 
 

  


  Neoclassic
  (19041980)   XX , - , ,  ,   .          .

                     .          ,     -        .       ,         ,         ,  .

            ,      :  ,               .

  a4.pdf   .





 ,   

 


  

 



 ,

        ,   





 


 ,         ,   1904 . ,     ,     ,        ,            .        1936       ,    .         .

       .           (1947);            -;            - (19531963),       - (.,  ,  ,  )     [1 -  (double bind)     .,     ,    . ,          - (. .: 1972; . .: -, , 2008,    .)  double bind    .     double bind        ,  -.  (   ) -        ,      . ,      ,  ,  ,   ..                 :        .           ..              ,          ,    .       : https://double-bind.livejournal.com/19716.html.] (double bind theory)   .           - ,          .      .

               .  1972       -, .        (Bateson, 1972),    (Bateson, 1979),   (Bateson, 1991),     :    (Bateson, Ruesh, 1951),             ,      (Laing).


* * *

                   ,     .         ,           :  .           ,              .       (1979).        ,         .   ,       ,     .          .



           ,   ,   4,    ,   .  , ,  ,       ,  ,     ,          .


* * *

    .   ,                 -.           ,   ,  ,   ,   .        ,  ,        .       ,    -,      , ,           .

          ,      ,              5.   ,    ,       ,      .

  ,             . , -,    ..,        ,      - ,  -,        ,       .             .    ,               ,      (,    )         ,   .

    (          ), ,    ,      , , ,   ()       ,   ,   .  ,            ,  -       XIX . , ,                        ,        (  ).

,     ,       ; ,        ,  (. 4),          .  ,   .

,   ,             , -      .          ,     ,            .         ,        .     ,     -  .            The Men who Stare at Goats (      ).


* * *

       ,  :       ,      .   ,                      . ,   ,       ,  ,  ,    .        ..       ,          .

            ,  ,       -,    1970-   ,         .   ,   Β, ,          ,  ,                (       1980.   ).

    ,    ,      ,     ,        ,     (SarfattiJ. In the thick of it). ,        - ,  ,     XIX ,      ,       .. ..,    -,   -    !


* * *

    ()  (), ,   ..,           ...      ..  ,    ,       .             ,     . ,  . .,  ,  .  ..,     .

   (  ,    )  ...        .

  ,    , , ,    ..,     .



..,
 20172019

		     .
		    .
		  ,   .
		     ,
		 ,  
		   .
		   .
		-! -!
		 : --!

, [2 -  ..-.  .  . .; ., 1950.  :Full fathom five thy father lies;Of his bones are coral made;Those are pearls that were his eyes:Nothing of him that doth fade,But doth suffer a sea-changeInto something rich and strange.Sea-nymphs hourly ring his knell:Ding-dong.Hark! now I hear them, Ding-dong, bell.]



 


      ,       .     .       ,     ,    .      ,   , ,      ,        .

     ,       :   ,   (Camaldolese,  , ), - -,  .   ,         ,   ,     .    ,       .                .

         ,       ,        ,    .       ,   .     ,      (        ),      .      ,  ,  ,  ,      ,      - ,    . ?      ,  ,   ,       .          ,     ,    , ,  ,       .



  
, 
 1986




1/1.     ()


 1978       ,     :   (  1979.).                .   ,     ,      ,              [3 -    Fools rush in where angels fear to tread,       ,     .  . .].   1980     ,               .    ,    .   4  1980 ,        .       ,         ,         (BatesonM.C., 1984).        ,    , ,   ,         ,    .

       .        ,   ,  :      ,  .    ,      ,    ,   -.        (Bateson, 1972)     ,       .          ,        .      ,        ,     ,      .               .

         .   ,   ,       ,      ,    .        ,   .        ,  ,      ,   ,       ,   .        .  ,   ,   ,           ; ,     ,         .     .     ,        ,     ,      .

             ,     .    ,    ,   ,                  sic ,     ,  ,   . ,   ,        ,                .  , , ,   - - ,    ,            ,     .       .               ,         .      ,      .     ,    ,       .

  , ,       ,      ,           .        ,   ,       .          ,        .         ,           .

   ,  ,     ,   ,     .       ,    ,     ,    .              ,    ,  ?..          .         ,    ,          ,         ,     .    ,      ,         :     ,        .

   . ,    , ,    ,  ,    ,         .       ,   ,   ,  ,     ,     .         ,           . ,     ,      , ,     .        ,    .        ,     .   ,         ,         ,         . ,     ,        .     ,           ,    ,   ,        ,         ,    .   ,     ,    ,        .   , ,   ,   .  ,     ,             .        ,      ,         .

  ,      ,      ,    :



     ,    ,    .          .           -  .     ,     .  ,    -   ,      [4 -         .  . .].  ,       .          ,    .       ,    .


  , ,  ,    ,     ,    ,    .  ,   ,     ,       .    ,  ,     ,    .    1980-       ,        ,          .           ,                ,  , ,    .    ,       ,      ,    .   ,  ,   ,    -      .            ,      .           ,       ,  :   ,     .  ,   ,   -       ,    .

 ,         ,      ,      ,          .     ,   , -   ,    . ,       , , ,      .   ,      ,        .

 1978 ,         ,    ,   ,   ,  ,         , , ,      .






		   
		 
		    
		  
		    
		    
		     
		 
		   
		 
		    
		    
		     
		    
		,   
		   
		    
		  
		 ,    
		
		
		[5 -  :The Manuscript - So there it is in wordsPreciseAnd if you read between the linesYou will find nothing thereFor that is the discipline I askNot more, not lessNot the world as it isNor ought to be Only the precisionThe skeleton of truthI do not dabble in emotionHint at implicationsEvoke the ghosts of old forgotten creedsAll that is for the preacherThe hypnotist, therapist and missionaryThey will come after meAnd use the little that I saidTo bait more trapsFor those who cannot bearThe lonelySkeletonof Truth.].

       ,      ,    .       ;         .            .         .     ,         ,        .

     ,     ,   ,    ,    .         .   , ,        ,        , ,    ,   : , ,        .     :      ,  -    ,      ,       .         , ,         ,       .

   ,       ,               ,     .       :      ,     ,    .   .          . , ,      ,   ? ,    ,      ,      .

     ,       ,   .      : -,      ; -,       ,     .       ,        , ,       .

   ,     .   ,   ,    ,      ,   , ,   廠   ,    .           ,         . (    .)

        :



      ,         ;

      , ,         ,      ;

   ,  ,     ()            ,       -,  .



      ,    ,  ,      ,  ,   ,   ,              .    , ,       ,  ;      ,    .       ,      ,  ,           .

             .     ,          ,     ,  .           ,    ,     .            ,  ,      .     ,            ,  .    ,     -    .     ,  , ,       ,      ,       .

         -   ,       ,  ,     ,  ,    .         ,         ,     ,       ,     .       (    ,      ),       (   ,    ),   ,       .  ,      ,    ,      ?       ,       ?   ,   ,      ,               .

  ,  ,      (        ),     ,    ,        .        ,          ,       .     ,      .

 ,              ,   .         ,    . ,    ,  : -            .  - ,     .    ,      ,   . , ,   ?        .




1/2.   ()


     ,     ,             .

 ,      ,    .     ,       ,     ,         ?  .       .    ,  ,    .   ,          ,        (),      .

 ,      ,       ( ) .        ,       .    ,             .               ,      .          ,      .

   ,      ?       ?         ?

        .       ,      .          ,        .    ,   .     ,      , , , ,     .   ,        ,    .

,  ,  ,  ,  ,    ,     ,      .       -   ,            ,     .

  ,      ,   ,    ,      .    .  ,      ,    ,      .

           ,      ,             ,    .            ,     ,      .

 ,           .    ,       ,  ,  ,     ,    ,        ,    .  ,         ,  ,     .    ,       :     ,     .      ,    ,        , ,      ,  ,   .

    ,     ,    .     ,         .     ,         ,          ;     ,       .  ,         ,        ,   ,          .  ,           .

         ,       .  XIII    (Summa theologica; Aquinas, 12651274)        .         :



a),      ;

b),       ;

c),  ,       ; 

d),  , ,       .



            ,         ,       ,    .

         .   ,              [. . .]  . ( , ,   ,       ,   .)           ,       ,         [ ,  ,  -     ].

 ,         ,   XIII .   ,    (15961650),     ,           .         ,        ? .                [-            ,    .     ,    ,     ].

     .      ,      : ,       ,     ,   ,  ,    .          ,   ,     ,     .     :        ,       .  -       ,          .  ,  ,    ,  ,  .

         ,     150 .                  (Paley, 1794),    15        65     .  ,             40-  XX .  ,     .

 ,       (Bateson, 1936)    .         .  ,                     .      (schismogenesis)     ,    ,   1936       ,       [ ,        ,  ].   ,  ,           status quo.

    [6 -   10  (19461953, ),          .    -  .  . .]  ,  -     ,     .          (   ),            .           ,   ,         ,     .

 ,         ,               .   ,      (deutero-learning),   [7 - Social Planning and the Concept of Deutero-Learning // SEM, 1972 (c.:       // .     . .: , 2005).].

   ,   ,                  ໠       ,      .        ,       .    ,       1940-. [       (Russell, Whitehead, 191013)       ,       ,    ,    ..           ,          ;        ,       .]

         1960 ,      (Wheelwright)         (Jung, 1916; 1966).            .[8 - Form, Substance and Difference // SEM, 1972. (.: ,    // .     . .: , 2005).]         .          ,     ,     ,     .    ,           ,      . ,           .     ,        .

       ,   ,   ,   -  ( ,   ),          .    ,         -   -     ,           .      :       ,          ,   .

,     ,      ,     .         , ,  ,   .     .

       .          [ , ,    ?     ].       , ,    .      .   ,     ,    2500 .      ,     , ,      .

      .  ,       ,    ,     ,         .   (     )      ,   .        ,   ,      .        ,   ,      .   ,   , , ,       ,    ,      ,     .

       .  ,       .     -,      .  ,    ,        ,   .  ,       .




2.   ()


    ,      ,    [9 -    .   ,    ,     ,      . ,         ,   ,           .]    .         ,   ,     ,   .    ,      ,   (),       ,       ,        .

        ,       . ,      ,         : , , ,     ..,       .        .         ,    ,   ,    ,     ,   ,   .    .              .

                     ,   ,    ,      .

 ,        ( ), ,    ,   .       (difference that makes a difference)[10 -      .   // .   :  . .: , 2016.].        (), ,   . ,     ,              .        ,        .           .       .

, ,           .      ,     . ,   ,       ,       .              ,      [11 -          ,         .         ,            ,  ,       .   ,    .  . .].      ,       ,    .       .      ,   .

   ,      .      ,    .    ?      .

    ,       .    ?        .

       .

?     ?,            .

           ,          ,    .         .

 ,        ,             .  ,  , -,     ..,  (   ) .     (    )   ,      ,    ,   Ding an sich,   ,    .    ,     ,  ,     ,  ,      ,    ,   ,   ,    [12 -    , ,  ,        .       .  . .].

          ,              .  , ,        .

,          ,         ,   .

         ,   ,         ,      .   ,         ,            ,      .   ,       .       ,   .           ,   ,    .  ,        (),     .       ,  ,     ,       ,    .

,          .     ,      ,    ,     ?             ,        .           :



      .

     .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/gregori-beytson/angely-strashatsya-48797557/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes



1


 (double bind)     .,     ,    . ,          - (. .: 1972; . .: -, , 2008,    .)  double bind    .     double bind        ,  -.

  (   ) -        ,      . ,      ,  ,  ,   ..                 :        .

           ..              ,          ,    .

       : https://double-bind.livejournal.com/19716.html.




2


 ..-.  .  . .; ., 1950.  :

		Full fathom five thy father lies;
		Of his bones are coral made;
		Those are pearls that were his eyes:
		Nothing of him that doth fade,
		But doth suffer a sea-change
		Into something rich and strange.
		Sea-nymphs hourly ring his knell:
		Ding-dong.
		Hark! now I hear them, Ding-dong, bell.




3


   Fools rush in where angels fear to tread,       ,     .  . .




4


        .  . .




5


 :



The Manuscript


		So there it is in words
		Precise
		And if you read between the lines
		You will find nothing there
		For that is the discipline I ask
		Not more, not less
		Not the world as it is
		Nor ought to be 
		Only the precision
		The skeleton of truth
		I do not dabble in emotion
		Hint at implications
		Evoke the ghosts of old forgotten creeds
		All that is for the preacher
		The hypnotist, therapist and missionary
		They will come after me
		And use the little that I said
		To bait more traps
		For those who cannot bear
		The lonely
		Skeleton
		of Truth.




6


  10  (19461953, ),          .    -  .  . .




7


Social Planning and the Concept of Deutero-Learning // SEM, 1972 (c.:       // .     . .: , 2005).




8


Form, Substance and Difference // SEM, 1972. (.: ,    // .     . .: , 2005).




9


   .   ,    ,     ,      . ,         ,   ,           .




10


     .   // .   :  . .: , 2016.




11


         ,         .         ,            ,  ,       .   ,    .  . .




12


   , ,  ,        .       .  . .


