 ! 6  ,       
 

 


Best Business Book Award
      :   ,   ,    .        ,          ?        ,    ,   -     ?           ,   ?

 ,     The New York Times  The Financial Times (U.K.),  6   ,     .      ,   -.          ,    ,        -,          ,   .

  PDF A4    .





 ,  

 !

6   ,       



MINE! HOW THE HIDDEN RULES

OF OWNERSHIP CONTROL OUR LIVES

 2021, Michael Heller and James Salzman

This edition published by arrangement with Levine Greenberg Rostan Literary Agency and Synopsis Literary Agency



 ..,    , 2023

 .   , 2023


* * *








   


 ,   




 , , ,

,   











    



!



       ,   .             .        [1 -    .  Melissa Dahl, Your Toddlers Possessive Phase, Explained, Parents, 4  2017.].    ,    -.   ,         . 廠     .

   ,     , .

   ,       ,    ,        . ,       , ,     .       .    .  ,       ,              , ,    .    ,          .

       .     ,       .  .  .     ,    ,    .       .




   Knee Defender


         [2 -    30,48. . .].   United Airlines           ,      ,      Knee Defender. Knee Defender       21,95  ,          . - ,  Knee Defender      ,      [3 - Knee Defender    Gadgetduck.com.].     ,   .

 Knee Defender  .  ,   ,   ,    ,      .   ,     .     .     ,  Knee Defender    .          .           .    ,    ,               .      ,              .

        [4 - Aimee Ortiz, Recline in Your Airplane Seat? A Debate Rages in the Skies and Online, New York Times, 15  2020.].   American Airlines            . ,  ,    ,       .    ,   ,     .         .

       ,          .  -      ,   :  ,    -  ,      [5 - Jayme Deerwester, Recline to one another: Ellen DeGeneres Defends Reclining Passenger in Punching Drama, USA Today, 19  2020.].   Delta Airlines      :  ,      -,  ,     [6 - Jessica Bursztynsky, Delta CEO Says He Doesnt Recline His Seat  but for Those Who Do, Its Proper to Ask First, CNBC.com, 14  2020.].   .

   ?

   :       .  ,     ,    .       ,     -,   ,       ,   [7 - Thomas Merrill, Accession and Original Owner-ship, Journal of Legal Analysis 1 (2009): 462510.].    -   ,    ,   ,   ,      .      ,    ,  :          .          ,    .

 -       .          ,    ,   ,   ,     ,           .     ,            .

              .             ,   .           .       .  ,   ,          .      ,      .  ,     ,   Knee Defender      .    :   .

             ,   .

       Knee Defender,   - :  ,     .          , ,  ,      ,        .   USA Today,   2020      ,   :    ,   ,    : ,     [8 - Nick Schwartz, Poll: Is It Acceptable to Recline Your Seat on an Airplane? USA Today, 13  2020.].    ,    .        ,  ,  ,   .   ,   .

     ?        .                   ,    ,     .      ,    ,       .    : 35 ,     ,   31    .       28 .

     :   ,    ,      ,   .   ,         ,       ,         .     :        .

 ,  Knee Defender ( -           ),   :      ,  ,     , ,    . ,         [9 - Katia Hetter, Knee Defender Speaks Out About Airline Legroom Fight, CNN, 5  2014.].

     ?

 .  2018          ,      . ,   ,   ,             ,  .         ,     .     :      ,      .          ,    .

    .       (   ,     ),         .      ,        ,       Delta .     ,           ,   .     ,               .          . (   ,           ,          [10 - Christopher Buccafusco and Christopher Jon Sprigman, Who Deserves Those 4 Inches of Airplane Seat Space? Slate, 23  2014.].)

  ,        ,      .    ,   ,     ,          . Knee Defender     .             .    ,       .  ,       -,   .

   Knee Defender    ,           :     ,    ,      ,        [11 -    ,     ,  Harold Demsetz, Towards a Theory of Property Rights, American Economic Review 57 (1967): 34759.].

          1800- ,      .   ,       ,    .  ,   ,     ,        .      ,     .     ,    ,       -.

  1874        ,    [12 -   .  Tim Harford, The Devils Rope: How Barbed Wire Changed America, 50 Ideas that Changed the World, BBC World Service, 17  2017.].   ,   ,   Knee Defender,     ,     :       .    :  ,  ,  .   ,  ,      .      1883 :  ,        ,  ,     ,        .      .

    [13 -   .  Richard Hornbeck, Barbed Wire: Property Rights and Agricultural Development, Quarterly Journal of Economics 125 (2010): 767810.].      .    ,           .       .         ໠       .           ,   ,         .

       ,                         .           , Knee Defender         .              .            ,     .

  - :     ,      Knee Defender  ,   ,       .

       -        ,    ,    .         :   ,   ,     . ,     ,           . Google   - (     )      .     ,          ,         .

          -.   ,      ,          Knee Defender.   -  ?   .         .    ,          ,       ,          .

            ,  -    Knee Defender     .    ,  ,       .




  -


     ,         : ,           HBO  . ,  :   ,      .       ,  , ,  .     :     ,      . ,      -,      [14 - Jenna Wortham, No TV? No Subscription? No Problem, New York Times, 6  2013.].

    - .    -          .        ,    The New York Times.            HBO     (-   )    .

  ,  ( )   ,                    ,       .          ,    HBO   .    ,         Forbes[15 - David Thier, How Many Are Watching Game of Thrones Without Subscribing to HBO, Forbes, 10  2013.  . Kashmir Hill, Even New York Times Is Oblivious to Fact That Sharing HBO Go Passwords to Watch Game of Thrones Breaks Law, Forbes, 10  2013.].     ,       ,  , ,  .

, ,        HBO.     -,   ,     .      (!)  ,        ?.       (?).   ,   ,     .      ?

-,      .       DVD       .  ,         ,  ,  ,  ,       .

,             .     . HBO   ,    .       ,   ,    Napster,         . HBO  ,  ,      .

       .     ,       . ,         .    -   - ,   .    ,       ,    ,  -     ,    ,   [16 - Hey, Thats My Idea!: Childrens Understanding of Idea Ownership, Psychology Today, 16  2013.]. ,           .  ,           ,     .

   .  ,   ,         ,        .       ,   DVD-,       ,     ,    .        .     ,       ,            [17 -     ,     ,        . Mark Lemley, Romantic Authorship and the Rhetoric of Property, Texas Law Review 75 (1997): 902.].  ,          .

             .        : ,   ,     ?      ,    ,  ,      ,    ?   .

       ?  Knee Defender   ,  ,   .  HBO         ,      ,    ,       ,   ,  .

       ,       [18 -       .  Kal Raustiala and Christopher Sprigman, The Knockoff Economy: How Imitation Sparks Innovation (New York: Oxford University Press, 2012).].     .    ,    . ,       ,  .     .   .          ,   ,            ,         ,       .  ,   :   ,   .         ,     ,  ,   .

          ,    . ,  ,      ,    .         ,              .      ,        ,      .

HBO   .  , ,     TechCrunch,    ,  ,      -[19 - Sarah Perez, Netflix CEO Says Account Sharing Is OK, TechCrunch, 11  2016.]. HBO    .     ,     .  HBO     (  ,   )  .           , HBO          .

  HBO                  [20 - Greg Kumparak, HBO Doesnt Care If You Share Your HBO Go Account For Now, TechCrunch, 20  2014.].   ,  ,           ,   ,   .  ,   ,  :   ,   ,  .   ,    ,  ,       .

    HBO           .   Netflix   :   ,   Netflix.   ,   [21 - Richard Nieva, Netflix Is Cool with You Sharing Your Account, CNET, 6  2016.].  Netflix          .

 HBO  Netflix    ,       ,   ,   .    ,       ,   ,         .  , ,      ,    ,      .

     .         :     ,            .




   


    -        HBO.      ,        ,       ,            .         ,                    .                ,         .

      ,    ,   .           .    :       .   ,       ,     .     ,   ,   ,      ,     ,        .

 !       :  ,     ,      .    ,   ,     ,   ,        -,   :



1.  ,    , .



  ,      ,   .  ,       ,    .    , ,  ,       :



    .

  .

 ,   .

    .

    .

  .

  ,             ,       ,        ,        ,    .

     , ,     ,        .   ,            .  ,         ,  ,  -  ,   .    ,       . ,    -     -  ,    :     ,       ,   ,       .

    -     ,    .          :  ,  ,   ,      .            ,      ,     .    ,    - .

             .              .        ?     ,    ?      ,    ?

     .               .           ,  - .

    ,     Kindle,     ,    .      .  Amazon  -. ,   ,    . ,  Amazon       .           ,   .  Amazon ,      ,     .    ,  ,   ,    . Amazon      [22 -   , 83  -  ,         ,    . . Aaron Perzanowski and Chris Jay Hoofnagle, What We Buy When We Buy Now, University of Pennsylvania Law Review 165 (2017): 31778.]    - ,  ,     ,          ,           .       .     Amazon   -   .

  ,    .          ,    ,  ,      .



2.    ,     .



       ,    .     ?  ,      -,            ,     .        ,    .

           .     ,      .    ,      ,     ,       - .  ,   :     ,       ,         ,     .

        ,       ,     .         .              ,       .       ,      ,       .

       ,     -         .     Knee Defender.        ,  ,     ,   ,   ,     .     :                [23 - Tim Wu, Why Airlines Want to Make You Suffer, The New Yorker, 26  2014.]. ,     , ,          .

   ,    ,    .

        .       , ,             ,     -      .   .     Knee Defender.            ?

      .    ,       ,    ,         .     .  ,  ,     .      ,        .     ,  ,  -     .



3. -        .



         .         ?    ,             .     ?           .              .

         .      ,              .     -,        ,  , ,    ,    ,   .    :          ,     ,   ,   ,   .








         .


    ,        ,     ,      .        , HBO          .

         ,        .     .     ,         .    ,      ,        ,        .




  !?  ?


             .       ,   [24 -  , 2016.],           :         .      ,  Nudge.  [25 - ,   , 2017.],       ,      ,   .      .   .     .         ,      .

           ,   ,    ,       ,   .         :



              ,   -  ?  ,    -           ,      ?

  Disney World      VIP- ( 3000  ),       ,   ?   ,        ,  ,     ?

      ,     ?           (      ),       ?

      ,    ?                    ,    ?



,    ,      .           ,       ,   . ,            ,      ,   ,       ,    ,    .




-


 ,    .

    1973      -.       -   ,   .      ,      ,      .      ,   ,          .           .    ,  . ,      ,    .       .   [26 -  , 74 Misc.2d 663 (1973).     ,      ,   . Lauren Vinopal, The Rise of the Dogvorce, GQ, 15  2020.].

,   .  -    ,     .     :  ,  .     ,     .   ( ) ,     :



 .

  ,    .

  ,     .

 .     ,    .

    ,      .

          .

    ,  ,   .

  .



,   ?  ,   ,            - .

     [27 -      . Adam M.Samaha, Randomization in Adjudication, William and Mary Law Review 51 (2009): 186.]. ,   ,       ,       .           ,    .        ,    ,      .

     .     ?    ,     . -,    ,   ,     .             .         ,         ,        .      ,      ,     ,         .          ,    .

     .     :            ,      .   ,   ,            .     ,          ? ,       ? ,              ,   ,   .  ,         ,     .

  ,    ?           ,           .    .     .  ,         .

   :     ,   ,     , .      ,     ,      .            .           , , .     ,   ,   ,   ,   ?

           ,   ,    .




 1

 ,  





  


    ,  ,   .          .               .      ,     .        ,     ,  .              ,       .

         ,   ,  ,       .   ,  ,            .      ,     .     ,  -      :            .

   ,      ,   .               .             ,  ,    ,   .   ?

      [28 -      . Adam Liptak, Supreme Court Spectator Line Acts as a Toll Booth, New York Times, 15  2013; Sarah Kliff, Paid Line-Standing: The Bizarre Congressional Practice that Shocked Ocasio-Cortez, Explained, Vox, 13  2019; Joe Pinsker, The Growing Market for Getting Paid to Wait in Line, The Atlantic, 25  2014.].   ,    ,  ,       ,     ,   ,   .       ,        ӻ,       ,    ,   ,      .  ,   Linestanding.com, Skip the Line  Washington Express,     6000    ,         ,   ,      .

              ,       ,    .        ,   ,       .        :    ,    .                    .

          .    ,     iPhone   Apple,     Supreme,            -,    Macys   .    ,   SOLD (Same Ole Line Dudes),    ,     ,      Shark Tank   -  .  ,  ,   SOLD,      ,    ,       .

      .             .         -     .    ,         ,       ,     .          ,               ,  StubHub.        ,    .       ,        ,    ?     ,        ,  ,  SOLD,    ,   .

    ,        .      TicketMaster,     - Verified Fun,   ,                    .         :      ,      10000     850 .

     ,          ?

       .                   2015       .  ,   , :    ,        [29 - Dahlia Lithwick and Mark Joseph Stern, Not All Must Rise, Slate, 27 , 2015.].   ,   , ,    :    ,     ,     ,   ,     ,      ,   .

      .      ,        .




 ?


               ,    :    ,    .  :  ,  .

     .     .       ,      ,   ,    ,  ,     ?            .  ,      ,    .       .

 ,   ,         .    ,      ,   ,    ,      ,     .

        .             ,        .         ,    ,    ?    ,   , , ,        .   ,    ,   .     ,        [30 - Henry Wheaton, Elements of International Law (Boston: Little, Brown, 1855), 220.].

           .   ,  ,  ,   .  :  ,  ?     :    [31 -    ̒ 21 U.S. 543, 589 (1823).   .  Stuart Banner, How the Indians Lost Their Land: Law and Power on the Frontier (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 2005).].             1823      ̒,           .   -   ,           , ,   ,     ,      ,        .

   ,        ,           1969 ?         ,        .    ,   1960-             ,   .  1967                ,            .

,       ,      . ,    ,  1969      ,   , ,       ,                     [32 - Anne Platoff, Where No Flag Has Gone Before: Political and Technical Aspects of Placing a Flag on the Moon, NASA,  1993.].

             .  2007       ,          .                 ,  ,     -     .    ,      ,    ,   ,    .      4,         ,     -       .

          .     ,      ,     .          1848   .  1889              ,        . (   ,  .)           ,                  [33 - Atossa Araxia Abrahamian, How the Asteroid-Mining Bubble Burst, MIT Technology Review, 26  2019.       . Mike Wall, Trump Signs Executive Order to Support Moon Mining, Tap Asteroid Resources, Space, 6  2020.].     Uber, Airbnb, YouTube    -,   ,  ,    .       , ,   ,    .

    .

    ,   ,   ,   .  1800-              160 ,   ,      , ,                 .     ,      ,         .   ,        ,     ,            [34 - William Cronon, Changes in the Land: Indians, Colonists, and the Ecology of New England (New York: Hill and Wang, 1983).].  ,            ,    .

,   ,   :     ,     .          ,  .         :   ,          ,   [35 -   -,   (-: Reynal & Hitchcock, 1943).].    ,     ,    ,     .          ,                   .

  1,3       ,   1805    [36 -    , 3 Cai. R. 175, 178, 181 (N.Y. 1805).],   -   .       ,   ,       ,    ,    .    ,     ,        ,        .    , ,     :   ,           . (:   ,    .     -     -?    .  .    .)

    ?  .     ,         ,  .    ?         :       [37 -        .  Carol Rose, Crystals and Mudin Property Law, Stanford Law Review 40 (1988): 577610.             ,   ,             . . Hanoch Dagan, Reconstructing American Legal Realism & Rethinking Private Law Theory (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012), 194.  . Lawrence Solum, Legal Theory Lexicon 026: Rules, Standards, Principles, Catalogs, and Discretion, Legal Theory Lexicon.      ,     .].      , ,  ,       .    ,               .      ,       55   ,        Ȼ.

       .   ,        .    ,   ,   ,      ,  .   ,           .     ,            .

   ,    ,  ,      .         ,  ,          .   ,      ,       .    :       ,         ,   ?

      ?    ?     . ,     .  ,    ,   ,      ,       .      -  ,      .           .    ,         , ,      ,  ,      .

         .          ,    ,   ,  ,      . ,  2011 ,         :   ,     ,   ,      .      ,           .  ,         ,         .

    .    ,    .          .               ,       4  7.

            .   ,     ,      -  .     -,     ,   .          .        ,        ,   .  ,  -    .   :    X,    Y, :   ,    Y,   Z?

        ,   ,    .  ,      , , ,        ,   ,     ,       :       .             ,        :   ,  .

 ,    軠             .  ?    ?

-,      ,      .      . ,     ,     .    ,  ,    .         ,       .     .








      .


       ,   .  , ,   :    ,     ,     ,      .              :         ,      .         .     .

     ,   ,    ,          :       .

   .

          .  ,         .  ,   SOLD, ,     .         .

   ,        :    ,  ,      . ,     ,        ,    ,   .

   ,         ,  .   ,                  .




 


         ,  :    ,      .       .

      :   ,   ,      ,   ,     ,  -          .        .        ,      .

            .            .        ,      ,     ,  ,    .  -         ,           ,    .

 ,   , ,   ,       .      ,  ,      .        .       ,            .        ,            .    ,        ,    ,        ,   ,    [38 - Ziv Carmon and Dan Ariely, Focusing on the Forgone: How Value Can Appear So Different to Buyers and Sellers, Journal of Consumer Research 27 (2000): 36070.].

  - .   ,          .        .          ,      ,        ,            ?

 ,       ,   .     .         ,    .   ,  :      ?

       .      .      ,         ,   ,    .   ,         , ,    ,   .               .      ,      .

,      ,   ,      .         ,  : ,   ,   .                    .           ,    ,        ,         (      ,           ).

      ,     .     -        .         ,    .        ,        ,   .    ,                 .         .

      ,         .     ,          8000 ,     Iron Dukes.   ,       ,   ,    .    .

       :    .                .    .                     ,      (,   ).  ,     ,              ,    . , ,   ,   ,      K-        .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/dzheyms-salzman/eto-moe-6-paradoksov-vladeniya-sobstvennostu-kotorye-mnogo/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


   .  Melissa Dahl, Your Toddlers Possessive Phase, Explained, Parents, 4  2017.




2


   30,48. . .




3


Knee Defender    Gadgetduck.com.




4


Aimee Ortiz, Recline in Your Airplane Seat? A Debate Rages in the Skies and Online, New York Times, 15  2020.




5


Jayme Deerwester, Recline to one another: Ellen DeGeneres Defends Reclining Passenger in Punching Drama, USA Today, 19  2020.




6


Jessica Bursztynsky, Delta CEO Says He Doesnt Recline His Seat  but for Those Who Do, Its Proper to Ask First, CNBC.com, 14  2020.




7


Thomas Merrill, Accession and Original Owner-ship, Journal of Legal Analysis 1 (2009): 462510.




8


Nick Schwartz, Poll: Is It Acceptable to Recline Your Seat on an Airplane? USA Today, 13  2020.




9


Katia Hetter, Knee Defender Speaks Out About Airline Legroom Fight, CNN, 5  2014.




10


Christopher Buccafusco and Christopher Jon Sprigman, Who Deserves Those 4 Inches of Airplane Seat Space? Slate, 23  2014.




11


   ,     ,  Harold Demsetz, Towards a Theory of Property Rights, American Economic Review 57 (1967): 34759.




12


  .  Tim Harford, The Devils Rope: How Barbed Wire Changed America, 50 Ideas that Changed the World, BBC World Service, 17  2017.




13


  .  Richard Hornbeck, Barbed Wire: Property Rights and Agricultural Development, Quarterly Journal of Economics 125 (2010): 767810.




14


Jenna Wortham, No TV? No Subscription? No Problem, New York Times, 6  2013.




15


David Thier, How Many Are Watching Game of Thrones Without Subscribing to HBO, Forbes, 10  2013.  . Kashmir Hill, Even New York Times Is Oblivious to Fact That Sharing HBO Go Passwords to Watch Game of Thrones Breaks Law, Forbes, 10  2013.




16


Hey, Thats My Idea!: Childrens Understanding of Idea Ownership, Psychology Today, 16  2013.




17


    ,     ,        . Mark Lemley, Romantic Authorship and the Rhetoric of Property, Texas Law Review 75 (1997): 902.




18


      .  Kal Raustiala and Christopher Sprigman, The Knockoff Economy: How Imitation Sparks Innovation (New York: Oxford University Press, 2012).




19


Sarah Perez, Netflix CEO Says Account Sharing Is OK, TechCrunch, 11  2016.




20


Greg Kumparak, HBO Doesnt Care If You Share Your HBO Go Account For Now, TechCrunch, 20  2014.




21


Richard Nieva, Netflix Is Cool with You Sharing Your Account, CNET, 6  2016.




22


  , 83  -  ,         ,    . . Aaron Perzanowski and Chris Jay Hoofnagle, What We Buy When We Buy Now, University of Pennsylvania Law Review 165 (2017): 31778.




23


Tim Wu, Why Airlines Want to Make You Suffer, The New Yorker, 26  2014.




24


 , 2016.




25


,   , 2017.




26


 , 74 Misc.2d 663 (1973).     ,      ,   . Lauren Vinopal, The Rise of the Dogvorce, GQ, 15  2020.




27


     . Adam M.Samaha, Randomization in Adjudication, William and Mary Law Review 51 (2009): 186.




28


     . Adam Liptak, Supreme Court Spectator Line Acts as a Toll Booth, New York Times, 15  2013; Sarah Kliff, Paid Line-Standing: The Bizarre Congressional Practice that Shocked Ocasio-Cortez, Explained, Vox, 13  2019; Joe Pinsker, The Growing Market for Getting Paid to Wait in Line, The Atlantic, 25  2014.




29


Dahlia Lithwick and Mark Joseph Stern, Not All Must Rise, Slate, 27 , 2015.




30


Henry Wheaton, Elements of International Law (Boston: Little, Brown, 1855), 220.




31


   ̒ 21 U.S. 543, 589 (1823).   .  Stuart Banner, How the Indians Lost Their Land: Law and Power on the Frontier (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 2005).




32


Anne Platoff, Where No Flag Has Gone Before: Political and Technical Aspects of Placing a Flag on the Moon, NASA,  1993.




33


Atossa Araxia Abrahamian, How the Asteroid-Mining Bubble Burst, MIT Technology Review, 26  2019.       . Mike Wall, Trump Signs Executive Order to Support Moon Mining, Tap Asteroid Resources, Space, 6  2020.




34


William Cronon, Changes in the Land: Indians, Colonists, and the Ecology of New England (New York: Hill and Wang, 1983).




35


  -,   (-: Reynal & Hitchcock, 1943).




36


   , 3 Cai. R. 175, 178, 181 (N.Y. 1805).




37


       .  Carol Rose, Crystals and Mudin Property Law, Stanford Law Review 40 (1988): 577610.             ,   ,             . . Hanoch Dagan, Reconstructing American Legal Realism & Rethinking Private Law Theory (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012), 194.  . Lawrence Solum, Legal Theory Lexicon 026: Rules, Standards, Principles, Catalogs, and Discretion, Legal Theory Lexicon.      ,     .




38


Ziv Carmon and Dan Ariely, Focusing on the Forgone: How Value Can Appear So Different to Buyers and Sellers, Journal of Consumer Research 27 (2000): 36070.


