 .   
 


  / Contemporary Judaica
              .     - ,   ,                     ,      .     1902 ,       ,    

       -,  ,     . Dov Schwartz, a former Dean of Humanities at Bar Ilan University and head of the departments of philosophy and of music, currently heads its interdisciplinary unit, and holds the Natalie and Isidore Friedman Chair for Teaching Rav Joseph B. Soloveitchiks Thought.

  PDF A4    .

Religious Zionism is a major component of contemporary Israeli society and politics. The author reviews the history of religious Zionism from both a historical and an ideological-theological perspective. His basic assumption is that religious Zionism cannot be fully understood solely through a historical description, or even from social, political, and philosophical vantage points.





 

 .   



Dov Schwartz

Religious-Zionism

History and Ideology



Academic Studies Press

2009



    








 Dov Schwartz, text, 2009

 Academic Studies Press, 2009

 . .,   , 2021

     , 2021



       -,  ,     . Dov Schwartz, a former Dean of Humanities at Bar Ilan University and head of the departments of philosophy and of music, currently heads its interdisciplinary unit, and holds the Natalie and Isidore Friedman Chair for Teaching Rav Joseph B. Soloveitchiks Thought.



Religious Zionism is a major component of contemporary Israeli society and politics. The author reviews the history of religious Zionism from both a historical and an ideological-theological perspective. His basic assumption is that religious Zionism cannot be fully understood solely through a historical description, or even from social, political, and philosophical vantage points.







     ,      - .      ,             ,       -    .

    :       1902-,   ,          .             ,       (-),   ,      ,  ,          .        XIX      . ,           ;       ,     -       - .

 , ,   ,      .             ,   ,    .       ,              (  ),      .    -     ,           ,         .                . ,        ,       .

                   ,  -    .                  .

     ,    ,    ,      .




 

 



      (1902)       .        ,   ,     [1 - ,          ( : -:  , 19781991)     .].         ,              ,          .

        ,     -    .                       ,      .             , ,  ,                   .     ,    軠    ,          .        ,        .







      ,               (      ) .     ,     -       .      ,            ,     . ,            :      [Aviad 1962: 117][2 -       .].

                 ,      .   ,              ,        () [Landau 1935: 27][3 -      -  . [Don-Yehiuah 1992: 129155].].               [Kook Zwi 1983: 80]. .  ,     ,      , ,     ,         ,   - [Berkovits 1973: 120].  ,    ,     ,       ,            ,     [Bernstein 1956: 87].   ,         [Aminoah 1931: 105].       ,    ,           [4 - - ,    ,   [Avneri 1988: 64].].

 -,   ,         ,            [5 - . [Maimon 1965: 96].].       ,   ,    : ,           ,     [Glasner 1961: 67][6 -        ,  . . : [Schwartz 2002b: 8; Schwartz 1997b: 3133, passim].].      [7 -      : [Unna 1955: 63].]   .

              :           (,   )     .         .   -     , ,          .   ,          (  -),         .        ,        ,      .     ,              ,      ,        .

,               ,  .   ,      ,        :          .     ,       ,            [8 - .   ,    : [Goren 1996b: 1827].].




- 


            ,       . ,          .       ,     .      ,              .       ,    ,    ,            ,   ,            .

      ,     ,      - ,      -      .        ,       [9 -    .  [Shapira Y. 1997: 133135]. . [Nehorai 1991].]. ,   ,      ,      :            [Berkovitz 1973: 156].            ,      .

    -        :  -       ,   .           ,       ,          .     ,       ,      :          ,           [Goren 1996: 643].              .            ,   ,  ,  ,              [10 -    .  [Schwartz 1997b].]


.   ,                   .




 


 ,  ,      :    


.              ,     ,     [12 - . [Glasner 1961: 72].];     ,    [13 - . [Kook 1980, 1:30].];          [14 - . [Kook Zvi 2004, 1: 136137].  ,      , :          ,          ,           [Aviner 1983, 2: 184185].];         .

    ,   :   ,    -,      ,  ,     ,        ,      ,    .  ,   ,     :   ,          [Aviad 1962: 30].    :



      ,               ,       -        . <>         ,  ,             :                 [Soloveitchik 2002: 154].


   ,           .        -       [Dushinsky 1982: 152][15 -     , ,       .]. ,   ,    ,        ,         .    -   ,       ;       ,           [16 - . [Schwartz 2002b: 140151].].




   


    ,    -      .      , ,             .     ,                 .   ,   :            [17 -   , ,  - ()    - - - (1935); . [Avneri 1988: 32].].  ,          ,      : ,       [18 -   , . : [Zehavi 1966: 336].].         .             ,     1910- ,     ,       ,   .   ,  ,    ,    [Kressel 1969: 174][19 - .   .]; ,        :    - (  )    ,     ,     ,       [20 -     . . [Friedman 1977: 166].].           (1937):     ,         [21 -     . . [Warhaftig 1988: 276]. . : [Dotan 1979: 182].].           ( ),     .

         :       (  ).  ,    ,       :



 ,     ,    -  ;       ,     ,  ,   ,        ;      ,     ,     ,      [22 -     (), . : [Rubinstein . 1981: 158].       .].


-  ()  ,    -     ;  ,  



     - <> ,        ,   , ,     ,   ,       ,       .     ,   ,       ,       ,      [23 - . : [Rubinstein . 1981: 164].].


    , ,      ,         ,    ,  ,       [24 - . : [Rubinstein . 1981: 167].     ,    .].

           ,      .   ,   ,       -,         ,      [Admanit 1977: 352][25 -       .].

  ,         .   ,   19431946         -,      :   ,        .     ,  -        :       .           [Kadari 2003: 351].       ,       .

         ,       .            ,          ,     .           1998      ,          -,        ,    .  ,        .  ,      ,    .







        .           [26 - . [Eisenstadt 1978].].  ,          ,    ,      ,          .    ,       XX ,        - ,    .   ,          . ,    , ,                          .      ,    [27 - .  .].




 

    



         1902      ()    [28 - . [Don-Yehiyah 1983; Bat-Yehuda 1985: 1985; Schweid 1986].].             .              ,         ,           .  ,   ,  ,        .          ,     ,     ,     ,  ,    .    , ,       ,      ,      .   ,         , ,     ,     ,     ,    .




 


                     .   ,    ,   -,         . ,         ,       .            ,      .    ,  , :     [29 - . [Kaniel 1981].].

           .         .             ,         ( )[30 - . [Almog 1987: ch. 2]; [Bat-Yehuda 1982: 6686]; [Luz 1988].].   -              . ,      ,  ,    ,      ,  ,     [31 - . [Klausner 1960].].            (1901);       .         .   ,           ,     ,            .  , ,     ,    .




 


           .      (       - (   )),               . -           :



  .         ,       .       ,                 .    ,        ,     ,      .   ,     .

  .        :       .    -      ,   .


               -  .      ,       .   :     .      ,        ,    .  ,      .     ,        .   , ,      ,    , .          [32 - . [Schwartz 2002b: 4689].].     , ,   :



      , ,       . <>  ,       ,       ,          ,          [Reines 1896: 21-].


 ,       ,       ,       .   ,    ,    ,    . ,    ,        :        ,  ,           .          ,                  .       ,           .

   ,    ,   ,         ;        ,   - .   -           .      1902   ,     ,          ,   ,    . ,       ,      . ,       ,  .    (    軠  )     ,       .

   ,         ,    ,      ,        .               ;           ,       .              ,      .




  ?


   ,          ,            ,   .   ,            ,    ,    .     ,        .             ()  ,      .   ,      - ,         .        .     ,      ,              .    , ,         - ()      () ,  ,  ,  -   --. ,  ,   ,    ,      , ,  ,         .  , ,   .

 ,          .     ,    , ,     .      ,       . ,           ,          .

 ,                .          ,           , ,    ,        .     ,      .        ,    ,            .      ,  :



    ,     ,          <>     ,     .   ,   ,    ,        ,   ,         ,  .    .   ,     ,     ,    , ,       ,      .          ,        [Reines 1926: 205].


     ,                   .   ,           [33 - ., ., [Schwartz 2002; Halbertal 2007].]. ,      ,       :  ,       ,      ,           .             ,       .        ,        ,       . ,   1940-         ,    ,    .  ,  ,                     .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/dov-shvarc/religioznyy-sionizm-istoriya-i-ideologiya/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


,          ( : -:  , 19781991)     .




2


      .




3


     -  . [Don-Yehiuah 1992: 129155].




4


- ,    ,   [Avneri 1988: 64].




5


. [Maimon 1965: 96].




6


       ,  . . : [Schwartz 2002b: 8; Schwartz 1997b: 3133, passim].




7


     : [Unna 1955: 63].




8


.   ,    : [Goren 1996b: 1827].




9


   .  [Shapira Y. 1997: 133135]. . [Nehorai 1991].




10


   .  [Schwartz 1997b].




11


     -    . . [Shapira . 1997: 155174].




12


. [Glasner 1961: 72].




13


. [Kook 1980, 1:30].




14


. [Kook Zvi 2004, 1: 136137].  ,      , :          ,          ,           [Aviner 1983, 2: 184185].




15


    , ,       .




16


. [Schwartz 2002b: 140151].




17


  , ,  - ()    - - - (1935); . [Avneri 1988: 32].




18


  , . : [Zehavi 1966: 336].




19


.   .




20


    . . [Friedman 1977: 166].




21


    . . [Warhaftig 1988: 276]. . : [Dotan 1979: 182].




22


    (), . : [Rubinstein . 1981: 158].       .




23


. : [Rubinstein . 1981: 164].




24


. : [Rubinstein . 1981: 167].     ,    .




25


      .




26


. [Eisenstadt 1978].




27


.  .




28


. [Don-Yehiyah 1983; Bat-Yehuda 1985: 1985; Schweid 1986].




29


. [Kaniel 1981].




30


. [Almog 1987: ch. 2]; [Bat-Yehuda 1982: 6686]; [Luz 1988].




31


. [Klausner 1960].




32


. [Schwartz 2002b: 4689].




33


., ., [Schwartz 2002; Halbertal 2007].


