 .   
 


      ,       ,           .               , ,   .     ,     ,    ,   ,    ,     ,    .    ,           .

       : ⠫                .  ,    1950-  -      ,              .    ,        .    ,     .               .      -   ,   ,                 .                    .( )

  PDF A4   .





 

 .   



  ,      


Matthew Syed

REBEL IDEAS

The Power Of Diverse Thinking



     2019.  John Murray ( Hachette UK)



 Matthew Syed Consulting Limited 2019

  ..,    , 2021

    .    -, 2021

 







I

 





1


9 2001.   , 33-  ,  ,       Pan Am , [1 -           .      : https://oig.justice.gov/special/s0606/chapter4.htm]. ,   -,       .    ,   ,  ,   , ,      ,     .         .   , $8300,      [2 -   . http://edition.cnn.com/2006/US/03/02/moussaoui.school/index.html].   ,                 ,       -   .

   ,               .    .    ,         ,       .   ,     ,   ,       ,  ,     ,             .



  11      ,                      .    ,    ,   ,        .

   .   ,            ,  ,   - .   1998.    1999-   ,   ,       ,        ,    .    .  ,       .  ,    -  .    ,      ,      ӻ.

   ,      11 2001.,   , ,      . -[3 - ,     . . .]  1993.        .           ,    .  ,           ,      , : ,  -  ,  ,   . ,      ,  .

2 1996.       ,  ,         .        ,     .         ,   5%      . -  .    [4 - Hoffman Bruce. The Modern Terrorist Mindset // Terrorism and Counterterrorism: Understanding the New Security / Eds R.D. Howard and R.L. Sawyer. McGraw-Hill, 2011. . : Jones Milo and Silberzahn Philippe. Constructing Cassandra: Reframing Intelligence Failure at the CIA, 19472001. Stanford Security Studies, 2013.].

           .  1994.             .           ,  -747     [5 -       (Debt of Honor). -. .].        The New York Times.  1995.        -    - .

 1997.  -         -,     :   62 ,    .         .      ,      .      , -         ,    .

 1998.           .   ,   :         ,         ,       ,    . 7,      --,  224      4000.       900 .

7 2001.,        ,     -                    ,        [6 - Russian Files on Al Qaeda Ignored // Janes Intelligence Digest, 5 October 2001.].         ,        ,  ,  .          ,  -      .  ,      .

  2001.,           ,  ,   ,    .   :       -   ,                .           ,         ,     .              .

  ,    ,       ,     ,      .      :          ,      11 2001.        ,    .

     ,  ,  .       , ,   .  , ,          .         ,                 .       ?        ?      ?

    ,     ,      . , ,   ,   ,      .   ,  ,         .      [7 - https://www.researchgate.net/publication/223213727_I_Knew_It_Would_Happen_Remembered_Probabilities_of_Once-Future_Things].

     11,  ,                ?      ?  ,     ,           ?[8 - Gladwell Malcolm. Connecting the Dots: The Paradoxes of Intelligence Reform // New Yorker, 10 March 2003.]

 ,   ,     .      .      ,          .       ,     .        .       ,    ,        [9 - Zegart Amy B. Spying Blind: The CIA, the FBI, and the Origins of 9/11 (Princeton University Press, 2009).].

     11    ,    .      .  ,      .   :    ,   ,  ,   ,    ,   .

     ,       .




2


   1947.       .      .        , ,    ,        .  ,    .

       SAT      ,    ,    .   ,        .   ,    ,       .      ,      [10 -     .].

          :  , , ,  .            :    ,      .  ,   ,   ,    .         :        1947  2001.      , ,     (        )[11 - Jones Milo and Silberzahn Philippe, Constructing Cassandra.].          :



 1964.          ,   ,         1967. ,    12000  ,    ,  20 .          , 1960- .     ,  ,    ,      1980- . <>  1975.          [12 -      ,  ,  ,     ,    .   ,    , . .][13 - https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/08850600150501317?needAccess=true].


  1979.       ,         ,         .      $410000     24- ,  1982. $1       .         .     -,   [14 -    .].

 1980- .          :       ,        ,   : ,    ,      ,     ,  ,    ,  ,   .  ,   ,   ,    ӻ[15 - Gates Robert. From the Shadows: The Ultimate Insiders Story of Five Presidents and How They Won the Cold War. Simon & Schuster, 2008.].

 1999.                 .    ,  ,       [16 - Jones Milo and Silberzahn Philippe. Constructing Cassandra.].  300         .

    ,    ,   ,    :   ,      ,  ,        [17 - Ibid.].      :    .

       .         .      ,    1990-   ,   ,     ,    -   ; ,      ; ,       ; ,     . -  ,     , ,   ,      -   .

   ,   1990- .     .      11 ⠫     (International Journal of Intelligence and Counterintelligence)  ,   :             ,    ,     ,  ,             .

       ,    .   ,       ,    .  ,             ,     ,        . , ,  ,    ,      .      ,  ,        .       ,    .            ?    ,  ,  .       .

         .           .           :  ,  -.     , ,                 .         ,   , ,    ,      .

         .     :     . -      :  ,  .     ,        ,   .   ?      :   ,   .           ,       .       .

 2016.        .    National Review  ,   ,          ,     .            ,           ,                 ,      .

        ,     . ,    ,     .      !   ,       !     :        .

  ,       ,   .




3


     ,    ,   ,   -.        -   .    ,         -.    ,  ,     ,   .   ,       .     .

 ,    ,    .  ,  ,         ,    ,      ,   .       :   ,   ,    ?

  ,                 .         ,       ,       ,     ,     ,    .              .

  ,     .        ,   ,       .             ?   ,      ,     蠫   ,  .      -,      .

  ,    ,      .     ,       ,      .      ,     蠫         ,   ,          .

 ,   ,      .        .      ,  ,    . -,      :  ,      !           ,   ,       . ?          ,  .    ,      ,    .   ,       ,    :   ,         ,    ,   .

  ,                .       ,   :    ,      .               .      90%    .            .

     .      ,     . ,      ,    1975.,  ,   ,   ,         .       .          ;        .             ,         ,  .

     .           ,   .           ,  ,       ,     .

,    . , ,             (  ).     ,   :   , ,    .     (  )  .    , , ,     -      .        .

         ,  ,  ,    ,   ,  ,     ,  ,       .       ,      ,    .   .     .    ,  ,      .   .         .      ,   .

 ,   ,   ,      ,     ,      .  ,    ,         -,     ,  .   ,           ,    .    ,   -,      -  .

       .        : ⠫     ,        2008.          .  ,    1950-  -      ,              .    ,        .    ,     .               .

     -   ,   ,                 .                    .  ,      .

         ,       ,      11         .        .




4


 2001.    ,        -,        ,              .   ,   ,    .     .  : ,     ,  ,      .       ,  .    ,   ,    ,     ,      [18 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SbgNSk95Vkk].

   ,     ,      .    ;     .      ,    .

        ,   -   ,  -  .       ,      ;    .      :    ,   .

   .      , , ,       .  :  ,     ,       ,       . -,      ,               , , -    .

      ,                 ,  .  ,    ,     .   ,   ,         .    ,     ,    ; , ,  ,   .    ,     .      .   .

  ,       ⠫.               .       ,  .       ,     ,        .



          ,    .   ,    ,      ,  -?  ,         ,     ,    (   ).

       ,         .     -     ,        , , ,  .  -     - ,     ,  ,      .        ,   ,      .   :



,       ,      .    , ,    ,  . ,         .           ,   .  ,       ,      .        ,      .    ,      ,         ?[19 - .: http://reasoninglab.psych.ucla.edu/KH%20pdfs/Gick-Holyoak%281980%29Analogical%20Problem%20Solving.pdf]


    ,   .  75%  ,         .     ,       :



,    ,    ,     .     ,  ,            ,       .             .    ,   ,     .      ,            [20 - http://reasoninglab.psych.ucla.edu/KH%20pdfs/Gick-Holyoak% 281980%29Analogical%20Problem%20Solving.pdf].


      .  ?  ,         70%          ,  .    -     ,  [21 -       ,     10- .    ,    .].

,   .      ,           :        .     ,     .   ,           ,      .

       .       ,  ,   ,           ,          .           ( ,    ),  蠫  ,  ,    .      -  ,  .

 ,         ,      ,  ,    .        :    ,      ,     .   ,           ,         ,        .




5


     ,  11 2001.,     ,       .     .    ,        .        ,            ,          .

      ,  - 2005.  Time      ,    .       .        ,    :  ,   ?    ,  ,        :   ,  ?

    :       ,    ,      .   ,      ,         ,       ,       ,  .        :    .  ,     ,  , ,   ,  ,      .

  -     . ,   ,                .     -   :



   -    ,    :    ,   ,  .  .  .       ,         ,    .         ,    .     ,       [22 - Eddo-Lodge Reni. Why Im No Longer Talking to White People About Race. Bloomsbury, 2017.].


      ,    ,       .        .  , ,  ,          .   ,           ,      .           .  ,   ,     ,       ,   ,        ,    ,      .

         , ,     .         .        ,             ,   .

     ?  2011.          ,   .          :   ,   .      Amazon        $10  $30.         ,  .

  .  ,       ,    ;  , ,       .   :         .    ,         ,     .    ,      .

?         .  ,    ,   .       ,       !      :    ,           .

  ,    (  , , ,  ,  ,    )       .  ,       , ,  ,          . ,     ,    ,     ,         .     ,  ,  ,    ,  ,   ,             25%[23 - Sparber. Racial Diversity and Aggregate Productivity; Florida and Gates. Technology and Tolerance: The Importance of Diversity to High-Tech Growth // Research in Urban Policy, 9:199219. December 2003.].  ,    McKinsey     ,   ,                ,       66% ,    ,        [24 -      .].                100%[25 -    ,     . ,     ,     ,        .        .].

,         . ,    .      ,    .     ,              ,    ,     .      :      ,   .       ,             ,      .      .        ,      ,    ,       ,        .

     ,  -  ,     .      : ,  ,   ..  ,  ,    ,        蠫,      ,     .   ,    ,    :    .  .     75%     54%    44%  ,     .

   .         .  ,  ,     .     ,    ,      .  ,      ,       .         ,      .

     ?            ,        ,    .        ,     ?     .      ,      ,          .                .      :     ,        .




6


         -  23 1996.   -,    !  .                      ,  :   .

 ,    ,         . ,     ,  ,      .             ,     :    ,     ,     ,       [26 - . : Shenon Philip. The Commission: The Uncensored History of the 9/11 Investigation. Twelve, 2008.].

       .         ,  ?  ,         ,   ,   :        ,    ?[27 - The 9/11 Commission Report.]  ,  , :            蠓-,      .      [28 -    .].

  ,       ,   .             :     .     ,   .  ,               ,        . , -       ,      .

       -,   11    ,     ,   ,      ,     ,   .      , ,             ,     ,    ,   -47,     ,        [29 - Scheuer Michael. Through Our Enemies Eyes: Osama bin Laden, Radical Islam, and the Future of America. Potomac Books, 2003.].

      .    ,     ,   ,    .       ,   .    :    ,   ,     ,        ,  ,     .   ,  ,        ,      [30 - Jones Milo and Silberzahn Philippe. Constructing Cassandra.].

     .     .     .       -   ,        .          ,      .   .  ,      ,       11.    :      ,      -,    ,       ,          .

 ,          ,     .         , , , , ,    ,   ,    ,     1999.,     ,     -          .

         20000 ,  1996  2000.     ;            .       .  ,    -      ,           .      .

    ,       .      .        .    -     ,   ,    - :      ,  .

        ,              -,       ,        (Constructing Cassandra).           :       .       [31 -     ,   The Cell: Inside the 9/11 Plot (Hyperion, 2002),    :  -              ,   .].       ,          ,     . ,       2000.    :

		  ,    ,
		    .   
		    ,
		  ,    ,
		 -,  .

  ,    ,   ,   .    ?      .       .    .       .      .    ,     .   :      ,        ,         .

                   .       .           : , ,  .        .   ,   蠫 .  ,   11,   .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/metu-sayed/buntarskie-idei-sila-divergentnogo-myshleniya/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


          .      : https://oig.justice.gov/special/s0606/chapter4.htm




2


  . http://edition.cnn.com/2006/US/03/02/moussaoui.school/index.html




3


,     . . .




4


Hoffman Bruce. The Modern Terrorist Mindset // Terrorism and Counterterrorism: Understanding the New Security / Eds R.D. Howard and R.L. Sawyer. McGraw-Hill, 2011. . : Jones Milo and Silberzahn Philippe. Constructing Cassandra: Reframing Intelligence Failure at the CIA, 19472001. Stanford Security Studies, 2013.




5


      (Debt of Honor). -. .




6


Russian Files on Al Qaeda Ignored // Janes Intelligence Digest, 5 October 2001.




7


https://www.researchgate.net/publication/223213727_I_Knew_It_Would_Happen_Remembered_Probabilities_of_Once-Future_Things




8


Gladwell Malcolm. Connecting the Dots: The Paradoxes of Intelligence Reform // New Yorker, 10 March 2003.




9


Zegart Amy B. Spying Blind: The CIA, the FBI, and the Origins of 9/11 (Princeton University Press, 2009).




10


    .




11


Jones Milo and Silberzahn Philippe, Constructing Cassandra.




12


     ,  ,  ,     ,    .   ,    , . .




13


https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/08850600150501317?needAccess=true




14


   .




15


Gates Robert. From the Shadows: The Ultimate Insiders Story of Five Presidents and How They Won the Cold War. Simon & Schuster, 2008.




16


Jones Milo and Silberzahn Philippe. Constructing Cassandra.




17


Ibid.




18


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SbgNSk95Vkk




19


.: http://reasoninglab.psych.ucla.edu/KH%20pdfs/Gick-Holyoak%281980%29Analogical%20Problem%20Solving.pdf




20


http://reasoninglab.psych.ucla.edu/KH%20pdfs/Gick-Holyoak% 281980%29Analogical%20Problem%20Solving.pdf




21


      ,     10- .    ,    .




22


Eddo-Lodge Reni. Why Im No Longer Talking to White People About Race. Bloomsbury, 2017.




23


Sparber. Racial Diversity and Aggregate Productivity; Florida and Gates. Technology and Tolerance: The Importance of Diversity to High-Tech Growth // Research in Urban Policy, 9:199219. December 2003.




24


     .




25


   ,     . ,     ,     ,        .        .




26


. : Shenon Philip. The Commission: The Uncensored History of the 9/11 Investigation. Twelve, 2008.




27


The 9/11 Commission Report.




28


   .




29


Scheuer Michael. Through Our Enemies Eyes: Osama bin Laden, Radical Islam, and the Future of America. Potomac Books, 2003.




30


Jones Milo and Silberzahn Philippe. Constructing Cassandra.




31


    ,   The Cell: Inside the 9/11 Plot (Hyperion, 2002),    :  -              ,   .


