 .   ,      
 


  (. 1951), ,           ,          .  ,   ,  ,          .   ,       ?

  ,        .     ,     ,  ,  ,  .       ,        ,             ,  .





 

 .   ,      



Michael Frame

Geometry of Grief

Reflections on Mathematics, Loss, and Life



The University of Chicago Press



             .



Licensed by The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, Illinois, U.S.A.

 2021 by Michael Frame. All rights reserved.

    , 2023







,   .


     ?

 , ?  , ?

.  . ,  ,    .    .      .

   , ,   .

 .   ,  . ,   ,    .

.   ,    ,    .

, .  ,   ?

     ?

  .

       ?

.

        1958.   ,    -,   ,       .         ,  ,    -,   .   ,     ,     .       . ,    ,     .   -,  -   ,       .   ,     .    ?       .

    .                    .    ,       ;        .      ,         .     :     ,      -     ,       .   , ,     ,    ,    ?     ,        . ,   ,   ,   ,      ,              ,    ,    . , , ,        ,   -  ,   ,    -     .       ,         .

     ,    , ,     ,   ,    (         ,   ),  ,   ,   .   ,       .        .      .    ,       .     (    ,         ),      .   :   ,     ,      .     ,      ?

         ,          ,      ,              .

     .       ,    ,    1960-.   , , ,          ,      .      ,       .     ,       ,     .       .   ,  ,       .  ,      .     ,         .    ,     ,     .   ,       .      ,  ,  ,   ,    .         .     :   .      .  ,    ,   ,     [1 - 1., ,      ,       .     ,     ,        ,     .  :   ;    ,      .][2 - 1*       ,    .],    .    ,   .

 .       .  ,    ,    .      .   .

,  .    ,   - .   .   - ,   - .      ,       .         .

,   .

, , .

    .   ,  .      -     .    ,   ,   ,    ,  ,     ,      .                 .     .      ,        .  ,  ,      ,       .

 ?   ,   ,    ?

,   ,      , ,  ,  .     ,     .

  ,   .     ,     (     ,   ,  )         .   .        .       ,   .         ,  ,      ,   ?   - ,    .

  .           ,   .    ,      .     ,  .  ,  .   ,     ,       ,  ,   .

 ?  .

          .   ,   .   ,   .        ,   ,    ,     .  ,    .    ,    ?     .   

  ,  , ,   .     ,      ,   .         .       .        ,       .    ,  ,     ,         .     :      ,           .    .

     .       , , ,      .        .        .  ,       ,      .      :               ,   ,        . ,     .

    :     ,          .          ,      .

           .            .    ,  - , , .  ,   ,       .         .    ,      ,       .

        , ,       .       ,           .      ,         .            ,        ?        ,       (    ),  ,             . ,     .   ,        ,     .    - .

          ?  ,      ,               .         .     ,    .      ,     ,          .    ,    ,     .

,   ,      ,      .  ,        ;  ,     .     -  ,       .    .

      [3 - 2*   (. 1960)  ,   .] :



     ,     ,     ?  ,   ?    ,       ?..       

   ,          ?  ,   ,   ,     ,  .    ?[4 - 2.             (Canin E. ADoubters Almanac. New York: Random House, 2016).         .       ,           ,      , , ,      .]


 ,    ,       ,     ,          .        (         ,                 ),     If it werent for bad luck, Id have no luck at all[5 - 3* :    ,   ]   Nessun dorma .     ,          .



         ,    ,      .       :       .       ,      , ,         .   ,      ,       .          ,      ,     -       [6 - 3.   (Archer J. The Nature of Grief. New York: Taylor & Francis, 1999)   (King B. How Animals Grieve. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2014)          .    ,  ;      .        ,  .            .         (Nesse R. An Evolutionary Framework for Understanding Grief / ed. D. Carr, R. Nesse, C. Wortman // Spousal Bereavement in Late Life. New York: Springer, 2005. P.195226)                 ,     (.: Nesse R., Williams G. Why We Get Sick: The New Science of Darwinian Medicine. New York: Random House, 1994).].        ,   ,   .     .

     ,      ,    ,     ?    ,    .             .           .      ,         .      ,       .


* * *

      , ,    ,  ,  ,             .      .   [7 - 4*   (18581936)  , ,      .]   ,      ,      ,         ,   ,          [8 - 4.     (ShandA. The Foundations of Character. London: Macmillan, 1914)     .].     , ,   ,     ,   ,     [9 - 5.          .].

     ,     .              ,        [10 - 6.  -                     .              :   . ,     .      ( ,  蠫  )      .    .].         .

 ,        ,    ,    My Skin       ⠫Beloved Wife.  ,     Dantes Prayer  .     5       .          ,               .         [11 - 7.  , ,        .        ,       ,    .    ,  ,    .             ,    .   :  , My Skin  Ophelia (Elektra, 1998) 蠫Beloved Wife  Tiger Lily (Elektra, 1995);  , Dantes Prayer  The Book of Secrets (Quinlan Road, 1997);  ,  5      (Elektra, 1993).      ,    .   . ,     ?].

        ,  , ,        .       :        .            .    ,             .        .

  .       .    ,  ,         :     ? -   :



   :    ,    .     ,   .   .    .   -   .  ,    .  , .  :     .


:     . :  , . :    .        .       [12 - 5*    (. 1955)     , .]    .   ,       ,    ,   [13 - 8.     ,   ( , 2000)   (       ,    , ,    ,       )     .].

  ,     ⻠           -. ,   ,      : ,    ,      .               .     ,    Breathe me  [14 - 9.  Breathe Me   Color the Small One (Astralwerks, 2006).].         ,      ,    ,     .       (    )     ⠫,          .

              ,    [15 - 10.     .        , ,                .      ,        .          ?          ,    . - .].     .          , .        ,     :



 ,   ,          .   ,    ;   ,     ,     ,        ,     


   . ,    ,      .   ,                 ,    .

        ,     ,        . ,   ,   .     -    .

  ,      ,      ,        .           ,      ,  ,       ,     .     ,            .

,      .   ,      .        ?   .      .        ?


* * *

       ,               .     ,    .

      . ,    [16 - 11.              (Lindemann E. Symptomatology and Management of Acute Grief // American Journal of Psychiatry. Vol. 101. 1944. P.141148. . .:  .    [1944] /  . . . , . .  // . .  . .: - . -, 1984).         ,    ,     .         .].   ,    ,            .  ,      .      : ,    .      .     , ,   ,      :   ,  , .        

    .       ,    ,    .  ,  ,              .      .

 ,     ,   .   ,   ,    ,      ,       :   ,      . ,   ,  .  ,   ,    .

        ,      ,         -     .      ,      ,   :



        ,    ,     (, ).

        ,    ,  .

       (, )   ;  ,      ,         .

        ,        , ,       ,       -   .

     ,     (   ).

    ,     ,       , , -    ,   ,    .        .



 ,  :           .      ,         ,    .    黠       ,  ,        .  ,      ,    .  ,             .      ,  ,     .

       , ,    ,  ,   .       ,    .           ,       .

          ,     ,    ,   . ,    ,  ,    ,     . , ,         ,      .




1.


,     ,    .


,    ,  ,     -  .   ,      ? ,       ,       ;  ,  ,  ;     .     .      ,   ,  ,   .

 ,    ,     , ,        .

        ,     .   ,   ,       (      ,  ,      ).         ,        .

      .    .      ⠫,    .

 IX,    XIII            .   ,  ,   ,     .








 ,         ,          (  ).             ,    .

   [17 - 6*   (19292018)    ,      .]  [18 - 7*   (19272016)  ,    .]   (      )         ,    [19 - 1.Gr?nbaum B., Shephard G. Tilings and Patterns. NewYork: Freeman, 1987.].     ,     . ,     ,    XIX,             ,       Ը     [20 - 2. ,      ,    : Ը . .    //   -  . .28. .:    , 1891. .345390.     ?   ,   ,       ( ,    ),  -       .].     ,         .













       .      ,    ,     ,      .   ,     ,      .      ,   ,    ,   ,      .    ,    ,         ,     ,      .         .

 ( ,     ) ,   ,        .   ,    ,   ,       ;        ;               ,            .  ,     .        .

           XIII     ,    ,    ,    [21 - 3.       ()   1104.  ,     ,     ,    .     (Guyon E., Stanley H. E. Fractal Forms. Haarlem: Elsevier, 1991)      . .  : https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File: Anagni_katedrala_04.JPG]. (  ,      ,     .    .    ,   ,     .     ,  ,     ,     .)








     . ?       ,      .

         (1940),      .     ,         ,        ,        .        ,   ,            .    ,   :         [22 - 4.         (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Face_of_War)   .97     (DescharnesR. Dal?. New York: Abrams, 1985),       .]




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/pages/biblio_book/?art=69549868)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


1., ,      ,       .     ,     ,        ,     .  :   ;    ,      .




2


1*       ,    .




3


2*   (. 1960)  ,   .




4


2.             (Canin E. ADoubters Almanac. New York: Random House, 2016).         .       ,           ,      , , ,      .




5


3* :    ,   




6


3.   (Archer J. The Nature of Grief. New York: Taylor & Francis, 1999)   (King B. How Animals Grieve. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2014)          .    ,  ;      .        ,  .            .         (Nesse R. An Evolutionary Framework for Understanding Grief / ed. D. Carr, R. Nesse, C. Wortman // Spousal Bereavement in Late Life. New York: Springer, 2005. P.195226)                 ,     (.: Nesse R., Williams G. Why We Get Sick: The New Science of Darwinian Medicine. New York: Random House, 1994).




7


4*   (18581936)  , ,      .




8


4.     (ShandA. The Foundations of Character. London: Macmillan, 1914)     .




9


5.          .




10


6.  -                     .              :   . ,     .      ( ,  蠫  )      .    .




11


7.  , ,        .        ,       ,    .    ,  ,    .             ,    .   :  , My Skin  Ophelia (Elektra, 1998) 蠫Beloved Wife  Tiger Lily (Elektra, 1995);  , Dantes Prayer  The Book of Secrets (Quinlan Road, 1997);  ,  5      (Elektra, 1993).      ,    .   . ,     ?




12


5*    (. 1955)     , .




13


8.     ,   ( , 2000)   (       ,    , ,    ,       )     .




14


9.  Breathe Me   Color the Small One (Astralwerks, 2006).




15


10.     .        , ,                .      ,        .          ?          ,    . - .




16


11.              (Lindemann E. Symptomatology and Management of Acute Grief // American Journal of Psychiatry. Vol. 101. 1944. P.141148. . .:  .    [1944] /  . . . , . .  // . .  . .: - . -, 1984).         ,    ,     .         .




17


6*   (19292018)    ,      .




18


7*   (19272016)  ,    .




19


1.Gr?nbaum B., Shephard G. Tilings and Patterns. NewYork: Freeman, 1987.




20


2. ,      ,    : Ը . .    //   -  . .28. .:    , 1891. .345390.     ?   ,   ,       ( ,    ),  -       .




21


3.       ()   1104.  ,     ,     ,    .     (Guyon E., Stanley H. E. Fractal Forms. Haarlem: Elsevier, 1991)      . .  : https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File: Anagni_katedrala_04.JPG




22


4.         (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Face_of_War)   .97     (DescharnesR. Dal?. New York: Abrams, 1985),       .


