  
- 


      -       ,       .    ,       ,       ,        .

    ,       ,   .

    .





- 

  



   



   Ha-Jon Chang c/o Mulcahy Conway Assocs Ltd.   Andrew Nurnberg



  .                          ,     ,       ,       .



 Ha-Joon Chang, 2014

    ,    , .  ,   , 2018


* * *


  







.     



   -   

       , ,      . ,     . ,   , ࠖ  .      ,  ,         .   , ,     :  , ,    ,       .   ,  ,          .

       ? , ,      .     23. ,      [1 -   . 23 . ,      ..: , 2014.]     ,  95  蠖     ,          .

   ,     ,     .   ,    ,   ,   ,  ,    ,      .  ,         ,     :     ,      .

                   .     ,         :  ,  ,     .     ,     ,        . - ,        ,        ?           ,     .  ,        ,      ,  ,  ,     .

       ,       ,     ,  ,   .   ,   蠖     ,     ,    ,           .                 .  ,              , :      .     .   ,       ,              ,      -  [2 -      The macroeconomist as scientist and engineer, Journal of Economic Perspectives, vol. 20, no. 4 (2006).].

 ,  ,          ,   ,     .      ,        ,                .  ,                   ,   ,     ,             [3 -            2013      ࠖ  ? (Robert Shiller Is economics a science?): http://www.theguardian.com/business/economics-blog/2013/nov/06/is-economics-a-science-robert-shiller (http://www.theguardian.com/business/economics-blog/2013/nov/06/is-economics-a-science-robert-shiller).].

        , ,        .  ,      -   .  ,     ,          -      .                  ,          ,         ( ,      - ).       ,      ,      , ,  ,       .


   

       ?

  頖     .    .         .          ,        .          , ,  :             (  )  .    ,      ,          .   ,        ,    ,      ,   , ,        [4 - ,    ,        .].  ,   ,  ,    .

          ,   ,     .     ,         . ,    ,  ,  ,     ,    .

             ,         .      .       .   ,         . ,        ,  頖           (,     ).        :    ;        ;          ;      .          ,  ,     .  , ,  ,   ,        ,      .

    [5 -         . . .]




 I.    


,          ,      .           ,  ,   ,     .

     ,       .   ,        ,        .

     ,  1 (#g1)  2 (#g2),    (#litres_trial_promo).    .

    ,        ,      .    ,          .

      ,    , ,   .   .    .         ,     ,    .




 I. 





 1. ,    :   



  

,   ,  ,      .   ,    ,   ,   , ,     .         ,  ࠖ   .   ,      ࠖ ,     (      -     [6 - .  ..: , 2002.],   2005        ).    ,  Financial Times       ,   ;       [7 - .   . .: BestBusinessBooks, 2009; .  ,      . .: BestBusinessBooks, 2011.].

     ,     .         ⠖                 [8 -      .].     :  ,     .  , ,         Economic Naturalist ( ):     .

      .   軠     .  , [9 - ., .. (http://litres.ru/pages/biblio_book/?art=431992) .: ,  , 2011.]    ࠖ ,       蠖       [10 -          :  -       . . .].      ,       .                .  -!  ( )  ,    [11 -  ,      ,           42.       .].

    ,  ,      ,    ,    ,    ,         ,   .     2008    ,              ,   .  ,      1995[12 -         .        , , , , ,       ,         XIX,         1968,             .], 2003 ,     [13 - R.Lucas, Macroeconomic priorities, American Economic Review, vol. 93, no.1 (2003).           .].  ,    2008    [14 - ,        (19082006),      ,        ,     .].  ,              .

     ,          ,          , ,       ?


       

  ,   .         ,      , , ,         ?  ,   ,              ,     .

          .         ,     ,  ,  堫      .

    - ,        ,    ,   .    ,      ,   1932           [15 -   (18981984)  . Ѡ1925- 1961     .        1959      .        (THESIS. 1993. .1.. 1023). . .].        ,              ,   .

         ,    .       ,    ,               .      : ,  ,    (    ,          1992),     ,      ,    .    The Economic Approach toHuman Behaviour (    ),  1976,       ,     .

        ,    ,        ,  .              ,      .       ,   ,   ,    ,    --.   (   ),     ,     ,      .  ,     , ,      ,    ,       ,      , ,      ,   ,      ,       Samsung Apple   ,        (      55).            ,        ( ,  ,   ),     ,              ,    .


         ?

   ,     ,  ,      .     ?



    ,    ?

       ,         蠖   , , , , ,   .     ,            蠖  .

, ,      ,          . ,   ,    ,   ,         ,   . 蠖  ,     -   ,         [16 -     Money: The Unauthorised Biography (London: The Bodley Head, 2013)     .].

  ,       (   ,        ,        ) ,   ,       ,   .   ,        ,           ,         .

蠖  ,     - ,   .      (  ) .



ࠖ     

    ,     ,  (    ).        .       .

      .           ,   ,          .      ,       , , ,     .     (  ),  -  ,    ,   ,    堖     ,  ,        ,         [17 -    ,     ,    ,   ,     ,   .]. ,             ,       -  , , .     .  ,  ,         ,      ,     .

                 (    ,        ,       ,  11 (#litres_trial_promo)).                  ,          .        XIX  XX   :    ,          .     ,          ,     .



    [18 -     ,   . . .]

 ,       ,       -.         ,      (, )   (,  ).   ,   ,     .   :   ,          , ,    .    ,   .

       . ,   ,   (,     ),  ,  .

           ,        .    , ,   젖  ,    .

       ,       (,  ) ,     : , , , .    ,  ,           .     ;      (,   ,   ⠖   )     (    ,                  ,     ).



      

       ,    .    ,       , , ,        .     ,      :  ,  , , ,     .      ,     , ,        [19 -        ,    ;            .].

,        :          ,            ,    /   ,            .



 ,     

      ,    :     , 蠖    .   ࠖ   ,     ,  1960-     ,      .

          ,   -  -   (,  )   (  ) ,       .   ,       ,      ,    ,         .  ,     ,        頖         ,         .

        컠    . ,  ,       . ,    ,  ,      .            ,    ,      .    ,         ,      ,   .


:      

  ,             ,      .      ,     , , ,  ,    ,  ,      ,       ,   ,  堫,     (   ),    .            .

     ,   ,        󻠖   .       ,     ,  .

        ,     ,       ,      ,  ,    .   ,             ,     ,         ,    .




 2.    PIN-:  1776-  2014 



  PIN-

       ? ? ?  ?  ?

. .

-,    ,      , ,            .

       ,   (  )[20 -    ,      ,    ;      4 (#litres_trial_promo).]     ,         [21 - .       ..: , 1993.] (17231790).

   ,  ,              ,         .   ,      . -,      ,      ,    (  ). -,        ,         (   ).  ,    ,         ,         ().

   ,   ,                   48    ( 4800   ).      , ,   ,     ,     .

           ,          . ,  ,     ,   ,       ,   - .

            ,         ,        .             .   ,  ,  XIX,     [22 -      ,       -        .     : ., .  ..: -, 2003. . .], 1832      .  ,           .    150     100,  800     ,   1980     [23 - Clifford Pratten, The manufacture of pins, Journal of Economic Literature, vol. 18 (March 1980),. 94.  ,             .     480   .].

        ,  ,    .      ,          ,  ,      堖 , , ,     ,   ,     , ,  PIN-[24 -   :   pin , PIN PIN-,  . . .].


 :       

 ,        ,       .   蠖  ,    ,     ,       ,     .

    ,     ,      ,       .          .        (  ,     ),     .

     ,  ?  ,        ,      (   ,         )      (      ,   ,      , ,  ).

     ,   ,       (        ),         .                  ,    :     ,  ,    .

   蠖 ,    .  ,    ,        (,  ,      ).          ,    [25 -          .].

     , ,    ,    ( ) 蠖  , ,         ,    .    ,       ,     .     ,   .   ,          ,       .  ,       ,             ,       .

                 .          ,   蠖     ,   ,           .



      

              ,     ,     .       ,      ,   ,     .

      頖    ,   .        .   ,     ,        .           .    300 300  Volkswagen,   ,      , , ,  ,       ࠫ   ,        .          .

          .      ()     (),    -   ,    ,    ,     .         ,  ,    ,      ,   ,       [26 -   ,     ,    (-   )    ,        .].      .  ,  ,    ,   ,    (  ,     ,     1991     ), ,        ,  ,   ,    .

 , ,    ,    ,    .  XVIII              ,    ,   , ,   (    ).    ,            .  Walmart, ,  2,1 ,  McDonalds,   [27 -   ,         ,    ,      .] ,   1,8.      , -   ,  ,    ,   ,     ,         .



  

        .         ,   ,     [28 -      ,   ,  40     .         50,    80 .].        ,            (,          )   .

      ,    ,    .     .     ,    ,  ,      [29 -    -  -   ,    , , ,   , , , , , , , ,  .             . . .],    ,   .       [30 -            . . .]     (  1833).             ,        (1862).       1888.

    ,   ,    ,   ,  - ,        .   .      ,      - .    ATour Through theWhole Island ofGreat Britain (    ),  1724,  ,   ,   ,  ,     ,   -           1700   ࠖ   ,     [31 - D. Defoe, A Tour Through the Whole Island of Great Britain (Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1978),. 86.].     ,    ,         , 1790.

        [32 -    ,      ,  -     ,        .       ,             . 30 90         ,         .].   ,             .      .     10⠖   (   ), 1525⠖  ,   堖  ,   [33 -     6080 ,   ,      ,        .       250     500 .].



 

            ,     ,      (, , , ),      (, , ,  ).      ,    ,     ,           .        ,      ,     (0,8  1800),           ,        ( McDonalds  120)[34 -                 .    1,1 .     ,             () , ,        .].

           .      () ,   ,     ()     ,      . , Boeing Airbus   90      .       ()      ().

       ,          ,  ,     . -   ,         ,     (      11 (#litres_trial_promo)).         ,  ,       ,    ,         ,   .      ,             (  ),     ,   ,   (, 1984      AT&T)      .

          .           ,     .  (   )           ,  ,  Walmart, Amazon, Tesco Carrefour,  堖   堖   ,    , ,       ,      .



 ( )  [35 -         H.-J. Chang, Kicking Away the Ladder: Development Strategy in Historical Perspective (London: Anthem Press, 2002), . 939,    .]

    ,       ,    ,    , , ,       .        (    )    .         .     ,      ,  [36 -        : http://www.bankofengland.co.uk/banknotes/Pages/about/history.aspx (http://www.bankofengland.co.uk/banknotes/Pages/about/history.aspx).].  1759        , 10 (    1793-,       ).   1853             .           ,         ,   ,   -.      ( ..) .

 ()    ,   ,   ,        ( ).   ,        ,    ,                ⠖ ,       ,  40    .    ,             ,      .  1717         [37 - ,   .  ,         .],         ,        1870-.               (       3 (#g3)).

    ,         ,    ,  .         .           1860- .  ,        ,    ,              XX.

 ,       () ,        . , ,       (   ,          ),        .  ,      -    ( ,      ).         ;          ,    .

      .   ,    ,    ,    (     ,    2009),     ,   ,  .    ( ,  )     .

       (   ,  ).       ,     ,          (, , )    ,  MBS (    ), CDO (  ) CDS (  ). ( ,  8 (#litres_trial_promo)  ,    .)        ,                 ,      . ,            .

   ,     :  ,    ,    ;       ,   ;         (,      ).    ,         堖         2008.


:      

    ,   ,           .        ,  ,   ,       . ,     -    ,     .      ,  , ,    ,         .       ,         ,            (    Apple Samsung)         .

      ,       .    ,        ,   ,   ,       .  ,          ,   ,   .        .




 3.    ?   


 : .     ,  ?

:    , ?   ?

 :   .

:   ?       .

 .  


    :    ?

  , ,     ,             2006   ,    ,    ,    .

    ,   ,    ,   .     ,       ,  ,      ,               ?                        ?

    . , 1980- ,           ,         .  ,    ,              [38 - ,   ,      :      ,         ,     .      . . .],   젖     ,       ,    .

         ( ,   )  ,                  .



   ,  ,     

   堖   ,    ,     ,   ,   (, , , ,   ,    )    .      ,         ,      ,   . , ,    ,  ,  ,          .    ,        (   ),       ,    .       .

 ,       ,   .    ,       堖 ,  (),  ,  ,     ,   ,      -   ,   ,    .   ,           1950- 1970- ,        ,         ,          .

      .      ,  ,          (   , ,  ),       -   . ,       ,  TheEconomist  Wall Street Journal,                .  ,   ,     ,             ,    ,        , 85    ,    (   ), 22      (      10).      蠖 , , ,  ,         .                 蠖      .

 ,   :     ,               .        (   )        ,     ,         1980- 1990-       ,        .   , ,   ,       ,      ,     ,    ,      .

        , ,    ,      ,    .  ,         .


  :    

     

    ,  ,     (    ,  ), XVIXVII.    ,  , ,   ,          ,     .     堖  ,       (    ),         .       .   ,      .

    ,       ,   .        ,                    .

 X XV ,     ,      0,12  [39 - A. Maddison, Contours of the World Economy, 1-2300 AD (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007),p.71, table2.2.             .]. ,  1500   82 ,  1000-.  ,  ,     11           2002- 2008.  ,            83     (        ࠖ        24).



 - ,      

  ,                ( ), ,  ,      (0,04).  ,  500       22.      ,      .


  (15001820 )

    

  XVI.      ,        .    1500- 1820             0,14ࠖ  ,    ,   (0,12).           XVIII,         [40 -        1700- 1760  1,4  ,    1770- 1801  7,7  .   1780- 1790    12,8  䠖           .      5      1770- 1801.     N. Crafts, British Economic Growth during the Industrial Revolution (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1995, p.23, table2.4.].   1500- 1820           0,27 0,28 .         ,      .     .



  ,   

           ,      .           [41 -  J. Hobson, The Eastern Origins of Western Civilization (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004)    ,               ,    .],  XVI XVII      . -     , , , ,       .         ,             ,       .         堖  .

XVIII     ,      ,   ,    [42 -         (1733.)     (1764.)   ,   (1709.)           (1730- 1740- .)   .].      ,         ,      XIX.             ,     ,  ,   䠖  ,    .        ,         ,       , ,     .

   ,      .           .   ,  ,      ,    ,     , , ,    .



  

  XV      .       ,               .

  ,      ,   XV       .   XVIII      ,  .          18101820- .       (   ),  (- )   (  ,   ).        (     1788).         ,       (   -, - )   (,  XVII).

    . ,  1858      (- ),   .      .            (  ),    (  ).        蠖  ,     ,    ,    .  ,        ,    , ,   .    ,      , 蠖    (  ),  ,    ,   .



   

      ,   XVIXVIII    :  ,    ,   ,    ,     ,   [43 -         P.Bairoch, Economics and World History: Myths and Paradoxes (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1993), Chapters. 58.].   ,        ,  ,         .   ,  ,   .         ,      蠖 .      ,   ,   ,  2006,          堖    ,      ,     1492 (   ,   18581872).

 ⠖   ,  12⠖          .      ,    (       ),           .                  . ,          ,    ,       ,     ,      .

           . , 1700      (     2),     ,          .        XIX   ,        .  ,          ,       .  1835  , - - ,   :     [44 - B. Hartmann andJ. Boyce, Needless Hunger (San Francisco: Institute for Food and Development Policy, 1982),p.12.].



  (18201870 )

  

      1820    ,         .      ,     1820    [45 -     ,       , 堖       .       17501850    頖 18201870 .].            1,       (           1990- ),       0,14,   1500- 1820,     .



  17 80-  :     

,              .  ,   蠖 , ,  ,    ,     ,     ,     .       . ,       ,    ,   : 7080     , -   100  ,         .

    .          - ,    .      ,     1520.   ,      .    .        17[46 - R. Heilbroner andW. Milberg, The Making of Economic Society, 13th edition (Boston: Pearson, 2012),.62.],  30          ,  1066 (    24).



  

 ,     , ,      .         . ,    ,     -   1810- ,            .    ,      .  ,  ,           ,   [47 -  . . .].

       (18181883),    ,        蠖       .     ,  , -     ,         .      ,  ,        ,    .  , ,         ,      ,  ,          .  ,  ,            :       ,   ,        .     .

    蠖         ,        ,   ,        ,  .       ,   ,  -,     , ,        ,    .     ,       ,      .

 ,  ,       ,   ,   ,       .   , ,    ,        ,     ,      .

  1870         .    .           ,          ,       60  .     36 1800- 41 1860-[48 - N. Carfts, Some dimensions of the quality of life during the British industrial revolution, Economic History Review, vol. 50, no. 4 (November 1997):  1 . 623   1820   3 . 628   1860 .].         ࠖ ,       1871      .



      :      

         XIX         .  ,              (  )        ( ).      ,      .   ,       ,         .

     .           ,        [49 -   Chang, Kicking Away the Ladder H.-J. Chang, Bad Samaritans: Rich Nations, Poor Policies and the Threat to the Developing World (Random House, London, 2007).].



   

 VII (14851509)             ,     ;    [50 -   ,                ,  : , , ,   . . .],  .   (  )         .         ,   ,      .        㠖   . ,       007 (,    )   (   ); ,   , , [51 -      . . .]




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/ha-dzhun-chang/kak-ustroena-ekonomika/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


  . 23 . ,      ..: , 2014.




2


     The macroeconomist as scientist and engineer, Journal of Economic Perspectives, vol. 20, no. 4 (2006).




3


           2013      ࠖ  ? (Robert Shiller Is economics a science?): http://www.theguardian.com/business/economics-blog/2013/nov/06/is-economics-a-science-robert-shiller (http://www.theguardian.com/business/economics-blog/2013/nov/06/is-economics-a-science-robert-shiller).




4


,    ,        .




5


        . . .




6


.  ..: , 2002.




7


.   . .: BestBusinessBooks, 2009; .  ,      . .: BestBusinessBooks, 2011.




8


     .




9


., .. (http://litres.ru/pages/biblio_book/?art=431992) .: ,  , 2011.




10


         :  -       . . .




11


 ,      ,           42.       .




12


        .        , , , , ,       ,         XIX,         1968,             .




13


R.Lucas, Macroeconomic priorities, American Economic Review, vol. 93, no.1 (2003).           .




14


,        (19082006),      ,        ,     .




15


  (18981984)  . Ѡ1925- 1961     .        1959      .        (THESIS. 1993. .1.. 1023). . .




16


    Money: The Unauthorised Biography (London: The Bodley Head, 2013)     .




17


   ,     ,    ,   ,     ,   .




18


    ,   . . .




19


       ,    ;            .




20


   ,      ,    ;      4 (#litres_trial_promo).




21


.       ..: , 1993.




22


     ,       -        .     : ., .  ..: -, 2003. . .




23


Clifford Pratten, The manufacture of pins, Journal of Economic Literature, vol. 18 (March 1980),. 94.  ,             .     480   .




24


  :   pin , PIN PIN-,  . . .




25


         .




26


  ,     ,    (-   )    ,        .




27


  ,         ,    ,      .




28


     ,   ,  40     .         50,    80 .




29


   -  -   ,    , , ,   , , , , , , , ,  .             . . .




30


           . . .




31


D. Defoe, A Tour Through the Whole Island of Great Britain (Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1978),. 86.




32


   ,      ,  -     ,        .       ,             . 30 90         ,         .




33


    6080 ,   ,      ,        .       250     500 .




34


                .    1,1 .     ,             () , ,        .




35


        H.-J. Chang, Kicking Away the Ladder: Development Strategy in Historical Perspective (London: Anthem Press, 2002), . 939,    .




36


       : http://www.bankofengland.co.uk/banknotes/Pages/about/history.aspx (http://www.bankofengland.co.uk/banknotes/Pages/about/history.aspx).




37


,   .  ,         .




38


,   ,      :      ,         ,     .      . . .




39


A. Maddison, Contours of the World Economy, 1-2300 AD (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007),p.71, table2.2.             .




40


       1700- 1760  1,4  ,    1770- 1801  7,7  .   1780- 1790    12,8  䠖           .      5      1770- 1801.     N. Crafts, British Economic Growth during the Industrial Revolution (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1995, p.23, table2.4.




41


 J. Hobson, The Eastern Origins of Western Civilization (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004)    ,               ,    .




42


        (1733.)     (1764.)   ,   (1709.)           (1730- 1740- .)   .




43


        P.Bairoch, Economics and World History: Myths and Paradoxes (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1993), Chapters. 58.




44


B. Hartmann andJ. Boyce, Needless Hunger (San Francisco: Institute for Food and Development Policy, 1982),p.12.




45


    ,       , 堖       .       17501850    頖 18201870 .




46


R. Heilbroner andW. Milberg, The Making of Economic Society, 13th edition (Boston: Pearson, 2012),.62.




47


 . . .




48


N. Carfts, Some dimensions of the quality of life during the British industrial revolution, Economic History Review, vol. 50, no. 4 (November 1997):  1 . 623   1820   3 . 628   1860 .




49


  Chang, Kicking Away the Ladder H.-J. Chang, Bad Samaritans: Rich Nations, Poor Policies and the Threat to the Developing World (Random House, London, 2007).




50


  ,                ,  : , , ,   . . .




51


     . . .


