     13  2015 . 224-  - , -             
  


 
       -     .       - ,    - ,     .   ,  ,       .





.. 

     13  2015. 224-  - , -             



         1  2016.



A.V. Belitskaya



Commentary to the Federal Law

Dated 13 July 2015, N 224-FZ



On public-private partnership, the municipal-private partnership in the Russian Federation and making changes to certain legislative acts of the Russian Federation



Material was prepared using the legal acts as on the August 1, 2016



The commentary analyzes the provisions of the law on public-private partnership as part of the investment legislation. the focus is made on the agreement on public-private partnership that is a form of public-private partnership based on the ownership of a private partner. the commentary contains comparative analysis of this agreement with the concession agreement.



Keywords: public-private partnership, municipal-private partnership, investment activity, private financing initiative, public property, public interest, state investment policy.

 A.V. Belitskaya, 2016

 Ltd. Yustitsinform, 2016







               .       ,        .          .

     ,    ,      .          -   ,      ,         .             - ,               .   ,  -      ,   ,                    .

        -    ,             .     ,           .            :           .  ,  ,      -          ,        .

-  (Public Private Partnership)               1992.           (Private Finance Initiative).      ,              ,        .           - ,                       .

-           .          ,     ;          ;          ;   -      .[1 - .:  ..    : ,    : . . . . . . 2008. . 5.]     -           ,    ,  -                 .            .




 1

 





 1

      


 .1      ,      .

-,             , ..        -     .                     ,     ,       ,    ,         .

-, ,   ,     , , ,          .   .. ,       -       ,       (, ,   .)[2 - .:  ..   - :    . . 2009.].

,      21  2005. N 115-   [3 -  . 2005. 30 (. II). .3126.] (     )        ,    ,      ,    ,   , , ,  .

    ,    -           ,     ,         ,    ,     ,    [4 - .:  ..   : . (2- ,   ). , 2012.].

      -          /          [5 - Bult-Spiering M., Dewulf G. Strategic Issues in Public-Private Partnerships: an International Perspective. Blackwell Publishing Ltd., uK, 2006. R 16.].   -    , ,        [6 - Green Paper on Public-Private Partnerships and Community Law on Public Contracts and Concessions. Commission of the European Communities. Brussels. 30 April 2004.]    ,       .

 ,    -       ,           .

.2       .     ,    :

  -  - ;

,      -  - ;

       .

 ,       -  - :

  ,  , ,       (       - ,   ,    .);

,     ,     - .

  ,                 ( ,    ,  , ) (   .   .4  ),     ,     -      ,    [7 - .:  ..   - :    //    . 2015. 4. .139145.].    ,          ,                   .    ..          - ,          - ,       , ,     .  ,   ,        ,   (   )  ,     ()          [8 - .:  ..          //   . 2003. 2. .1424.]. ..   ..  ,     -       ,           ,   -                [9 - .:  ..,  RR   -   -  // . 2015. 10. .147156.].

           -  -  (.   .15  ),  ,   ,       - , ,   ,        .

 ,      , ,   -       ,   ,    . ,   -              ,      .           - , ,      (.   .2 .8  ).           ,       -   .    .. ,   -              [10 - .:  .       -     //   .  . 2014. 1. .179188.].     -       ,      .     -            .

        ,  ,         30  1995. N 225-     [11 -  . 1996. 1. . 18] (       ).            ,  ..      ,       ,    ,    ,  -    .




 2

    - , - ,     - 


           .       ,    ,  ,  , - .       ,          ,   ,      .             - , ,   ,    ,  .

 .1         -  - ,       ,        , , , , , , .     ,          ,            .             .

   ,   ,                    ,     ,    .            - ,            - .      .47  ,    ,                      .   ,       ,       ,      (.   .47  ).

,        -                              -  (   .   .3  ).           -     ,      ,  ,           ,    ,  ,            - , .     ..   , ,        -       ,             [12 - .:  ..       -  // . 2015. 2. .173195.].

   ,    -        . ,    -                    , ..          .    -        -  -    .       ,    -  -       .     ,   ,    -              -  -          .

.2    ,     , ,     ,             -     ,        .             -  -           -    - .

   , ,      ,       ,      - . ,       ,                      .




 3

 ,     


     ,    .

,  .1            - /- ,            ,     ,   ,   ,   ,       -  - ,             ,          , ,     .

        - ,    ,      ,          ,   ,   ,  [13 - .:  ..   - . ., . 191 .].         ,  - ,     -  - .

   ,   -       . , ..         -           ,     , , ,         ,   ,  -    ,     [14 - .:  .. -    . - . . 2009. . 41.].      .. ,  ,  -              ,    ,     -  [15 - .:  ..     -    //    . 2014. 5. .1618.]. ,     -     .    ,                   . - /-           ,     ,                .

      -                    ,      ,      [16 - .: -     . . . .,  .. . 2009. . 9, 167.],       -  , ,  ,  ,    -        . ,    -     .    ,            .    -        ,       .

   -           ,    .     -                :            [17 - .:  ..          - .: . . . . . . 2010. . 27.],       [18 - .:  .. -   :   //  . 2004. 6. .172177.].

,  -/-       ,  ,    ,    ,   ,        ,  ,      ,                  ,     ,   ,    .  , -       ,  ..       .  ,   .. ,      -          , .. ,           . ..  ,                 ,  -     [19 - .:  ..  - :      // . 2015. 7. .1521.],      .

     ,   -    :

1) -  -     ,   ,    ,       ;

2)   , -  -     , .. ,    ,         -  (.   .4  );

3)-  -       (      ),                 ,          , ,     ;

4)-  -                  , .. -  -         ,            (       );

5)  -  -       ,      , ..        ,           ,     ,  ,     (     ).

    ,               -  - ,      .    ,         -  -       ,                    ,        ,       .

 .2    -  -    ,            -  - .

        ,          .         .4  ,   ,          ,   .      ,   -   ,          , ..        ,               [20 - .:  ..  . .: -, 2009. . 69].

     .1    25  1999. N 39-      ,     [21 -  . 1999. 9. .1096] (         ),       ,      ,  ..   ,       ,         (-).

,    ,   -  -         .

.3       -  - ,   -      ,             ,    .     ,       ,      [22 - .:  ..  ,     . .: , 2013. 368 .].

          - ,   ,          ,         -.     ,      - ,   ,     -  -     - ,     - ,    ,    .

 .4        -    . ,                 ,       ,   ,   .  

              ;

                      ;

                   .

       -     (   )      ,    [23 - .:  ..   -   -  //     . 2015. 8. .2130.],         .   ,      -            (,  ,  ,  )[24 - .:  . . -   :       //   . 2015. 8. .1620.].

,      ,         .  ,          ,              . ,                   .        ,      ,      (   .   .4 .5  ).

 .5      ,     ,          .          - ,     .       50%       ,            -  (   .   .2, 3 .5  ).

    ,      ,       ,                (   )      .                               .    ,        . .  ,        -       -  -      () [25 - .:  .     // -. 2015. 44. . 9.].      .       ,    -       ,     .

           ,     .          ,     ,         .  ,          [26 - .:  ..      (    ). .: , 2003. . 139.].   ,         . ,            ,     -  -      ,       ,   ,               . ,                ,     ,       .

.6                .                       ,           , , .  , ,    ,  ,          ,      ,   .

    ,  .9        ,     ()   .     26  1991. N 1488-1     л[27 -      1991. 29. .1005.] (       )   ,    ,       ,     ,        ,    ,       , ,   (.8      ).   [28 - .:  ..,  ..   : -  // . 2012. 4. .4353.],        ,   , ,          .         ,        ,      ,     , ,  .       ,     , ,     .          :        ,           [29 - .,    . . 2- . /.  .. , . . (   .. ). . 781.].            , ..          , , .

,        ,                  .  ,  -  -       .       ,           .  ,           . ,                   .

.7           ,       .     - ,    ,                     ,       .  ,    ,            -  - .       , ..         -  - .

         -  -             . ,    ,  ,      ,     ..   , ..           .         -  -    , ..          -  -  (   .   .3 .6).   ..   .. ,         ,      .        (        ,  ,     ..)                          -  - ,    ,  ..   ,             ..[30 - .:  ..,  .. :    // . 2015. 3. .5059.].

 .8       ,        ,     -     ,       ,  ,   , , ,  ,    ,   ,  ,  ,   , ,       , , ,        .  ,     ,                   -  - ,      ,        . , ,         ,          ,            .

.9       ,          ,   ,   ,  ,       ,   .           ,     ,    . ,      -  -     .           .     ,        - ,                     ,            , ..       .           -  -     , ..            .

.10   ,        ,       , ,            .     ,           ,   .    -  -       . ,             .

 .11          ,       ,  .2 .16  ,      ,            ,  .2 .17  ,   ,          ,  .2 .18  .               (   .   .1618  ).

        , ,    ,      ,    ,       .        ,  ,   ,      ,     [31 - .:  ..           //  .    . 2016. 1. .2025.].

 -              .

.12       ,   ,    ,    ( .   .20  ),                         ,            .

          -       .

  .. ,             ,           .          , ..    -       [32 - .:  ..   - :    ,   //    III  -             (25  2016 ,  ) / .. , .. , ..   .;  . . . . , .. . .:     .   . ..      , , 2016. 496 .].




 4

 - , - 


-     ,   ,    .      -  -                  (., ,   .15  ).

   -      ,    ,  ..   ,     - .      ,           ,   , ,   ,     .     -  -     ,     -  - ,     ,  ,      ,        .

     -  -    .

           -  - ,   ,        .

 ,         ,       - .               .            (      .11  ).

       ,            ,        ,      - [33 - .:  ..      //   . 2009. 2. C. 1729.].            ,     ,         S      (Official Journal of the European Communities),     ,      ,      .  ,    , :    (,  , ),  ,       ,  .

       -  -         -  .    ,   .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/anna-viktorovna-belickaya/kommentariy-k-federalnomu-zakonu-ot-13-iulya-2015-224-fz-o-gosudarstvenno-chastnom-partnerstve-municipalno-chastnom-partnerstve-v-rossiyskoy-federacii-i-vnesenii-izmeneniy-v-otdelnye-zakonodatelnye-akty-rossiyskoy-federacii/)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


.:  ..    : ,    : . . . . . . 2008. . 5.




2


.:  ..   - :    . . 2009.




3


 . 2005. 30 (. II). .3126.




4


.:  ..   : . (2- ,   ). , 2012.




5


Bult-Spiering M., Dewulf G. Strategic Issues in Public-Private Partnerships: an International Perspective. Blackwell Publishing Ltd., uK, 2006. R 16.




6


Green Paper on Public-Private Partnerships and Community Law on Public Contracts and Concessions. Commission of the European Communities. Brussels. 30 April 2004.




7


.:  ..   - :    //    . 2015. 4. .139145.




8


.:  ..          //   . 2003. 2. .1424.




9


.:  ..,  RR   -   -  // . 2015. 10. .147156.




10


.:  .       -     //   .  . 2014. 1. .179188.




11


 . 1996. 1. . 18




12


.:  ..       -  // . 2015. 2. .173195.




13


.:  ..   - . ., . 191 .




14


.:  .. -    . - . . 2009. . 41.




15


.:  ..     -    //    . 2014. 5. .1618.




16


.: -     . . . .,  .. . 2009. . 9, 167.




17


.:  ..          - .: . . . . . . 2010. . 27.




18


.:  .. -   :   //  . 2004. 6. .172177.




19


.:  ..  - :      // . 2015. 7. .1521.




20


.:  ..  . .: -, 2009. . 69




21


 . 1999. 9. .1096




22


.:  ..  ,     . .: , 2013. 368 .




23


.:  ..   -   -  //     . 2015. 8. .2130.




24


.:  . . -   :       //   . 2015. 8. .1620.




25


.:  .     // -. 2015. 44. . 9.




26


.:  ..      (    ). .: , 2003. . 139.




27


     1991. 29. .1005.




28


.:  ..,  ..   : -  // . 2012. 4. .4353.




29


.,    . . 2- . /.  .. , . . (   .. ). . 781.




30


.:  ..,  .. :    // . 2015. 3. .5059.




31


.:  ..           //  .    . 2016. 1. .2025.




32


.:  ..   - :    ,   //    III  -             (25  2016 ,  ) / .. , .. , ..   .;  . . . . , .. . .:     .   . ..      , , 2016. 496 .




33


.:  ..      //   . 2009. 2. C. 1729.


