  .        
 


,       ,         . ,         ,        .    ,      ,   ,   ,          ,   ,   ,       ,    ,   ,  ,   ,           ,   .

  ,      14 ,       ,   ,    .             ,          ,         .

       ,    ,   ,   ,   .      ,            ,   . (. . )

  PDF A4    .





 

  .        



David Fideler

BREAKFAST WITH SENECA

A Stoic Guide to the Art of Living



David Fideler, 2022

 ..,    , 2022

    , .    -, 2022












          .

    ,         . ,      - .  ,    ,  :      .    ,    .

 .

  ,    ,   .

     ,           .           .  ,      .        ,         .

,      . -    ,    ,       - .    .  ,   .    ,   ,    .  ,         ,  .

 ,    ,      .  , -    .              (. 4.  .. 65. ..) ,        .       ,          -  .

,            ,      ,   ,      .        .              .      ,          ,  ,      .        ,      ,   ,  ,      .

 ,  ,           ,  ,   ,   . , , ,         ,  ,   , -  .

    ,   ,      ,     ,        ,            ,    (  )   .

   ,       .     ,         .      :      ,         , :     ,  ,  ,    [1 -   .     / . . .. . .: , 1977. 104.26. . 265.].            .

     ,   .

  ,     ,         ,    . ,     ,       ,     .    ,              ,        .

              ;     .     ,    ,           Hotel Central     - .     ,           ,   .     .   , ?  ,     ,         ,    ,    ,        .

 ,        .  : ,    ,     ,   [2 - .    . 5.4. . 10.].       ,   ,  ,         ,   .

  ,       ,   ,     ;  ,      .          .      ,      ,  . ,       ,       ,    .          (.  1   ).     ,      .

              ,      .  ,         ,         .          :       ,     ,  ,        ,        . (,        ,    ,      ,     .)

         ,         ,       , ,      -[3 - Pigliucci Massimo. How to Be a Stoic: Using Ancient Philosophy to Live a Modern Life. N. Y.: Basic Books, 2017. P. 230. ( .   :      / . . .. . .:  -, 2018.)]. ,             . (   ,   ,    ,    .)

         .   ,             ,       .



 




. ,   ,  



 (. 4.  .. 65...)         .     ,        .        :     ,       .

           ,        .      .     ,        .           ,           .       .

              .        ,       ,    ,    .     ,   ,  (. 50135)    (121180),    ,     ,   .




   :     


  ,      ,  ,       .

.    . 117.33 [302]

     ,     .             컠   ,   .   -,   ,         :          .     ,           .    ,    ,  ,     .   ,        ,  .      ,   ,     ,   , , , .       ,    .

         (. 470399.  ..);   :     .    .        .   ,   ,       ,    ,     .      ,   ,      ,     [4 - .: Sellars John. The Art of Living: The Stoics on the Nature and Function of Philosophy. L.: Bristol Classical Press, 2009. Ch. 2. The Socratic Origins of the Art of Living.].

                         .        300.  .. ,     (. 334 . 262.  ..)       ,       [5 -   ,    , . .  https://www.stoicinsights.com/about-stoicism/].

,      ,  :     ?   ,        ,     ,       ,       .        ,     ,         , ,          .

 , ,     ,     ,   .  ,           .       ,              ,    ,       ,      .

           ,           ,           .       (340270.  ..):



   ,      .      ,       ,    ,       [6 -       : Nussbaum . The Therapy of Desire: Theory and Practice in Hellenistic Ethics. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1994. P. 13. (  / . .-. ..  // .   :  2. . II. , ,    . .; ., 1947. . 641.)].


          .    -   ,       .      ,        .   ,     ,         ,      [7 - .    . 8.2. . 14.            .: Sellars John. The Art of Living. Ch. 2, 3.].




    


  , ,  -      ,      ,        .       ,       .        ,       ,  .

          ,      ,  ,    . (       ,     .)


1.    ,   

,     ,   ,    .      ,   ,       .     ,         .    ,  ,       ,    . (,    ,     .)           ,    ,  ,         .


2.,    ,   

    ,       :         -  ,     .

,      ,        ,  .     ,    , ,  ,     .   -,        ,            ,   ,             .   , ,   ,      ,     [8 - .    . 76.16. . 147.].


3.         ,  

  ,     ,     ,    ,  ,    ,   .

         ,     ,        . (      6     8   :      .)


4.     ,       ,           

     ,            .        ,       ,      . (.  3       4  .)


5.    ,    ,       

     ,    ,        .  ,   ,     ,    . ,        ,  . (.  6   .)


6.,   ,     .      ,  .      

   -: , ,       .      ,   , ,  ,   ,  . (.  14 ,    .)

     ,   ,  ,    , -,        . ,    ,  ,      ,    ,    ,   ,  ,        [9 -             ,    .]. ,        ,   .  ,   ,    ,   ,     .


7.   

   ,       .         ,         .        ,          . (.  1   .)


8.,       

      .  ,        ,    ,       . (.  10        .) ,               [10 -       ,        -,    ,    .  ,              .          ,           .].




    


    ,    .   ,     ,           . ( ,       ,     ,   [11 - Wilson Emily. The Greatest Empire: A Life of Seneca. N. Y.: Oxford University Press, 2014.    : Romm James. Dying Every Day: Seneca at the Court of Nero. N. Y.: Knopf, 2014.       ,     ,     ,    .  ,       ,    ,   .   ,    (. 155 . 235)    ,     ,          .     (. 56 . 120),   ,  .].)

   4.  .. ( )    ,    ,     ( ).  ,   (54.  .. 39...)  ,   .   ,     ,              ,           .

     ,           .        ,    .

 ,     -   ;  ,      .      ,          ,         . ,          ,      .  ,       ,          ;     .

     .   ,       ,       .   (1241),  (10.  .. 54...)   (3768),    ,    ,    ,   (   ),     ,     ,       .       ,   ,   ,    .

     ,  ,        .      ;         ,      .

  ,   ,           .                 .          ,        ,     .        -.                  .

 ,      ,   ,  ,          ,  .  ,      ,    .

        ,    ,        ,       .  ,         ,    ,   ,       .

,      ,  ,   ,                   .  ,        ,         ,   .

    ,     (       ),      ,   ,      ,       .

          .     ,  .      ,    ,      .       ,    ,    (       ).        ,      ,      .      ,         .

   ,      ,            .     ,  ,         ,            ,     ;     ,      .

  ,         ,       ,        ,   .

   :    ?         ,     [12 - . .:  2. . I. .   / . . .. . .: , 1969. 15.62. . 307].         ,   ,      ,   :      ,     [13 -       .           . (. . . 83.)   ,  ,        ,  :    ,     .].       ,      .




    


     ,     ,          .

         ,    .             ,     ,         ,     ,       .

        ,     .          .     :



       ,    ,     !      ,              ,     .       ,     ,    ,      ( ,   - ,   ),       ,    [14 - .    . 123.6. . 318.].


    ,  ,     ,      ,    ,    .                ,  .    ,   ,           ,      ,        .     ,     .

 ,         ,     ,         - .  :



,   , ,   ,      ,     ,  ,   .    ,     -  .   ,    ,        ,     - .  ,    ,     [15 - .    . 122.14. . 317.].


          .       ,          ,    .   ,     , , , , ,  ,               .

   ,         ,     . ,       ,      ,          .  ,            ,   :



  ,    ,   ,    ,    .     ,      ?    ,     !         ;   ,       ,  .   ,       [16 - .    . 115.9. . 294.].


        ,       .        .  ,       ,    ,       .  ,       ,  ,     :  ,      [17 -    ,      , ,  ,   ,           . Inwood B. Reading Seneca: Stoic Philosophy at Rome. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 2005. P. 3.].      ,   ,      ,    .         ,       .

 ,     .   ,         .




 1.   



  ,     ,     ,    .       ,      .

.    . 6.4 [11]

     ,        .

          .    ,   , ,    .         .          -      .   ,    .

     ,      .            ,       .    ,    ,      ,    ,      ,      ,   .    ,            .

     ,         .

   ,     ,        ,      ,     .                  .       ,          :



     ,    ,       ,      ,   .     ,      ,  :    .       ,           ;    ,     .      ,        ,        ,       ,    .      ,     [18 - .    . 48.2, 48.3. . 80.      ,        .  ,   ,       Motto Anna Lydia and Clark John R. Seneca on Friendship // Atena e Roma. 1993. 38. P. 9196.].


        ,         ,   .       ,        .    ,         ,    . ,    , ,   ,        .

   -  ,       .           .         ,      ,  .   ,  ,   ,      ,    .  ,     ,    [19 - .    . 106.12. . 269.].       ,           .            ,      .

      ,        ,         .      . ,  ,    ,    ,          .       ,         (    ),     .

            ,     .       ,   .        ,            .          ,          .         .           ,   ,     [20 -    ,    (   . 94.16),      ,   ,   ,    .    .             .       ,      -,    .              24.   - ,     ;      ,    .].




 


    ,  ,   ,     ,      ,   .

.    . 67.2 [121]

                .     .    ,      ,   ,  .   :            [21 - .    . 40.1. . 68.].        ,        .

 ,      -  .      ,      .        ,        .      ,            ,      .

  ,           ,      .   ,         ,         .  ,   :      ,    ,    ,      .      ,             .

,        .  ,   . ,         ,             ,      .  ,         ,   .

          .           ,       ,     ,         .




  


 (384322.  ..)             , ,       .        ,                 ,  ,       .

  ,  ,    .   ,    ,    ,    .       .     ,  ,    .       ,  .  :      ,     [22 - .    . 9.12. . 17.   ,   ,         ,    . (.     . 3.70.)].

     . ,  ,  ,     .      ,       ,      .

         ,         ,   .  ,   .      ,        .     ,   ,        .    ,       .    ,      .

  ,          ,   ,     [23 - .: John M. Cooper. Aristotle on the Forms of Friendship // The Review of Metaphysics. 1977. 30. 4. P. 648.].   , ,           ,   .   :      ,    ,    ,  [24 - .: Sherman Nancy. Aristotle on Friendship and the Shared Life // Philosophical and Phenomenological Research. 1987. 47. 4. P. 610.].

   ,       ,   ,    .  ,     ,        ,    ,        .    ,   ,  ,   ,    ,     .        ,      .




 


          .        :  , ,      ,     [25 - .    . 6.1. . 11.].

          .   ,      .      ,  ,             .

   ,    ,    .  ,      ,     ,   [26 - .    . 6.1. . 11.],      .     ,       .

     ,        . ,           .   ,           ,  .

              (.  9    ,  ).   ,  ,    ,      .  ,      ,         ,      .         .     .




 :   


 ,             .

      .        .   ,      ,    .     ,    ,      .  ,      , ,    [27 - .   / . .-. ..   . .: , 2013. 203E 204A.].

 ,      ,   ,    ,     ,       .

  ,    ,            ,    -,   .

   ,        (  )       ,          .  ,      -,      ,    .      ,      .

          .            , .     ,              ,     . (   -   [28 -  .  ,      / . .-. .. . 2- . .: , 1986. 6.54. . 230.].)          .         (  )    [29 - .: Sellars John. The Art of Living: The Stoics on the Nature and Function of Philosophy. L.: Bristol Classical Press, 2009. P. 5964.].

,    -   .       .         :      ,     .   ,    ,    .     ,                [30 -         .: Sellars John. The Art of Living, 5964; Sellars. Stoicism. L.: Routledge, 2014. P. 3641,  Brennan Tad. The Stoic Life: Emotion, Duties, and Fate. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005. Ch. 4.    .              ,         . .: Becker. A Modern Stoicism. 2nd ed. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2017. P. 132, 133  .].

 ,             ,    .           ,    .

    ,   ,    ,    .         ,      .   ,  -    ,     .   ,       ,        .  ,      : , ,    ,  ,     .         ,        ,  [31 - Introduction to Seneca. Letters on Ethics to Lucilius / trans. by Margaret Graver and A.A. Long. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2015. xx.].       ,      ,          .         (..1),     :     .






.1.      ,    



       ,   ,                   ,   .       -,    ,  ,    .

     -,   .    - , ,   .  ,     (pathe  )   ,   ,       . -   ,      ,       . (   -    ;       4  12.)

  , -    .         ,       . (             .)   -      ,       -.  ,     ,      [32 -   ,       . .: Brouwer Ren. The Stoic Sage: The Early Stoics on Wisdom, Sagehood and Socrates. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2014. P. 109, 164.].

     ,   ,      ?  ,    :    ,         .  ,  , :   -     ,   ,       [33 - Wilson Emily. The Greatest Empire. P. 146.].

     .  :     ,     [34 - .    . 57.3. . 96.].       ,     .          ,          :      -? ,    ,   .

         ,     :   ,    ,         . ( ,        ,    ,     .)

  ,    ,               .         : , , ,    ,      .     ,           , , , ,    .       ,        ,            .  ,         ,   , ,   .

 ,     ,      ,    ,   - ,          (   ),    ,    .   ,            .      ,       ,  .

       ,   ,prokopton,  ,  . -     ,           ,        .

      , , -,    (     ),  -,    .    ,             .  ,      [35 - .    . 71.36. . 133.].     .

  ,       :     ?       ,   ,     ,   ,   .     ,   ,        ,    ,      ,      .                ,           .




   


    ,     ,      .   ,               .

.   [36 -       ,       .  ..   .:   .  . 2- . .: , 2001.       . . .]. 17.3 [27]

   ,  ,  ,  ,   .   ,    ,    ,   ,     ,           .

      ,         ,    ,   ,      (  ) .

     ,    ,  .            ,    .     ,       ,   ,    ,     [37 -  ,       ,  , .: Sellars John. Marcus Aurelius. L.: Routledge, 2021. P. 2036.    .   ,         ,           ,    . Stephens. Marcus Aurelius. N. Y.: Continuum, 2012. P. 2.].     ,        .         ,        ,      .

    ,     ,          ,    ,   .      ,    ,  ,      .     ,  ,      ,     :      ,   .   ,     ,     : ,    ;    [38 -   .   / . . ..  //  . 2- . .: , 2001. . III. 36. . 174.].

          :

  ?

   ?

   ?

      ?



    ,  .         ,           . ,    ,    ,          ,  .




  


   -      ,         ,      ,       ,     .         ,    ,      ,   . ,         ,   .

          .       -  .     ,       ?      ,     ,     ,        ,     ,       ,  .

      ,     ,    ,        .          ,  ,            .

     - :   ,      ,  .       .          .       (    ),          ,     ,  .   ,    ,           .




 2.        



         .

.   . 15.5 [60]

     ,         .      ,    .        ,   .   ,          ,     .     ,   ,     ,         ,    .

 ,       ,      ,    .      ,             .

  ,      .   ,         .     -           . ,   ,        .

      ,            ,      .     :


 I



  !

  ,  !     ,    ,       ,   .    ,    :      ,  ,   [39 - .    . 1.1. . 5.].


 ,              .    ,     ,    .   :     ,    ,   ,   ,   ,     ? ,   ,  :  -   ,     ;       ,     ,   [40 - .    . 1.2.].

,       ;          ,   .  ,        .        ,      ,     . ,    ,     ,                .   :     ,         ,      :  ,     ,    [41 -   .   / . . ..  //  . 2- . .: , 2001. . III. . 2. . 251.].       ,  , ,     ,      .          ,             .   ,     ,         ,       .  ,            .    ,         ,   .       -       .




  


  ,            ,   ,   ,  . ,  ,      ,     ,    :    .

  ,   ,  ,                  .  ,       ,       . ,      ,     ,       ,        . ,       ,   ,    ,  ,   .

    ,  ,         ,     .       ,            , ,     ,    ,  ,     , [42 -   .    / . . ..  //  . 2- . .: , 2001. II.1  I.3. . 41.].

  ,       :     ,    . -   , -   .  ,          .      ,    .    ,    ,     ,   ,       ,        ,        [43 -   .    / . . ..  //  . 2- . .: , 2001. II.1, II.2.].         ,  ,       ,     .




 ,   


      ,   , ,      ,    -  .       ,   .   ,      ,      [44 - .    . 3.5. . 7.].            .

  ,      ,           [45 - .    . 106.1  22.8. . 267, 241.]. ,    .      .        .  ,        ,     .     ,      ;        ,        .

        :   ,    ,   , , .     ,   , - .    -  ,   :  ?   ?   :  ,  !  - , - !        ,             ,  ,  ,   .    :     ,   ,    : []   ,   [46 -   .   . 12.2, 12.3.    .  ..   .:    . . I. ( 50- .)   - : . 15.  III. Instrumenta studiorum: 6. .: , 2000. . 175200. http://ancientrome.ru/antlitr/t.htm?a=1448800900].

          , ,         .  ,      .  ,    ,  ,     ,  ,   ,     ,     .

 ,      ,       . ,    ,     ,       -  ,    ,      .    ,                 ,  ,    ,     .      :          ,           ?        ?

       ,         ,  -        ,    .         . -  ,    .     ,      ,       ,      ,   .        ,      ,  -  ,  ,    .      .    :



,          :      ,        .  , ,  ,      ?      ,   ?    ,             ,         ,        ?      ,   ?[47 - .   . 3.5. . 43.]


   ,      :     ,    ,  ,   ,  .  ,        ,    .

  ,         .        ,    .   ,         .

,         .      ,          ,    ,      .           ,  .     ,   ,   ,    ,   ,    .   ,    .  ,        ,    ,      .




 :    


      ,       .                .    ,     .

    ,     ,   ,   ,  .

         :   ,  !  ,    ,       ,   .     : ,  !     [48 -    . 1: 1 [5].]

               .  ,      :   ,  ,     !

           .    .     ,   ,   ,      .

,           ,       .  ,      ,        ,    .    ,          .          ,  ,     .       ,         :   ,     [49 - , .   .  ,     . 7.121, 7.122. . 282.].

 ,        ,    ,   -,    .    ,         .    ,               ,    ,   , , ,   [50 -       .   ..   Epictetus. How to Be Free: An Ancient Guide to the Stoic Life. Eds Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2018.     .: Edwards Catharine. Free Yourself! Slavery, Freedom, and the Self in Senecas Letters // Seneca and the Self / ed. by S. Bartsch and D. Wray. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009. P. 139159.].       ,        :      .

   :          ,         .   .        .

     : ,  , :   ,     .            ,  ,        ,    [51 - .    . 22.11. . 42.].

            ,  ,   ,   .   ,     ,        -.

  ,     ,     ,       , ,    . ( , ,     .)

       ,   ,         .   ,   ,     [52 - .  / . .-. .. . .:  , 1997. 2.1.22. . 95.].    ,   ,   ,  ,   [53 - .  / . .-. .. . .:  , 1997. 4.1.113. . 226.].                ,     .

                 . ,      ,   ,       ,     .    ,    ,      .




   


  ,     ,          ,   .   ,         ,         .          :    ;         [54 - .   . 9.1. . 50.].

   ,   .       ,        .     ,   .            ,     ,         .



   ,      ,  ;     .       :        ,     ,   [55 - .   . 14.1. . 58.].


 ,               .           ,      .          .           ,      ,    .      , ,       ,          [56 - .   . 14.1, 14.2.           .   Edwards Catharine. Absent Presence in Senecas Epistles: Philosophy and Friendship // The Cambridge Companion to Seneca / Eds. Shadi Bartsch and Allesandro Schiessaro. N. Y.: Cambridge University Press, 2015. P. 4153.].

  , ,       ,      .   ,         ,    ;         ;           ;   [57 - .   . 15.2. . 59.].      ,       :    ,    ,       [58 - .    . 62.2. . 106.].

       ,        ,      .      :



        ,   :      ;    ,  .  - :      ; - :   ; -  :    .             .

       ,    ,  ,  .   ,    ,     ,     [59 - .   . 15.516.1. . 59, 60.].


 ,        . ,      ,   ,   .         ,   ,        .       ,   ,          .

          ,       .

  ,          .         . , ,  , ,   , ,        .           ,    -   .         ,           .




 3.     



,  ,    ,  .

.    . 13.4 [23]

    .

               ,     .    ,         ,      .

    :  ,  ,          .             ,   .      ,          .

 ,   - ,     ,      ,    ,       .      ,   ,    ,  ,  ,     .         ,       .

,     : , ?

,     ,   ,      ? (     ,        .) ,      ,   ,    ? (  ,       .) ,          ,    ? , ?.. , ?..

         ,     .      ,     .    , ?        -  ,  .

      ,   ,               ,   .




  


          .          ,      .

    ,  ,        ( ,    ),        .      ,     ,     [60 - .    . 5.8. . 10.].

      ,             ,   ,   .     ,    ,    ,   .

     ,    :      (   ).           .   ,     .   ,     ,   .

  ,   ,   ,     ,    ,    ,       .      ,   .  ,         .        ,       .

     ,      :     ;    [61 -  .  / . . .. . .: , 1985. 4.7. . 18.].

     -:      ,       . ,       ,        ,      .       ,        .   : ,  ,     :     !           ,    .

     軠     ,      .        !    ,     .

,   ,      ,       ,     :  ,   .     ,    .     ,        ,        ,          .    ,      .       .

 ,     ,       .   ,       ,   ,     ,      ,  .     - ,     ,      , ,      . ,    ? ,           ? ,            ?

     ,  ,  .     ,           .     ,        ,    ,    . -       [62 - .    . 101.8. . 254.].        ,     , ,         .   ,          ,    .

    ,   ,    :         ,    - ,     ,    ,   .        .  ,      [63 -  . . . 12.26. C. 71.        .: Sellars. Marcus Aurelius. P. 12.].

 ,      ,     :  ,        ,         .  ,    .

 ,    .         .        ,   ,   .




  


        .     ,       ,   .   ,         , : ,      ,  ,        !      ![64 - .    . 89.1. . 197.]  , ,    -,    ,  ,    .   ,     ,    :  ,           , ,   ,         .

    ,    .       ,     .      ,    ,  - .  ,  ,   ,         ,     [65 - .    . 13.13. . 24.].

      ,     ,    ,  ,   ,  . (        ,  .)   ,       ,     - ,      ,      . ,    ,    ,     ,  .      ,            .  :   ,    [66 - .    . 78.13. . 155.].

     ,   .  ,       ,   .            ,     ,    ,   .    ,     ,   ,   :    ,     :    [67 - .    . 44.7. . 74.].




  


       ,     .         ,  ,       .

               ,   ,   ,    ,   -  . -     prosoche,  .   ,   ,        ,   ,    ,         .             ,      .

,   ,      ,        ,     .      :         ,  ,       ,          [68 - .    . 13.4. . 23.].        .         :    ,    ,   ,    ,      [69 -  . . . 7.8. . 36.].

-, ,  ,        ,      ,      :     ,    .     ,           .  ,       ,  ,    , ,     ,     [70 - .    . 13.8, 13.9. . 24.],      .                  .

 ,    -  (),   .     ,        :       ,       [71 - . . 5. . 58.].        .    ,     ABC,       (..2).     (),   , , .     ,    ().    (),   .

      ,    :  ,      ,     .    :    ,      ,  ,  ,   .  ,     ,   .  ,            ,      ,      .






.2.   ABC        ,        ,       



 20        .   ,       , ,       ,    .

 ,        ,           .         ,     ,        . ,    ,          .         .

 ,     - ,   ,       . ,          .          :        -[72 - .  Robertson Donald. The Stoic Influence on Modern Psychotherapy // The Routledge Handbook of the Stoic Tradition / ed. John Sellars. L.: Routledge, 2017. P. 375. ,    - ,    .    (2010), The Philosophy of Cognitive-Behavioural Therapy (CBT): Stoic Philosophy as Rational and Cognitive Psychotherapy. 2nd ed. L.: Routledge, 2020,     .     How to Think Like a Roman Emperor: The Stoic Philosophy of Marcus Aurelius. N. Y.: St. Martins Press, 2019,   ,        - .].  ,   ,    ,   ,  ,           . ,     ,    ,     . ,             .   ,     75  80        ,     .

   ,    ,     ,  ,    .   5  ,           .     - :   ,    [73 - .    . 5.7. . 10.].

 ,      ,        .  :     ,   .                  [74 - .    . 5.8.].

 ,   ,    ,      .      ,   . , ,  ,       ,     .    ,     -   .     - :



      ,       . ,     ,         . ,      ,     .    ,     ,     ,     ,   ,    [75 - . . 5. . 58.].


 ,        ,   ,               .  ,  ,          .  ,  ,    .                   .

  ,    ,    ,         ,       .          . ,      ,     .      ,    ,     .               .         ,   ,         . (    .)

     .   ,     ,       ,        .           ,        .




   


        .

.    . 5.9 [10]

  ,      ? ,      !

 . 32.4 [60]

    , ,          .

    ,    ,               ,  .   ,   ,    ,   .    :  ,  ,     ,        .     ,    ,       .    ,          .

        ,         :    ,   ,  ,   ,    [76 - .    . 92.18. . 215.].   ,     , ,   ,  ,         [77 - .    . 27.3. . 51.].

            .      ,    ,       ,  ?          ,      ,     ?

   ,   ,          .         .

,     ,        ,     ,        .      ,    -  ,     ,     .      ,         .




 4.  





 


    ,  ,   , .       .  ,     ,     -    .

    :       ,        ,     ,     .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/devid-fideler/zavtrak-s-senekoy-kak-uluchshit-kachestvo-zhizni-s-pomoschu/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


  .     / . . .. . .: , 1977. 104.26. . 265.




2


.    . 5.4. . 10.




3


Pigliucci Massimo. How to Be a Stoic: Using Ancient Philosophy to Live a Modern Life. N. Y.: Basic Books, 2017. P. 230. ( .   :      / . . .. . .:  -, 2018.)




4


.: Sellars John. The Art of Living: The Stoics on the Nature and Function of Philosophy. L.: Bristol Classical Press, 2009. Ch. 2. The Socratic Origins of the Art of Living.




5


  ,    , . .  https://www.stoicinsights.com/about-stoicism/




6


      : Nussbaum . The Therapy of Desire: Theory and Practice in Hellenistic Ethics. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1994. P. 13. (  / . .-. ..  // .   :  2. . II. , ,    . .; ., 1947. . 641.)




7


.    . 8.2. . 14.            .: Sellars John. The Art of Living. Ch. 2, 3.




8


.    . 76.16. . 147.




9


            ,    .




10


      ,        -,    ,    .  ,              .          ,           .




11


Wilson Emily. The Greatest Empire: A Life of Seneca. N. Y.: Oxford University Press, 2014.    : Romm James. Dying Every Day: Seneca at the Court of Nero. N. Y.: Knopf, 2014.       ,     ,     ,    .  ,       ,    ,   .   ,    (. 155 . 235)    ,     ,          .     (. 56 . 120),   ,  .




12


. .:  2. . I. .   / . . .. . .: , 1969. 15.62. . 307




13


      .           . (. . . 83.)   ,  ,        ,  :    ,     .




14


.    . 123.6. . 318.




15


.    . 122.14. . 317.




16


.    . 115.9. . 294.




17


   ,      , ,  ,   ,           . Inwood B. Reading Seneca: Stoic Philosophy at Rome. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 2005. P. 3.




18


.    . 48.2, 48.3. . 80.      ,        .  ,   ,       Motto Anna Lydia and Clark John R. Seneca on Friendship // Atena e Roma. 1993. 38. P. 9196.




19


.    . 106.12. . 269.




20


   ,    (   . 94.16),      ,   ,   ,    .    .             .       ,      -,    .              24.   - ,     ;      ,    .




21


.    . 40.1. . 68.




22


.    . 9.12. . 17.   ,   ,         ,    . (.     . 3.70.)




23


.: John M. Cooper. Aristotle on the Forms of Friendship // The Review of Metaphysics. 1977. 30. 4. P. 648.




24


.: Sherman Nancy. Aristotle on Friendship and the Shared Life // Philosophical and Phenomenological Research. 1987. 47. 4. P. 610.




25


.    . 6.1. . 11.




26


.    . 6.1. . 11.




27


.   / . .-. ..   . .: , 2013. 203E 204A.




28


 .  ,      / . .-. .. . 2- . .: , 1986. 6.54. . 230.




29


.: Sellars John. The Art of Living: The Stoics on the Nature and Function of Philosophy. L.: Bristol Classical Press, 2009. P. 5964.




30


        .: Sellars John. The Art of Living, 5964; Sellars. Stoicism. L.: Routledge, 2014. P. 3641,  Brennan Tad. The Stoic Life: Emotion, Duties, and Fate. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005. Ch. 4.    .              ,         . .: Becker. A Modern Stoicism. 2nd ed. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2017. P. 132, 133  .




31


Introduction to Seneca. Letters on Ethics to Lucilius / trans. by Margaret Graver and A.A. Long. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2015. xx.




32


  ,       . .: Brouwer Ren. The Stoic Sage: The Early Stoics on Wisdom, Sagehood and Socrates. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2014. P. 109, 164.




33


Wilson Emily. The Greatest Empire. P. 146.




34


.    . 57.3. . 96.




35


.    . 71.36. . 133.




36


      ,       .  ..   .:   .  . 2- . .: , 2001.       . . .




37


 ,       ,  , .: Sellars John. Marcus Aurelius. L.: Routledge, 2021. P. 2036.    .   ,         ,           ,    . Stephens. Marcus Aurelius. N. Y.: Continuum, 2012. P. 2.




38


  .   / . . ..  //  . 2- . .: , 2001. . III. 36. . 174.




39


.    . 1.1. . 5.




40


.    . 1.2.




41


  .   / . . ..  //  . 2- . .: , 2001. . III. . 2. . 251.




42


  .    / . . ..  //  . 2- . .: , 2001. II.1  I.3. . 41.




43


  .    / . . ..  //  . 2- . .: , 2001. II.1, II.2.




44


.    . 3.5. . 7.




45


.    . 106.1  22.8. . 267, 241.




46


  .   . 12.2, 12.3.    .  ..   .:    . . I. ( 50- .)   - : . 15.  III. Instrumenta studiorum: 6. .: , 2000. . 175200. http://ancientrome.ru/antlitr/t.htm?a=1448800900




47


.   . 3.5. . 43.




48


   . 1: 1 [5].




49


, .   .  ,     . 7.121, 7.122. . 282.




50


      .   ..   Epictetus. How to Be Free: An Ancient Guide to the Stoic Life. Eds Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2018.     .: Edwards Catharine. Free Yourself! Slavery, Freedom, and the Self in Senecas Letters // Seneca and the Self / ed. by S. Bartsch and D. Wray. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009. P. 139159.




51


.    . 22.11. . 42.




52


.  / . .-. .. . .:  , 1997. 2.1.22. . 95.




53


.  / . .-. .. . .:  , 1997. 4.1.113. . 226.




54


.   . 9.1. . 50.




55


.   . 14.1. . 58.




56


.   . 14.1, 14.2.           .   Edwards Catharine. Absent Presence in Senecas Epistles: Philosophy and Friendship // The Cambridge Companion to Seneca / Eds. Shadi Bartsch and Allesandro Schiessaro. N. Y.: Cambridge University Press, 2015. P. 4153.




57


.   . 15.2. . 59.




58


.    . 62.2. . 106.




59


.   . 15.516.1. . 59, 60.




60


.    . 5.8. . 10.




61


 .  / . . .. . .: , 1985. 4.7. . 18.




62


.    . 101.8. . 254.




63


 . . . 12.26. C. 71.        .: Sellars. Marcus Aurelius. P. 12.




64


.    . 89.1. . 197.




65


.    . 13.13. . 24.




66


.    . 78.13. . 155.




67


.    . 44.7. . 74.




68


.    . 13.4. . 23.




69


 . . . 7.8. . 36.




70


.    . 13.8, 13.9. . 24.




71


. . 5. . 58.




72


.  Robertson Donald. The Stoic Influence on Modern Psychotherapy // The Routledge Handbook of the Stoic Tradition / ed. John Sellars. L.: Routledge, 2017. P. 375. ,    - ,    .    (2010), The Philosophy of Cognitive-Behavioural Therapy (CBT): Stoic Philosophy as Rational and Cognitive Psychotherapy. 2nd ed. L.: Routledge, 2020,     .     How to Think Like a Roman Emperor: The Stoic Philosophy of Marcus Aurelius. N. Y.: St. Martins Press, 2019,   ,        - .




73


.    . 5.7. . 10.




74


.    . 5.8.




75


. . 5. . 58.




76


.    . 92.18. . 215.




77


.    . 27.3. . 51.


