 :        
 


            ,    .           ,    -.         ,    ,   .    蠖   ,   ,   ,    ,      .    -        ,     .

      :  - ,    ,  ,     . ,   ,        ;    ,      ,  . ,  ,   ,   .   ,    .      ,      堖  .





  ,        .  , ,    ,       .

Ӡ       ,   ,   .    .





 

 :      



  

   

  , . . 

 . 

  . 

  . 

 . , . 

  . 

- . 

  Olivia Knapp



  .         () .  , ,  ,  ,  ,       .  ,   ,    , ,        ,     ,  ,     .

,     , ,  ,      () ,      ,   .



Ward Farnsworth, 2021

  , , .   -, 2023


* * *













 ࠖ  .    .     ,           , ,    .  ,  ; , -        ,  ,      ,      - .      ,      ,  ,    .         ,     . ߠ   ,  ,    ,  ,       ,   .

  ,        ,   ,       .  ,   .  ,         .    :     ,          .   蠖  ,     ;     ,     .       ,   , ,   ,  ,  ,  ,   .

 ,     ࠖ    ,     .  ,   ,   ,  ,   ,  ,   ,  .   , ,  ,          .

         .   ,   젖     ;  , ,  ,     ;     ,    .  ,  堖   ,       .


* * *

   ,  .     .






1.  2500     ,    .  ,  ,    ,    .   .      .     , ,  ,  .   ,  ,      ,     ,  . Ӡ, ,   ,    . ,   , ,    ,  ,    ,       .      (蠫 ).

        .  ,      XX.,      ,  



      ,  .    ,      ,      .       [1 - Vlastos, TheParadox ofSocrates, .20.].


    ,   ,   .   ,       ,   .       ,        [2 - Robson, ed., Collected Works ofJohn Stuart Mill, vol.11, p.46.].

 , 䠖   ,  , ,      .  ,   ,      .      ;  ,         ,  ,  .      ,   , ,    ,   ?

 ,   . -,      .       .     ,   ,  ,     ;  ,         ,   .

-, ,  ,   ,  .    ,    .   ,   ,     ,        .     ,       ,   ,   ,  ,  ,    .

-,    -  ,    , ,   ,  .    , .     .          ,     .      ,  ;        .      ,  ,     蠖  ,  .

    ,          , , .     ,    .      ,    .   ,  ,      ,    . , ,      (   )  ,    .

      ,     .        ,   .






2. Π    ,    ,     .       .   ,    ,         . ߠ     .       ,     ,   ,   . ߠ         .      :    ,   ,         .        .   ,    ,    ,   ,  ,     ,  ,      .

  ,            ,   .     .    ,         . , , ,     ,   ,     ,    .        , ,  ,     .  ,     ,    .     ,       ,   ,     ,   .    ,       .






3.          (ThePracticing Stoic).         ,     . ,     ꠫ ,   ,      .      , ,    ,  ;         ,   . Ƞ ,   .    ,   ,     ,  , -   ,     .        ,       .       . Ƞ   ,    . ,   ,   :       ,    .

     堖   ,    ,      .       .     .






4.       ,        .     .      ,    ,  .     .     ,   .    ,        : ,      ,     ,    .   ; ,    .      .    ,   ,     . Ƞ   .        . ,    ,      ,  ,    .     ,   .    ;  ,  ,   ,    .        .              ,       .

    .     ,     , ,    ,    ,          .          ;        . ,  ,        .    .         ,    .

     ,  ,  ,  .     ,   ,    .  ,      ,   ,  ,   ,  ,   ,   ,    ,   .       ,  ,     .      , , , ,           (  )   .     ,  ,    .   ,     , , .

      ,   ,        .          ;          .        :  ,    ,     . ,     ,   ,      堖   : ,    ,        ,    .   ,   .

     ,     ,        .     :    ,      ,   .      .






5.     ,    ,        .     .

  1 2    .  1   ,  ( ) ,  ,     .  2       ,   .

 3 12 ,   .  3    ,   .  4       ,    .  5   ,   . 6 7 ,  񻠖   ,  ,     . 8  ,    ,  9    .  10      . 11  ,    ,    蠖 ,     . 12   頖 ,     ,  ,   .

 13  ,    .   14 16   ,     .  14      ,  ,   .  15 ,    ,    .  16    .

  17 18     ,  ,    . ,           ,   .          .






6.   .       ,   .      ,      . ߠ    ,        . ,    ,    :    .

     .      .          .      ,  XVI.   ,   (    ).       1  ;  ,    ,    a e.         . (      ,   .)

  . ,    , : , 221d.      ,     221d,   .    ,    d  221  ,        (    ).   :          .



.         ,  ,  ,  ,  ,   ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  , ,  ,  ,  -,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,    .  ,             .




1

 


   ,     ,    ?  ,     .  ,   ,         ,  .  ,   ,    ,       ,       ,    . ,             ,   ,      .

 ,      ,    ,  ,   .



.    470399. .. Π     .   ,       , ,   .   ,    ,    .     .     .  ,    -        [3 - . Π , 18.6.].    .  , -,  ,    . ,  ,    (, )    [4 - ., : , 143e,   :             ,       . .     12. (        .  . ..)].   ,      ,  [5 - . , .5.        .:Guthrie, History ofGreek Philosophy, vol.3, ch. 8. (. .:  . . .   : 6. .III: . . .:  , 2021. . ..)].

    ,          蠖  ,    [6 -  . . .   . .III; Annas, Classical Greek Philosophy, p.281283.].   ,      ;     ,       (  ).  70-          .   ,  ,  500    30,   (20000  ,   ).    ,   .     .



.    427347. ..  80.    ,     .   ,    ,    ,  ; ,   -    .      젖   -   .

  ,   ,  , , ,   ,   ,   .   ,   ,         .           .    ,    12.      렖         :   , 36    , 14 [7 - Guthrie, History ofGreek Philosophy, vol.5, . 401.       : Ӡ    ,     (Kahn, Plato andthe Socratic Dialogue, p.48).  , , ,       ,                  - ,  ,        (Annas, Classical Greek Philosophy, p.285).].       .   ,        ,      .            :



     . Π      .    ;       .   -   ?         .       .  ,  ,  ?  .     .      ,       [8 - Emerson, Representative Men, p.48. (. .:  . .  . .: , .: ACT, 2001. .231. . ..)].


,      . (     .)   ,    30.      , ,   -,   ,     . ,  ,   ,    30.   ,  ⠫      .   ,       , ,  ,    [9 - ., :  . . .   . .IV: .  :  . .:  , 2023. .3539. Vlastos, Socrates, Ironist andMoral Philosopher, . 128130.].   ,          .

,   ,  , , , ,  ,   60   ,      (      ).     . Ӡ      ,  ,           .      ,   ,       (   )   .



, ,      ,   : ,  ,  : Π .     ?  ,  , -   .         ,        [10 -  . Π,    , 3.35.].


   ,    [11 -     -,   . .:Kahn, Plato andthe Socratic Dialogue, .6.].



 (.431354. ..)   ,       .    ,    .        .  ࠖ     ,  .  :



 ,  ,  ,    ,       : ,  ,  ,    .   , ,  -,   , ,       ,          ,      . ,     ,      [12 - .  . .III, .9.].


    ,    .     堖 ,   . ,      ,    .    ,   ,  [13 - Kahn, Plato andthe Socratic Dialogue, . 7579, 393401.].  ,      ,  .



 (.446386. ..)  ,    ,      (     ).       ,      ,  25  . ,     ,     ,    .     砫    .       ,    .  ,        (   )[14 -    .:Woodruff, Socrates Among theSophists;  . . .   . .III.];  ,        [15 - Nussbaum, Aristotle andSocrates.]. ,   ,     ,  ,    ,   ,   ,  .    ,      [16 -      .:Dover, Socrates inthe Clouds; Lacey, Our Knowledge ofSocrates; Nussbaum, Aristotle andSocrates.].

       (384322. ..).     15   .       ,   ,       ,   .  ,   ,    ,       .         ,     . ʠ,  ,    ,  ,       [17 - Kahn, Plato andthe Socratic Dialogue, . 8587; Nehamas, Voices ofSilence, .170.].     ,        [18 - Kahn, Plato andthe Socratic Dialogue, . 7986.]. ,         [19 - Lacey, Our Knowledge ofSocrates.].

   ,  ,   ,  ,  ,      .      [20 -    ,    (Nails, Agora, Academy, andthe Conduct ofPhilosophy, p.831)        . .: Waterfield, Quest forthe Historical Socrates; Dorion, Rise andFall ofthe Socratic Problem; Brickhouse andSmith, Socratic Moral Psychology; Nehamas, Voices ofSilence, p.160165.]:






1.  . ,     ,      . ,     蠖   .  (  )       .    ,        ;    ,   - .     , - . ,     ,     ,  . ,    ,    .

Ӡ   [21 -      ࠖ . .:Burnet, Greek Philosophy; Taylor, Socrates, 162. (. :  . :   . .: , 2010. . .)].  ,         ,  [22 - Ross, Plato's Theory ofIdeas; Popper, Open Society andItsEnemies, note 56. (. .:  .    : 2. .:  , 1992. . .)].  , ,      ,    ⠫ 蠫.  ,  [23 - . theory offorms  .        . . ..]   ,      .      ,        ,   .






2.   .    -: ,   ,    ࠖ ,  , .       - ,    . ,       ,          .   ,   ,      ,   . ,  ,   ,   .    , ,    ,    ,    .    ;   ,  .

    .   ,        .   ,    ;   ,     ,    .  ,        ࠖ ,     .  ,          . ,  ,       .        ,   .   , ,    ,     ,   ,    . Ѡ          :  ,  ,   .






3.  ,  .          .  ,    ,      [24 -      .:Graham, Socrates andPlato; Vlastos, Socrates, Ironist andMoral Philosopher, ch.2.].  ,    ,     ,  ,     ,   ,    [25 - ., ,  ( . . .   . .IV. .106):          . .  : Vlastos, Socrates, Ironist andMoral Philosopher, . 50,117.].    ,     ,   ,     .

     . ,      (, ,    , ,   ).   ,  , ,       ,  ,   , , [26 -     :  ,   ,     ,  ࠖ ;     ,      (Vlastos, Paradox ofSocrates, . 23). C. ,  :     .    ,    ,     (Burnet, Greek Philosophy, p.149).].  ,  , ,   .  ,    .    ,      -   .     :



   ,  ,   ,      , , ,   . ߠ,         , ,  .     ,  ,    -      ,  ,  ,    [27 - Russel, History ofWestern Philosophy, p.82. (. .:  .           . 7- . .:  , 2009. .115. ..)].


     ,     [28 - Howland, Xenophon's Philosophic Odyssey; Vlastos, Socrates, Ironist andMoral Philosopher, p.99100; Morrison, OnProfessor Vlastos's Xenophon.].        -     ,      ,   [29 - Cooper, Reason andEmotion: Essays inAncient Moral Philosophy andEthical Theory. .   :   -   ,     ,  ,           (Morrison, OnProfessor Vlastos's Xenophon, p.19).]. , ,  ,    ,  ;        . ,     .     ,     ,    ,      .       , -  .

   , ,      , ,     . Ƞ     ,       :    [30 -   Π    :  ,    ,   ,   , ,  ,  .            ,  ,  ,   (Morrison, OnProfessor Vlastos's Xenophon, p.18).].     ,   ,   ,    [31 -  .   . .116.].



 .      ,   .   , ,    ,    :       ,     .   ,       ,     .     .       ,     .    ,  ,    .     ""          [32 - Vlastos, Paradox ofSocrates, p.4.].  , ,  .    .     㠖    .  ,        ,        ,     .

      ,   . ,     ,    .            . Ƞ  , .    ,       [33 - Waterfield, Xenophon onSocrates' Trial andDeath; Shorey, What Plato Said, p.33. .: Grote, Plato andthe Other Companions ofSorates, vol.1, p.281; Brickhouse andSmith, Socrates onTrial, p.210.].  404. ..  ,     ⠖  ,  . ,   ,   :    ,  .        [34 -   (21)     ;  ,   ,      .].         ;       .    ,   .     .    ,     -    ,       ,      ࠫ[35 - Waterfield, Xenophon onSocrates' Trial andDeath, p.282283.].     ,   : -, ,    ,    ,  ,  [36 - .  , 1.173.].

,    ,  ,      .      ,     [37 - Irwin, Review: Socrates andAthenian Democracy.].       ,       . ,      ,    ; ,    ,        .       ,  ,    ,      .



.   ,     ,          ,   .          .        ?

    .        ;       132  [38 - Thesleff, Studies inPlatonic Chronology.].         ,  ,       .    ,  ( )                ,  .  ,    頖 ,   , ,       .            .         .  , ,   .     ,    .

   ,     ࠫ 蠫       [39 -  ,    , .:Annas, What Are Plato's "Middle" Dialogues inthe Middle Of?; Kahn, Plato andthe Socratic Dialogue.].      ,    : ,  ,  , , , , , , , ,  蠫.       , , ,   ,    , , , .      ,        ,    ,  ꠫,  . ,        .  ,       ,          .



  .        ,   .   ,    :  ,    ,     ,  [40 -      ,  ,   XIX.   .    .       : Kahn, Plato andthe Socratic Dialogue, p.3840; Friedlander, Plato, p.162; Shorey, Unity ofPlato's Thought. .    : Sprague, Platonic Unitarianism, orWhat Shorey Said.].    ,   ,    .     ,      ࠖ  ,    ,  ,     . ,   ,  ,      ,        [41 - .   :       ,      (Shorey, Unity ofPlato's Thought, p.88).].        ;  ,            .    ( )   ,       ,       .



 .       ,      . -,       ,  ,  ,    . -, 蠫   ,   ,   ;       - 蠫  -.  , ,   ,    ,  ,        ,   ⠫ .   - .   ,      ,  ,    ,     .

    ,   ,     .  ,          ,  , -, .   ,      ,     .     .      ,       .     ( ),      .




2

  


          ,   .         ,        .      .         ,   .



 .    -  .  ,   ,   ,       . ,        . ,       ,         [42 - Whitehead, Process andReality, 2.1.1.].        .   ,       -  ,    .     -, , ,  ,     -.      .         ,       .       :



  ,      ,   ,   ,  ,        , .    ,      .      ,         .   ,         [43 -    , 5 1814. .: Ford, Writings ofThomas Jefferson, vol.9, p.463. (. .:  .  : 2. .2. .: , 1969. .102. ..)].


        ,   .    . ߠ  ,       ,   . (,    ,    ,    [44 -       31 1819.   : ߠ    (       )      ""   , ,       . .:  . .2. .127128.].)

,  ,       . Ӡ    , ,   ,  ,    (, ,     :   ,  帻[45 - , 38a;          (Kraut, Examined Life, p.230231). (   . .  ,    ,  :      ,    ,  , ,     ,      . ..)]).  ,      .       .   ,  , , .        :    ,    ,   .



  .      ,   ,     XIX.    .  Π廠   ,      . (2         .)  Π     :        ,            .       ,  .    33 . ( ,     .)

      ,         .    (   ,   ?),    ; ,       . ,  ,  , ,  ,   .      .   :      .  20        ,    .   ,    ,    . ,            蠫         c  [46 - Mill, Early Draft ofJohn Stuart Mill's Autobiography, p.24.].  ,  



    ;     ,   ,  ,     , , ,  , ,  [47 - .].


  ,   .

 ,       . -,  , ,  ,  .       -  ,   ,    ,     .       ,  ,   .  ,        :



 ,   ,       ⠖  ,       ,      . :         ,      [48 - Robson, Collected Works ofJohn Stuart Mill, vol.11, p.415.].


          :



[Ѡ ]   ,      ,        , ,     ,     ,        ,            [49 - , vol.1, p.25. (. .:  . .    . .:  , 1896. .21. . .)].


,     :     ,    .       .  ,   , , ,    .



.    ?       .   ,      ;         ;  ࠖ   ?      - ,      .   :




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/pages/biblio_book/?art=69675565)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


Vlastos, TheParadox ofSocrates, .20.




2


Robson, ed., Collected Works ofJohn Stuart Mill, vol.11, p.46.




3


. Π , 18.6.




4


., : , 143e,   :             ,       . .     12. (        .  . ..)




5


. , .5.        .:Guthrie, History ofGreek Philosophy, vol.3, ch. 8. (. .:  . . .   : 6. .III: . . .:  , 2021. . ..)




6


 . . .   . .III; Annas, Classical Greek Philosophy, p.281283.




7


Guthrie, History ofGreek Philosophy, vol.5, . 401.       : Ӡ    ,     (Kahn, Plato andthe Socratic Dialogue, p.48).  , , ,       ,                  - ,  ,        (Annas, Classical Greek Philosophy, p.285).




8


Emerson, Representative Men, p.48. (. .:  . .  . .: , .: ACT, 2001. .231. . ..)




9


., :  . . .   . .IV: .  :  . .:  , 2023. .3539. Vlastos, Socrates, Ironist andMoral Philosopher, . 128130.




10


 . Π,    , 3.35.




11


    -,   . .:Kahn, Plato andthe Socratic Dialogue, .6.




12


.  . .III, .9.




13


Kahn, Plato andthe Socratic Dialogue, . 7579, 393401.




14


   .:Woodruff, Socrates Among theSophists;  . . .   . .III.




15


Nussbaum, Aristotle andSocrates.




16


     .:Dover, Socrates inthe Clouds; Lacey, Our Knowledge ofSocrates; Nussbaum, Aristotle andSocrates.




17


Kahn, Plato andthe Socratic Dialogue, . 8587; Nehamas, Voices ofSilence, .170.




18


Kahn, Plato andthe Socratic Dialogue, . 7986.




19


Lacey, Our Knowledge ofSocrates.




20


   ,    (Nails, Agora, Academy, andthe Conduct ofPhilosophy, p.831)        . .: Waterfield, Quest forthe Historical Socrates; Dorion, Rise andFall ofthe Socratic Problem; Brickhouse andSmith, Socratic Moral Psychology; Nehamas, Voices ofSilence, p.160165.




21


     ࠖ . .:Burnet, Greek Philosophy; Taylor, Socrates, 162. (. :  . :   . .: , 2010. . .)




22


Ross, Plato's Theory ofIdeas; Popper, Open Society andItsEnemies, note 56. (. .:  .    : 2. .:  , 1992. . .)




23


. theory offorms  .        . . ..




24


     .:Graham, Socrates andPlato; Vlastos, Socrates, Ironist andMoral Philosopher, ch.2.




25


., ,  ( . . .   . .IV. .106):          . .  : Vlastos, Socrates, Ironist andMoral Philosopher, . 50,117.




26


    :  ,   ,     ,  ࠖ ;     ,      (Vlastos, Paradox ofSocrates, . 23). C. ,  :     .    ,    ,     (Burnet, Greek Philosophy, p.149).




27


Russel, History ofWestern Philosophy, p.82. (. .:  .           . 7- . .:  , 2009. .115. ..)




28


Howland, Xenophon's Philosophic Odyssey; Vlastos, Socrates, Ironist andMoral Philosopher, p.99100; Morrison, OnProfessor Vlastos's Xenophon.




29


Cooper, Reason andEmotion: Essays inAncient Moral Philosophy andEthical Theory. .   :   -   ,     ,  ,           (Morrison, OnProfessor Vlastos's Xenophon, p.19).




30


  Π    :  ,    ,   ,   , ,  ,  .            ,  ,  ,   (Morrison, OnProfessor Vlastos's Xenophon, p.18).




31


 .   . .116.




32


Vlastos, Paradox ofSocrates, p.4.




33


Waterfield, Xenophon onSocrates' Trial andDeath; Shorey, What Plato Said, p.33. .: Grote, Plato andthe Other Companions ofSorates, vol.1, p.281; Brickhouse andSmith, Socrates onTrial, p.210.




34


  (21)     ;  ,   ,      .




35


Waterfield, Xenophon onSocrates' Trial andDeath, p.282283.




36


.  , 1.173.




37


Irwin, Review: Socrates andAthenian Democracy.




38


Thesleff, Studies inPlatonic Chronology.




39


 ,    , .:Annas, What Are Plato's "Middle" Dialogues inthe Middle Of?; Kahn, Plato andthe Socratic Dialogue.




40


     ,  ,   XIX.   .    .       : Kahn, Plato andthe Socratic Dialogue, p.3840; Friedlander, Plato, p.162; Shorey, Unity ofPlato's Thought. .    : Sprague, Platonic Unitarianism, orWhat Shorey Said.




41


.   :       ,      (Shorey, Unity ofPlato's Thought, p.88).




42


Whitehead, Process andReality, 2.1.1.




43


   , 5 1814. .: Ford, Writings ofThomas Jefferson, vol.9, p.463. (. .:  .  : 2. .2. .: , 1969. .102. ..)




44


      31 1819.   : ߠ    (       )      ""   , ,       . .:  . .2. .127128.




45


, 38a;          (Kraut, Examined Life, p.230231). (   . .  ,    ,  :      ,    ,  , ,     ,      . ..)




46


Mill, Early Draft ofJohn Stuart Mill's Autobiography, p.24.




47


.




48


Robson, Collected Works ofJohn Stuart Mill, vol.11, p.415.




49


, vol.1, p.25. (. .:  . .    . .:  , 1896. .21. . .)


