  .     
 


        ,     .     ,  ,  ,       .       ?

   ,       ,  ,          ,      .     ,      ,           ,             .

  PDF A4   .





 

  .     



Elisabeth Schimpf?ssl

RICH RUSSIANS

From Oligarchs to Bourgeoisie



 Elisabeth Schimpf?ssl, 2018, 2022

  , , 2022

   , 2022




 2022



        2018         .     ,    2020.           :  2008;   2014-,    ;       .  ,          ,     ,       2000- ,     .

     -,        .       24 2022.   ,   ,     ,  ,        ,    ,    -       .       ,    ,                        ,                 .

       .        .   ,      ,    .

 ,       :  ,       .        ,         :       ,    ,        ,    .          .        .  .  .    .          ,      .    ,        .

 ,       .  The Sunday Times 22 2022                    퓻.       ,     ,       .        ,     .        .

              ,  .    ,  .  ,         ,      ,       .           ,           . ,        (      - :     ,       ),            .       .       ,   ,   .




 


      , ,  ,     .                    .     :      ,    ?  : ,  ,    ,    .  ,  

   ,   .        : ,       ?    ,     ?  :    : ,   ,             .   [   ],     ,  !

  ,   ,      ,      ,         . ,        ,      ,       ( ,     )   ,   . ,    ,          ,     ,            .  ,  ,      ,    :   ,  , , ,    .              .  ,     .  -   .         .




       


  ,   ,     .       ,      .     ,       .

   ,   ,    ,      .      ,   ,    ,   ,   .        .     ,    , ,           .   ,      .  1990-    ,           ,           .

      :      ,      , ,   ,         ,  -  ,    ?     ,      -  , , ,         ,     ?

       .      ,        .        ,      .  ,     ,        ,    ,         .        Forbes-200  -30,    ,      ,         (          ,     ).   ,               .

   ,               ,  ,       Luxoft IBS,  ,    .   IT-, 2019      , Luxoft,  DXC Technology 2 .            ,  -  2014       .

 Forbes    23 2022,           ,   -100     .      .    ,              ,       .     2020,       ,       .         2022,           .     ,    ,          ,       .              ,         .




   ?


     ,   ,      (,       2014).             [1 -  17  2015          . . .].   ,            (   , , ,   )    .    ,          Forbes.      Forbes 2022,   81,   2021-  117.  Forbes   2022    88.

     ,  ,    . ,   ,      ,       .   G7      ,  -    ,                 .    ,     .       ,     ,          , , ,  Forbes,    .

         .  ,      ,    .            ,       .                  ,    .




  


 ,   ,  ,    2022     .            ,    .  ,    ,     ,    .        ,    ,         ,      ,        .

    ,       ,            500 .   ,                       .              ,    ,        .             .       .       ,   ,     .

      :     ?   ,   :   ,    .         ,       ,   ,  ,   , , ,     , ,    .        ,       24. ,     ,     ,          ,    .

     :        ,  ,         .      (        )        .       . ʠ2021           ,      .       ,            .

   ,   ,              .     ,      1990- .              ,   ,           ,    .          ,       ,    2018  .   , ,       ,     .      ,    ,  , ,  ,  .




 


       ,      ,         ,    .            ,         .  ,             ,           .

      22 2022,  -          :      ( ),    ,       ,    .         , , ,       .

         .               ,    .

           ,      .  ,              ,     .       ,      .

        ,  ,  ,  . ,      ,                   .   - ,     .           , ,    PR-.                 .   ,     .        ,    2019       .       .

  The Times 12 2022,        ,     .     ꠫ .  ,                    .        ,      .  ,   :                .

                      ,      ,    .       .      ,                  .

      蠫    ,  ,        .        .      , , ,    ,    -      ,    .   ,     ,     - ,        .            - .

      ,           .       ,     .       ,       ,    :        .                 .        ,        ,      -  .



 
, 15 2022




 2018


                 .   ,     ,      ,    The Daily Telegraph.    ,     ,     -,            .      ,            .     :   ,     .   ,                Pimms.

       : , ,  .     ,     .             .        Leander Club        .     ,        ,        --.      ,   ,     . ,     ,     (    ), ,   -      .     , ,  ,   ,    ,  ,   .

   ,           .        .       .      ,  ,   -      ,         ,  ,    .        ,        ,       .       2000- ,                      .              ,  -        .

     ,             -  The Pierre,      .                  ,     .    !   .  , ,      ,      .   ,  !  !  .      ,      .  ,     ,       .          .  ,    ,   .

                     -- .    ,    ,  ,         Park Place Estate,    .      ,     180 .    -   ( 2021  800 [2 -      Forbes   2021 ,        2022-,                .   Bloomberg Billionaires Index,    2022- 25     60 . . .], [3 - 200    2021.  Forbes // Forbes Russia. 2021. 22. URL: https://www.forbes.ru/rating/426935-200-bogateyshih-biznesmenov-rossii-2021-reyting-forbes]).  2013     ,     .       (    ,           ,      2010).    [4 - OliphantR. Russian Court Seizes Britains Most Expensive Home // The Telegraph. 2016. 12. URL: www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/05/12/russian-court-seizes-britains-most-expensive-home/].  ,         ,     .            -  156 ,          36      [5 - .  :         // Tatler. 2015. 11. URL: www.tatler.ru/nashi_lyudi/interview_and_photo_set_21/352520_pole_chudes_v_gostyah_u_andreya_borodina_i_ego_zheni_v_londone.php#p=352531].     (       ) ,     .       ,   .

   .  ,   ,             .        ,       ,            .       .     ,   ,      (   ).             .      . ,  ,    -   .         ,    London Evening Standard.                   .              [6 - WalkerS. Russian Oligarch Sergei Polonsky: Everyone in Russia Has Gone Mad // The Guardian. 2013. 11. URL: www.theguardian.com/world/2013/nov/11/russian-oligarch-sergei-polonsky-arrested. 10     // . 2014. 13. URL: https://snob.ru/selected/entry/70381].  ,            .       ,      . ,     ?  .

        ,  ,              :  ,   -       ;   ,      ;     .   ,    ,  ,        .    , ,    ,       ,      .          ,  2015         The Sunday Times ( 2021    32 [7 - The Richest in 2021. Forbes Worlds billionaires list // Forbes. 2021. 6. URL: www.forbes.com/billionaires/]).

  1957  ,     ,  1978     .    ,     .         1990- .            ,    .           ,       Tate Modern (      ).   , ,       ,          .      ,        .      ?  .     , ,       .

    ,         .       :        [8 - BruckC. The Billionaires Playlist// The New Yorker. 2014. 20. URL: www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/01/20/the-billionaires-playlist],  2017           .   ,     ,      ,    :            .   ,       ,    - -    , ,        ,    ,       .        :    ,        ,      .

    .           ,    ,      .   ,           :       ,     .          ,  ,       :    ,         .

    ,       ;         ,    ,       .     , , -,            , -,                         .

                    ,    .       , ,   ,      ,           ,   .        :      ,           ,      .



,     ,    2005.              ,       ,      .  ,                     ,          .   ,        .

   ,      ,        .          ,      III.  ,          ,  .     ,   ,            .    ,        ,      .     ,      .       ,       -   .

     .    ,   7000   ,      ,     .                .

  ,   -   .                  .   ,      ,       ,  ,  ,  ,  ,      ,  ,  , - ,  ,  ,  ,  a,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,         .

    ,          :            ,          ,         .








          ,         .      ,         ,     ,         .         ,      :     ,     ?                ?        ,         ?

   ,     ,      , 2015  53-     Forbes (2018  -200      )[9 -        Forbes,    .     .].         2015     -     .    ,      .   -    ,  -         ,     .            ,     :    ,     .

  1958    .     ,   ;    .   -,          .        ,     -   ()     ,    .      ,   1990- ,    ,   ,  .      ,  XIX      , -      .  1994                    . Ѡ19962000          .      , 1990-            ,     ,  ,     .              .

        .   2000-                O1 Group,          .  2014      ,  2015    1,6 .         .     ,     ,     ,   .           .     .       , ,   ,   .

     ,   .  ,       ,    , 2017        .     ,   2018       .  2016         ,      .

              .        ,            .    ,         .   ,    ,     .       :      2001.        ,    ,   ,    ,    .      :      .                ,    .       ,       ,      ,        ,     .    20 [10 -  :    Forbes    // Forbes Russia. 2016. 30. URL: www.forbes.ru/forbeslife/321567-masshtab-vpechatlenii-boris-mints-rasskazal-forbes-o-svoem-muzee].

   ,  ,              .  ,         (   ),     -, , .     ,   .

       .  , ,  .             ,        .    ,    ,                ,      .




  


    1991,        ,        :      ,    ,       [11 - ScheidelW. The Great Leveler: Violence and the History of Inequality from the Stone Age to the Twenty-First Century. P., NJ: Princeton University Press, 2017.].      , ,    .   ,           ,    .    ,   [12 -  1990-     7 ,            . .: EberstadtN. Russias Peacetime Demographic Crisis: Dimensions, Causes, Implications. S.: National Bureau of Asian Research, 2010.     ,           ,  1930- . .:TherbornG. The Killing Fields of Inequality. C.: Polity Press, 2013.].    ,     1960-   ,  ,   1990-   57,           [13 -     ,   //  . 2015. 1. URL: http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.LE00.MA.IN?page=4].   ,          .

             ,     .   ,         [14 - FreelandC. Plutocrats: The Rise of the New Global Super-Rich. L.: Penguin, 2013.],            .          [15 - ,  1990-       ,      Generation ϓ (1999),     -   ,    .     (2005)               ,         ,     .   ,      (       ),     ,  1990-     ,        . .: .  //  . 2009. 29. URL: http://ruspioner.ru/cool/m/single/2007],     [16 -           ,  .        ,        ,       ,         1990- . .:..  , XXI: - . .:   -, 2012.].

 ,      ,       , ,          軠   ,        .     ,          ,   1991,          .   ,   ,        ,   ,  ,     ,     [17 - SzelnyiI., EyalG., TownsleyE. Making Capitalism Without Capitalists: Class Formation and Elite Struggles in Post-Communist Central Europe. L.: Verso, 1998.].

 1990-             ,    .       ,     (?????? , ; ???? ).  ,  ,       [18 - ?slundA. Comparative Oligarchy: Russia, Ukraine, and the United States, in Europe After Enlargement. C.: Cambridge University Press, 2007.].   , ,   :     ,  ,   ,     .  ,     ,       ,   ,     [19 - WintersJ. Oligarchy. C.: Cambridge University Press, 2011. . : MountF. The New Few, Or a Very BritishOligarchy. L.: Simon & Schuster, 2013.].   ,   -      1996.

    .   2000-   ,      ,         .           (2000)  ,  1990-     Financial Times,       , 蠫 (2001)  .     1990-,  ,   ,            [20 -   ,    2000,  2013- .              .     ,            2010,    -    . [    2019,      . . . ]   ,    , 2000  ,         .    ,      1998,    . .:HoffmanD. The Oligarchs: Wealth and Power in the New Russia. 3rd ed. NY: PublicAffairs, 2011.       .    ,      ,       (2003)        ,                . .:. . .: , 2005.         . .:MezrichB. Once Upon a Time in Russia: The Rise of the Oligarchs and the Greatest Wealth inHistory. L.: William Heinemann, 2015.].  ,      ,        ,  2003        [21 - FreelandC. Sale of the Century: TheInside Story of the Second RussianRevolution. L.: Little, Brown, 2000.].

       ,           [22 - HillF., GaddyC. Mr. Putin: Operative in the Kremlin. W., DC: Brookings Institution Press, 2013.],     [23 -                  .        ,     . DavishaK. Putins Kleptocracy: Who Owns Russia? NY: Simon & Schuster, 2014. . : BeltonC. Putins People: How the KGB Took Back Russia and Then Turned on the West. L.: HarperCollins Publishers Limited, 2020.     ,      ;       . ., : KryshtanovskaiaO., WhiteS. The Sovietization of Russian Politics // Post-Soviet Affairs 25. 2009. 4; RenzB. Putins Militocracy? An Alternative Interpretation of Siloviki in Contemporary Russian Politics // Europe-Asia Studies 58. 2006. 6; RiveraD., RiveraS. Is Russia a Militocracy? Conceptual Issues and Extant Findings Regarding Elite Militarization // Post-Soviet Affairs 30. 2014. 1.            -    :A.,  .  .    // SoldatovA., BoroganI. The New Nobility: The Restoration of Russias Security State and the Enduring Legacy of the KGB. NY: PublicAffairs, 2010.].         ,       . ,    ,   -  .  ,  ,  1990-    , , ,    ,  ,     ,  ,    [24 - TreismanD. Russias Billionaire // American Economic Review: Papers & Proceedings 106. 2016. 5; GurievS., RachinskyA. The Role of Oligarchs in Russian Capitalism // The Journal of Economic Perspectives 19. 2005. 1.].

       .        -     2000-     .  ,           ,   [25 -   less,  2006    ,   -    ,     ,      ,  ,    ,      . .:. yxless.    . .: , 2006.            .             ,  .      (2014)          ,        ,       .      (2011)  ,  ,   ,    ,    .   ,        ,    . ,                   ,   . .:Pomerantsev P.Nothing Is True and Everything Is Possible. NY: PublicAffairs, 2014.].            ,   ,                 ,       .            ,     ,     [26 - .,   .    . M.:  .  , 2016.].

    2000-          [27 -     35,6  2002 15,7  2013  24,611% . .: TikhonovaN., MareevaS. Poverty in Contemporary Russian Society: Formation of a New Periphery // Russian Politics 1. 2016. 2.  2018  ,       ,  18%. SlobodenyukE., MareevaS. Relative Poverty in Russia: Evidence from Different Thresholds // Social Indicators Research151, 2020.,    ,        ,          -     .       (Poverty in Contemporary Russian Society)     ,   ,          .  ,          ,              ,    ,             -        .].    ,     ,   ,     .  ,       ,         2008[28 -  :  2016 //  . 2017. 14. URL: http://databank.worldbank.org/data/reports.aspx?Code=SI.POV.GINI&id=af3ce82b&report_name=Popular_indicators&populartype=series&ispopular=y].            ,   , ,   .  2013  Credit Suisse           ,        -[29 -  2013    $11      ,         $170. 110  35%   . .:KeatingG., OSullivanM., ShorrocksA. . Global Wealth Report 2013. Z.: Credit Suisse AG, 2013.  2015    10%   87%       ,  ,    10%  76%   ,  ,     66%. .:StierliM., ShorrocksA., DaviesJ. . Global Wealth Report 2015. Z.: Credit Suisse AG, 2015.].    2014  Credit Suisse       ,          ,       [30 - ShorrocksA., DaviesJ., LluberasR. Global Wealth Report 2014. Z.: Credit Suisse AG, 2014.        ,   ,      ,   ,               . .:MilanovicB. Global Inequality: A New Approach for the Age of Globalization. C., MA: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2016.].

   2014         .           ?       ,      2000-[31 -       ,     ,  ,  .      2000- ,      ,          (); .:      2014// Human Development Reports. 2014. URL: https://hdr.undp.org/data-center       ,   .     16    36,2% 2014 62,9% 2015. .:TikhonovaN., MareevaS. Poverty in Contemporary Russian Society: Formation of a New Periphery // Russian Politics 1. 2016. 2.].    ,            2014.      1172013 882015,        . ʠ2017  ,      96,  2021  123 , 2022,   ,    ,   88[32 -       Forbes,   ,     -  .     Forbes Russia 2016,        , , ,            ,        .          ,        ,    .].

 ,              ,      ,         ;   ,            [33 - FreelandC. Plutocrats: The Rise of the New Global Super-Rich. L.: Penguin, 2013.].

        [34 - ., : TreismanD. Russias Billionaires // American Economic Review: Papers & Proceedings 106. 2016. 5; AdachiY. Building Big Business in Russia: The Impact of Informal Corporate Governance Practices. L.: Routledge, 2010; FortescueS. Russias Oil Barons and Metal Magnates: Oligarchs and the State in Transition. B.: Palgrave Macmillan, 2006.],      ,     ,                . ʠ2017       ,      ,       ,       ,   ,         .    ,   ,      ,   ,        [35 -      ,     2000- . .: .   . .: .. , 2004.      2015,       ,         .   ,  ,   ,     . .:    //      . 2015.].    ,     -     ,         2000-,      ,     [36 - MenzelB. Russian Discourse on Glamour, Kultura // Russian Cultural. 2008. 6; GosciloH., StrukovV. Celebrity and Glamour in Contemporary Russia: Shocking Chic. L.: Routledge, 2011; RatilainenS. Business for Pleasure: Elite Women in the Russian Popular Media // Rethinking Class in Russia. VT: Ashgate.].

       . -,                . -,      ,          [37 - ,      ,         , ,        . .:WhiteS. Politics and the Ruling Group in Putins Russia. NY: Palgrave Macmillan, 2002.]. -,            ,       ,      ,       [38 - ., : Rutland P.The Anatomy of the Russian Elite // The Palgrave Handbook on Political Elites. B.: Palgrave Macmillan, 2018; LaneD. Elites and Identities in Post-Soviet Space. L.: Routledge, 2012; UrbanM. Cultures of Power in Post-Communist Russia: An Analysis of Elite Political Discourse. NY: Cambridge University Press, 2010; ShlapentokhV. Wealth Versus Political Power // The Russian Case, Communist and Post-Communist Studies 37. 2004. 29; ShlapentokhV. Social Inequality in Post-Communist Russia: The Attitudes of the Political Elite and the Masses, 19911998 // Europe-Asia Studies 51. 1999. 7; SteenA., Gelman V. Elites and Democratic Development in Russia. L.: Routledge, 2003; MillerC. Putinomics: Power and Money in Resurgent Russia. CH: University of North Carolina Press, 2018.].  ,           ,     ,    ,   ,     .




  


          ,        , ,    .   ,           ,       ,         XIX [39 - VeblenT. The Theory of the Leisure Class. NY: Dover Publications, 1994(1899) // .   . .: , 1984.].       ,      ,    ,             .     ,     , ,   蠫 ,        ,     .

        ,     ,     .  ,     ,   ,        ,    [40 - .    //  . . . 3. .: ., 2008).].    ,   XX ,      ,         ,   [41 - .   //  . . . 2. .: , 1996].  ,               .   ,  ,  ,       ,     .         ,      .

      ,  ,    [42 - .   :   , .:   , 2017.].       ,   ,        .        ,     ,                .   ,      ,                .

        .              ,     ,  1956,       .         ,         .             : ,   . ,  ,         .   , ,              ,        [43 -   . . .:   , 1959.].    ,             (  ),          .

           .       ,              -         ,   1% ,    1990-        .         : ,         1970-   1980-  (.  6),         (.  5)    ,    ,         .

  19471973    ,     ,       [44 - .  :    (19141991). .:  , 2004.].                .     ,    ,   .   ,        ,     .     1960-      ,         : , ,    (  ,  ,      ).   ,               .    ,        .  ,   ,         . ,        , ,    ,        [45 - Bourdieu P.The Forms of Capital //Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education. NY: Greenwood Press, 1986..   //  . 2002. . 3. 5.. .    //  . 2005. . 3. 6.].

           ,      .   ,               ,    ,     [46 - LamontM. Money, Morals, and Manners: The Culture of the French and American Upper-Middle Class. C.: University of Chicago Press, 1992.      .:Pin?onM. Grand Fortunes: Dynasties of Wealth in France. NY: Algora Publishing, 1998.].  ,     -,      -,    -, ,             ,  ,            .

       ,     ,         ,     [47 -     ,      ,   ,  ,   ,   . .:KhanS. Privilege: The Making of an Adolescent Elite at St. Pauls School. P., NJ: Princeton University Press, 2011; KhanS. The Sociology of Elites // Annual Review of Sociology. 2012. 38.  : CousinB., KhanS., MearsA. Theoretical and methodological pathways for research on elites // Socio-Economic Review 16. 2018. 2.].      - ,    ,    ,        ,   ,    ,     .   ,     ,     ,   [48 - ShermanR. Conflicted Cultivation: Parenting, Privilege, and Moral Worth in Wealthy New York Families // American Journal of Cultural Sociology 5. 2016. 12; ShermanR. Uneasy Street: The Anxieties of Affluence. P., NJ: Princeton University Press, 2017.].      ,   ,    ,   ,  ;      ,        [49 - HartmannM. The Sociology of Elites, NY: Routledge, 2006; HartmannM. Die Globale Wirtschaftselite: Eine Legende. F./M.: Campus, 2016.]. -   ,            ,       ,   .   ,                ,        .           [50 - DalozJ. The Sociology of Elite Distinction: From Theoretical to Comparative Perspectives. B.: Palgrave Macmillan, 2009; DalozJ. Rethinking Social Distinction. B.: Palgrave Macmillan, 2013.].

 2010-      .  ,     ,    2008,  ,    , , ,   ,              .     XXI ,  2013-,     ,                   [51 - .  XXI . .: Ad Marginem, 2016; AtkinsonA. Inequality: What Can Be Done? C., MA: Harvard University Press, 2015; AtkinsonA., PikettyT. Top Incomes: A Global Perspective. O.: Oxford University Press, 2010; DorlingD. Inequality and the 1%. L.:Verso, 2014.].       ,          1%   [52 - SavageM. The Return of Inequality. Social Change and the Weight of the Past. C., MA: Harvard University Press, 2021.].

         [53 - SavageM. Pikettys Challenge for Sociology // British Journal of Sociology 65. 2014; SavageM. From the Problematic of the Proletariat to a Class Analysis of Wealth Elites // Sociological Review 63. 2015. 2; SavageM. Social Class in the 21st Century. L.: Pelican, 2015; SavageM., WilliamsK. Remembering Elites. O.: Wiley-Blackwell, 2008.]. -,    ,   1%      ,     .      . -,  ,          . ,           ,    . -,  ,              ,  - ,    .        ,        . -,                . ,          ,             ,      [54 -               ,       ,        ,         .            ,      , , ,  ,      ,      .  ,      -,           2000- ,    ,          2008.].

   ,      ,  ,         .   :  ,       1990- ,     ,          XX .      2000-            ,    ,        ,   .




 


  ,  ,       ,    ,    .      ,        (,      ,  -, -, -, -).      (       )      ,    ,     ,    .          .    ,       :  , ,  ,  .         ,     ,            .

,     ,              ,    1990- .               , ,    ,    .       , ,   ,     ,            ,     [55 -        ,       .          ,  - XIX .      ,        ,   :       ,    (  ,  )     .   , , ,    .          ,              . .:BeckertS. The Monied Metropolis: New York City and the Consolidation of the American Bourgeoisie, 18501896. C.: Cambridge University Press, 2001.].

 1840-   ,  , ,          [56 - MarxK., EngelsF. The German Ideology. Part One. NY: International Publishers, 1970.].     , ,  -    ,        - .      ,          .        XX   :            ,           ,    [57 - .   //  . 2002. . 3. 5.]




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/elizabet-shimpfessl/bezumno-bogatye-russkie-ot-oligarhov-k-novoy-burzhuazi/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


 17  2015          . . .




2


     Forbes   2021 ,        2022-,                .   Bloomberg Billionaires Index,    2022- 25     60 . . .




3


200    2021.  Forbes // Forbes Russia. 2021. 22. URL: https://www.forbes.ru/rating/426935-200-bogateyshih-biznesmenov-rossii-2021-reyting-forbes




4


OliphantR. Russian Court Seizes Britains Most Expensive Home // The Telegraph. 2016. 12. URL: www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/05/12/russian-court-seizes-britains-most-expensive-home/




5


.  :         // Tatler. 2015. 11. URL: www.tatler.ru/nashi_lyudi/interview_and_photo_set_21/352520_pole_chudes_v_gostyah_u_andreya_borodina_i_ego_zheni_v_londone.php#p=352531




6


WalkerS. Russian Oligarch Sergei Polonsky: Everyone in Russia Has Gone Mad // The Guardian. 2013. 11. URL: www.theguardian.com/world/2013/nov/11/russian-oligarch-sergei-polonsky-arrested

. 10     // . 2014. 13. URL: https://snob.ru/selected/entry/70381




7


The Richest in 2021. Forbes Worlds billionaires list // Forbes. 2021. 6. URL: www.forbes.com/billionaires/




8


BruckC. The Billionaires Playlist// The New Yorker. 2014. 20. URL: www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/01/20/the-billionaires-playlist




9


       Forbes,    .     .




10


 :    Forbes    // Forbes Russia. 2016. 30. URL: www.forbes.ru/forbeslife/321567-masshtab-vpechatlenii-boris-mints-rasskazal-forbes-o-svoem-muzee




11


ScheidelW. The Great Leveler: Violence and the History of Inequality from the Stone Age to the Twenty-First Century. P., NJ: Princeton University Press, 2017.




12


 1990-     7 ,            . .: EberstadtN. Russias Peacetime Demographic Crisis: Dimensions, Causes, Implications. S.: National Bureau of Asian Research, 2010.     ,           ,  1930- . .:TherbornG. The Killing Fields of Inequality. C.: Polity Press, 2013.




13


    ,   //  . 2015. 1. URL: http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.LE00.MA.IN?page=4




14


FreelandC. Plutocrats: The Rise of the New Global Super-Rich. L.: Penguin, 2013.




15


,  1990-       ,      Generation ϓ (1999),     -   ,    .     (2005)               ,         ,     .   ,      (       ),     ,  1990-     ,        . .: .  //  . 2009. 29. URL: http://ruspioner.ru/cool/m/single/2007




16


          ,  .        ,        ,       ,         1990- . .:..  , XXI: - . .:   -, 2012.




17


SzelnyiI., EyalG., TownsleyE. Making Capitalism Without Capitalists: Class Formation and Elite Struggles in Post-Communist Central Europe. L.: Verso, 1998.




18


?slundA. Comparative Oligarchy: Russia, Ukraine, and the United States, in Europe After Enlargement. C.: Cambridge University Press, 2007.




19


WintersJ. Oligarchy. C.: Cambridge University Press, 2011. . : MountF. The New Few, Or a Very BritishOligarchy. L.: Simon & Schuster, 2013.




20


  ,    2000,  2013- .              .     ,            2010,    -    . [    2019,      . . . ]   ,    , 2000  ,         .    ,      1998,    . .:HoffmanD. The Oligarchs: Wealth and Power in the New Russia. 3rd ed. NY: PublicAffairs, 2011.       .    ,      ,       (2003)        ,                . .:. . .: , 2005.         . .:MezrichB. Once Upon a Time in Russia: The Rise of the Oligarchs and the Greatest Wealth inHistory. L.: William Heinemann, 2015.




21


FreelandC. Sale of the Century: TheInside Story of the Second RussianRevolution. L.: Little, Brown, 2000.




22


HillF., GaddyC. Mr. Putin: Operative in the Kremlin. W., DC: Brookings Institution Press, 2013.




23


                 .        ,     . DavishaK. Putins Kleptocracy: Who Owns Russia? NY: Simon & Schuster, 2014. . : BeltonC. Putins People: How the KGB Took Back Russia and Then Turned on the West. L.: HarperCollins Publishers Limited, 2020.     ,      ;       . ., : KryshtanovskaiaO., WhiteS. The Sovietization of Russian Politics // Post-Soviet Affairs 25. 2009. 4; RenzB. Putins Militocracy? An Alternative Interpretation of Siloviki in Contemporary Russian Politics // Europe-Asia Studies 58. 2006. 6; RiveraD., RiveraS. Is Russia a Militocracy? Conceptual Issues and Extant Findings Regarding Elite Militarization // Post-Soviet Affairs 30. 2014. 1.            -    :A.,  .  .    // SoldatovA., BoroganI. The New Nobility: The Restoration of Russias Security State and the Enduring Legacy of the KGB. NY: PublicAffairs, 2010.




24


TreismanD. Russias Billionaire // American Economic Review: Papers & Proceedings 106. 2016. 5; GurievS., RachinskyA. The Role of Oligarchs in Russian Capitalism // The Journal of Economic Perspectives 19. 2005. 1.




25


  less,  2006    ,   -    ,     ,      ,  ,    ,      . .:. yxless.    . .: , 2006.            .             ,  .      (2014)          ,        ,       .      (2011)  ,  ,   ,    ,    .   ,        ,    . ,                   ,   . .:Pomerantsev P.Nothing Is True and Everything Is Possible. NY: PublicAffairs, 2014.




26


.,   .    . M.:  .  , 2016.




27


    35,6  2002 15,7  2013  24,611% . .: TikhonovaN., MareevaS. Poverty in Contemporary Russian Society: Formation of a New Periphery // Russian Politics 1. 2016. 2.  2018  ,       ,  18%. SlobodenyukE., MareevaS. Relative Poverty in Russia: Evidence from Different Thresholds // Social Indicators Research151, 2020.,    ,        ,          -     .       (Poverty in Contemporary Russian Society)     ,   ,          .  ,          ,              ,    ,             -        .




28


 :  2016 //  . 2017. 14. URL: http://databank.worldbank.org/data/reports.aspx?Code=SI.POV.GINI&id=af3ce82b&report_name=Popular_indicators&populartype=series&ispopular=y




29


 2013    $11      ,         $170. 110  35%   . .:KeatingG., OSullivanM., ShorrocksA. . Global Wealth Report 2013. Z.: Credit Suisse AG, 2013.  2015    10%   87%       ,  ,    10%  76%   ,  ,     66%. .:StierliM., ShorrocksA., DaviesJ. . Global Wealth Report 2015. Z.: Credit Suisse AG, 2015.




30


ShorrocksA., DaviesJ., LluberasR. Global Wealth Report 2014. Z.: Credit Suisse AG, 2014.        ,   ,      ,   ,               . .:MilanovicB. Global Inequality: A New Approach for the Age of Globalization. C., MA: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2016.




31


      ,     ,  ,  .      2000- ,      ,          (); .:      2014// Human Development Reports. 2014. URL: https://hdr.undp.org/data-center       ,   .     16    36,2% 2014 62,9% 2015. .:TikhonovaN., MareevaS. Poverty in Contemporary Russian Society: Formation of a New Periphery // Russian Politics 1. 2016. 2.




32


      Forbes,   ,     -  .     Forbes Russia 2016,        , , ,            ,        .          ,        ,    .




33


FreelandC. Plutocrats: The Rise of the New Global Super-Rich. L.: Penguin, 2013.




34


., : TreismanD. Russias Billionaires // American Economic Review: Papers & Proceedings 106. 2016. 5; AdachiY. Building Big Business in Russia: The Impact of Informal Corporate Governance Practices. L.: Routledge, 2010; FortescueS. Russias Oil Barons and Metal Magnates: Oligarchs and the State in Transition. B.: Palgrave Macmillan, 2006.




35


     ,     2000- . .: .   . .: .. , 2004.      2015,       ,         .   ,  ,   ,     . .:    //      . 2015.




36


MenzelB. Russian Discourse on Glamour, Kultura // Russian Cultural. 2008. 6; GosciloH., StrukovV. Celebrity and Glamour in Contemporary Russia: Shocking Chic. L.: Routledge, 2011; RatilainenS. Business for Pleasure: Elite Women in the Russian Popular Media // Rethinking Class in Russia. VT: Ashgate.




37


,      ,         , ,        . .:WhiteS. Politics and the Ruling Group in Putins Russia. NY: Palgrave Macmillan, 2002.




38


., : Rutland P.The Anatomy of the Russian Elite // The Palgrave Handbook on Political Elites. B.: Palgrave Macmillan, 2018; LaneD. Elites and Identities in Post-Soviet Space. L.: Routledge, 2012; UrbanM. Cultures of Power in Post-Communist Russia: An Analysis of Elite Political Discourse. NY: Cambridge University Press, 2010; ShlapentokhV. Wealth Versus Political Power // The Russian Case, Communist and Post-Communist Studies 37. 2004. 29; ShlapentokhV. Social Inequality in Post-Communist Russia: The Attitudes of the Political Elite and the Masses, 19911998 // Europe-Asia Studies 51. 1999. 7; SteenA., Gelman V. Elites and Democratic Development in Russia. L.: Routledge, 2003; MillerC. Putinomics: Power and Money in Resurgent Russia. CH: University of North Carolina Press, 2018.




39


VeblenT. The Theory of the Leisure Class. NY: Dover Publications, 1994(1899) // .   . .: , 1984.




40


.    //  . . . 3. .: ., 2008).




41


.   //  . . . 2. .: , 1996




42


.   :   , .:   , 2017.




43


  . . .:   , 1959.




44


.  :    (19141991). .:  , 2004.




45


Bourdieu P.The Forms of Capital //Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education. NY: Greenwood Press, 1986.

.   //  . 2002. . 3. 5.

. .    //  . 2005. . 3. 6.




46


LamontM. Money, Morals, and Manners: The Culture of the French and American Upper-Middle Class. C.: University of Chicago Press, 1992.      .:Pin?onM. Grand Fortunes: Dynasties of Wealth in France. NY: Algora Publishing, 1998.




47


    ,      ,   ,  ,   ,   . .:KhanS. Privilege: The Making of an Adolescent Elite at St. Pauls School. P., NJ: Princeton University Press, 2011; KhanS. The Sociology of Elites // Annual Review of Sociology. 2012. 38.  : CousinB., KhanS., MearsA. Theoretical and methodological pathways for research on elites // Socio-Economic Review 16. 2018. 2.




48


ShermanR. Conflicted Cultivation: Parenting, Privilege, and Moral Worth in Wealthy New York Families // American Journal of Cultural Sociology 5. 2016. 12; ShermanR. Uneasy Street: The Anxieties of Affluence. P., NJ: Princeton University Press, 2017.




49


HartmannM. The Sociology of Elites, NY: Routledge, 2006; HartmannM. Die Globale Wirtschaftselite: Eine Legende. F./M.: Campus, 2016.




50


DalozJ. The Sociology of Elite Distinction: From Theoretical to Comparative Perspectives. B.: Palgrave Macmillan, 2009; DalozJ. Rethinking Social Distinction. B.: Palgrave Macmillan, 2013.




51


.  XXI . .: Ad Marginem, 2016; AtkinsonA. Inequality: What Can Be Done? C., MA: Harvard University Press, 2015; AtkinsonA., PikettyT. Top Incomes: A Global Perspective. O.: Oxford University Press, 2010; DorlingD. Inequality and the 1%. L.:Verso, 2014.




52


SavageM. The Return of Inequality. Social Change and the Weight of the Past. C., MA: Harvard University Press, 2021.




53


SavageM. Pikettys Challenge for Sociology // British Journal of Sociology 65. 2014; SavageM. From the Problematic of the Proletariat to a Class Analysis of Wealth Elites // Sociological Review 63. 2015. 2; SavageM. Social Class in the 21st Century. L.: Pelican, 2015; SavageM., WilliamsK. Remembering Elites. O.: Wiley-Blackwell, 2008.




54


              ,       ,        ,         .            ,      , , ,  ,      ,      .  ,      -,           2000- ,    ,          2008.




55


       ,       .          ,  - XIX .      ,        ,   :       ,    (  ,  )     .   , , ,    .          ,              . .:BeckertS. The Monied Metropolis: New York City and the Consolidation of the American Bourgeoisie, 18501896. C.: Cambridge University Press, 2001.




56


MarxK., EngelsF. The German Ideology. Part One. NY: International Publishers, 1970.




57


.   //  . 2002. . 3. 5.


