   
. . 

. . 

. . 

. . 


            .         ,        .





 . .,  . .,  . .,  . .

   :    








     ,  ,      ,    .        , ,           ,       ,       ,       .  ,  ,     ,     ,              .

  ,      ,      ,   ,   .          ,       ,         ;     ,   ,   ,       .

       ,     ,     .     ,     ()        . ,  ,  ,        ,          ,     , . .   .     / ,  ,    ,   :        ,     ,   -        ,       .

,        ,   ,         . ,     ,    ,        ,    ,           - .                  ,    ,           .         ,  ,    ,   ,     .

  .         ,          .    ,            ,       ,         ,    .  ,   ,            .        ,         ,   .      ,        ,      ,   ,     .

   ,        :  ( ),      .    ,       -,       ,              .       ,     . . ,              .      , ,  -    ,            ,    .



. . 




 1

   :    [1 -       (),   15-03-00572.]


       ,    ,       . ,      ,        ,       .         ,   ,          ,             ,     .   ,     ,      .      ,     ,         .  ,           ,      , ,    ,    .         :     ,        .         ,   ,            .

             ,   ,       [2 - :   / . . , . . , . . , . . . .:   , 2016. . 976.].                     .       ,   ,        ,     ,    status quo    . ,  ,      ,            ,            .


      

   ,     ,                 ,      .     ,           ,       .       ,          .   ,                    .         ,            ,        ,       [3 -  .     //  . .: 2 . . 2. .: , 1994. . 2021.].         ,                   ,          , ,  .       ,       ,      .        ,     ,           .       ,             :     .          , ,    ,   .

                  ,             .               ,            ,     , ,  ,        .           .

  ,   , , ,  ,       ,   ,     ,       .          .   ,        ,                [4 -  .   .         //   . 2016. 2(138).             ,         ,                 .          .].    ,              ,    [5 -  .,  .,  .        :     //   . 2016. 2 (138).            ,      ,    ,    ,   .].   ,   ,       ,         [6 -   .         . .: -, 2016. 272 c.;  . .          .       // Alma Mater.   . 2016. 11. . 97101;   .      / . .   . // .     . 2017. . 9,  1. . 112.  ,      ,         ,            .      , ,          ,     ;     ,     .].

,            ,       ,     ,   ,               . , ,       ,          .           ,         ,    .         :    ,            ,                  .

    ,            , ,          XX .      ,         ,      .        ,  ,             XVIII   XIX .                 ,   [7 - :  . . 946.].

     ,      .    .          ,            [8 -             .   ,         .].  ,  ,        ,       .           ,      ,     ,       .             ,      [9 - .  , .:  . . Homo Mathematicus     // . 2015. 19. . 6189.].        ,     ,           .

   ,  ,   ,    ,   ,        [10 -  .  . .: , 1975. . 299.].    ,    ,  ,        .               ,    .    ,        ,      .      ,    ,  [11 -    ,          .:  . .        //     2017. . 51,  1. . 817; Galison P. Trading with the enemy // Trading zones and interactional expertise: creating new kinds of collaboration / ed. by M. E. Gorman. Cambridge: MIT Press, 2010. P. 2552.].   ,      ,             ,         .    ,    ,   .

   ,  ,             ,           ,                 .

                       ,     ,   ,    .                    .                   ,     ,         ,   .   ,    ,       .


       

        ,      .   ,        , ,           ,     ,          .         .        .     ,  ,      .        [12 -  . .,  . .,  . .    . .:  , 2012. . 52.].      . ,                   ,     ,            . <>             ,       ,            [13 -  .    //  . . . : 4 . . IV. .: , 1967. . 40.].  ,        ,        ,   , , . , ,    ,             .      .

      ,   ,      .     ,   ,    , -   .      ,    .       ,                 [14 -       ,           .   ,            :                  . .  : Harding S. Strong objectivity: aResponse to the New Objectivity Question // Synthese. 1995. N 104. P. 331349.].    ,   ,      .       ,   ,  ,      [15 -     ,       ,     ,       , .:  . .      // . 2017. 1. . 159173.].       ,      ,    .  ,   ,               . ,                                .                ,   .          .

         .      XVII        1665  Philosophical Transaction       .             ,       ,                [16 - Kronick D. A. Devant Le Deluge and Other Essays on Early Modern Scienti?c Communication. Latham, MD; Oxford, UK: Scarecrow Press, 2004; Gar?eld E. Has Scienti?c Communication Changed in 300 Years? Current Contents. N 8. 1980. P. 511.].              [17 - Price D. J. de S. Networks of Scienti?c Papers: The Pattern of Bibliographic References Indicates the Nature of the Scienti?c Research Front // Science. Vol. 149, iss. 3683. July 30, 1965. P. 510515.].            ,     ,           [18 -  .    //  . 2010.  9. 3. . 5788.].

         ,         .   ,    XX ,    :   ,     .  ,        ,       ,   .       . -, ,  ,      [19 - .   ,        : Gar?eld E. From the Science of Science to Scientometrics Visualizing the History of Science with HistCite Software // Journal of Informetrics. 2009. N 3. P. 173179.]. , -,  ,             .  ,     ,                . ,  ,   .               ,     -   [20 -   ,   -  ,     ,      .:  . .: 1)    ?  . .    // . 2000. 1. . 160183; 2)   .       // -. - . 30  2016 . URL: http://trv-science. ru/2016/05/30/vykhodit-ili-ostatsya/ ( : 20.12.2017);  . .   .  . .:   ̻, 2012. 728 .].                 [21 -     , .:  . .     ,      //   :      / . . , . . , . . , . . . : -  -, 2014. . 110163.].

           . ,         :   ,   ,       .       . -,     ,               [22 - .     2  .]. -,        , ,       ,  ,  ,  ,  [23 -  . .          . . 101.]. -,   (   )            ,        .

            .   ,          ,      ,      .           ,        ,   ,       ,       ,      .


  

                  ,  ,      ,  ,      ,      .

       ,       .             . . [24 - .,    ,           , : ,          ,      ,     ( . . . 1. .: , 1988. . 547).        ,       ,   ( . . 552).   . . ,       ,                  ((Mis)readings of Marx in Continental Philosophy / eds J. Habjan, J. Whyte. Springer, 2014. P. 7375).            :           ,      (Ibid. P. 74).               ,   ,     .].                  ,     ,       ,   ,     ,  ,    . . .          , ,         .        ,    . 1)   ; 2)     ,   ; 3)       ,    ,       ,      ; 4)             ,  ,     ,  ; 5)      ,   ,      [25 -  . .      . .  //  . 1999. 6. . 7077.].

  ,           .    ,              ,       [26 -          ,         ,              .  ,   ,       ( . .   (   ) //  . .    . .: , 1990. . 325).     .      ,       ,          ,        ,        .            .: Khvatova T., Dushina S. To Manage or Govern? Researching the Legitimacy of NPM-based Institutional Reforms in Russian Universities // Journal of Management Development. 2017. Vol. 36. N 2. P. 250-267.]. ,            ,   ,    .           :     .            ,          .                     ,   ,      ,           ,    .         , ,         .

            ,      .                 .        . -,            ,     ,       ,    , ,     ,      . -,  ,          ( ),                  . -,  . .       ,          .

  ,         ,   ,   .        .     ,        ,   .           ,      : , , , .       ,       ,   ,  ,      [27 -  ,              , .: Cummins R. Meaning and Mental Representation. Cambridge: MIT Press, 1991. 180 p.           ,    ,     ,  ,     ,  ,        .].                       ,       ,   ,      ,  ,    .            .   ,   ,           . .   . ,           ,        ,        ,  ,       .         ,         [28 - Marcus G. E., Fischer M. M. I. Anthropology as Cultural Critique: An Experimental Moment in the Human Sciences. Chicago; London: University of Chicago Press, 1986. P. 12.].     ,          , ,   ,     .

            , ,          [29 - Trift N. Non-Representational Theory. London; New York: Rutledge, 2008; Non-Representational Methodologies. Re-envisioning Research / ed. by Ph. Vannini. New York; London: Routledge, 2015; Rorty R. Objectivity, Relativism and Truth. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1991.]. ,         ,     .  ,  ,   ,   ,          ,               .           . - ,            .        ,         ,     ,      . -,  ,    ,          [30 -           .: Representation in Scienti?c Practice Revisited / eds. by C. Coopmans, J. Vertesi, M. Lynch, S. Woolgar. Mass.: MIT Press, 2014.]. ,                 .

              .               .         ,          ,       ,        .    ,           .            ,    .              ,              .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/v-kupriyanov-19084679/nauchnaya-effektivnost-v-rabote/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes



1


      (),   15-03-00572.




2


:   / . . , . . , . . , . . . .:   , 2016. . 976.




3


 .     //  . .: 2 . . 2. .: , 1994. . 2021.




4


 .   .         //   . 2016. 2(138).             ,         ,                 .          .




5


 .,  .,  .        :     //   . 2016. 2 (138).            ,      ,    ,    ,   .




6


  .         . .: -, 2016. 272 c.;  . .          .       // Alma Mater.   . 2016. 11. . 97101;   .      / . .   . // .     . 2017. . 9,  1. . 112.  ,      ,         ,            .      , ,          ,     ;     ,     .




7


:  . . 946.




8


            .   ,         .




9


.  , .:  . . Homo Mathematicus     // . 2015. 19. . 6189.




10


 .  . .: , 1975. . 299.




11


   ,          .:  . .        //     2017. . 51,  1. . 817; Galison P. Trading with the enemy // Trading zones and interactional expertise: creating new kinds of collaboration / ed. by M. E. Gorman. Cambridge: MIT Press, 2010. P. 2552.




12


 . .,  . .,  . .    . .:  , 2012. . 52.




13


 .    //  . . . : 4 . . IV. .: , 1967. . 40.




14


      ,           .   ,            :                  . .  : Harding S. Strong objectivity: aResponse to the New Objectivity Question // Synthese. 1995. N 104. P. 331349.




15


    ,       ,     ,       , .:  . .      // . 2017. 1. . 159173.




16


Kronick D. A. Devant Le Deluge and Other Essays on Early Modern Scienti?c Communication. Latham, MD; Oxford, UK: Scarecrow Press, 2004; Gar?eld E. Has Scienti?c Communication Changed in 300 Years? Current Contents. N 8. 1980. P. 511.




17


Price D. J. de S. Networks of Scienti?c Papers: The Pattern of Bibliographic References Indicates the Nature of the Scienti?c Research Front // Science. Vol. 149, iss. 3683. July 30, 1965. P. 510515.




18


 .    //  . 2010.  9. 3. . 5788.




19


.   ,        : Gar?eld E. From the Science of Science to Scientometrics Visualizing the History of Science with HistCite Software // Journal of Informetrics. 2009. N 3. P. 173179.




20


  ,   -  ,     ,      .:  . .: 1)    ?  . .    // . 2000. 1. . 160183; 2)   .       // -. - . 30  2016 . URL: http://trv-science. ru/2016/05/30/vykhodit-ili-ostatsya/ ( : 20.12.2017);  . .   .  . .:   ̻, 2012. 728 .




21


    , .:  . .     ,      //   :      / . . , . . , . . , . . . : -  -, 2014. . 110163.




22


.     2  .




23


 . .          . . 101.




24


.,    ,           , : ,          ,      ,     ( . . . 1. .: , 1988. . 547).        ,       ,   ( . . 552).   . . ,       ,                  ((Mis)readings of Marx in Continental Philosophy / eds J. Habjan, J. Whyte. Springer, 2014. P. 7375).            :           ,      (Ibid. P. 74).               ,   ,     .




25


 . .      . .  //  . 1999. 6. . 7077.




26


         ,         ,              .  ,   ,       ( . .   (   ) //  . .    . .: , 1990. . 325).     .      ,       ,          ,        ,        .            .: Khvatova T., Dushina S. To Manage or Govern? Researching the Legitimacy of NPM-based Institutional Reforms in Russian Universities // Journal of Management Development. 2017. Vol. 36. N 2. P. 250-267.




27


 ,              , .: Cummins R. Meaning and Mental Representation. Cambridge: MIT Press, 1991. 180 p.           ,    ,     ,  ,     ,  ,        .




28


Marcus G. E., Fischer M. M. I. Anthropology as Cultural Critique: An Experimental Moment in the Human Sciences. Chicago; London: University of Chicago Press, 1986. P. 12.




29


Trift N. Non-Representational Theory. London; New York: Rutledge, 2008; Non-Representational Methodologies. Re-envisioning Research / ed. by Ph. Vannini. New York; London: Routledge, 2015; Rorty R. Objectivity, Relativism and Truth. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1991.




30


          .: Representation in Scienti?c Practice Revisited / eds. by C. Coopmans, J. Vertesi, M. Lynch, S. Woolgar. Mass.: MIT Press, 2014.


