      , .      ()          ,    [9 - .   , 179.] (      [10 -     , 393.]).       ,    ;    .  ,  . ,  .

         [11 -  . .   . . .  . .   . .   , 1992, 2, 144.]; .    .      ,       ;       ,      ࠖ , ,  .  ,             ,     -:     ,    ,     []   ,             []  ,   1904   [12 - ,  .  ࠖ  , 1904, 10, 715.        ,     ; .    -, ,    ,   1950-:        7     .        ,     []       ,  ,     컠 . : . . .      .    , 1960, 34, 30.];        .     ,          ⠖  ,  ,  .

      ,      ;   ,  ,         .  ,            .       - ,  ,     ,    ,         [13 - .  . . ࠖ    . , 1940, 7, 132.].          . ,  :  ,      [14 -     . . , 35.].             .     , ,        [15 -  .]. -,     :          , ,    ,     ,   .         . . -,    []     ;     :     (  ..   )[16 - Horst Lampl. Zinaida Hippius and S.P.Remizova-Dovgello Wiener Slawistischer Almanach, 1978, 1, 164.].

       ; , ,   .            :  -    -     ,    ( )[17 - ..   . , 1990, 176;   . .   499.].      :  ,   ,   ,      ,     ,   [18 - . . -.  . , 1951, 145.]. ,     ,     :         ,        .  ,    .             :



   ?  .         (, , ).   .      . 蠖   ;   . ,        .    .       ,        . , . ,         ()        : , ,   [19 -  . . . :    , 3.          ( , );  ,       .].








   蠖  ,        ,     ,  ,  .   , - ,    .         ࠖ    .         .

    ,    ,       .        ,      ,   ,   .       .       ,       ,     ,     ,    ;         .             , ,     .           .          ;          .         ,         .

                    -蠖   11   16       [20 - Norman Cohn. The Pursuit of the Millennium. London: Secker and Warburg, 1957;  Norman Cohn. Cosmos, Chaos and the World to Come. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1993.].           ,         ;         20 .    , ,    ,   ࠖ  .      ,       .  ,    ,  2  ..     ;  ,     ,   ,    , .         ,     .        ,     :         ,    ,    .       ,    ,  .         .   4      ,       :   ,      ,     .         ,      .

       .    5      ,            .    ,      , , ,      ,  .      ,          :      ,      ,      [21 - . . .   . -: , 1908, 2, 67.].

 12        ,      :   -,       ,     . ,   ,       .  ꠖ  ࠖ   .           ;      ,       .          [22 - Cohn. The Pursuit of the Millennium, 99.].         ,    .

      .  10      ,     . ,       ,      :       . , ,       .          .        ,      .      ,        .    12     ; 1208     .        ,     .

   ,        .        ,         .       ,    ,     .  ࠖ , , , , 蠖         .     ,    蠖 , ,      .        ,  ,  .    ,       ,     ,    ,           .  , ,   ,    12     ,   , 12          .

       ,      1260 .   , ,         ,     .     ,   .         ,     .       ,      ,      .    ,       .    ,  ,   ,      .     ,   ,           .  1349    ,   ;    ,    15      .

      ,     .         ,     .      ,    ,  .          ,       ,   ;          젖 , , , .          ;               .        ;       ,     ;      ;  ,   ,       ,      .          .      14   ,      .   ;        .

     :     ,           .         ,     . ,           .        ,     .          .   ,            .          1022   .       ,   ,    .  1114        .  1240        ,       .       .   1157      .  1233          [23 - Jeffrey Richards. Sex, Dissidence and Damnation. Minority Groups in the Middle Ages. London: Routledge, 1990, 59.].

        ,     ,         ,   .    12    ,       ,     ,    .       .  ,               ;       ,   ,   .



    -,     -;   ,        ;     ,         [24 - Cohn. The Pursuit of the Millennium, 316;    .: Robert E. Lerner. The Heresy of Free Spirit. Berkeley: Berkeley University Press, 1972.].


      ,      ,      , ,    . ,     ,     .    ,                .  1163  11 ⠖ 8        .      .   ,     ,          .     ,                .               .      ,  ,  : ߠ  ,  .      ars erotica  :  ,   ,  ,   ,   [25 - Cohn. The Pursuit of the Millennium, 160.].      ,       ;   1215      .   14       , , ,      .      ;             1551 .       .    ,            ,   .

     ,        ,   .        ,    .  ,             . ,        ,    .       .  ,   15      ,      []       ,       []    ,  [26 -  , 150, 174, 183.].      ,        ,    .

   ,    ,   ,         2     13-,    17  , ,    19 .  14   , ,  : ,  ,    ,   ;    ,  ,    ; ,   ,       ; ,    ,   []   ;        ,         ,     [27 - Cohn. The Pursuit of the Millennium, 187191.].

   ,    ,       ,     ,       .    ,  ,   ,   ; ,    ,   .              .        ,           .         ,    ,    ,       .    ,    ,     .         10  .           ;     .       ,         :     [28 -  .].

,    ,   ,      ,    .     ,   ;     .    1317   ,  ,    ,      .        .       ,   ,   .   ,        ,     .   ,      堖    ,        .   ,   ,   ,       ;           ,  ,         .

  14        ,     .          ,   1418   ;      .               .          .        ,      .   ,   ;           .   ,       ; ,  ,      .  1421     ;        .

,      ,      ;  15       .   16      .     ,     ,       .         .        :   ?  ,       ,    ,        .  ,      ,    ,  ;     .      ,     ,     ,       .  1525        .      ,     .         .

 ,           ,      [29 -      .: Malcolm B. Hamilton. Sociology of Religion. Theoretical and Comparative Perspectives. London: Routledge, 1995, ch.7.          .: Bob Schribner. Practical Utopias: Pre-Modern Communism and the Reformation Comparative Studies in Society and History, 1994, 36, 4, 743774.].    ,      .       ,   -   ,      .     .  1534     ,      .       .   ;    ,   .    .       .  ,  ,           .

      .   ,         .     ,  ,     , ,  .    ;     ;         .           .       .             .         ;     .       15 .       .   . ,          -   .    ,   .  ,    ,       렖    ;          .  1535   [30 - Cohn. The Pursuit of the Millennium, 306;          .: Lyndal Roper. Oedipus and the Devil. Witchcraft, Sexuality and Religion in Early Modern Europe. London: Routledge, 1994, ch.4.].

 1413           ,      .  1570          -;                .    , ,     16 [31 - . . .     .  . : , 1977, 6070.].    17                 ,     [32 - . . .      (   - )       , , 1930, 3, 3032.].  19 堖         .        .  ,  , ⠖           .   20           .

  ,         ,   .          ,      .                      19 [33 - .     .  , 68.].        ,    16 ,     .     ,    -      ;      .  1869        ,         , []     ,   - [34 - . .  . -:  . . , 1869, 1, 25.].          ,   .     ,        .        .     .      堖  ,  ,      .       ,  .        ,    .         ;           ,   ,   ,    .        ;      :           ,   [35 -  , 36.].    ,       [36 -  , 51.].          ,        .      ,      [37 -        ,  .     1869  ,     :     ,        ,     .     1978,      ,            .  -,    ,                : . . .      14-젖   16- . :  , 1960;  .     . : , 1965;  .    . . -堖    , 1983, 44, 6688;  .     .  ;  .     . 19- . : , 1978.].







    頖   ,    ,   ;        .  ,   ,         ,    ,     .     1920-,      -        ;     .             ,  ,   [38 - Rene Fuelop-Miller. Geist und Gesicht des Bolschevismus. Zurich: Amathea-Verlag, 1926 ( : Rene Fuelop-Miller. The Mind and Face of Bolshevism. New York: Harper, 1965).    ,      ,      ,     ; . : James Rice. Dostoyevsky and the Healing Art. Ann Arbor: Ardis, 1985, 218219.].      [39 -   ; . ,  2.]. .   1927       -:     []   -  [40 - .  (. ).  蠖 , 1927, 2, 177.].  ,               ,     ,  ,  ,   .  1932      :



  ,   []   ,    , []    [] ()                .           [41 - . .      Р  , 1932, 4, 45.].


               .      , ,       . , ,    .       ,      .               .          ,   .  ,        ;  ,    ,       ,    .   ,  ,   .       , , ,        .  ,        .    ,     ,    ,      ,        .   ,      ,      [42 -                     , 1931, 4, 175203;  .: . .  .    . -: , 1993, .6 (Alexander Etkind. Eros of the Impossible. The History of Psychoanalysis in Russia. Boulder-London: Westview, 1997).].      ,   .       : ,   ;   ,   ;  ,    .       ,   ,         ,   .

           ,      [43 - .: James H. Billington. Fire in the Minds of Men. Origins of the Revolutionary Faith. New York: Basic Books, 1980;      : Michael Walzer. The Revolution of the Saints. A Study in the Origins of Radical Politics. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1965;        : Lawrence Foster. Religion and Sexuality. Three American Communal Experiments of the 19th Century. New York: Oxford, 1981; Yaacov Oved. Two Hundred Years of American Communes. New Brunswick: Transaction Books, 1988.];    , ,    .               [44 - . .  . : , 1987;  .     ࠖ   .:  . : , 1990, 273302.].   ,       .     ,          .    ,  ,    , ,       ,    -.      ,         ,   ;         .     [45 -       -; .: Aage A. Hansen-L?ve. Apokalyptik und Adventismus in russischen Symbolismus der Jahrhundertwende R. G. Grubel (Hg.). Russische Literatur an der Wende vom 19. Zum 20. Jahrhundert. Amsterdam/Atlanta, 1993, 273.]      ,      .       ,     蠖    ;    ,     ;     ,     , ,      .       .  ,           ,         .   ,   ,   ;   ,    ;  .        ,  ,  ,  , .

          ,      ,       ,    .     ,      :   [46 -  ,         , .: Marianne Weber. Max Weber. A Biography. Translated by Harry Zohn. New Brunswick: Transaction, 1988, 323.].            ,      .   ,  :          ,           , []    ,      [],      [47 - Max Weber. Gesammelte Aufsatze zur Soziologie und Socialpolitic. Tubingen, 1924, 469470.].  ,       .             ,   .      1905    [48 - Max Weber. Zur Russischen Revolution von 1905. Tubingen: Mohr Verlag, 1996.].             ,       .                 ,      [49 - Arthur Mitzman. The Iron Cage. An Historical Interpretation of Max Weber. New Brunswick: Transaction, 1985, 272; Marianne Weber. Max Weber. A Biography, 327.].             ,    [50 -      .: B.Naarden. Marx and Russia History of European ideas, 12, 6, 1990, 783797;      .: .  .    , .4; James L. Rice. Freuds Russia. National Identity in the Evolution of Psychoanalysis. New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers, 1993.].              [51 - . . , . . .        , 1994, 2, 7478.].              , ,     [52 - Mitzman. The Iron Cage; L.A. Staff. Fleeing from the Iron Cage. Culture, Politics and Modernity in the Thought of Max Weber. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1989.      .: Bryan S.Turner. Max Weber. From History to Modernity. London: Routledge, 1992; Ernest Gellner. Postmodernism, Reason and Religion. London: Routledge, 1992.].

  1909            ,      .



   ,            [] , ,        []         [53 - . .        .: . : , 1993.].


 ,    ,     .     ,           .             .    ,     .        ,   . ,  ,   .        .    ,   ,         ,  ,   .   頖     ,  ,   ,   [54 - . . .   .  . . .   . . . , 1, 1906; 2, 1913.      .: M.Hagemeister. Nikolaj Fedorov: Studien zu Leben, Werk und Wirkung. M?nchen: Sagner, 1989.].       -    .

           ,      .              ;    , ,   .  ,  -    ,  ,   ,  ⠖    ;     , , .           ;  ,    ,   .        ;        . ,       ;        ,        .   [55 - Irene Masing-Delich. Abolishing Death. A Salvation Myth of Russian Twentieth-Century Literature. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1992.];      .      ,  ,      ,  ,   [56 - . . .  .     . : - . . , 1911.];  , ,   ,      .

               .   ,        ,    ,   ,     .        .    ,    [57 -  ,          , : Alexander Gershenkron. Europe in the Russian Mirror. Cambridge University Press, 1970, ch.2.       ,   ,          .].       ,  ,  ,    ,   .           ,  : -       ,  堖 horribile dictu   [58 - . .  . , 1923, 78; horribile dictu  .].

              ;         ,     ,   .                   ;     ,          .  ,      ,                [59 - . .   蠖  , 1927, 33, 361.].         ,      .           ,   -,       .

             . , ,    ,     ,  :



      ,    ;       ,    [60 -  , 360.].








  ,   1631                 .      ,      ,  ,  12 .       :   ,   ,      ,    .    ,     ,   .  ,   ,      .   ,  .  , -,     .

  ,     .     ,  ,    ,  ,      ,    .   ,      .       ,   [61 - . . .    . :  , 1872, 79; . .   . -, /, 290.].    , - ,  ,  ,        .      ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  .           .

  ,    ,   ,            .         ,      :   .       :    ;       ,       .

     ,     .      ,        ,         .         ,   ,   ,         .    , ,   ,         ,          .        ,   ,        ,  -     .          ,           .

     ,       [62 -    .: .   .    . M?nchen: Wilhelm Fink Verlag, 1970, 144156; . . .     . : , 1986, 6681.].       ,      ,   1620- .             2030 .           .            .   1660-      :        .     ,      1674        1682 .   ,      ,   1639    .        (1669 )   :       []    [63 - .     , 201.]. -,    17 ,       ,      ,  ,        .

    ,        .    ,  ,  1645[64 -  (   , 85)    ,    19      ;  .: .     . :   , 1882, 41.].           ,   .                   [65 -  ,     ,        (.      . : YMCA-Press. 1959, 2, 148).   ., .: . . .  .     . , 1931, 1; 1934, 2.].              .  ,       ,     ,     .    ,       .  ,        ;         .       .         ,     .         ,         .

 ,       ,   ,      I.     17         ,          ,    ,   ,    ,     .   ,             ,      .   16661667 ,        ,    .   .     ,      .     ,        .       ,   .     ;  ,     ;          .

         1652 [66 - .   , 3.].              ,           .  ,   ,    ,    .     ,       ,         ,    .       ,     ;  , ,          ,    .

  ,     ,           [67 - Paul Avrich. Russian Rebells. London: Allen Lane Penguin, 1973, 143.].  ,     ,        .       ,         (, ) [68 - . .   렖 , -: - . . , 1908, 1, 466.       .: . .  :     ,  .].            ; 1686     2  .   ,         .    , ,  ,   ,  ,      [69 - . . .      17- . -, 1912, 99, 272; .     .  , 117119.].  ,    ,       .   ,       ,      ;       .

        ,      [70 - .  , 401.].              ,     1682 .      .        ,    ,   .        ,        ,        ,    :   ,           -;    ,        ;  ,      ,       ,   ,   ,   .      -    .    ,    ,   ,  .           ,   .

        , -   ,    ,      .      ,           .        .          ,     ,    ,     ,      ,    .     -       .          .

     ,           .    17               .       ,        .          ,          .

      .             .          : ,        ; ,         ; ,        .   18          .        . , ,      ,     ,   ,     .

     .   ,      ,              .     ,   ;       .      ,     :      ,         .    ;  ,    ,  ,    ,  .     ;     ,    ,   ,  ,     ..

  ,     .   17   18    ;       .           ,     .   ,        ,    [71 - . .     .  , 1864, , 83.]. ,  ,  ,        .      ;     ,    ,  .      ,      ,     .   ,     ,        ,         [72 - . . .  . : , 1993, 2, 446.].   17      20  .      19 ,          20-.        ,     ,    .           .        ,     .

 1716             ;    .          ,  ,    ,   .     ,     ,        [73 - . .    , . 8.    . -, 1863, 1315.].        ,        ,   .  1723           .             ,          .       ,       [74 - . . .       堖  , 1906, , 116117; Robert Crummy. The Old Believers and the World of Antichrist. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1970, 82.].         :    ,          .   1765          ,  1782     [75 - .    , 8, 3335.].  1785       ;      ,         [76 -  , 47; . : Pia Pera. The Secret Committee on the Old Believers: Moving away from Catherine IIs Policy of Religious Toleration Russia in the Age of Enlightenment. London: Macmillan, 1990, 223.].

  ,     .   ,  ,       ,    [77 - . .     堖  , 1866, 23, 515.].               .           .           ,    ,    19     [78 - .    , 8, 197.]. ,               .   , ,         .    II  ,       -;  , ,      .

            .      ,     ,      .   , ,    ,    ,           -[79 - . . .     - ࠖ Semiotics and the History of Culture. Columbus: Slavica, 1988, 48.].  ,       ,      -   ,    .      ,    ,     ,   ࠖ   ,    .            ,    -  -,    .







       ,  ,  - .    18           , , , [80 -   1775          : . .  ,       1826 .       ,  頖        , 1872, 3, . 5, 40.].    ,  .           ,   .            ,    ,    .             ;       ,      .

        ,    ,  ,   , .               ,           .       .          ,     .   ,      .      ,   17      . ,   ,      ;         .    ,      ,   ,       .

       ,    ,          . ,      ,       ,  ,    ,      . ,     ,  , ,     ,  .            - .     ,         :     .

 ,       .        ,        ;    ,         .           ,     .      (      )     ,     .          ;     ,               .

  ,        :   .      , ,     ,      : , ,  ,   .         ,       . ,       ,     [81 -       19    ,   .          ; ,       ,         .       20  .: . . .  , ,  ,    ,   . :  . . , 1916.].   ,      , , , ,   ..     ,      .    ,    ,    , .       .          (     ,          ). ,            .

     蠖          .       . ,        .    :           ,     .     ,     ,  , ,     .      ,      ,     .         ,     .         .    ,    ,     ,         :    ,        ,     .        ,        ,         [82 - .  ().     . - :  . . , 1898, 14, 281.].           ,      .   , ,    ;     ,    .

            .      1849      7 [83 -  . -: -  , 1937, 1, 43.].   ,     ,     ,    1867[84 - . . .  -   . .: , 1952, 773.].          ? .   :

		   
		  
		  .
		   ,
		   ,
		    ?[85 - . . .   . : , 1982, 5, 23.]

    ,     ,   1820-      [86 - .    , 8, 179.].    ,    1850-   ,   37  ,     .    ,       ;   ,          [87 -  , 528; . .      堖  , 1872, , 260.].     ,   , ,     .    ,               [88 - . . .        , 1866, 4, 642.].   ,         ,    :    ,     []  ,      ,   [89 - .    , 8, 182.].  1862     ,         8 ;              ,    2  .       黠  ,             ;       ,  [90 - . -.   堖  . : , 1963, 6, 195.].      ,           .  ,          , , ,     ,          ;        .    ,      3 [91 - , .      蠖  , 1876, 3, 213.].  ,      .   , ,            ,      .

             ,          . ,   []   ,   ,   1881   ,    ,    [92 - . .      蠖  , 1881, 1, 348.].   ()       .          1314. [93 - . .  .    . -, 1881, 46.].  1882   . .           15 [94 - . . .    蠖  , 1882, 12.].   ,             .  1886  ,   ,       [95 - . -, .    -  ⠖  , 1886, 10, 1.].           .    ,      1887,       ,    ,  ,     .         15  ,   60     [96 - G. Brandes. Impressions of Russia. New York: T.Y.Crowell Co, 1966, 19.].   -   1883,         20. ,      [97 - . . -.    . :  , 1905, 2, 368.].

    ,           19    .   1903          2.1    ,      ,  4.217 .            1904 :     ,   ,      [98 - . . .     I .     . , 1904, 8.].        ,        :



            :                []    17-    ,    [99 - . .       , 1928, 37, 396.].


  ,  1900    (  )   20  ,   1917  25 .      6.[100 - . .     . : -  , 1931, 2, 157.]  -  2-   -   1903   :           .    ,       堖  35     [101 - . -.     蠖  , , 1959, 1, 175.]. -    (    )        [102 - Fuelop-Miller. Mind and Face of Bolshevism, 85.].          ,  o   .        20      ,    1215  [103 - Gershenkron. Europe in the Russian Mirror, 136; Crummy. The Old Believers and the World of Antichrist, II.].

  ,     19       ,         .           ,   1862  [104 - -.   , 226.].  1869       ,  ,    [105 - . . . ,    . -, 1879, 103.].           .     1898 :



      ,    ,             ,   ,      ,   ,          [106 -  - .   1898 䠖 . : .     I , 16.     .: Robert F.Byrnes. Pobedonostsev: His Life and Thought. Bloomington: University of Indiana Press, 1968; Gregory L. Freeze. The Parish Clergy in Nineteenth-Century Russia: Crisis, Reform, Counter-Reform. New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1983.].


   1910    :        [107 - . . .      . , 1910, 56.].     ;  , ,           ,        45  [108 - .     1 , 17.].     -    ,    ,   [109 - . . -.    , 1910, 9, 2- , 13;   :       , 4.  . . . -. -, 1910, XL1.].

,      ,   .        1870-    5  ,   [110 - . . -       . -:  . . , 1872.].       .      ,     ;            (, , ,   ..).  1870 1910-            (, , ,   ..),       . ,     1880-   25 ;         ,        ,   ,  ,    ,  [111 - .  , 25.].   ,      (, , ,   ..),       .             ;       1906                [112 - -.  , 13.].    ,           100  ;         30 ,    [113 - . . .     . : , 1965, 84.].    1906        175 [114 - J.-B. Severac. La secte russe des Homme-de-Dieu. These de Doctrat. Paris: Cornely, 1906, 811, 122.].    ,  1910     1  130  ,       컠 ,  [115 -  , 1911, 1, 52.].

      .    -      . ,      ,        ,      .   ,   ,        ,    .   ,    , ,        ;   ,   .     ,        ,     ,           .           ,    ,     :          ;   , ,       ; ,   ,        ,       ,   .       ,         ,      .      :



      ,          :     蠖      [116 - W. H. Dixon. Free Russia. New York: Harper, 1870, 152.].








,       19   20      30 ;   ࠖ        .     , ,      .   10-    :       ,   ,   ,  .       .       ,       ,       .   . .      1869 :       蠖  ,      , -,    ,    ,    [117 - . . .   .  , 1869, 9, 443.].   35      :      ,   ;   ,   [118 - .     I , 15.].      ,     [119 - . . .    (   ). : , 1917, 1.].

        ,        .    ,            ,     ,     .      , ,       ,         .       ,         .     ,       ,      ,   ,  .   ,         ,   .    ,  ,    ,    ,   ,  ,     .       ,  -     .

, , ,        頖    , ,   黠     .    ,         ,        [120 - . . .   - .   . , 1979, 59; . : . . .   :     -    . : , 1982, 201235;      , ,  : . .    , 1867, , 2; : , 1869, .].      ,        , , , .         (, , ) ,   , :       -;  ,    , ,      ,     .          ,       .

  ,   ,             .           ,  ,    ,    .  ,    -   ,   , ,    ,    ,   ,        ,       .    ,   ,     .       ,      .           ,   ,   .

     .        :              [121 -   .: . . .       17- ࠖ Semiotics and the History of Culture. Columbus: Slavica, 1988, 187, 191.].        頖          .  ,     ,  ,    , , .      ,       .  1809    ,     ,     :



       ,       . []        ,   ,              ,   - ,    .          []         ,     [122 - , .  ,    ࠖ        , 1874, 3, 6970.].


         .        :   19           [123 - Michel Foucault. The History of Sexuality. Vol.1. An Introduction. New York: Vintage Books, 1990, 118.].     ,      ,           :



   .    ,   []         , ,   -    []   ,       .     ,     ,  .     ,      []            ,   [124 - . -.  . :  , 1979, 2, 18.].


           ,     ,  -;        :



      ,   ,    ,    , , ,     [125 -       , 4, 204.].


    ,      ,       ,    .       ,             ,      .    19111912 :



    . ,  .,       .     .     [],     .              ,     .     -  ,       .        ,    .       ,     .             - , -  ,       .  :         ..             .    ,        .       -       .          ,      []       ;      . []        .        ,        ,   [];  ,            [126 - .  , 84.].


  ,            .          ,  ,      .



     []       ,     ;      ,   ,     ,  ,  []        ,      ,   [127 - .    , 151.],


    .   ,



           .    , ,    ;       ,      [128 -  , 159.].


     .     ,   :     ,  ,   -  .    ,               .   ,    , :     ,            ,   ,        ,    [129 -  , 160.].    ,   ..   ,     ,     ,      .        ;        -.       ,  ,     ,    ,    ,    ;          [130 - . . .      .  , 1908, 69.].         ;            .

      , , ,      .         ,        ,        .          :  ,  ,     ,          ,   1826   .     :       (),            ,       ;     ,      [131 - .     , 159161.].

   ,   .      []     ,    ,     1834 .        []     ; [] ,   ,    ,    ,       .       : , ,  ;  , !  ;       : ! , [132 -  , 127128.].          ,   ,   ,         ,    [133 -  , 117.].    ,     , , , ,  , , ,  ,  蠖     [134 -   .: .  , passim;        .: Aage A. Hansen-L?ve. Allgemeine Haretik, Russische Sekten und Ihre Literarisierung in der Moderne Orthodoxien und Haresien in der Slavischen literaturen. Wiener slawistische almanach, 1996, 41, 214224.].     ,        ,     :   ,     ,       .    :   ,       [135 - .  , 34.].

        ,   .   ,    ,   ,  .  ,  ,  .   堖  ,  , ,  , ,  ࠖ    ,        .        ;   ,   ,    .    ,    ,   , ,     .      ,  ,          20 .       ; ,           ,   ,       [136 - .   , 447.].

 ,    ,  ,  , ,             .             1839 :



 ,       .   , ,    ,   []   ,  ,   []         ,      ,   , , -        .  []        ,        [] ,    ,      ,        []   ,      ,         ,  ,     ,    ,    [137 - . .      . , 1915, 1, 95.].


           :       ,       .       ,        ( ),     ,     .  ,  ,     ,       ,  ,  .

 1871         .    ,  ,   ,   ,       .   - ,       []  ,  ,      [138 - - , 1873, 209; . -, 446.].  ,          ,      ,       [139 - .  , 24.].

         ,         [140 - . .     ࠖ . .  . : , 1991.].            .         ,     .          :        .   ,  .       ,        , ,  ,   [141 - Stanislav and Christina Grof. Beyond Death. The Gates of Consciousness. London: Thames, 1980; Stanislav Grof. Beyond the Brain: Birth, Death and Transcendence in Psychotherapy. Albany: State University of New York Press, 1985.]. ,   ,         ,   .     ,     .

       ,       ,     ,     .      (      ,     ),       ,     .   ,    .      [142 - .  ,     , 297.].         , ,  ;        - ,          [143 - .      , 56.].   , , ,       ,   ,  :  ,   ,      [144 - .   , 264.].    ,         ,    .  ,   ,      ,  ,    ,         - ;     ,    [145 - .    , 154.]. ,          .   ,       .       ,         .  ,          :   ,     ,  ,  , []          ,      1851 [146 - .  , 2.].

        .    ,    ,  ,    ,      :       ,        ,      [147 - .     , 161.].     ;      , ,  .   ,  ,        .     ,    ,      :



  []     ,         ,         .        ,         ,        ,   []     .   []    ,     ,      ,     ,    ,        []      []      , ,  ,            [148 - . .   .     , 1892, , 14.].


     -.        ,            .  1886    :     []    ,  ,    ,        ;     ,     [149 - .  , 162.].   , ,       .      ,       ,      ,     ,    [150 - . .  -. . .   . . 頖  , 1895, , 10.].

     ,          ,    .         ,  , , , , , ,       [151 - .  , 41.].          , .      ,   .        ,   .      .    ,     ,    .     .   ,   ,  ,  ,   [152 - . . .  . .  5. , 374           , , .].

 ,         ,             ,    .     .  ,           [153 -   ,     -  1910- ,           ; .:  . -.    . : , 1991, 390.].               ,    .        ,        ,    .

 ,   ,   ,            ,  ,  ,        ,     .    ,    ,       :               [154 -      ,   ,        ,   .     ,         ,   .       O. Hofler. Kultische Geheimbunde der Germanen. Frankfurt a. M., 1934. :  .      蠖 . : , 1990, 132146.].          ,    ,              .           ,         . , ,    ,       :      ,        [155 - Carlo Ginzburg. Ecstasies. Deciphering the Witches Sabbath. London: Roberts, 1990;      .: Diane Purkisse. The Witch in History. Early Modern and Twentieth-Century Representations. London: Routledge, 1996.].







                젖 ,      19 .     -, -   ,      , ,     [156 -            , 1858, , 336; ,  , 8;      .: . . .        17- .   . : , 1982, 184200.].  1838    ,     ,   ,  ,          [157 - . , 1, 49.].    :

		,  !   - ,
		        ;
		       ;
		    ,    [158 - . . .      . , 1910, 19.].

       1804 :     ,   ,        [159 - . .     젖        , 1867, 4, . 5, 80.].          ,     :       ,    .    , ,     ;         ,       .     ,     ,       ,  ,     .  .     ,    ,     ,       ,    1862   [160 - . .          .  , 1862, 8, 325.].         ,   ,       ,    .           ,    .       .     :



   ,             ,  ,   ,     ;    ,          []     , ,   ,          , ,         []  ()   ,    ;  堖 , 堖 ,    堖   [161 - . . .   .  , 1869, 9, 442.].


   ,   1809,    1869,    ,    ,   .      ,         :



 ,   ,      []       ,        []          ,    㠖 -  []         [] .   ,    []     []             [162 - . .      (     )  . , 1895, 226.].


   젖  ,  ;        .        :   ,   ,      ,        ,        [163 -  , 293, 312.].     1900-        :



 ,  ,    :   . []   ,   ;    -.   ;     .    ,    . []      ,   ,   ,    .     ,        ,    ;     []     젖     ,    ,   . []         ,      -  [164 - , . 238, . .55.].


     ,    ,     (   ,     )    (   ,    ).      ,    ,      .             [165 - . , . .   ࠖ  .: . .    3 . : , 1992, 1, 73.].   ,   - ,  - ,  ,            .    - ,    , -      ,  , .   ,       ;  ,      .  .    ;       ,    .       :        [166 -  .];            蠖 .

   ,   ,   ,    ;  ,       .       ,            :          . ,          ,      (   ),  .   堖 , , ,   ,                .       .  ,  ,  ,           ,   .

       , ,    .      ,      . ,    ,  ,       ;      ,    . ,                    ,     .   ,   ,       ,           .   ( )  ,     頖    .   ,   1906   ,    :    [],      ,  [167 - . .    8 . :  , 1982, 1, 750.].       ,        .         ,  ,   [];   ,    , ,  [168 - . .   . II. . , 1, 544.].         ,   [169 - . .   (  ). , 1914, 33.].

    ,       ,     ,         : ,    ;        ;    ,      ;         ;   ,      ,  ;   ,   ,  ,         ; , ,    ,     .       ,    ,       .     ,    ;      .







,         ,   ,  .              .        ,      .      .  -,       ,     .    ,     ,   .        [170 - .  , 84.],            .              廠     .      ,        ,      ,          .

    ,         ,        .    ,          .    ,    ,   ;   ,   ;    ,       .  --  .          , ,     --,     .

         [171 - Emile Durkheim. The Elementary Forms of Religious Life. New York: Macmillan, 1915; Steven Lukes. Emile Durkheim: His Life and Work. New York: Harper, 1982, 482ff;      .: Lynn Hunt. The Sacred and the French Revolution in: Durkheimian Sociology: Cultural Studies. Ed. by Jeffrey C. Alexander. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988, 2543.].   /     ,     ,       . 렖  ,     ;     ,        .    ,      .   ,     ;       ,        .        ,      [172 - Clifford Geertz. The Interpretation of Cultures. New York: Basic Books, 1973, 112.].

      ,    ,       ,    ,   . - ,     ,  [173 - .  , 91.]. ,  ,    ,            .   18             ,        [174 - . . .      . :   . , 1887, 4.].          ,  -    ,    []  :   !    ,  .    :    렖            []  []  ,   ,  ,      [175 - .  , 86.].           ,     ,  :   . . ,    ,    ,        [176 - . .  -. . .   . . 頖  , 1895, , 11.].    ,           .    ,     ,          [177 - , .      蠖  , 1900, 2, 7576.].

   -       ,         ,      .         ,   ,   .     ,      ;    ,       (  ,       ).    ;   [178 - . .        . -:  . . , 1885, 810.].      ,      ,   1857,    .       ,     .      .      ,       . ,  ,   ,        .       12     ,    .    ,             .      ,    1858     [179 -  , 74.]. , ,           ,        -.

     .  ,  ,   ,        ,   .    ,    ,   ,            .           .  19     ,      ,      ,  , .    ,      ,   .      .    20       .   , ,      ,   .                1700  (,  젖  1907 ;     1914)[180 - Karl K. Gross. Die russischen Secten. Leipzig: J.C.Hinrichs Verlages, 1907, 1; 1914, 2; 2nd ed.: Leipzig: Zental-Antiquariat, 1966.]; , ,     ,   .  1908          ;          ,      .   . .   ,  1903  1906 ,   .            [181 - J.-B. Severac. La secte russe des Homme-de-Dieu. These de Doctorat. Paris: Cornely, 1906, 811, 122.         (. . .  蠖  , 1979, 90, .2, 380).].  19111912     . .     .          :



       .   ,    []  ,      ,    []      ,         [182 - .  , 5.].


               ,   .   ,   , ,         20 ,    19-. , ,    ,        .  1890-        (  Stunde ),     .          ,     .            : ,   ,      ,     .           .   ,   ,     ,            .  ,      , ,    .

            :      1874  ,      1898 1900,  -    1912.          [183 -      .: Edmund Heier. Religious Schism in the Russian Aristocracy 1860 1900. Radstokism and Pashkovism. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff, 1970; Alexander Fodor. A Quest for a Violent Russia. The Partnership of Leo Tolstoy and Vladimir Chertkov. New York: University Press of America, 1989.].    1905     ;        ,   [184 -        1905.: . . .      (    ). , 1907.].   1917          .              [185 -     : . .     :   -ࠖ , 1996, 19, 275319,  ,  8.]. , ,  ,         ,    .             .

     ,  ,      .   , ,     ,       .  1883       :  ,  ,   ,   钻[186 - . .  堖  . : , 1957, 8, 191.        ; . ,  7.].  1917        ,     . . .     ⠖ , , ,        .   ,        ,   . [187 - . .  . .  5. , 365, 394.].          ,  -,   1910   [188 -  , 179.].       ,     ,    .  ,       ,        .

    .        [189 -      .: Claudio Sergio Ingerflom. Communistes contre castrats (19291920) Preface de: Nikolai Volkov. La secte Russe de castrats. Paris: Les belles lettres, 1995.];             .  1960          23 [190 - . . .      蠖    , 1960, 34, 33.    1930 ,      ,     ;         蠖 .: . .  .  . : , 1965.].          ,    .

-,      20             ,  ,  .           ,    ,    ,    . ,     1819            ,        .               - .        .         .     ,            ,           .      20  ,     ,    .

    ,              ,  ,  .







             .        ,     .    .      ,       .         ,  ,      . ,    ,   ,      .        ,     .

  .  ,              ( ,   ).   ;   ; ,    .         ,     .    ,       ,    /      [191 -     -  .: Edward W. Said. Culture and Imperialism. New York: Knopf, 1993; The Post-Colonial Studies Reader. Ed. by Bill Ashcroft, Gareth Griffiths, Helen Tiffin. London: Routledge, 1995.].   ,  ,      ,     ,  ,    .      .              .         [192 - Edward W.Said. Orientalism. London: Routledge, 1978.],          ,   ,  .      :  ,    ;      ;  ,        .

  19      ,           :  ,        .       .     ,      ;  ,       ,  ,      ,    .               .           ,           ,  .

          ,       ,       ,   [193 - C.     : Dave Harker. Fakesong: The Manufacture of British Folksong. 1700 to the Present Day. Milton Keynes: Open University Press, 1985.].             [194 - . . , . .     ࠖ : . . .    . : , 1971, 167296.].            ,     ,  [195 - .  , 70, 72.].      1916: -        [196 - . .  ()  , 1916, 5, 201. ,       ,    -    .      1910-         .      ,   ,        ,  ,  ; .: .  . , 181.].     1911,         [197 - .  , 7, 71.].   ,       ,



  , , , , ,              , ,     ,    []      ,  ,  []  ,     , []           [198 - .  . , 496.].


            ,    .    ,    ,     ,   19     .   ,    .    ,      , ,        ,   [199 -           .: .  .    , .3.].



    ,      ,   ,     [200 - , .     , 377.      ,   .          ,        .           ; .: . . .      :     ⻠  . : -, 1995, 1, 680691.].


 ,         ,  ,     .            ,    [201 -        .: Mircea Eliade. Symbolism, th Sacred, and the Arts. New York: Crossroad, 1986.    ,  ,         .: Anthony D. Smith. The Ethnic Origins of Nations. New York: Blackwell, 1986, ch.78.        : Mona Ozouf. Festivals and the French Revolution. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1988; Susann Desan. Reclaiming the Sacred. Lay Religion and Popular Politics in Revolutionary France. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1990.       : George L. Mosse. The Nationalization of Masses. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1991;     : Richard Stites. Revolutionary Dreams. Utopian Vision and Experimental Life in the Russian Revolution. New York: Oxford University Press, 1989.].

          .    , ,     ,    .    ,      1910- .         .    ,      -.   -    ,  .     -.       ,    ,    .   ,      . , ,   .  ,     -    ,     .           ,         .        .        .            ,   ,          - .

  1830-     ,        .       ,       .       ;     20           .    ,    ,                   . ,     , ,       .  ,      ,  ,    19 ,   ,     19 .

   -  ( ,  ,  ,  ,  )      .             ,     .          ( ,  ,  ,        )       ( , ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ).          ;  ,     ,       . . [202 -      ,         廠 . . .  蠖  , 1979, 90, . 2, 423.].

  ,   ,   1887   [203 - . . . -.    -   . 1.     . :  . . , 1887.].        ,        .   ,     ,   -,      ,    .   1895      (,      ,  ),        :



        ,      , []         컠    .       , - ,  , , ,          [204 - . . .          . -, 1985, 497.].


   1900-   1910- ,                  - .    [205 -  . . .  , 76.],      1909.    (,      )         [206 - . . .      .  , 1908.   ,            .             .: . .       . , 1998. 31. . 102122.].       ,          ,          -      .    1908       (, ,   )     ;     [207 - . . ,     ,   ⠖   .  . . . , 2.  . -: - . . , 1908, 396421.].                ,   1912  T. .   . . .  ,                   - [19081916],      ;           . .  .       [1915].  ,             .  , ,         ,      ,         .

            [208 - . ,            :   .      (  ).  , 1913, 5, 32.].         .   ,   ,          .     ,          ,   .         ,      ,        .     , ,  ,     . ,    1870-     -        -,       ,     , ,    .       19          , -,    [209 - . Engellstein. Keys to Happiness, passim.].  -        ;                  ,   .

,     , , , 蠖   ,     :  , , .           ,   ,    -,      .    ,         (       ,           ),                .          -   .  ,    ,  ,  ,     ,    .   ,       ,  (   )    ,    (   )     .              ;         ;       ,            ;          .  , ,    .

          [210 - . .    , 1909, 5, 5356.],        .        .   ,   ,      .        .             ,       .         ,         ;    .     ,           ,     ,     .    ,      ,    .          .         .    ,  , ,    .     ,           [211 - .  -     ,      ,       ,     ,     ,     ,    -     ,    .],     .

, ,                 ,      .         ,         ,       .    ,       ,     II , ,    ,     .         .       ,        ,  -   ,     .    :



 ,     ,         ,        1870- [212 - . .    . :  , 1987, 314.].








     ,      -.    : ,    .      ,     ;         .      堖 ,        .   ,     , -, ,  -          .

   ,      ;     .     ,    ,       .      ,       .         ;        .          ,    .      ,         .     ,   ;    , ,   .

,      ,         :        ;       ;     .           ࠖ , , , .   ,       ,     ,  .            ,    .

     ,          ,   ,      .     ,       ,   ,  .           .    ,         ,   ;         ,        .           .     ,     .        [213 - .: Isaiah Berlin. The Counter-Enlightenment in his: Against the Current. Essays in the History of Ideas. London: Hogarth, 1979, 20.].   ,    , , ;   ,       ,   ,    .           ,         .         ,     ,       ,   [214 - Norbert Elias. The Civilizing Process. New York: Urizen, 1978; . : Mennell Stephen. Norbert Elias. Civilization and the Human Self-Image. New York: Basil Blackwell, 1989; The Body. Social Processes and Cultural Theory. Ed. by Mike Featherstone, Mike Hepworth, and Bryan S.Turner. London: Sage, 1991.].          :   ,        .

   ,   -            ,       .   , -         .      ,       .   , -     .          .   ,     -,         ,  .     .     ,      ,   ,     .    , ,      :     ,         [215 -   - .: Gary Saul Morson. The Boundaries of Genre. Dostoyevskys Diary of a Writer and the Tradition of Literary Utopia. Austin: University of Texas Press, 1981; Krishan Kumar. Utopia and Anti-Utopia in Modern Times. New York: Basil Blackwell, 1987, ch.4; . .       Wiener Slawistischer Almanach, 1994, 34.]. T    ,  ,    ,    ,     ,    .

           .   ,       ; ,  ,          .     ,  ,     ,       .     ,           .      ,         ,    ,   ,   .         ,   [216 - . . . :  , 1989, 56.].       ,    :   ,    ! [] ! ,     ,   .         ; ,    , -  ,  .

      ,      ,  ,         [217 - Karl Mannheim. Ideology and Utopia. London: Routledge, 1991.].   ,         .   , ,   ,          .      ,  - ,     ,      .                .    ,    .   ,     ,   ,   ,   ,      .







          .        ,     ,   .            .        ,       :   ,     ;  , ,      ,      .   , ,         .

            :   ,     ,           .            ,        .             .      ,   ,  ,  ,  ,         .        :



   ,    .     ,       .         , .     ,           [218 - . .     .      . -, 1869, 1, 212213.].


    ,  :        ,    .

            .    ,     ,   :     ,        ,    :  ,   [219 -  .      , 1847, 301.].  ,      .  ,   , 1672 , -   10,     40   ,    .   ,   ,  .     :          [220 - .   , 204.].     .

 ,        .  ,      ,        ,   ,    .       ,    -     ,    .          ,        .    [221 - Norman Cohn. The Pursuit of the Millennium, passim.],         ,         ,         .       .         .

        ,   1853     .              .      ,      ,  :         ,     ,     . 17-     , ,       ,   ,      ,      ,  ,           .                 . ,     ,           .     -   ,   [222 - . , 1, 114; . .    . 2. . -⠖  , 1914, 3, 103.].           ,       ;  , ,      .

     ,            :  , ,    .     ,  ,     .   []       ,     []   ,   ,   [223 - . .    . 1.  ⠖  , 1914, 1, 121.].

 , ,   ,       ,     .     ,    .  , ,     ,  ,  - ;         .             minimum   ,   ,       [224 - .  , 10.];       .   ,          [225 -     : .  , 115116.]. -,        ,   ,    .  ,    -,  18     ,  ;      .    :      ,     ,       [226 - .    . 1.  , 121.].  ,    , ,       ,     ,     ,    : ,     ,       . 19-          :     ,      ,        []       [227 - .  , 46.].        ,     :    ()      ,            ; []    ,     ,    ,   ,   .       :    :     (    ),   ,    ,      ,    ; ,      [228 -  .].

      .  1864         .    ,       ,   ,       ,    [229 -  , 1910, 10, 7576.].  1882        .       ,  :          ,     .       ?[230 - . -, 443.]         ,      .  1892     ,           .      ,                 ,  ;               .    ,       ,   , ..       .      .     ,        ,  .  1893        ,      200 .    20  .   :  ,     ,   .          ,              ,      ,   .     1893 ,      ,      ,         ,    ,       ..[231 - . , 1, 384.].     ,        .

        ,     .  1900        ,    :              . ,      ,    :     []     ,  ,  .   ,       [232 -  , 572.].  1901  ,     ,   ,         ,       ,        []    []   :        [233 - .       .   .  , 1901, 1, 661.].     ,      ,  ,     ,  ,    ,     [234 - .  , 77.].            ,        ;     ,   ,    ,   [235 -  , 78.].       ,        .    ,   :



          .     ,   []    ,  ,   []  ,   [] ,   ,    ,  ,  :  [236 - . . .    (   ). : , 1917, 1, 74.].


 1897        ,    -     ,        .     12-    ,     [237 - .  , 95.].  1908              ,     ,  ,       []  .   ,     ,         21-  .       ;   ,      ,    ,   ,       [238 - . , 3, 237.].  1910          :          ;    ,  [239 -  , 1910, 11, 1011.].

-,   19111912      ,    ,     .        , ,     ,  ,  [240 - .  , 713.].              .



       .        .    .       .      .   ,        ,   .              .   []       [241 - . . .    , 1910, 2, 45;  . ,  8.].


   ,    ,     ,           .              .            [242 - . . .     , 1913, 5, 23.].               [243 - .  , 43.].     ,    -  1880- 



        .   ,     .   .   (   ),     ,    . []    ,   .   ,     ,     [244 - , .238, . .19.    . . -   1936   ,     .].


 -,      ;             .                .       ,       .



     .   ,  ,    ,       .        ,  ,      []      ,      .


  ,           .    ,  ,  .



    ,     ,            []             ,       [245 - , . 238, . . 126.].


 ,   ,       ,    :



  ⠖    .      .    , . []          ,     ;    ,     ,       [246 - , .238, . .181, .40;   ,  ,   1910.].








  18  ,   :   ,  []     ,            [247 - .  , 5.].  ,   ,     ,         . ,  ,   ,      ; ,   ,   ,    ;  ,          . T       젖   ,   .

  ,           ,         .   , ,   ;           .  ,   ,    . ࠖ          . T  ,           ,    , .   ,          .        ,              ,       .       :      ,       [] ,       ,  ,   [248 -     . :  , 1991, 9697.]




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/aleksandr-etkind/hlyst/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


. : Carl E. Schorske. Fin-de-Ciecle Vienna. Politics and Culture. London: Weidenfeld, 1979, XXV.




2


Julia Kristeva. Semiotike. Paris: Seuil, 1969; Harold Bloom. The Anxiety of Influence. New York: Oxford University Press, 1973; Michael Riffater. Text Production. New York: Columbia University Press, 1983.        .: Renate Lachmann. Gedachtnis und Literatur. Intertextualitat in der russischen Moderne. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp, 1990.




3


 ,    ,        ; . Stephen Greenblatt. Shakespearean Negotiations. The Circulation of Social Energy in Renaissance England. Oxford: Clarendon, 1988; New Historicism and Renaissance Drama, ed. Richard Wilson and Richard Dutton. London, 1992; The New Historicism Reader, ed. A. E. Veeser. New York, 1994,    Representation.   ,   ,   : Irina Paperno. Chernyshevsky and the Age of Realism. A Study in the Semiotics of Behavior. Stanford University Press, 1988; Richard Stites. Revolutionary Dreams. Utopian Vision and Experimental Life in the Russian Revolution. New York: Oxford University Press, 1989; Laura Engelstein. The Keys to Happiness. Sex and the Search for Modernity in Fin-de-Siecle Russia. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1992; Svetlana Boym. Common Places. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1994; Katerina Clark. Petersburg, Crucible of Cultural Revolution. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1995; Eric Naiman. Sex in Public. The Incarnation of Early Soviet Ideology. Princeton, New Jercy: Princeton University Press, 1997.




4


       .  . .   . . ࠖ  -1.   .   , 1964, 393.




5


     . -,     ,         ,   (18551937)   .      ,           ,       (-, 1905).




6


    . . . -, 1936, 109;     : . . .          . : - , 1989, 176180.




7


.   , 179.




8


    , 393.




9


.   , 179.




10


    , 393.




11


 . .   . . .  . .   . .   , 1992, 2, 144.




12


,  .  ࠖ  , 1904, 10, 715.        ,     ; .    -, ,    ,   1950-:        7     .        ,     []       ,  ,     컠 . : . . .      .    , 1960, 34, 30.




13


.  . . ࠖ    . , 1940, 7, 132.




14


    . . , 35.




15


 .




16


Horst Lampl. Zinaida Hippius and S.P.Remizova-Dovgello Wiener Slawistischer Almanach, 1978, 1, 164.




17


..   . , 1990, 176;   . .   499.




18


. . -.  . , 1951, 145.




19


 . . . :    , 3.          ( , );  ,       .




20


Norman Cohn. The Pursuit of the Millennium. London: Secker and Warburg, 1957;  Norman Cohn. Cosmos, Chaos and the World to Come. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1993.




21


. . .   . -: , 1908, 2, 67.




22


Cohn. The Pursuit of the Millennium, 99.




23


Jeffrey Richards. Sex, Dissidence and Damnation. Minority Groups in the Middle Ages. London: Routledge, 1990, 59.




24


Cohn. The Pursuit of the Millennium, 316;    .: Robert E. Lerner. The Heresy of Free Spirit. Berkeley: Berkeley University Press, 1972.




25


Cohn. The Pursuit of the Millennium, 160.




26


 , 150, 174, 183.




27


Cohn. The Pursuit of the Millennium, 187191.




28


 .




29


     .: Malcolm B. Hamilton. Sociology of Religion. Theoretical and Comparative Perspectives. London: Routledge, 1995, ch.7.          .: Bob Schribner. Practical Utopias: Pre-Modern Communism and the Reformation Comparative Studies in Society and History, 1994, 36, 4, 743774.




30


Cohn. The Pursuit of the Millennium, 306;          .: Lyndal Roper. Oedipus and the Devil. Witchcraft, Sexuality and Religion in Early Modern Europe. London: Routledge, 1994, ch.4.




31


. . .     .  . : , 1977, 6070.




32


. . .      (   - )       , , 1930, 3, 3032.




33


.     .  , 68.




34


. .  . -:  . . , 1869, 1, 25.




35


 , 36.




36


 , 51.




37


       ,  .     1869  ,     :     ,        ,     .     1978,      ,            .  -,    ,                : . . .      14-젖   16- . :  , 1960;  .     . : , 1965;  .    . . -堖    , 1983, 44, 6688;  .     .  ;  .     . 19- . : , 1978.




38


Rene Fuelop-Miller. Geist und Gesicht des Bolschevismus. Zurich: Amathea-Verlag, 1926 ( : Rene Fuelop-Miller. The Mind and Face of Bolshevism. New York: Harper, 1965).    ,      ,      ,     ; . : James Rice. Dostoyevsky and the Healing Art. Ann Arbor: Ardis, 1985, 218219.




39


  ; . ,  2.




40


.  (. ).  蠖 , 1927, 2, 177.




41


. .      Р  , 1932, 4, 45.




42


                    , 1931, 4, 175203;  .: . .  .    . -: , 1993, .6 (Alexander Etkind. Eros of the Impossible. The History of Psychoanalysis in Russia. Boulder-London: Westview, 1997).




43


.: James H. Billington. Fire in the Minds of Men. Origins of the Revolutionary Faith. New York: Basic Books, 1980;      : Michael Walzer. The Revolution of the Saints. A Study in the Origins of Radical Politics. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1965;        : Lawrence Foster. Religion and Sexuality. Three American Communal Experiments of the 19th Century. New York: Oxford, 1981; Yaacov Oved. Two Hundred Years of American Communes. New Brunswick: Transaction Books, 1988.




44


. .  . : , 1987;  .     ࠖ   .:  . : , 1990, 273302.




45


      -; .: Aage A. Hansen-L?ve. Apokalyptik und Adventismus in russischen Symbolismus der Jahrhundertwende R. G. Grubel (Hg.). Russische Literatur an der Wende vom 19. Zum 20. Jahrhundert. Amsterdam/Atlanta, 1993, 273.




46


 ,         , .: Marianne Weber. Max Weber. A Biography. Translated by Harry Zohn. New Brunswick: Transaction, 1988, 323.




47


Max Weber. Gesammelte Aufsatze zur Soziologie und Socialpolitic. Tubingen, 1924, 469470.




48


Max Weber. Zur Russischen Revolution von 1905. Tubingen: Mohr Verlag, 1996.




49


Arthur Mitzman. The Iron Cage. An Historical Interpretation of Max Weber. New Brunswick: Transaction, 1985, 272; Marianne Weber. Max Weber. A Biography, 327.




50


     .: B.Naarden. Marx and Russia History of European ideas, 12, 6, 1990, 783797;      .: .  .    , .4; James L. Rice. Freuds Russia. National Identity in the Evolution of Psychoanalysis. New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers, 1993.




51


. . , . . .        , 1994, 2, 7478.




52


Mitzman. The Iron Cage; L.A. Staff. Fleeing from the Iron Cage. Culture, Politics and Modernity in the Thought of Max Weber. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1989.      .: Bryan S.Turner. Max Weber. From History to Modernity. London: Routledge, 1992; Ernest Gellner. Postmodernism, Reason and Religion. London: Routledge, 1992.




53


. .        .: . : , 1993.




54


. . .   .  . . .   . . . , 1, 1906; 2, 1913.      .: M.Hagemeister. Nikolaj Fedorov: Studien zu Leben, Werk und Wirkung. M?nchen: Sagner, 1989.




55


Irene Masing-Delich. Abolishing Death. A Salvation Myth of Russian Twentieth-Century Literature. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1992.




56


. . .  .     . : - . . , 1911.




57


 ,          , : Alexander Gershenkron. Europe in the Russian Mirror. Cambridge University Press, 1970, ch.2.       ,   ,          .




58


. .  . , 1923, 78; horribile dictu  .




59


. .   蠖  , 1927, 33, 361.




60


 , 360.




61


. . .    . :  , 1872, 79; . .   . -, /, 290.




62


   .: .   .    . M?nchen: Wilhelm Fink Verlag, 1970, 144156; . . .     . : , 1986, 6681.




63


.     , 201.




64


 (   , 85)    ,    19      ;  .: .     . :   , 1882, 41.




65


 ,     ,        (.      . : YMCA-Press. 1959, 2, 148).   ., .: . . .  .     . , 1931, 1; 1934, 2.




66


.   , 3.




67


Paul Avrich. Russian Rebells. London: Allen Lane Penguin, 1973, 143.




68


. .   렖 , -: - . . , 1908, 1, 466.       .: . .  :     ,  .




69


. . .      17- . -, 1912, 99, 272; .     .  , 117119.




70


.  , 401.




71


. .     .  , 1864, , 83.




72


. . .  . : , 1993, 2, 446.




73


. .    , . 8.    . -, 1863, 1315.




74


. . .       堖  , 1906, , 116117; Robert Crummy. The Old Believers and the World of Antichrist. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1970, 82.




75


.    , 8, 3335.




76


 , 47; . : Pia Pera. The Secret Committee on the Old Believers: Moving away from Catherine IIs Policy of Religious Toleration Russia in the Age of Enlightenment. London: Macmillan, 1990, 223.




77


. .     堖  , 1866, 23, 515.




78


.    , 8, 197.




79


. . .     - ࠖ Semiotics and the History of Culture. Columbus: Slavica, 1988, 48.




80


  1775          : . .  ,       1826 .       ,  頖        , 1872, 3, . 5, 40.




81


      19    ,   .          ; ,       ,         .       20  .: . . .  , ,  ,    ,   . :  . . , 1916.




82


.  ().     . - :  . . , 1898, 14, 281.




83


 . -: -  , 1937, 1, 43.




84


. . .  -   . .: , 1952, 773.




85


. . .   . : , 1982, 5, 23.




86


.    , 8, 179.




87


 , 528; . .      堖  , 1872, , 260.




88


. . .        , 1866, 4, 642.




89


.    , 8, 182.




90


. -.   堖  . : , 1963, 6, 195.




91


, .      蠖  , 1876, 3, 213.




92


. .      蠖  , 1881, 1, 348.




93


. .  .    . -, 1881, 46.




94


. . .    蠖  , 1882, 12.




95


. -, .    -  ⠖  , 1886, 10, 1.




96


G. Brandes. Impressions of Russia. New York: T.Y.Crowell Co, 1966, 19.




97


. . -.    . :  , 1905, 2, 368.




98


. . .     I .     . , 1904, 8.




99


. .       , 1928, 37, 396.




100


. .     . : -  , 1931, 2, 157.




101


. -.     蠖  , , 1959, 1, 175.




102


Fuelop-Miller. Mind and Face of Bolshevism, 85.




103


Gershenkron. Europe in the Russian Mirror, 136; Crummy. The Old Believers and the World of Antichrist, II.




104


-.   , 226.




105


. . . ,    . -, 1879, 103.




106


 - .   1898 䠖 . : .     I , 16.     .: Robert F.Byrnes. Pobedonostsev: His Life and Thought. Bloomington: University of Indiana Press, 1968; Gregory L. Freeze. The Parish Clergy in Nineteenth-Century Russia: Crisis, Reform, Counter-Reform. New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1983.




107


. . .      . , 1910, 56.




108


.     1 , 17.




109


. . -.    , 1910, 9, 2- , 13;   :       , 4.  . . . -. -, 1910, XL1.




110


. . -       . -:  . . , 1872.




111


.  , 25.




112


-.  , 13.




113


. . .     . : , 1965, 84.




114


J.-B. Severac. La secte russe des Homme-de-Dieu. These de Doctrat. Paris: Cornely, 1906, 811, 122.




115


 , 1911, 1, 52.




116


W. H. Dixon. Free Russia. New York: Harper, 1870, 152.




117


. . .   .  , 1869, 9, 443.




118


.     I , 15.




119


. . .    (   ). : , 1917, 1.




120


. . .   - .   . , 1979, 59; . : . . .   :     -    . : , 1982, 201235;      , ,  : . .    , 1867, , 2; : , 1869, .




121


  .: . . .       17- ࠖ Semiotics and the History of Culture. Columbus: Slavica, 1988, 187, 191.




122


, .  ,    ࠖ        , 1874, 3, 6970.




123


Michel Foucault. The History of Sexuality. Vol.1. An Introduction. New York: Vintage Books, 1990, 118.




124


. -.  . :  , 1979, 2, 18.




125


      , 4, 204.




126


.  , 84.




127


.    , 151.




128


 , 159.




129


 , 160.




130


. . .      .  , 1908, 69.




131


.     , 159161.




132


 , 127128.




133


 , 117.




134


  .: .  , passim;        .: Aage A. Hansen-L?ve. Allgemeine Haretik, Russische Sekten und Ihre Literarisierung in der Moderne Orthodoxien und Haresien in der Slavischen literaturen. Wiener slawistische almanach, 1996, 41, 214224.




135


.  , 34.




136


.   , 447.




137


. .      . , 1915, 1, 95.




138


- , 1873, 209; . -, 446.




139


.  , 24.




140


. .     ࠖ . .  . : , 1991.




141


Stanislav and Christina Grof. Beyond Death. The Gates of Consciousness. London: Thames, 1980; Stanislav Grof. Beyond the Brain: Birth, Death and Transcendence in Psychotherapy. Albany: State University of New York Press, 1985.




142


.  ,     , 297.




143


.      , 56.




144


.   , 264.




145


.    , 154.




146


.  , 2.




147


.     , 161.




148


. .   .     , 1892, , 14.




149


.  , 162.




150


. .  -. . .   . . 頖  , 1895, , 10.




151


.  , 41.




152


. . .  . .  5. , 374           , , .




153


  ,     -  1910- ,           ; .:  . -.    . : , 1991, 390.




154


     ,   ,        ,   .     ,         ,   .       O. Hofler. Kultische Geheimbunde der Germanen. Frankfurt a. M., 1934. :  .      蠖 . : , 1990, 132146.




155


Carlo Ginzburg. Ecstasies. Deciphering the Witches Sabbath. London: Roberts, 1990;      .: Diane Purkisse. The Witch in History. Early Modern and Twentieth-Century Representations. London: Routledge, 1996.




156


           , 1858, , 336; ,  , 8;      .: . . .        17- .   . : , 1982, 184200.




157


. , 1, 49.




158


. . .      . , 1910, 19.




159


. .     젖        , 1867, 4, . 5, 80.




160


. .          .  , 1862, 8, 325.




161


. . .   .  , 1869, 9, 442.




162


. .      (     )  . , 1895, 226.




163


 , 293, 312.




164


, . 238, . .55.




165


. , . .   ࠖ  .: . .    3 . : , 1992, 1, 73.




166


 .




167


. .    8 . :  , 1982, 1, 750.




168


. .   . II. . , 1, 544.




169


. .   (  ). , 1914, 33.




170


.  , 84.




171


Emile Durkheim. The Elementary Forms of Religious Life. New York: Macmillan, 1915; Steven Lukes. Emile Durkheim: His Life and Work. New York: Harper, 1982, 482ff;      .: Lynn Hunt. The Sacred and the French Revolution in: Durkheimian Sociology: Cultural Studies. Ed. by Jeffrey C. Alexander. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988, 2543.




172


Clifford Geertz. The Interpretation of Cultures. New York: Basic Books, 1973, 112.




173


.  , 91.




174


. . .      . :   . , 1887, 4.




175


.  , 86.




176


. .  -. . .   . . 頖  , 1895, , 11.




177


, .      蠖  , 1900, 2, 7576.




178


. .        . -:  . . , 1885, 810.




179


 , 74.




180


Karl K. Gross. Die russischen Secten. Leipzig: J.C.Hinrichs Verlages, 1907, 1; 1914, 2; 2nd ed.: Leipzig: Zental-Antiquariat, 1966.




181


J.-B. Severac. La secte russe des Homme-de-Dieu. These de Doctorat. Paris: Cornely, 1906, 811, 122.         (. . .  蠖  , 1979, 90, .2, 380).




182


.  , 5.




183


     .: Edmund Heier. Religious Schism in the Russian Aristocracy 1860 1900. Radstokism and Pashkovism. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff, 1970; Alexander Fodor. A Quest for a Violent Russia. The Partnership of Leo Tolstoy and Vladimir Chertkov. New York: University Press of America, 1989.




184


       1905.: . . .      (    ). , 1907.




185


    : . .     :   -ࠖ , 1996, 19, 275319,  ,  8.




186


. .  堖  . : , 1957, 8, 191.        ; . ,  7.




187


. .  . .  5. , 365, 394.




188


 , 179.




189


     .: Claudio Sergio Ingerflom. Communistes contre castrats (19291920) Preface de: Nikolai Volkov. La secte Russe de castrats. Paris: Les belles lettres, 1995.




190


. . .      蠖    , 1960, 34, 33.    1930 ,      ,     ;         蠖 .: . .  .  . : , 1965.




191


    -  .: Edward W. Said. Culture and Imperialism. New York: Knopf, 1993; The Post-Colonial Studies Reader. Ed. by Bill Ashcroft, Gareth Griffiths, Helen Tiffin. London: Routledge, 1995.




192


Edward W.Said. Orientalism. London: Routledge, 1978.




193


C.     : Dave Harker. Fakesong: The Manufacture of British Folksong. 1700 to the Present Day. Milton Keynes: Open University Press, 1985.




194


. . , . .     ࠖ : . . .    . : , 1971, 167296.




195


.  , 70, 72.




196


. .  ()  , 1916, 5, 201. ,       ,    -    .      1910-         .      ,   ,        ,  ,  ; .: .  . , 181.




197


.  , 7, 71.




198


.  . , 496.




199


          .: .  .    , .3.




200


, .     , 377.      ,   .          ,        .           ; .: . . .      :     ⻠  . : -, 1995, 1, 680691.




201


       .: Mircea Eliade. Symbolism, th Sacred, and the Arts. New York: Crossroad, 1986.    ,  ,         .: Anthony D. Smith. The Ethnic Origins of Nations. New York: Blackwell, 1986, ch.78.        : Mona Ozouf. Festivals and the French Revolution. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1988; Susann Desan. Reclaiming the Sacred. Lay Religion and Popular Politics in Revolutionary France. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1990.       : George L. Mosse. The Nationalization of Masses. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1991;     : Richard Stites. Revolutionary Dreams. Utopian Vision and Experimental Life in the Russian Revolution. New York: Oxford University Press, 1989.




202


     ,         廠 . . .  蠖  , 1979, 90, . 2, 423.




203


. . . -.    -   . 1.     . :  . . , 1887.




204


. . .          . -, 1985, 497.




205


 . . .  , 76.




206


. . .      .  , 1908.   ,            .             .: . .       . , 1998. 31. . 102122.




207


. . ,     ,   ⠖   .  . . . , 2.  . -: - . . , 1908, 396421.




208


. ,            :   .      (  ).  , 1913, 5, 32.




209


. Engellstein. Keys to Happiness, passim.




210


. .    , 1909, 5, 5356.




211


.  -     ,      ,       ,     ,     ,     ,    -     ,    .




212


. .    . :  , 1987, 314.




213


.: Isaiah Berlin. The Counter-Enlightenment in his: Against the Current. Essays in the History of Ideas. London: Hogarth, 1979, 20.




214


Norbert Elias. The Civilizing Process. New York: Urizen, 1978; . : Mennell Stephen. Norbert Elias. Civilization and the Human Self-Image. New York: Basil Blackwell, 1989; The Body. Social Processes and Cultural Theory. Ed. by Mike Featherstone, Mike Hepworth, and Bryan S.Turner. London: Sage, 1991.




215


  - .: Gary Saul Morson. The Boundaries of Genre. Dostoyevskys Diary of a Writer and the Tradition of Literary Utopia. Austin: University of Texas Press, 1981; Krishan Kumar. Utopia and Anti-Utopia in Modern Times. New York: Basil Blackwell, 1987, ch.4; . .       Wiener Slawistischer Almanach, 1994, 34.




216


. . . :  , 1989, 56.




217


Karl Mannheim. Ideology and Utopia. London: Routledge, 1991.




218


. .     .      . -, 1869, 1, 212213.




219


 .      , 1847, 301.




220


.   , 204.




221


Norman Cohn. The Pursuit of the Millennium, passim.




222


. , 1, 114; . .    . 2. . -⠖  , 1914, 3, 103.




223


. .    . 1.  ⠖  , 1914, 1, 121.




224


.  , 10.




225


    : .  , 115116.




226


.    . 1.  , 121.




227


.  , 46.




228


 .




229


 , 1910, 10, 7576.




230


. -, 443.




231


. , 1, 384.




232


 , 572.




233


.       .   .  , 1901, 1, 661.




234


.  , 77.




235


 , 78.




236


. . .    (   ). : , 1917, 1, 74.




237


.  , 95.




238


. , 3, 237.




239


 , 1910, 11, 1011.




240


.  , 713.




241


. . .    , 1910, 2, 45;  . ,  8.




242


. . .     , 1913, 5, 23.




243


.  , 43.




244


, .238, . .19.    . . -   1936   ,     .




245


, . 238, . . 126.




246


, .238, . .181, .40;   ,  ,   1910.




247


.  , 5.




248


    . :  , 1991, 9697.


